Author Topic: The LCN DNA test results  (Read 27171 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #90 on: July 27, 2019, 08:53:08 PM »
So what?  Even if a sample from the hire car was a 100% match to Maddie it wouldn't prove anything so what would be the point exactly?

It would depend on the source of the DNA (i.e from blood, saliva, urine etc).... And anyway, it's for exactly the same reason the FSS examined the human material (after the cadaver and blood dog alerts) to establish DNA evidence. Everything helps build up a picture of the objective reality.
« Last Edit: July 27, 2019, 09:30:48 PM by Billy Whizz Fan Club »

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #91 on: July 27, 2019, 09:19:40 PM »
It would depend on the source of the DNA (i.e from blood, saliva, urine etc).

It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN.
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Holly Goodhead

Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #93 on: July 27, 2019, 09:36:57 PM »
It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN.

I'll take your word for that...  but ask the question should it be: "It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN" or "It isn't always possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN"... And is it the case they use that technique because they only have microscopic amounts? Finally, I'm no expert but surely blood cells compared to urine for example are identifiable under a microscope?

OK - one more thing! Why didn't the FSS say we can't identify the source of the DNA, we only have microscopic amounts, it's entirely possible that we do not have the DNA from the substances that Eddie and Keela alerted to so this whole test is a complete waste of time. You'd think if that was the case they would have said so at the time????

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #94 on: July 27, 2019, 09:55:03 PM »
What do you think his methods would establish that would take the case forward?

It would contribute towards the question was MM's corpse transfered in the hire car.... or did MM bleed behind the sofa and this was cleaned up so well that only a few remnants were left seeping into the floor tile grout... This would lead to new aspects to investigate. We know GM was asked if MM had lost blood in the apartment.

However, where that would lead ultimately - I don't know. Could reasonable doubt be created? probably!:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3012025/

Forensic trace DNA: a review

Quote
Transfer issues

Throughout the years of trace DNA use, the major focus has been on improving techniques in order to obtain highly discriminating genetic profiles from minute amounts to help identify the person from whom the DNA at a crime scene is derived. However, much less effort has been expended on understanding the activities that explain how the DNA got there.

Although the first report on trace DNA identified the occurrence of secondary transfer [51], debate regarding the existence of secondary transfer followed for several years [212]. However, empirical research has since demonstrated substantial levels of transfer under a variety of situations, confirming that secondary, and possibly further transfer, may well be occurring in a number of casework situations [210,213-215].

Greater effort needs to be made by police/crime investigators to investigate how a DNA sample arrived at the location where it was found, as well as by scientists to better understand the impact of activities on the relative amounts of DNA from particular sources at a crime scene. In some instances, it is possible to derive the chain of events that led to a trace DNA sample being present at a crime scene - for example, prior visits to the scene or the known use of an item. Awareness of these variables, and their impact on transfer events, will assist in weighting the likelihood of proposed alternative scenarios. Some preliminary contributions to our knowledge of transfer in relation to residential burglary and street robbery have recently been made [67]. Others have also started collecting this type of data with preliminary investigations focusing on the type of biological material being deposited, the condition of the biological material, the type of substrate on which the biological material is present and with which it comes into contact and the manner of contact [216-218]. It is clear that more data on these and other variables are necessary to improve the accuracy of the likelihood assessment of alternative scenarios.

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #95 on: July 27, 2019, 09:58:17 PM »
I'll take your word for that...  but ask the question should it be: "It isn't possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN" or "It isn't always possible to identify the source of DNA with LCN"... And is it the case they use that technique because they only have microscopic amounts? Finally, I'm no expert but surely blood cells compared to urine for example are identifiable under a microscope?

OK - one more thing! Why didn't the FSS say we can't identify the source of the DNA, we only have microscopic amounts, it's entirely possible that we do not have the DNA from the substances that Eddie and Keela alerted to so this whole test is a complete waste of time. You'd think if that was the case they would have said so at the time????

No need to take my word its stated quite explicitly in the FSS reports Jassi uploaded:

LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.

How can scientists determine the particular body fluid when they're dealing with samples as small as 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt which in many cases are incomplete and degraded?

The FSS have said as much in the reports Jassi uploaded.

LCN is only used when the samples are invisible to the naked eye/degraded/incomplete.  LCN = low copy number.  The material is amplified up. 

Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #96 on: July 27, 2019, 10:21:19 PM »
No need to take my word its stated quite explicitly in the FSS reports Jassi uploaded:

LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.

How can scientists determine the particular body fluid when they're dealing with samples as small as 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt which in many cases are incomplete and degraded?



I read that as the FSS could not attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid... i.e specific only to that particular sample. I don't know if that's always the case with low copy DNA. Circumstantially however we know what Eddie and Keela are trained to alert to. But I do concede that in all likelihood with the evidence presently available  reasonable doubt could be argued with regards to the validity of any possible criminal charges towards any suspects.

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #97 on: July 27, 2019, 11:10:46 PM »
I read that as the FSS could not attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid... i.e specific only to that particular sample. I don't know if that's always the case with low copy DNA. Circumstantially however we know what Eddie and Keela are trained to alert to. But I do concede that in all likelihood with the evidence presently available  reasonable doubt could be argued with regards to the validity of any possible criminal charges towards any suspects.

Several DNA profiling techniques exist eg Short Tandem Repeat (STR) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR).  Low Copy Number (LCN) is used to profile small samples which often contain DNA from multiple sources and/or degraded samples.  And when I say small I mean, as I've said previously, 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt.

Assuming Keela was alerting to blood there's not a shred of evidence this originated from MM through some foul play.  Numerous individuals have stayed at 5A probably running into thousands.  Others have also attended eg constriction workers, cleaners, maintenance personnel etc.

Even the witness statements of recent holiday makers talk of cuts.  Eg Claire Fawkes talks of her young daughter cutting her chin and Saleigh Gordon talks of her husband cutting himself shaving. 

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SA-L-GO.htm

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CLAIRE_FAWKES.htm

There's not even a tiny shred of evidence to suggest the McCanns and/or T7 were involved in MM's disappearance.
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Robittybob1

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #98 on: July 28, 2019, 02:33:36 AM »
As I understand it if the sample is large enough to identify the type of cells e.g. blood or body fluid there is no need for  the multiplication that is a feature of the LCN technique.
Low Copy Number:
Wikipedia.
"It is a more sensitive technique because it involves a greater amount of copying via polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from a smaller amount of starting material, meaning that a profile can be obtained from only a few cells, which may be as small as a millionth the size of a grain of salt, and amount to just a few cells of skin or sweat left from a fingerprint.[2]"


https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/low-copy-number
Low Copy Number
Low copy number (LCN) is defined as less than 100 pg of DNA or the equivalent of the DNA contained in 15 to 17 diploid cells (Gill, 2001).
« Last Edit: July 28, 2019, 03:15:35 AM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #99 on: July 28, 2019, 03:25:51 AM »
Several DNA profiling techniques exist eg Short Tandem Repeat (STR) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR).  Low Copy Number (LCN) is used to profile small samples which often contain DNA from multiple sources and/or degraded samples.  And when I say small I mean, as I've said previously, 1,000,000th the size of a grain of salt.

Assuming Keela was alerting to blood there's not a shred of evidence this originated from MM through some foul play.  Numerous individuals have stayed at 5A probably running into thousands.  Others have also attended eg constriction workers, cleaners, maintenance personnel etc.

Even the witness statements of recent holiday makers talk of cuts.  Eg Claire Fawkes talks of her young daughter cutting her chin and Saleigh Gordon talks of her husband cutting himself shaving. 

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SA-L-GO.htm

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CLAIRE_FAWKES.htm

There's not even a tiny shred of evidence to suggest the McCanns and/or T7 were involved in MM's disappearance.

Well you can keep telling yourself that there's "not even a tiny shred of evidence...."

However, if Keela's alerts could be explained away by the possibility that hundreds (or thousands) of other people might have bled in apartment 5A.... you certainly can't say that about cadavers and the fact that Eddie also alerted in the apartment and hire car. There are no records of cadavers in 5A previously.... Additionally why was it only in apartment 5A that Eddie detected blood when hundreds of people might have also bled in the other apartments? And don't you find it incredibly coincidental that material collected in an area that both dogs alerted material was found to have at least 15 DNA markers that MM had.... How do you explain 17 alerts to possibly hundreds of people's blood and cadaver odour but for some reason only the McCann's apartment, hire car, and other articles have been alerted to. Surely, if these are random alerts to the blood and transferred cadaver odour from other people the odds of all 17 alerts being directed towards only one family would be tiny, IMO.

This is why it is so important to try and get a conclusive interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It would help us understand what has happened. It would narrow down reasonable scenarios, and allow us to filter out some of the nonsense. Doesn't everyone want justice after all?

Offline Robittybob1

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #100 on: July 28, 2019, 03:34:15 AM »
Well you can keep telling yourself that there's "not even a tiny shred of evidence...."

However, if Keela's alerts could be explained away by the possibility that hundreds (or thousands) of other people might have bled in apartment 5A.... you certainly can't say that about cadavers and the fact that Eddie also alerted in the apartment and hire car. There are no records of cadavers in 5A previously.... Additionally why was it only in apartment 5A that Eddie detected blood when hundreds of people might have also bled in the other apartments? And don't you find it incredibly coincidental that material collected in an area that both dogs alerted material was found to have at least 15 DNA markers that MM had.... How do you explain 17 alerts to possibly hundreds of people's blood and cadaver odour but for some reason only the McCann's apartment, hire car, and other articles have been alerted to. Surely, if these are random alerts to the blood and transferred cadaver odour from other people the odds of all 17 alerts being directed towards only one family would be tiny, IMO.

This is why it is so important to try and get a conclusive interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It would help us understand what has happened. It would narrow down reasonable scenarios, and allow us to filter out some of the nonsense. Doesn't everyone want justice after all?
I'm not sure that Keela was taken through the other apartments to look for blood.  From memory Eddie was taken through and in the areas where he alerted Keela then gets her turn to isolate blood.
In the other apartments Eddie did not alert hence IIRC Keela wasn't sent in.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #101 on: July 28, 2019, 03:37:47 AM »
As I understand it if the sample is large enough to identify the type of cells e.g. blood or body fluid there is no need for  the multiplication that is a feature of the LCN technique.
Low Copy Number:
Wikipedia.
"It is a more sensitive technique because it involves a greater amount of copying via polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from a smaller amount of starting material, meaning that a profile can be obtained from only a few cells, which may be as small as a millionth the size of a grain of salt, and amount to just a few cells of skin or sweat left from a fingerprint.[2]"

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/low-copy-number
Low Copy Number
Low copy number (LCN) is defined as less than 100 pg of DNA or the equivalent of the DNA contained in 15 to 17 diploid cells (Gill, 2001).

I'm interested to know why even one cell can't be identified. We know that human cellular material was collected following the dog alerts. There are 200 different types of cells in the human body. Each of the 200 different types of cells in the body has a different structure, size, shape, and function, and contains different organelles.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #102 on: July 28, 2019, 03:50:37 AM »
I'm interested to know why even one cell can't be identified. We know that human cellular material was collected following the dog alerts. There are 200 different types of cells in the human body. Each of the 200 different types of cells in the body has a different structure, size, shape, and function, and contains different organelles.
It is a good question but I think it would be a matter of finding it  on the microscope slide.  Generally you have billions to choose from so when you see a cell, you are not looking at a specific cell but just the cell that is in your field of vision.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Billy Whizz Fan Club

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #103 on: July 28, 2019, 03:57:41 AM »
I'm not sure that Keela was taken through the other apartments to look for blood.  From memory Eddie was taken through and in the areas where he alerted Keela then gets her turn to isolate blood.
In the other apartments Eddie did not alert hence IIRC Keela wasn't sent in.

Yes you're correct - that's a fair point.

This debate though highlights the importance of better interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It's entirely reasonable to cast doubt by pointing out all the other people that blood might have come from.... If it can be proved that the cellular material did come from MM that should be significant.... except of course people will then say it might not be blood.... I hope they have preserved some of the evidence (though I don't believe the FSS preserved the body fluid samples) because cell type identification methods employed in forensic science are improving all the time:

https://www.dovepress.com/forensic-body-fluid-identification-state-of-the-art-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRFMS

Quote
Conclusion

Body fluid identification is an important aspect in criminal investigations and as advancements in technology have improved, the ability to detect and identify body fluids has also improved. At the crime scene, quick and easy-to-use presumptive tests have been used to locate and indicate the body fluid of interest, with confirmatory testing being available in the laboratory

Offline Robittybob1

Re: The LCN DNA test results
« Reply #104 on: July 28, 2019, 04:15:55 AM »
Yes you're correct - that's a fair point.

This debate though highlights the importance of better interpretation of the low copy DNA data. It's entirely reasonable to cast doubt by pointing out all the other people that blood might have come from.... If it can be proved that the cellular material did come from MM that should be significant.... except of course people will then say it might not be blood.... I hope they have preserved some of the evidence (though I don't believe the FSS preserved the body fluid samples) because cell type identification methods employed in forensic science are improving all the time:

https://www.dovepress.com/forensic-body-fluid-identification-state-of-the-art-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRFMS
With these very small samples that LCN DNA analysis (LCN) use it is either identify it  or run the DNA analysis, you can't do both with the same sample.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.