UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on July 26, 2019, 08:58:23 AM
-
Swabs were taken from apartment 5A and sent to FSS in UK for analysis. The type of DNA testing used was Low Copy Number (LCN). The FSS found the results inconclusive. Does anyone wish to draw any further inference(s) from this? if so what and on what basis?
Please can we stick to thread topic. Thanks.
-
Where is the best description of what LCN testing can do?
-
Where is the best description of what LCN testing can do?
I think its best if posters carry out their own research using whatever reference material they wish. If anyone is able to challenge FSS findings then please post it up.
If you want something to get you going:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_copy_number
https://www.promega.co.uk/resources/profiles-in-dna/2010/what-is-lcn-definitions-and-challenges/
As LCN DNA usually works with samples invisible to the naked idea and where its not usually possible for the scientist to even identify the source material eg blood, skin cells, saliva etc it doesn't work well in say for example the case of the McCanns.
- MM's DNA will be all over apartment 5A from direct and indirect contamination and indirect contamination of hire car given we all shed 30,000 - 40,000 skin cells a minute every day.
- If this case involves stranger abduction then he/she had no legitimate right to be in apartment 5A. Therefore it would be much more significant if the abductor is found and his/her DNA was found in 5A tested via LCN.
-
I assume PJ/SY have been able to collect some DNA evidence from 5A thought to belong to a suspect since Euclides Monteiro was ruled out of the investigation based on DNA evidence?
-
I assume PJ/SY have been able to collect some DNA evidence from 5A thought to belong to a suspect since Euclides Monteiro was ruled out of the investigation based on DNA evidence?
Why was it "thought" to be his DNA,crossed checked to eliminate from enquires is the standard surely.
-
Why was it "thought" to be his DNA,crossed checked to eliminate from enquires is the standard surely.
"Thought" as in all DNA evidence is based on a statistical probability albeit often high statistical probabilities nearing 100% but never 100%.
-
I assume PJ/SY have been able to collect some DNA evidence from 5A thought to belong to a suspect since Euclides Monteiro was ruled out of the investigation based on DNA evidence?
Is that just the PJ saying we didn't find his DNA at the apartment?
-
I think as the offer is there to make a conclusive analysis of the DNA data then all parties (PJ, OG, CM) should be accepting the offer. It might just take the investigation forward.
-
I assume PJ/SY have been able to collect some DNA evidence from 5A thought to belong to a suspect since Euclides Monteiro was ruled out of the investigation based on DNA evidence?
He wasn't.
Portuguese law on the use of DNA is quite, quite different to that of the UK.
-
Is that just the PJ saying we didn't find his DNA at the apartment?
I'm not sure if it relates to this case or other cases where children were sexually assaulted:
https://www.independent.ie/world-news/europe/madeleine-suspect-was-questioned-about-sex-assaults-30242298.html
-
I think as the offer is there to make a conclusive analysis of the DNA data then all parties (PJ, OG, CM) should be accepting the offer. It might just take the investigation forward.
Is Mark Perlin claiming he can conclude the sample where British scientists were unable to do so? If so on what basis?
Most forensics scientists analysing DNA samples hold degrees in biology, chemistry, biochemistry, microbiology etc. Mark Perlin holds a medical degree and doctorates in mathematics and computer science. My guess is that he wants to build some some complex mathematical model around the inconclusive results generated by FSS that only he will understand. This could be akin to the bankers at JPM who designed complex mathematical models in an attempt to manage credit risk and bring to market complex financial instruments, later described as "financial weapons of mass destruction", which without inter-governmental intervention would have caused the global financial system to implode.
https://www.cybgen.com/company/principals.shtml
Mark Perlin's business partner holds a degree in American history and executive MBA. What has any of this got to do with evaluating DNA evidence.
-
Is Mark Perlin claiming he can conclude the sample where British scientists were unable to do so? If so on what basis?
Most forensics scientists analysing DNA samples hold degrees in biology, chemistry, biochemistry, microbiology etc. Mark Perlin holds a medical degree and doctorates in mathematics and computer science. My guess is that he wants to build some some complex mathematical model around the inconclusive results generated by FSS that only he will understand. This could be akin to the bankers at JPM who designed complex mathematical models in an attempt to manage credit risk and bring to market complex financial instruments, later described as "financial weapons of mass destruction", which without inter-governmental intervention would have caused the global financial system to implode.
https://www.cybgen.com/company/principals.shtml
Mark Perlin's business partner holds a degree in American history and executive MBA. What has any of this got to do with evaluating DNA evidence.
To be frank, it doesn't matter what they find as transference will always be used as a counter argument. And even if a full DNA match with Maddie is found in samples taken from the infamous Scenic hire car, it can always be put down to innocent contamination by garments and other items associated with her.
-
Is Mark Perlin claiming he can conclude the sample where British scientists were unable to do so? If so on what basis?
Yes indeed through computer processing which can "effectively handle the mixed, damaged, and low‐level DNA evidence that currently consumes much of the human review effort." TrueAllele software has been peer reviewed, researched, evaluated... and approved by the New York State Commission on Forensic Science as part of the technology approval process mandated for NYS public DNA laboratories.
Here's a link to some interesting reading in a science journal:
New York State TrueAllele® Casework Validation Study
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1556-4029.12223 (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1556-4029.12223)
Computers can thoroughly examine every genotype possibility through statistical Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) computing 9, 10 on probability models 11, 12. Probabilistic genotypes have been recognized by regulatory bodies such as SWGDAM 13 and standards organizations such as ANSI/NIST 14 as a valid approach to DNA interpretation and reporting. Genotype probability has a long scientific tradition in genetics 15-17 and human identification 18-20, with statistical computer solutions for DNA mixtures 4, 21. Human review simplifies DNA data and considers only some genotype possibilities 22. The well‐established laws of probability 23, 24 and scientific inference 25, 26 permit a more complete interpretation.
This study examined Cybergenetics TrueAllele® Casework, a probabilistic genotyping computer system that interprets DNA evidence using a statistical model. We analyzed 368 items of anonymized, adjudicated evidence from the New York State Police (NYSP) Forensic Investigation Center (FIC). We studied 81 mixture items, focusing on contributors with mixture weights between 5% and 95%; these contributors yielded 87 inferred genotypes that matched a known suspect. We measured the sensitivity, specificity, and reproducibility of these genotypes using match information. We compared computer results with those from human review.
This study was submitted to the DNA Subcommittee of the New York State Commission on Forensic Science as part of the technology approval process mandated for NYS public DNA laboratories. The DNA Subcommittee made a unanimous binding recommendation for TrueAllele approval on May 20, 2011, which was ratified by the Commission on June 27, 2011.
-
To be frank, it doesn't matter what they find as transference will always be used as a counter argument. And even if a full DNA match with Maddie is found in samples taken from the infamous Scenic hire car, it can always be put down to innocent contamination by garments and other items associated with her.
I'm sure that defence would be used... but why didn't the dogs alert to those garments and other items in 4G?
-
I'm sure that defence would be used... but why didn't the dogs alert to those garments and other items in 4G?
5a had something in it which Eddie obviously recognised from his training whereas 4g didn't, it's that basic. I don't believe for a minute that there was anything in 5a which related to a deceased Maddie.
-
5a had something in it which Eddie obviously recognised from his training whereas 4g didn't, it's that basic. I don't believe for a minute that there was anything in 5a which related to a deceased Maddie.
But we are told that no-one else died in the apartment. Both dogs alerted and samples were tested for a DNA match (to various family members and maybe also the T7).
-
To be frank, it doesn't matter what they find as transference will always be used as a counter argument. And even if a full DNA match with Maddie is found in samples taken from the infamous Scenic hire car, it can always be put down to innocent contamination by garments and other items associated with her.
It is normal to pack a missing person's clothes/items inside bags so it would depend on corroborative evidence. It is wishful thinking for a blood alert and if a match to Madeleine to be ruled out as innocent.
https://nypost.com/2019/05/29/dna-evidence-links-uncle-to-missing-5-year-old-utah-girl-cops/
-
But we are told that no-one else died in the apartment. Both dogs alerted and samples were tested for a DNA match (to various family members and maybe also the T7).
Ah but the previous owner of 5a did die in hospital so there could very well have been contaminants associated with him brought back to 5a.
The point I'm making is that there are many possibilities for Eddie's alerts in 5a.
-
I'm sure that defence would be used... but why didn't the dogs alert to those garments and other items in 4G?
The dogs aren't alerting to DNA containing cells.
-
I think its best if posters carry out their own research using whatever reference material they wish. If anyone is able to challenge FSS findings then please post it up.
If you want something to get you going:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_copy_number
https://www.promega.co.uk/resources/profiles-in-dna/2010/what-is-lcn-definitions-and-challenges/
...snip ....
How did you get on with the following paragraph, did you understand it?
"LCN DNA (also now termed low template DNA or LT DNA) may refer to any situation where a small amount of DNA is present in a sample based on the sample type (e.g., an item that has been handled) and/or the estimated quantity of DNA determined using routine quantification assays. Samples containing <100–200 pg of total DNA available for amplification fall into the range generally considered to be LCN DNA by most practitioners. Consequently, these samples may undergo LCN DNA-testing procedures developed to increase assay sensitivity; commonly this includes increased PCR cycles (e.g., 28 cycles increased to 31 or 34 cycles) but may include other sensitivity-enhancing techniques such as desalting or concentrating products prior to electrophoresis, reducing amplification volumes, increasing injection times during electrophoresis, using high-purity formamide, etc. More recently, LCN has been used to refer to any DNA sample or DNA profile where stochastic effects (e.g., allele and locus drop-out, heterozygous peak height imbalance and elevated stutter peaks) are likely present and/or where the alleles detected are below a laboratory-defined stochastic threshold (see accompanying article by Dr. John Butler for further discussion). Regardless of whether a quantitative-, technological- and/or qualitative profile-based definition is used, the term LCN or LT DNA generally refers to any situation where: 1) the amount of DNA available for amplification is limited due to small sample size or other factors (e.g., DNA degradation, PCR inhibition), and 2) interpreting the resulting DNA profile may require more considerations than interpreting single-source or mixed DNA profiles generated using higher amounts of DNA due to the potential for incomplete DNA profiles. Other rarely recognized definitions have arisen in court documentation (e.g., quantity of DNA on a slot blot quantitation assay, any amount of DNA below the manufacturer’s recommendations)."
-
https://worldwide.promega.com/resources/profiles-in-dna/2010/what-is-lcn-definitions-and-challenges/
the article ends with 6 recommendations #6 was:
"6) use caution to not "over-interpret" the data by recognising that some samples may have insufficient data to definitively include or exclude an individual as a possible contributor, resulting in an “inconclusive” statement."
-
....snip ...
- MM's DNA will be all over apartment 5A from direct and indirect contamination and indirect contamination of hire car given we all shed 30,000 - 40,000 skin cells a minute every day.
....snip ...
40.000 per minute sounds a lot!
"It may seem like a lot but it is only a fraction of the averaged 37 TRILLIONS cells of your entire body in which it is estimated that 10% of them are skin cells (~3.7 trillions, so you shed about 0.0014% of all your skin cells daily)." https://www.quora.com/Exactly-how-many-skin-cells-does-a-person-shed-daily
-
Ah but the previous owner of 5a did die in hospital so there could very well have been contaminants associated with him brought back to 5a.
The point I'm making is that there are many possibilities for Eddie's alerts in 5a.
From the U.K.?
-
From the U.K.?
In the case of Shannon Matthews:
The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died. This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.
Page 25:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
-
Yes indeed through computer processing which can "effectively handle the mixed, damaged, and low‐level DNA evidence that currently consumes much of the human review effort." TrueAllele software has been peer reviewed, researched, evaluated... and approved by the New York State Commission on Forensic Science as part of the technology approval process mandated for NYS public DNA laboratories.
Here's a link to some interesting reading in a science journal:
New York State TrueAllele® Casework Validation Study
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1556-4029.12223 (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1556-4029.12223)
Sir Alec Jefferys developed techniques for genetic fingerprinting and DNA profiling which are now used worldwide in forensic science to assist police detective work and to resolve paternity and immigration disputes.
Why would the UK or Portugal need to refer to someone in the US when the UK has homegrown expertise from the daddy of dna if you will?
I would say the UK is at the cutting edge in the field of bio science? Please correct me if I'm wrong.
-
Sir Alec Jefferys developed techniques for genetic fingerprinting and DNA profiling which are now used worldwide in forensic science to assist police detective work and to resolve paternity and immigration disputes.
Why would the UK or Portugal need to refer to someone in the US when the UK has homegrown expertise from the daddy of dna if you will?
I would say the UK is at the cutting edge in the field of bio science? Please correct me if I'm wrong.
Mark Perlin is doing more analysis on the results. Maybe the UK is lacking in analysis techniques?
-
He wasn't.
Portuguese law on the use of DNA is quite, quite different to that of the UK.
The EU countries should have a central database for DNA profiles like they do in the USA.
-
To be frank, it doesn't matter what they find as transference will always be used as a counter argument. And even if a full DNA match with Maddie is found in samples taken from the infamous Scenic hire car, it can always be put down to innocent contamination by garments and other items associated with her.
But hopefully it will show there was someone else's other than Madeleine's DNA. It can never her's as there were 4 alleles missing, but using the other 21 alleles present is there possibility of a profile in the total pool of alleles.
I see Billy's cite refers to " Probabilistic genotypes". I think this is the clue as to how Mark Perlin identifies a genetic profile by using "Probabilistic genotypes".
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10917.msg548285#msg548285
-
The EU countries should have a central database for DNA profiles like they do in the USA.
The key is what Portugal did in 2007, not what other countries did or do.
If the article quoted earlier is correct, Sr Monteiro's DNA might have gone into a DB at the time, but as there was no DNA database, it didn't.
If Sr Monteiro's DNA was checked against the Algarve sex assaults, he gave his consent in each and every separate case where it was used. Without access to the files, I can only say this smells strongly of bull to me.
-
The key is what Portugal did in 2007, not what other countries did or do.
If the article quoted earlier is correct, Sr Monteiro's DNA might have gone into a DB at the time, but as there was no DNA database, it didn't.
If Sr Monteiro's DNA was checked against the Algarve sex assaults, he gave his consent in each and every separate case where it was used. Without access to the files, I can only say this smells strongly of bull to me.
They might not have a database but surely they have records so they wouldn't need to see him again every time.
-
I'm sure that defence would be used... but why didn't the dogs alert to those garments and other items in 4G?
The theory went this way. At some point between hiring the hire car in the last few weeks of May and having the car tested by the dogs in August it was used to move a frozen cadaver. Well the clothes don't need to be affected if the move occurred after the time they left 4G (was that in early July)? I forget all the dates.
The thing is if the cadaver was frozen there is no rush to move it.
-
But we are told that no-one else died in the apartment. Both dogs alerted and samples were tested for a DNA match (to various family members and maybe also the T7).
That is why in my theory an unknown deceased person was introduced on the 3rd and removed after the PJ left early hours on the 4th.
It seems like there are no other options.
If Madeleine is live on the 3rd, and no other died in the apartment, and no history of deceased estate furniture being bought, what options are left?
That is why I'm hoping the Mark Perlin analysis of the DNA found in the hire car might yield a probabilistic DNA profile of the "unknown deceased person who was introduced on the 3rd".
-
They might not have a database but surely they have records so they wouldn't need to see him again every time.
Law. One cannot go 'fishing' for DNA in Portugal. Each case is ring-fenced from each other.
In July 2014, the newspapers reported that OG wanted the DNA of the 3 alleged burglars, but that was refused.
I don't know how DNA is handled in NZ law, or in US law. I have a handle on how it is dealt with in PT law.
The people in the MBM case had to give consent that a DNA sample could be taken. Which then could only be used in the MBM case.
Euclides Monteiro is not on that list.
-
Law. One cannot go 'fishing' for DNA in Portugal. Each case is ring-fenced from each other.
In July 2014, the newspapers reported that OG wanted the DNA of the 3 alleged burglars, but that was refused.
I don't know how DNA is handled in NZ law, or in US law. I have a handle on how it is dealt with in PT law.
The people in the MBM case had to give consent that a DNA sample could be taken. Which then could only be used in the MBM case.
Euclides Monteiro is not on that list.
In NZ we have an offenders Database. Several databases depending on the age of the offender actually.
-
In the case of Shannon Matthews:
The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died. This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.
Page 25:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
As far as I remember the Grandfather died in the U.K.
-
As far as I remember the Grandfather died in the U.K.
In which case? Matthews or McCann?
-
That is why in my theory an unknown deceased person was introduced on the 3rd and removed after the PJ left early hours on the 4th.
It seems like there are no other options.
If Madeleine is live on the 3rd, and no other died in the apartment, and no history of deceased estate furniture being bought, what options are left?
That is why I'm hoping the Mark Perlin analysis of the DNA found in the hire car might yield a probabilistic DNA profile of the "unknown deceased person who was introduced on the 3rd".
How did someone get into the locked apartment after the PJ left? How did they convince the GNR to allow it? I would like to see evidence, not speculation if possible please.
-
How did someone get into the locked apartment after the PJ left? How did they convince the GNR to allow it? I would like to see evidence, not speculation if possible please.
Who took the key to the apartment once the PJ left? Whoever had a key could re-enter.
-
Who took the key to the apartment once the PJ left? Whoever had a key could re-enter.
If you can't answer that question then your theory falls at the first hurdle. It's based on assunptions. Assume nothing, the police are told. Good advice which some theorisers should take on board imo.
-
How did you get on with the following paragraph, did you understand it?
"LCN DNA (also now termed low template DNA or LT DNA) may refer to any situation where a small amount of DNA is present in a sample based on the sample type (e.g., an item that has been handled) and/or the estimated quantity of DNA determined using routine quantification assays. Samples containing <100–200 pg of total DNA available for amplification fall into the range generally considered to be LCN DNA by most practitioners. Consequently, these samples may undergo LCN DNA-testing procedures developed to increase assay sensitivity; commonly this includes increased PCR cycles (e.g., 28 cycles increased to 31 or 34 cycles) but may include other sensitivity-enhancing techniques such as desalting or concentrating products prior to electrophoresis, reducing amplification volumes, increasing injection times during electrophoresis, using high-purity formamide, etc. More recently, LCN has been used to refer to any DNA sample or DNA profile where stochastic effects (e.g., allele and locus drop-out, heterozygous peak height imbalance and elevated stutter peaks) are likely present and/or where the alleles detected are below a laboratory-defined stochastic threshold (see accompanying article by Dr. John Butler for further discussion). Regardless of whether a quantitative-, technological- and/or qualitative profile-based definition is used, the term LCN or LT DNA generally refers to any situation where: 1) the amount of DNA available for amplification is limited due to small sample size or other factors (e.g., DNA degradation, PCR inhibition), and 2) interpreting the resulting DNA profile may require more considerations than interpreting single-source or mixed DNA profiles generated using higher amounts of DNA due to the potential for incomplete DNA profiles. Other rarely recognized definitions have arisen in court documentation (e.g., quantity of DNA on a slot blot quantitation assay, any amount of DNA below the manufacturer’s recommendations)."
Yes but only because I did a shed load of research into it connected with the Bamber case:
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=5861.msg209101#msg209101
Perhaps one of the most relevant posts is here:
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=5861.msg211665#msg211665
- Inconclusive results -- Results may be inconclusive for several reasons. For example, contaminated samples often yield inconclusive results. So do very small or degraded samples, which may not have enough DNA to produce a full profile.
-
To be frank, it doesn't matter what they find as transference will always be used as a counter argument. And even if a full DNA match with Maddie is found in samples taken from the infamous Scenic hire car, it can always be put down to innocent contamination by garments and other items associated with her.
Agreed. As forensic scientist Dave Barclay said its not just a case of whose dna but how it actually got there.
-
Mark Perlin is doing more analysis on the results. Maybe the UK is lacking in analysis techniques?
Mark Perlin does not have the expertise to reanalyse the results further from a biological perspective.
After DNA has been tested and results produced it is expressed using statistical analysis. What Perlin wants to do is take the results (not the actual DNA) and design a mathematical model using computer software to reanalyse and possibly reinterpret the results. I can't see any justification in doing this. The UK is a world leader in bio sciences and we have mathematicians with double firsts from Oxbridge. I can't see any need whatsoever to involve Mark Perlin from the US.
Why do you think the PJ used the UK to evaluate the DNA evidence and I think said something like world leaders?
I've always said in the case of Bamber the UK needed outside assistance with regard to the ballistics evidence eg US. The US has far greater experience and knowledge due to the difference in firearms law and number of incidents. So there will be some cases where experts from other countries could/should be sought out but analysing and interpreting DNA evidence isn't one of them.
It could be argued Perlin wants to make a name for himself on the back of MM's disappearance.
-
As far as I remember the Grandfather died in the U.K.
I believe so but as I keep pointing out in the case of Shannon Matthews the odour is clearly capable of being transferred to one location from another on inanimate objects. So clearly primary contamination is an issue here but what about secondary contamination?
The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died. This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.
Page 25:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
-
Mark Perlin does not have the expertise to reanalyse the results further from a biological perspective.
After DNA has been tested and results produced it is expressed using statistical analysis. What Perlin wants to do is take the results (not the actual DNA) and design a mathematical model using computer software to reanalyse and possibly reinterpret the results. I can't see any justification in doing this. The UK is a world leader in bio sciences and we have mathematicians with double firsts from Oxbridge. I can't see any need whatsoever to involve Mark Perlin from the US.
Why do you think the PJ used the UK to evaluate the DNA evidence and I think said something like world leaders?
I've always said in the case of Bamber the UK needed outside assistance with regard to the ballistics evidence eg US. The US has far greater experience and knowledge due to the difference in firearms law and number of incidents. So there will be some cases where experts from other countries could/should be sought out but analysing and interpreting DNA evidence isn't one of them.
It could be argued Perlin wants to make a name for himself on the back of MM's disappearance.
Why is Perlin so keen to get involved on a no fee basis?
-
If you can't answer that question then your theory falls at the first hurdle. It's based on assunptions. Assume nothing, the police are told. Good advice which some theorisers should take on board imo.
Well you look through the file - who had the key to apartment 5A at 4:30 AM on the 4th?
-
But we are told that no-one else died in the apartment. Both dogs alerted and samples were tested for a DNA match (to various family members and maybe also the T7).
That's misleading. No one needed to die in the apartment for the dogs to alert:
The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died. This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.
Page 25:
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf
Primary contamination is clearly an issue but what about secondary contamination?
The DNA tests were described as inconclusive:
- Inconclusive results -- Results may be inconclusive for several reasons. For example, contaminated samples often yield inconclusive results. So do very small or degraded samples, which may not have enough DNA to produce a full profile.
-
There's not a shred of forensic evidence against the McCanns just a witch-hunt.
-
There's not a shred of forensic evidence against the McCanns just a witch-hunt.
Except the PJ thought there was a badly told story. If there was nothing to hide I don't think there would be so many discrepancies noted by the PJ. OK some might think they were trying to hide the childcare methods. I don't know but could it be more than that?
-
Well you look through the file - who had the key to apartment 5A at 4:30 AM on the 4th?
I think I'll pass, thank you, because in my opinion the one coming up with the theory is the one who needs to find the evidence to support it. According to the PJ;
the apartments and the surrounding area were sealed off, watched over by the GNR officers who remained on site.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOAO_BARREIRAS.htm
He then states that upon leaving the apartment was locked, leaving the space preserved for the GNR elements that were stationed next to the apartment.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VITOR_MARTINS.htm#p15p3862
-
I think I'll pass, thank you, because in my opinion the one coming up with the theory is the one who needs to find the evidence to support it. According to the PJ;
the apartments and the surrounding area were sealed off, watched over by the GNR officers who remained on site.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOAO_BARREIRAS.htm
He then states that upon leaving the apartment was locked, leaving the space preserved for the GNR elements that were stationed next to the apartment.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VITOR_MARTINS.htm#p15p3862
So it could be locked and the key given to the GNR for safe keeping, or to the reception staff at the 24 hour reception. Who held the key?
-
There's not a shred of forensic evidence against the McCanns just a witch-hunt.
Not all evidence is forensic and a lack of it rules no-one out.
-
There's not a shred of forensic evidence against the McCanns just a witch-hunt.
Or a witch hunt to try and prove it was anyone but them,12yrs on flip a coin its all in the air.
-
Except the PJ thought there was a badly told story. If there was nothing to hide I don't think there would be so many discrepancies noted by the PJ. OK some might think they were trying to hide the childcare methods. I don't know but could it be more than that?
But you see this sort of thing in all cases where the police struggling to conclude a case come up with all sorts which at the end of the day lack evidential value.
To most the "childcare arrangements" seem bizarre but that does not mean the McCanns or T7 were involved in MM's disappearance.
I've said loads of time when MM disappeared the penny suddenly dropped with T9:
- How was to going to look (authorities, media, friends, family work colleagues etc, etc) that T9 were at tapas quaffing wine and food leaving children alone every night from 8.30 pm to 11 pm/midnight? KM tells in her book she could not bring herself to tell her parents, GM did. Susan Healy subsequently said she was surprised KM and GM left the children alone.
- Was anyone going to have to answer to the authorities about child neglect?
- What sort of view would the GMC take?
- The McCanns not only left the children home alone but worse still left the patio doors unlocked.
- Were the checks as T9 claimed or were they simply going round the front and listening at the shutters? Did they leave slats open on the shutters and window slightly open to look/listen in?
-
Not all evidence is forensic and a lack of it rules no-one out.
I agree not all evidence is forensic but I can't see any evidence at all just people's interpretation of events.
When you say rules no one out...who is doing the ruling? As far as I can see its not even trial by media but trial but social media.
-
Or a witch hunt to try and prove it was anyone but them,12yrs on flip a coin its all in the air.
Have the McCanns ever seized on any particular individual(s) and embarked on a witch-hunt by social media?
-
Have the McCanns ever seized on any particular individual(s) and embarked on a witch-hunt by social media?
There would be no money in that!
-
So it could be locked and the key given to the GNR for safe keeping, or to the reception staff at the 24 hour reception. Who held the key?
In an ideal world OC/MW would operate Keycard locks:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keycard_lock
In reality no one knows who had a key to 5A. Previous holidaymakers staying in 5A may have had keys cut. The owners no doubt had a set of keys. Mrs Fenn as a permanent resident above may have been given a key to hold by the owners. And so it goes on and on.
-
There would be no money in that!
What do you mean?
-
But you see this sort of thing in all cases where the police struggling to conclude a case come up with all sorts which at the end of the day lack evidential value.
To most the "childcare arrangements" seem bizarre but that does not mean the McCanns or T7 were involved in MM's disappearance.
I've said loads of time when MM disappeared the penny suddenly dropped with T9:
- How was to going to look (authorities, media, friends, family work colleagues etc, etc) that T9 were at tapas quaffing wine and food leaving children alone every night from 8.30 pm to 11 pm/midnight? KM tells in her book she could not bring herself to tell her parents, GM did. Susan Healy subsequently said she was surprised KM and GM left the children alone.
- Was anyone going to have to answer to the authorities about child neglect?
- What sort of view would the GMC take?
- The McCanns not only left the children home alone but worse still left the patio doors unlocked.
- Were the checks as T9 claimed or were they simply going round the front and listening at the shutters? Did they leave slats open on the shutters and window slightly open to look/listen in?
So in your opinion they muddied the waters to protect themselves from censure arising from their childcare arrangements. That's perfectly believable, although less than helpful. It also amounts to putting their own interests before those of a missing child.
There's nothing ruling out one or more of them taking advantage of the fears of the others to hide something else, either imo.
-
Have the McCanns ever seized on any particular individual(s) and embarked on a witch-hunt by social media?
There was one individual in particular who was wished to feel fear.
-
So in your opinion they muddied the waters to protect themselves from censure arising from their childcare arrangements. That's perfectly believable, although less than helpful. It also amounts to putting their own interests before those of a missing child.
No it's not really my opinion I'm just saying it's possible for the reasons I've given.
There's nothing ruling out one or more of them taking advantage of the fears of the others to hide something else, either imo.
Such as and on what basis?
-
There was one individual in particular who was wished to feel fear.
Are you able/willing to expand?
-
I agree not all evidence is forensic but I can't see any evidence at all just people's interpretation of events.
When you say rules no one out...who is doing the ruling? As far as I can see its not even trial by media but trial but social media.
It seems to be generally agreed that when a child of Madeleine's age dusappears the prime suspects are those closest to her. That means the parents and their friends in this case. So how can they be ruled out?
-
It seems to be generally agreed that when a child of Madeleine's age dusappears the prime suspects are those closest to her. That means the parents and their friends in this case. So how can they be ruled out?
All the research shows when small children disappear or some foul play is involved often someone known to the child is responsible. I guess it stands to reason in that small children are usually only ever in the company of those known to them. But 'often' is the operative word. In this case I can't see any evidence whatsoever that the McCanns or T7 were involved.
They can't be completely ruled out until such time any further developments take place.
-
All the research shows when small children disappear or some foul play is involved often someone known to the child is responsible. I guess it stands to reason in that small children are usually only ever in the company of those known to them. But 'often' is the operative word. In this case I can't see any evidence whatsoever that the McCanns or T7 were involved.
They can't be completely ruled out until such time any further developments take place.
Going by that thinking should be the parents and friends who has access to MBM during the hours of her 'sleeping' NOT be the main initial suspects? What about walked and wandered, why isn't that a serious contenter ?why does the narrative of an abduction to order from a prep be a real choice of theories?
Can we have a few more dog threads.. at least another 6. thanks
Some choice titles
1 do dogs bark
2 do dogs wag their tails
3 can dogs chase their tails
...
-
There's not a shred of forensic evidence against the McCanns just a witch-hunt.
There are actually 15 DNA markers in common with MM but more than one contributor. Dr Perlin whose methods are approved by State used US forensic science laboratories has tested methods to successfully make sense of the data with the True Allele software.
“Not a shred of evidence” isn’t accurate is it? There is evidence but the link to MM remains unproven because analysis was “too complex” to allow for a meaningful interpretation.
-
Going by that thinking should be the parents and friends who has access to MBM during the hours of her 'sleeping' NOT be the main initial suspects? What about walked and wandered, why isn't that a serious contenter ?why does the narrative of an abduction to order from a prep be a real choice of theories?
Can we have a few more dog threads.. at least another 6. thanks
Some choice titles
1 do dogs bark
2 do dogs wag their tails
3 can dogs chase their tails
...
4 Wild dogs of the Algarve
5 Rogue dog
-
The theory went this way. At some point between hiring the hire car in the last few weeks of May and having the car tested by the dogs in August it was used to move a frozen cadaver. Well the clothes don't need to be affected if the move occurred after the time they left 4G (was that in early July)? I forget all the dates.
The thing is if the cadaver was frozen there is no rush to move it.
If you accept that a frozen cadaver was moved in the hire car then yes that would explain the alerts in the car but not 4G. It would explain why both Eddie and Keela alerted to the car. It would explain why forensic scientists were able to locate human cellular material, and of course this material would have MM’s DNA profile. However, this explanation is not proven because the DNA results were “too complex for meaningful interpretation”.. That was in 2007.... now the offer is there to reach a meaningful interpretation using APPROVED and verified forensic science computer profiling... IMO this offer should not be turned down.
-
Did we ever hear of DNA evidence being too complex to interpret before 2007, or is this a McCann phenomena ?
-
Did we ever hear of DNA evidence being too complex to interpret before 2007, or is this a McCann phenomena ?
To be fair I think there must have been many other instances before 2007. The point is that the offer is now there to make a meaningful interpretation.. People here might attempt to discredit Dr Perlin the actual fact is his methods are fully researched, validated and approved
-
In which case? Matthews or McCann?
McCann.
-
To be fair I think there must have been many other instances before 2007. The point is that the offer is now there to make a meaningful interpretation.. People here might attempt to discredit Dr Perlin the actual fact is his methods are fully researched, validated and approved
What do you think his methods would establish that would take the case forward?
-
There are actually 15 DNA markers in common with MM but more than one contributor. Dr Perlin whose methods are approved by State used US forensic science laboratories has tested methods to successfully make sense of the data with the True Allele software.
“Not a shred of evidence” isn’t accurate is it? There is evidence but the link to MM remains unproven because analysis was “too complex” to allow for a meaningful interpretation.
15 markers out of how many?
Perlin holds a medical degree (as do the McCanns and some of the tapas crowd) and doctoral degrees in mathematics and computer science. What exactly qualifies him in the field of bio-science?
Please provide evidence from FSS where they use the term "too complex" to enable us to understand the context. As it stands I doubt "too complex" means 'we can't figure it out' but rather the sample was "too complex" in that it contained DNA from multiple sources and/or degraded and/or incomplete. If good quality dna does not exist it cannot simply be conjured up. I keep pointing out that the test used in this case was LCN as opposed to say STR. LCN works off samples 1,000,000 th the size of a grain of sand where it isn't even possible to identify the source eg blood, saliva, skin cells etc.
Why is Perlin so keen to undertake a review on a pro bono basis?
-
To be fair I think there must have been many other instances before 2007. The point is that the offer is now there to make a meaningful interpretation.. People here might attempt to discredit Dr Perlin the actual fact is his methods are fully researched, validated and approved
Yes there are many other cases which begs the question why is Perlin so keen to involve himself with this case on a pro-bono basis?
-
If you accept that a frozen cadaver was moved in the hire car then yes that would explain the alerts in the car but not 4G. It would explain why both Eddie and Keela alerted to the car. It would explain why forensic scientists were able to locate human cellular material, and of course this material would have MM’s DNA profile. However, this explanation is not proven because the DNA results were “too complex for meaningful interpretation”.. That was in 2007.... now the offer is there to reach a meaningful interpretation using APPROVED and verified forensic science computer profiling... IMO this offer should not be turned down.
So what? Even if a sample from the hire car was a 100% match to Maddie it wouldn't prove anything so what would be the point exactly?
-
Yes there are many other cases which begs the question why is Perlin so keen to involve himself with this case on a pro-bono basis?
Well we all know the answer to that don't we.
-
If you accept that a frozen cadaver was moved in the hire car then yes that would explain the alerts in the car but not 4G. It would explain why both Eddie and Keela alerted to the car. It would explain why forensic scientists were able to locate human cellular material, and of course this material would have MM’s DNA profile. However, this explanation is not proven because the DNA results were “too complex for meaningful interpretation”.. That was in 2007.... now the offer is there to reach a meaningful interpretation using APPROVED and verified forensic science computer profiling... IMO this offer should not be turned down.
Can you post up please the source of "too complex for meaningful interpretation" to enable us to understand the context. Thanks.
-
Well we all know the answer to that don't we.
8(0(*
-
Can you post up please the source of "too complex for meaningful interpretation" to enable us to understand the context. Thanks.
Is this what you want ?
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm
-
Well we all know the answer to that don't we.
I guess its a good business ploy
-
In an ideal world OC/MW would operate Keycard locks:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keycard_lock
In reality no one knows who had a key to 5A. Previous holidaymakers staying in 5A may have had keys cut. The owners no doubt had a set of keys. Mrs Fenn as a permanent resident above may have been given a key to hold by the owners. And so it goes on and on.
You are beginning to sound like Sadie.
-
What do you mean?
It is a joke. Haven't you heard the McCanns lost their child so they could make a personal fortune, and the only one with real money were the mainstream media who would payout handsomely for damages, especially good returns when Carter Ruck would work on a no win no fee basis.
-
Going by that thinking should be the parents and friends who has access to MBM during the hours of her 'sleeping' NOT be the main initial suspects? What about walked and wandered, why isn't that a serious contenter ?why does the narrative of an abduction to order from a prep be a real choice of theories?
Can we have a few more dog threads.. at least another 6. thanks
Some choice titles
1 do dogs bark
2 do dogs wag their tails
3 can dogs chase their tails
...
No. That is an emphatic no.
-
4 Wild dogs of the Algarve
5 Rogue dog
Both of those topics would go off track and begin discussing Goncalo Amaral IMO.
-
If you accept that a frozen cadaver was moved in the hire car then yes that would explain the alerts in the car but not 4G. It would explain why both Eddie and Keela alerted to the car. It would explain why forensic scientists were able to locate human cellular material, and of course this material would have MM’s DNA profile. However, this explanation is not proven because the DNA results were “too complex for meaningful interpretation”.. That was in 2007.... now the offer is there to reach a meaningful interpretation using APPROVED and verified forensic science computer profiling... IMO this offer should not be turned down.
"IMO this offer should not be turned down."
Oh I agree, but it isn't going to happen IMO.
The reason why is that it can never show it was Madeleine but only someone else. Madeleine had 19 markers and 4 are missing, so no amount of analysis is going to bring back the other 4 for her.
-
Did we ever hear of DNA evidence being too complex to interpret before 2007, or is this a McCann phenomena ?
DNA testing is always going to improve.
-
So what? Even if a sample from the hire car was a 100% match to Maddie it wouldn't prove anything so what would be the point exactly?
I can't see how you can ever get a 100% match to Madeleine.
-
I guess its a good business ploy
Quickest and cheapest way to get some free press and publicity is to link to the McCann case.
-
I can't see how you can ever get a 100% match to Madeleine.
If it was her DNA you can.
-
Can you post up please the source of "too complex for meaningful interpretation" to enable us to understand the context. Thanks.
It’s the final report from Lowe / FSS. I’ll post up link when I’m not typing on a phone!! 😁🤓
-
So what? Even if a sample from the hire car was a 100% match to Maddie it wouldn't prove anything so what would be the point exactly?
It would depend on the source of the DNA (i.e from blood, saliva, urine etc).... And anyway, it's for exactly the same reason the FSS examined the human material (after the cadaver and blood dog alerts) to establish DNA evidence. Everything helps build up a picture of the objective reality.
-
It would depend on the source of the DNA (i.e from blood, saliva, urine etc).
It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN.
-
Is this what you want ?
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm
Yes, thanks.
-
It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN.
I'll take your word for that... but ask the question should it be: "It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN" or "It isn't always possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN"... And is it the case they use that technique because they only have microscopic amounts? Finally, I'm no expert but surely blood cells compared to urine for example are identifiable under a microscope?
OK - one more thing! Why didn't the FSS say we can't identify the source of the DNA, we only have microscopic amounts, it's entirely possible that we do not have the DNA from the substances that Eddie and Keela alerted to so this whole test is a complete waste of time. You'd think if that was the case they would have said so at the time????
-
What do you think his methods would establish that would take the case forward?
It would contribute towards the question was MM's corpse transfered in the hire car.... or did MM bleed behind the sofa and this was cleaned up so well that only a few remnants were left seeping into the floor tile grout... This would lead to new aspects to investigate. We know GM was asked if MM had lost blood in the apartment.
However, where that would lead ultimately - I don't know. Could reasonable doubt be created? probably!:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3012025/ (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3012025/)
Forensic trace DNA: a review
Transfer issues
Throughout the years of trace DNA use, the major focus has been on improving techniques in order to obtain highly discriminating genetic profiles from minute amounts to help identify the person from whom the DNA at a crime scene is derived. However, much less effort has been expended on understanding the activities that explain how the DNA got there.
Although the first report on trace DNA identified the occurrence of secondary transfer [51], debate regarding the existence of secondary transfer followed for several years [212]. However, empirical research has since demonstrated substantial levels of transfer under a variety of situations, confirming that secondary, and possibly further transfer, may well be occurring in a number of casework situations [210,213-215].
Greater effort needs to be made by police/crime investigators to investigate how a DNA sample arrived at the location where it was found, as well as by scientists to better understand the impact of activities on the relative amounts of DNA from particular sources at a crime scene. In some instances, it is possible to derive the chain of events that led to a trace DNA sample being present at a crime scene - for example, prior visits to the scene or the known use of an item. Awareness of these variables, and their impact on transfer events, will assist in weighting the likelihood of proposed alternative scenarios. Some preliminary contributions to our knowledge of transfer in relation to residential burglary and street robbery have recently been made [67]. Others have also started collecting this type of data with preliminary investigations focusing on the type of biological material being deposited, the condition of the biological material, the type of substrate on which the biological material is present and with which it comes into contact and the manner of contact [216-218]. It is clear that more data on these and other variables are necessary to improve the accuracy of the likelihood assessment of alternative scenarios.
-
I'll take your word for that... but ask the question should it be: "It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN" or "It isn't always possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN"... And is it the case they use that technique because they only have microscopic amounts? Finally, I'm no expert but surely blood cells compared to urine for example are identifiable under a microscope?
OK - one more thing! Why didn't the FSS say we can't identify the source of the DNA, we only have microscopic amounts, it's entirely possible that we do not have the DNA from the substances that Eddie and Keela alerted to so this whole test is a complete waste of time. You'd think if that was the case they would have said so at the time????
No need to take my word its stated quite explicitly in the FSS reports Jassi uploaded:
LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.
How can scientists determine the particular body fluid when they're dealing with samples as small as 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt which in many cases are incomplete and degraded?
The FSS have said as much in the reports Jassi uploaded.
LCN is only used when the samples are invisible to the naked eye/degraded/incomplete. LCN = low copy number. The material is amplified up.
-
No need to take my word its stated quite explicitly in the FSS reports Jassi uploaded:
LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.
How can scientists determine the particular body fluid when they're dealing with samples as small as 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt which in many cases are incomplete and degraded?
I read that as the FSS could not attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid... i.e specific only to that particular sample. I don't know if that's always the case with low copy DNA. Circumstantially however we know what Eddie and Keela are trained to alert to. But I do concede that in all likelihood with the evidence presently available reasonable doubt could be argued with regards to the validity of any possible criminal charges towards any suspects.
-
I read that as the FSS could not attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid... i.e specific only to that particular sample. I don't know if that's always the case with low copy DNA. Circumstantially however we know what Eddie and Keela are trained to alert to. But I do concede that in all likelihood with the evidence presently available reasonable doubt could be argued with regards to the validity of any possible criminal charges towards any suspects.
Several DNA profiling techniques exist eg Short Tandem Repeat (STR) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR). Low Copy Number (LCN) is used to profile small samples which often contain DNA from multiple sources and/or degraded samples. And when I say small I mean, as I've said previously, 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt.
Assuming Keela was alerting to blood there's not a shred of evidence this originated from MM through some foul play. Numerous individuals have stayed at 5A probably running into thousands. Others have also attended eg constriction workers, cleaners, maintenance personnel etc.
Even the witness statements of recent holiday makers talk of cuts. Eg Claire Fawkes talks of her young daughter cutting her chin and Saleigh Gordon talks of her husband cutting himself shaving.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SA-L-GO.htm
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CLAIRE_FAWKES.htm
There's not even a tiny shred of evidence to suggest the McCanns and/or T7 were involved in MM's disappearance.
-
As I understand it if the sample is large enough to identify the type of cells e.g. blood or body fluid there is no need for the multiplication that is a feature of the LCN technique.
Low Copy Number:
Wikipedia.
"It is a more sensitive technique because it involves a greater amount of copying via polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from a smaller amount of starting material, meaning that a profile can be obtained from only a few cells, which may be as small as a millionth the size of a grain of salt, and amount to just a few cells of skin or sweat left from a fingerprint.[2]"
https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/low-copy-number
Low Copy Number
Low copy number (LCN) is defined as less than 100 pg of DNA or the equivalent of the DNA contained in 15 to 17 diploid cells (Gill, 2001).
-
Several DNA profiling techniques exist eg Short Tandem Repeat (STR) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR). Low Copy Number (LCN) is used to profile small samples which often contain DNA from multiple sources and/or degraded samples. And when I say small I mean, as I've said previously, 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt.
Assuming Keela was alerting to blood there's not a shred of evidence this originated from MM through some foul play. Numerous individuals have stayed at 5A probably running into thousands. Others have also attended eg constriction workers, cleaners, maintenance personnel etc.
Even the witness statements of recent holiday makers talk of cuts. Eg Claire Fawkes talks of her young daughter cutting her chin and Saleigh Gordon talks of her husband cutting himself shaving.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SA-L-GO.htm
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CLAIRE_FAWKES.htm
There's not even a tiny shred of evidence to suggest the McCanns and/or T7 were involved in MM's disappearance.
Well you can keep telling yourself that there's "not even a tiny shred of evidence...."
However, if Keela's alerts could be explained away by the possibility that hundreds (or thousands) of other people might have bled in apartment 5A.... you certainly can't say that about cadavers and the fact that Eddie also alerted in the apartment and hire car. There are no records of cadavers in 5A previously.... Additionally why was it only in apartment 5A that Eddie detected blood when hundreds of people might have also bled in the other apartments? And don't you find it incredibly coincidental that material collected in an area that both dogs alerted material was found to have at least 15 DNA markers that MM had.... How do you explain 17 alerts to possibly hundreds of people's blood and cadaver odour but for some reason only the McCann's apartment, hire car, and other articles have been alerted to. Surely, if these are random alerts to the blood and transferred cadaver odour from other people the odds of all 17 alerts being directed towards only one family would be tiny, IMO.
This is why it is so important to try and get a conclusive interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It would help us understand what has happened. It would narrow down reasonable scenarios, and allow us to filter out some of the nonsense. Doesn't everyone want justice after all?
-
Well you can keep telling yourself that there's "not even a tiny shred of evidence...."
However, if Keela's alerts could be explained away by the possibility that hundreds (or thousands) of other people might have bled in apartment 5A.... you certainly can't say that about cadavers and the fact that Eddie also alerted in the apartment and hire car. There are no records of cadavers in 5A previously.... Additionally why was it only in apartment 5A that Eddie detected blood when hundreds of people might have also bled in the other apartments? And don't you find it incredibly coincidental that material collected in an area that both dogs alerted material was found to have at least 15 DNA markers that MM had.... How do you explain 17 alerts to possibly hundreds of people's blood and cadaver odour but for some reason only the McCann's apartment, hire car, and other articles have been alerted to. Surely, if these are random alerts to the blood and transferred cadaver odour from other people the odds of all 17 alerts being directed towards only one family would be tiny, IMO.
This is why it is so important to try and get a conclusive interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It would help us understand what has happened. It would narrow down reasonable scenarios, and allow us to filter out some of the nonsense. Doesn't everyone want justice after all?
I'm not sure that Keela was taken through the other apartments to look for blood. From memory Eddie was taken through and in the areas where he alerted Keela then gets her turn to isolate blood.
In the other apartments Eddie did not alert hence IIRC Keela wasn't sent in.
-
As I understand it if the sample is large enough to identify the type of cells e.g. blood or body fluid there is no need for the multiplication that is a feature of the LCN technique.
Low Copy Number:
Wikipedia.
"It is a more sensitive technique because it involves a greater amount of copying via polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from a smaller amount of starting material, meaning that a profile can be obtained from only a few cells, which may be as small as a millionth the size of a grain of salt, and amount to just a few cells of skin or sweat left from a fingerprint.[2]"
https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/low-copy-number
Low Copy Number
Low copy number (LCN) is defined as less than 100 pg of DNA or the equivalent of the DNA contained in 15 to 17 diploid cells (Gill, 2001).
I'm interested to know why even one cell can't be identified. We know that human cellular material was collected following the dog alerts. There are 200 different types of cells in the human body. Each of the 200 different types of cells in the body has a different structure, size, shape, and function, and contains different organelles.
-
I'm interested to know why even one cell can't be identified. We know that human cellular material was collected following the dog alerts. There are 200 different types of cells in the human body. Each of the 200 different types of cells in the body has a different structure, size, shape, and function, and contains different organelles.
It is a good question but I think it would be a matter of finding it on the microscope slide. Generally you have billions to choose from so when you see a cell, you are not looking at a specific cell but just the cell that is in your field of vision.
-
I'm not sure that Keela was taken through the other apartments to look for blood. From memory Eddie was taken through and in the areas where he alerted Keela then gets her turn to isolate blood.
In the other apartments Eddie did not alert hence IIRC Keela wasn't sent in.
Yes you're correct - that's a fair point.
This debate though highlights the importance of better interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It's entirely reasonable to cast doubt by pointing out all the other people that blood might have come from.... If it can be proved that the cellular material did come from MM that should be significant.... except of course people will then say it might not be blood.... I hope they have preserved some of the evidence (though I don't believe the FSS preserved the body fluid samples) because cell type identification methods employed in forensic science are improving all the time:
https://www.dovepress.com/forensic-body-fluid-identification-state-of-the-art-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRFMS (https://www.dovepress.com/forensic-body-fluid-identification-state-of-the-art-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRFMS)
Conclusion
Body fluid identification is an important aspect in criminal investigations and as advancements in technology have improved, the ability to detect and identify body fluids has also improved. At the crime scene, quick and easy-to-use presumptive tests have been used to locate and indicate the body fluid of interest, with confirmatory testing being available in the laboratory
-
Yes you're correct - that's a fair point.
This debate though highlights the importance of better interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It's entirely reasonable to cast doubt by pointing out all the other people that blood might have come from.... If it can be proved that the cellular material did come from MM that should be significant.... except of course people will then say it might not be blood.... I hope they have preserved some of the evidence (though I don't believe the FSS preserved the body fluid samples) because cell type identification methods employed in forensic science are improving all the time:
https://www.dovepress.com/forensic-body-fluid-identification-state-of-the-art-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRFMS (https://www.dovepress.com/forensic-body-fluid-identification-state-of-the-art-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRFMS)
With these very small samples that LCN DNA analysis (LCN) use it is either identify it or run the DNA analysis, you can't do both with the same sample.
-
Well you can keep telling yourself that there's "not even a tiny shred of evidence...."
However, if Keela's alerts could be explained away by the possibility that hundreds (or thousands) of other people might have bled in apartment 5A.... you certainly can't say that about cadavers and the fact that Eddie also alerted in the apartment and hire car. There are no records of cadavers in 5A previously.... Additionally why was it only in apartment 5A that Eddie detected blood when hundreds of people might have also bled in the other apartments? And don't you find it incredibly coincidental that material collected in an area that both dogs alerted material was found to have at least 15 DNA markers that MM had.... How do you explain 17 alerts to possibly hundreds of people's blood and cadaver odour but for some reason only the McCann's apartment, hire car, and other articles have been alerted to. Surely, if these are random alerts to the blood and transferred cadaver odour from other people the odds of all 17 alerts being directed towards only one family would be tiny, IMO.
This is why it is so important to try and get a conclusive interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It would help us understand what has happened. It would narrow down reasonable scenarios, and allow us to filter out some of the nonsense. Doesn't everyone want justice after all?
I don't need to keep telling myself there's not a shred of evidence against the McCanns no more than I need to tell myself the earth is round or if an apple falls from a branch with an unimpeded flight it will fall to the ground. They're all scientifically proven facts.
There is no way to get a conclusive interpretation of the LCN DNA collected from 5A. And the cadaver dog alerts are meaningless since its proven they alert around inanimate objects that have had contact with the odour and subsequently moved elsewhere.
If everyone wants justice I would suggest they start looking away from the McCanns/T7.
-
I don't need to keep telling myself there's not a shred of evidence against the McCanns no more than I need to tell myself the earth is round or if an apple falls from a branch with an unimpeded flight it will fall to the ground. They're all scientifically proven facts.
There is no way to get a conclusive interpretation of the LCN DNA collected from 5A. And the cadaver dog alerts are meaningless since its proven they alert around inanimate objects that have had contact with the odour and subsequently moved elsewhere.
If everyone wants justice I would suggest they start looking away from the McCanns/T7.
So please tell us which inanimate objects had contact "with the odour" and were subsequently moved into apartment 5A and the hire car? In the Matthews case it didn't take 12 years to establish that the dog alert is to second hand furniture from a room where a corpse was present. Incidentally, isn't that great work by the cadaver dog that people are keen to discredit!!?
-
I don't need to keep telling myself there's not a shred of evidence against the McCanns no more than I need to tell myself the earth is round or if an apple falls from a branch with an unimpeded flight it will fall to the ground. They're all scientifically proven facts.
There is no way to get a conclusive interpretation of the LCN DNA collected from 5A. And the cadaver dog alerts are meaningless since its proven they alert around inanimate objects that have had contact with the odour and subsequently moved elsewhere.
If everyone wants justice I would suggest they start looking away from the McCanns/T7.
kate had contact with father Pacheo...who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest...there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse
-
kate had contact with father Pacheo...who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest...there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse
Cite please as are you saying this contact occurred at a time that would cause the dogs to alert in 5A.
"kate had contact with father Pacheo..." When did this happen?
"who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest..." No cite required for this part.
"there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse" Show us how you think that affected the status of apartment 5A?
-
Cite please as are you saying this contact occurred at a time that would cause the dogs to alert in 5A.
"kate had contact with father Pacheo..." When did this happen?
"who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest..." No cite required for this part.
"there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse" Show us how you think that affected the status of apartment 5A?
kate had contact with father pacheo...thats an established fact
as regards cross contamination...grime himself confirms the alerts could be as a result of several scenarios...again an established fact
its on record that father pacheo gave the mccanns the keys to the church...could the keys have been contaminated
https://mmknowthetruth.blogspot.com/2017/03/i-was-deceived-says-portuguese-priest.html
-
kate had contact with father pacheo...thats an established fact
as regards cross contamination...grime himself confirms the alerts could be as a result of several scenarios...again an established fact
its on record that father pacheo gave the mccanns the keys to the church...could the keys have been contaminated
When did this happen and how could that contact affect the status of apartment 5A.
-
When did this happen and how could that contact affect the status of apartment 5A.
the church keys could be contaminated with cadaver odour
-
...see post above
I am requesting a cite. Has Fr. Pacheo been referenced on the forum before. A Cite is not just a statement "it is common knowledge", for it isn't common knowledge at all.
the church keys could be contaminated with cadaver odour
What are you saying the keys were given to the McCanns on the night of the 3rd/morning of the 4th?
-
Davel are you going to provide a cite or shall I delete your post?
-
the church keys could be contaminated with cadaver odour
That very precise possibility should have been tested using the cadaver dogs but I don't believe it was. As you and others have pointed out, Eddie was not trained using a cadaver when the police deployed him to Portugal so he alerted to other substances.
-
Davel are you going to provide a cite or shall I delete your post?
A cite for what.. Please be specific. I've provided a cite
-
A cite for what.. Please be specific. I've provided a cite
#108 http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10917.msg548608#msg548608
"Cite please as are you saying this contact occurred at a time that would cause the dogs to alert in 5A.
"kate had contact with father Pacheo..." When did this happen?
"who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest..." No cite required for this part.
"there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse" Show us how you think that affected the status of apartment 5A?
-
#108
"Cite please as are you saying this contact occurred at a time that would cause the dogs to alert in 5A.
"kate had contact with father Pacheo..." When did this happen?
"who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest..." No cite required for this part.
"there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse" Show us how you think that affected the status of apartment 5A?
The dogs alerted in August as I understand.. . Contamination
could have occurred anytime before August in that case
-
#108
"Cite please as are you saying this contact occurred at a time that would cause the dogs to alert in 5A.
"kate had contact with father Pacheo..." When did this happen?
"who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest..." No cite required for this part.
"there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse" Show us how you think that affected the status of apartment 5A?
Jose Manuel Conceicao Pacheco
The first time he had contact with the McCann's was on 5th May at about 19.00. This was a personal contact with them in the Ocean Club at their apartment, but not the apartment Madeleine disappeared from. They were accompanied by members of the holiday group.
He gave them the key to the church on the 7th or 8th May upon the suggestion of John Geraghty, a resident of the parish, so that they could calmly go to the church without any media pressure. Someone from the church gave the key to John Geraghty, who then passed it on to the McCann's, with Father Pacheco's permission.
Other contact with the McCann's took place at the end of mass when he would comfort them.
He would also meet with the McCann's after they returned from their trips and remembered they were animated when they returned from Morocco as they thought they would Madeleine there. He also comforted Kate when the news of a child buried in Arau broke, as she revealed great nervousness and anxiety, thinking that the child had died.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FATHER_PACHECO.htm
-
The dogs alerted in August as I understand.. . Contamination
could have occurred anytime before August in that case
John: Please note that Davel is not attempting to follow the rules on providing cites.
Davel: When did Fr. Pacheo give the McCanns keys to the Church? Did it happen before the date when the McCanns lost access to the apartment 5A?
-
That very precise possibility should have been tested using the cadaver dogs but I don't believe it was. As you and others have pointed out, Eddie was not trained using a cadaver when the police deployed him to Portugal so he alerted to other substances.
Why is the report dated August 2007 the same time as the dog alerts in Luz then.
Portimao 23 August 2007
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
Eddie & Keela Martin Grime Report
August 2007
'Eddie' The Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog (E.V.R.D.) will search for and
locate human remains and body fluids including blood in any environment or
terrain. The initial training of the dog was conducted using human blood and
stil born decomposing piglets. The importance of this is that the dog is
introduced to the scent of a decomposing body NOT FOODSTUFF. This
ensures that the dog disregards the 'bacon sandwich' and 'kebab' etc that is
ever present in the background environment. Therefore the dog would
remain efficient searching for a cadaver in a café where the clientele were sat
eating bacon sandwiches. He has additionally trained exclusively using
human remains in the U.S.A. in association with the F.B.I. The enhanced
training of the dog has also involved the use of collection of 'cadaver scent'
odor from human corpses using remote technical equipment which does not
contact the subject. This method is comparable to the simulation of cross
contamination. It does however differ in that the remote scent samples
recovery does not involve subject matter and therefore is a 'pure' scent
sample. The dog has since initial training gained considerable experience in
successfully operationally locating human remains and evidential forensic
material.
-
#108 http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10917.msg548608#msg548608
"Cite please as are you saying this contact occurred at a time that would cause the dogs to alert in 5A.
"kate had contact with father Pacheo..." When did this happen?
"who no doubt conducted funerals and may have had contact with corpses in his role as a priest..." No cite required for this part.
"there are just too many possibilities of cross contamination to simply beleive the dog alerted to maddies corpse" Show us how you think that affected the status of apartment 5A?
when did this happen... I havent claimed a specific time but its common knowledge and Ive providea acite it happened...therefore no right to remove post
there are several scenarios... Grime himself said the same ...that could have resulted in cadaver alerts
-
John: Please note that Davel is not attempting to follow the rules on providing cites.
Davel: When did Fr. Pacheo give the McCanns keys to the Church? Did it happen before the date when the McCanns lost access to the apartment 5A?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10917.msg548627#msg548627
-
Why is the report dated August 2007 the same time as the dog alerts in Luz then.
Portimao 23 August 2007
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
Eddie & Keela Martin Grime Report
August 2007
'Eddie' The Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog (E.V.R.D.) will search for and
locate human remains and body fluids including blood in any environment or
terrain. The initial training of the dog was conducted using human blood and
stil born decomposing piglets. The importance of this is that the dog is
introduced to the scent of a decomposing body NOT FOODSTUFF. This
ensures that the dog disregards the 'bacon sandwich' and 'kebab' etc that is
ever present in the background environment. Therefore the dog would
remain efficient searching for a cadaver in a café where the clientele were sat
eating bacon sandwiches. He has additionally trained exclusively using
human remains in the U.S.A. in association with the F.B.I. The enhanced
training of the dog has also involved the use of collection of 'cadaver scent'
odor from human corpses using remote technical equipment which does not
contact the subject. This method is comparable to the simulation of cross
contamination. It does however differ in that the remote scent samples
recovery does not involve subject matter and therefore is a 'pure' scent
sample. The dog has since initial training gained considerable experience in
successfully operationally locating human remains and evidential forensic
material.
If that additional training was given after the time Eddie alerted in the McCann case Martin Grime has committed a serious offence IMO.
-
John: Please note that Davel is not attempting to follow the rules on providing cites.
Davel: When did Fr. Pacheo give the McCanns keys to the Church? Did it happen before the date when the McCanns lost access to the apartment 5A?
I said he gave them the keys...Ive provided a cite to support that claim...Ive not specified dates so dont have to provide a cite re dates
-
Jose Manuel Conceicao Pacheco
The first time he had contact with the McCann's was on 5th May at about 19.00. This was a personal contact with them in the Ocean Club at their apartment, but not the apartment Madeleine disappeared from. They were accompanied by members of the holiday group.
He gave them the key to the church on the 7th or 8th May upon the suggestion of John Geraghty, a resident of the parish, so that they could calmly go to the church without any media pressure. Someone from the church gave the key to John Geraghty, who then passed it on to the McCann's, with Father Pacheco's permission.
Other contact with the McCann's took place at the end of mass when he would comfort them.
He would also meet with the McCann's after they returned from their trips and remembered they were animated when they returned from Morocco as they thought they would Madeleine there. He also comforted Kate when the news of a child buried in Arau broke, as she revealed great nervousness and anxiety, thinking that the child had died.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FATHER_PACHECO.htm
OK so even if the key had traces of cadaver odour on it , that odour could not be transferred back to the McCanns original apartment 5A where Eddie also alerted and from where samples were taken and tested using LCN.
-
OK so even if the key had traces of cadaver odour on it , that odour could not be transferred back to the McCanns original apartment 5A where Eddie also alerted and from where samples were taken and tested using LCN.
but could have been transferred to clothes...ther are lots of reasons why the cadaver dog alerted in 5a...the fact that humans are shedding skin constantly means that its not significant cellular material was found
-
but could have been transferred to clothes
I think your whole scenario is OTT.
-
I think your whole scenario is OTT.
I think your theories of two deaths on the same night is OTT..
-
If that additional training was given after the time Eddie alerted in the McCann case Martin Grime has committed a serious offence IMO.
The report to me seems as if training in the US prior to the alerts in Luz,why would he describe training methods after the fact of Luz.
-
but could have been transferred to clothes...ther are lots of reasons why the cadaver dog alerted in 5a...the fact that humans are shedding skin constantly means that its not significant cellular material was found
If that was the case forensic teams would often be wasting their time unless there was visible body matter to collect. Why would they bother if any test was not significant because human cellular material can be found all over the place.
-
If that was the case forensic teams would often be wasting their time unless there was visible body matter to collect. Why would they bother if any test was not significant because human cellular material can be found all over the place.
I think the alerts both in luz and Jersey were a waste of time
150 tonnes of earth and nothing useful found
-
I think the alerts both in luz and Jersey were a waste of time
150 tonnes of earth and nothing useful found
But they had to try as they did in Kos in the hunt for missing youngster Ben Needham.
-
But they had to try as they did in Kos in the hunt for missing youngster Ben Needham.
As I understand there were no children reported missing
-
As I understand there were no children reported missing
It would depend on how good the records were.
-
It would depend on how good the records were.
There were no children reported missing.. Fact
The official review... Posted here.. Was very critical of the decision to dig based on the alerts
-
There were no children reported missing.. Fact
The official review... Posted here.. Was very critical of the decision to dig based on the alerts
Grime didn't turn up without being asked.
-
Grime didn't turn up without being asked.
He was asked.. No one is disputing that... You need to read the report.. It was discussed here recently and was very critical of grimes role
-
He was asked.. No one is disputing that... You need to read the report.. It was discussed here recently and was very critical of grimes role
Easy to blame the dogs. I feel reluctant to involve myself in another case.
-
the church keys could be contaminated with cadaver odour
Reading the statement from Fr. Pacheco, someone handed the keys to Mr Geraghty and that someone wasn't Fr. Pacheco.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FATHER_PACHECO.htm
"Someone from the church gave the key to John Geraghty, who then passed it on to the McCann's, with Father Pacheco's permission."
So it seems rather a stretch to blame Fr. Pacheco for contaminating the key. Were the other two involved with handling a recent cadaver?
-
There were no children reported missing.. Fact
The official review... Posted here.. Was very critical of the decision to dig based on the alerts
For the record it is reported that the official review itself is not without criticism, and that Haut de le Garenne was a place where awful harrowing child sexual abuse took place.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2009/mar/14/haut-de-la-garenne (https://www.theguardian.com/society/2009/mar/14/haut-de-la-garenne)
At his first press conference, on 12 November, Gladwell stunned reporters with his findings: "There were no bodies, no dead children, no credible allegations of murder and no suspects for murder." Only three bone fragments could be definitely said to be human, he said - and they dated from the 14th to 17th centuries. Newspapers ran gleeful headlines: "Lenny Harper lost the plot." By the time we arrived on Jersey in February 2009, a year after the digging had begun, it was as if Harper and his inquiry had never existed.
The Jersey establishment was triumphant. One of the island's most senior social workers expressed a view we were to hear many times: "I'm not saying all the former children's home residents are liars but some have misremembered," he said. "Some have embellished and a small number have been telling porkies to get money." Nothing was wrong with the island. Jersey was off the hook. It was all a cock-up.
Nothing could be further from the truth.
Among the thousands of statements that still line the shelves of Harper's old incident room, and in the testimony of former residents and workers at Haut de la Garenne and other institutions across Jersey, many of whom we tracked down and interviewed, harrowing stories are buried.
Over a period of three decades, residents of the care homes made repeated complaints that they were being sexually and physically abused. A series of damning reports was produced, following confidential inquiries into these institutions, most of which went unheeded. Few prosecutions ensued.
It is true to say there were no corpses. However, the testimony provides compelling evidence of a catastrophic failure within Jersey's children's services that ran a regime so punitive, they preferred to lock up problem children en masse than deal with them in their own homes: four times more children, proportionately, are imprisoned in Jersey than in its nearest neighbour, France. And what happened to them once in care was something that Harper's team, had they not been distracted by murder plots, came close to exposing.
-
He was asked.. No one is disputing that... You need to read the report.. It was discussed here recently and was very critical of grimes role
Have you read Harper's point by point rebuttal of the report ?
-
Have you read Harper's point by point rebuttal of the report ?
It might be best if the discussion about Haut de la Garenne .... was taken across to the the thread on Cadaver dogs. http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10341.0
OP for reminder:
"Swabs were taken from apartment 5A and sent to FSS in UK for analysis. The type of DNA testing used was Low Copy Number (LCN). The FSS found the results inconclusive. Does anyone wish to draw any further inference(s) from this? if so what and on what basis?
Please can we stick to thread topic. Thanks. "
-
I would like a cite from Davel confirming the priests handling of corpses? Not a normal course of events IMO.
-
I would like a cite from Davel confirming the priests handling of corpses? Not a normal course of events IMO.
I've no idea... They touch the coffin which I would think would be contaminated
-
Have you read Harper's point by point rebuttal of the report ?
No.. Post it on the other thread
-
I would like a cite from Davel confirming the priests handling of corpses? Not a normal course of events IMO.
A priest will bless a dead person, usually making the sign of a cross on his/her forehead which means he will touch the corpse, and he will then pray with the family.
-
A priest will bless a dead person, usually making the sign of a cross on his/her forehead which means he will touch the corpse, and he will then pray with the family.
I thought this might be the case
-
A priest will bless a dead person, usually making the sign of a cross on his/her forehead which means he will touch the corpse, and he will then pray with the family.
Usually at around the time of death.
-
Usually at around the time of death.
do they have open coffins in portugal...in church
-
$6(& ft
Usually at around the time of death.
No.
The Sacrament of the sick will be administered to someone who is very ill or even preparing for serious surgery.
However in the case of an unexpected death or death after the Sacrament of the sick has been carried out previously, the priest will be called and will bless the corpse by placing his hand on the forehead and hands of the dead person.
This is a very, very common occurrence.
I have no idea why that little face is there.
-
A priest will bless a dead person, usually making the sign of a cross on his/her forehead which means he will touch the corpse, and he will then pray with the family.
They might stay a quarter of an inch off the skin. How much contact is there really?
-
They might stay a quarter of an inch off the skin. How much contact is there really?
No, the priest lays his hands directly on the forehead and hands of the person who has died.
-
No, the priest lays his hands directly on the forehead and hands of the person who has died.
There is a big difference between a cadaver that has been attended to by undertakers and those that have been left in the environment exposed to the elements after a death.
-
There is a big difference between a cadaver that has been attended to by undertakers and those that have been left in the environment exposed to the elements after a death.
I am unsure of what you mean.
-
I am unsure of what you mean.
One is decomposing and the other is kept cold to stop putrefaction. In normal conditions a body attended to by an undertaker may have no cadaver odour present at the time of laying on of hands by the priest.
-
One is decomposing and the other is kept cold to stop putrefaction. In normal conditions a body attended to by an undertaker may have no cadaver odour present at the time of laying on of hands by the priest.
The priest would attend before.an undertaker
-
The priest would attend before.an undertaker
Even fresher then.
-
It would depend on the source of the DNA (i.e from blood, saliva, urine etc).... And anyway, it's for exactly the same reason the FSS examined the human material (after the cadaver and blood dog alerts) to establish DNA evidence. Everything helps build up a picture of the objective reality.
With respect I think you are grasping at straws on that one.