UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: DevilsAdvocate on May 02, 2013, 09:21:18 PM

Title: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 02, 2013, 09:21:18 PM
*partly snipped from an earlier post*

Six years ago tomorrow a young British girl, Madeleine McCann disappeared without trace from apartment 5A, The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz.


Not one person here, irregardles of how they put their point across can prove exactly what happened 6 years ago tomorrow evening !
We are all entitled to our opinion and we are all entitled to express that opinion as long as we do not slander or suggest wrongdoing on behalf of the principle persons in this sad case.

Mature and logical discussion / debate is always welcome and enlightening, it is a shame when that mature debate descends into petty name calling and personal insults.

I am aware that there are so called Pro & Anti fora that trawl the dregs of perceived righteousness, I prefer to liken them to sad lifeless souls who have no interests in their lives other than to sit at a keyboard hurling insults, threats and childish name calling across the battlefields, these individuals are so called adults !

Sadly there are some of their ilk amongst us here on this forum who go scuttling back to their respective cess pits looking for plaudits and adulation from their peers for disrupting debate.

I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Eleanor on May 02, 2013, 09:59:48 PM

That's it, really.  God preserve me from The Righteous.  And hope that I never will be.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: icabodcrane on May 02, 2013, 10:12:36 PM

That's it, really.  God preserve me from The Righteous.  And hope that I never will be.

Do you scuttle back to some other forum then Eleanor  ? 

...  if you do, then I guess you are preserved from righteousness

( I'm with you, by the way DA, this is the only forum I post on, apart from Digital Spy )
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 02, 2013, 10:43:28 PM

That's it, really.  God preserve me from The Righteous.  And hope that I never will be.

I fear you may be confusing righteous with self-righteous Eleanor !
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 02, 2013, 10:50:47 PM
Lol !
I'm still waiting Eleanor's answers, though I disliked very much her treating me "silly" without justifying it.  I worship delicacy and courtesy !
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 02, 2013, 11:48:16 PM
*partly snipped from an earlier post*

Six years ago tomorrow a young British girl, Madeleine McCann disappeared without trace from apartment 5A, The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz.


Not one person here, irregardles of how they put their point across can prove exactly what happened 6 years ago tomorrow evening !
We are all entitled to our opinion and we are all entitled to express that opinion as long as we do not slander or suggest wrongdoing on behalf of the principle persons in this sad case.

Mature and logical discussion / debate is always welcome and enlightening, it is a shame when that mature debate descends into petty name calling and personal insults.

I am aware that there are so called Pro & Anti fora that trawl the dregs of perceived righteousness, I prefer to liken them to sad lifeless souls who have no interests in their lives other than to sit at a keyboard hurling insults, threats and childish name calling across the battlefields, these individuals are so called adults !

Sadly there are some of their ilk amongst us here on this forum who go scuttling back to their respective cess pits looking for plaudits and adulation from their peers for disrupting debate.

I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Now why don't I believe you?
I have followed this case for many years.
Indeed  I have posted on fora about this case.
Some folks on here post with different names . Why I don't know.
What I do know is I can, within a day or so, recognise members posting styles and therefore identify them.


You , IMO, are not new to posting about this case.

I notice that there is no claim not to have posted before elsewhere. Merely a claim not to be doing so currently. Interesting!
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 03, 2013, 12:00:15 AM
Quote
DevilsAdvocate
I am aware that there are so called Pro & Anti fora that trawl the dregs of perceived righteousness, I prefer to liken them to sad lifeless souls who have no interests in their lives other than to sit at a keyboard hurling insults, threats and childish name calling across the battlefields, these individuals are so called adults !

or alternatively you can watch it live

Quote
DevilsAdvocate
Hi Icabod, I was outside the police station in Portimao when Kate arrived the second time, there was a lot of unpleasant hecklin and name calling which the TV crews didn't pick up on, I personally found it a very intimidating atmosphere and I was only a bystander.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: icabodcrane on May 03, 2013, 12:10:31 AM
I know other forums are not open for discussion here  (  and I'm glad, really  )

It would be interesting, though, if forum members here came clean about whether they have  some sort of   'home base' forum  that they report back to,  looking for praise for having been good faithful foot-soldiers,  and seeking back-slaps for scalps taken

Are any of you doing that ? ... just out of curiousity
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 03, 2013, 12:20:32 AM
I know other forums are not open for discussion here  (  and I'm glad, really  )

It would be interesting, though, if forum members here came clean about whether they have  some sort of   'home base' forum  that they report back to,  looking for praise for having been good faithful foot-soldiers,  and seeking back-slaps for scalps taken

Are any of you doing that ? ... just out of curiousity
Gosh ! Are you serious Icabodcrane or just imagining ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: icabodcrane on May 03, 2013, 12:25:53 AM
I know other forums are not open for discussion here  (  and I'm glad, really  )

It would be interesting, though, if forum members here came clean about whether they have  some sort of   'home base' forum  that they report back to,  looking for praise for having been good faithful foot-soldiers,  and seeking back-slaps for scalps taken

Are any of you doing that ? ... just out of curiousity
Gosh ! Are you serious Icabodcrane or just imagining ?

I'd just like to know if I'm debating with veterans who have a specifice agenda Anne

Are you one ?

Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 03, 2013, 12:39:51 AM
The reality is that the identity of the poster is irrelevant unless they deliberately lie about their posting history because such lying would make it very difficult not to treat the content of all their posts with suspicion.

If there is no suspicion (or evidence) of lying about the past on the part of the poster then the content of the post is the only thing that matters.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: icabodcrane on May 03, 2013, 12:49:50 AM
The reality is that the identity of the poster is irrelevant unless they deliberately lie about their posting history because such lying would make it very difficult not to treat the content of all their posts with suspicion.

If there is no suspicion (or evidence) of lying about the past on the part of the poster then the content of the post is the only thing that matters.

I disagree

It hadn't occured to me until I read the opening post,  but I don't much like the thought of having a discussion with someone who then scuttles off to another forum to  'report back'

Are you relaying information and conversations on this forum to others, on another forum,  Gilet ?

Or will you not say ?



Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 03, 2013, 01:00:39 AM
The reality is that the identity of the poster is irrelevant unless they deliberately lie about their posting history because such lying would make it very difficult not to treat the content of all their posts with suspicion.

If there is no suspicion (or evidence) of lying about the past on the part of the poster then the content of the post is the only thing that matters.

I disagree

It hadn't occured to me until I read the opening post,  but I don't much like the thought of having a discussion with someone who then scuttles off to another forum to  'report back'

Are you relaying information and conversations on this forum to others, on another forum,  Gilet ?

Or will you not say ?

Whether I discuss what I post here with my children, uncles, aunts, godchild or mother or with the local police or with members of other forums is frankly none of your business.

It is the content of my posts which matters.

The fact is that whatever people say in these matters is impossible to verify. Your question is pointless. I have no idea whether you post under other names on pro or anti forums, no matter what you tell us.

Such questioning of posters is simply a waste of time.

I can tell you that I do post or that I don't post elsewhere. What difference would that make? You don't know if it is true or not do you?

Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 03, 2013, 01:04:47 AM
I know other forums are not open for discussion here  (  and I'm glad, really  )

It would be interesting, though, if forum members here came clean about whether they have  some sort of   'home base' forum  that they report back to,  looking for praise for having been good faithful foot-soldiers,  and seeking back-slaps for scalps taken

Are any of you doing that ? ... just out of curiousity
Gosh ! Are you serious Icabodcrane or just imagining ?

I'd just like to know if I'm debating with veterans who have a specifice agenda Anne

Are you one ?
Well, Icabodcrane, I'm surprised some here who will know I'm thinking of them are hostile, not to say uncouth ! Life is nicer when people are gentle. What are we doing here ? Just arguing ! Nobody will suffer from this, luckily. It will affect no one, change the destiny of no one.
I post sometimes on another forum where most suspect me to be "pro", possibly because I once said Mrs McCann was a beautiful woman ! One admin picks on me every time I post. She might be ugly, who knows ;) Fortunately another admin knows I'm neither the pro nor the anti type, rather a sceptic as some call it here.
My agenda is to understand. Nothing else.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 03, 2013, 01:09:34 AM

Well, Icabodcrane, I'm surprised some here who will know I'm thinking of them are hostile, not to say uncouth ! Life is nicer when people are gentle. What are we doing here ? Just arguing ! Nobody will suffer from this, luckily. It will affect no one, change the destiny of no one.
I post sometimes on another forum where most suspect me to be "pro", possibly because I once said Mrs McCann was a beautiful woman ! One admin picks on me every time I post. She might be ugly, who knows ;) Fortunately another admin knows I'm neither the pro nor the anti type, rather a sceptic as some call it here.
My agenda is to understand. Nothing else.

Am I not right in thinking that you claimed on this forum not to post elsewhere? That you did not use twitter or know others on other McCann forums? That you went to great lengths to suggest that the other person using exactly the same name as you was not you?

I believe I can find that post if you are finding it hard to recall having posted that.

Now, you seem to be claiming that you do know others on other forums and do post about the McCanns elsewhere?

Which is the truth please?

As I said it is only when people post lies on this forum about their posting history that I am interested in such history, not because of the actual posting history, but because of the way such lies reflect on the content of what that poster posts in general.

Why did you say that you don't use twitter or FB and don't know other pro or anti McCann sites?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: icabodcrane on May 03, 2013, 01:17:49 AM
Am I not right in thinking that you claimed on this forum not to post elsewhere? That you did not use twitter or know others on other McCann forums? That you went to great lengths to suggest that the other person using exactly the same name as you was not you?

I believe I can find that post if you are finding it hard to recall having posted that.

Now, you seem to be claiming that you do know others on other forums and do post about the McCanns elsewhere?

Which is the truth please?

Are you serious ?

When asked about your own posting history you say, mind your own business

That's fair enough ...  but then you  demand that another member declare theirs !

Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 03, 2013, 01:23:49 AM
Believe me Anne, you will never be mistaken for a"pro"!!.
Thank you for acknowledging that, Neeley ! But I'm not an anti as well... I find one and the other ridiculous.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 03, 2013, 01:24:47 AM

Are you serious ?

When asked about your own posting history you say, mind your own business

That's fair enough ...  but then you  demand that another member declare theirs !

Wrong.

I am not questioning this poster about her previous posting history but about the content of her post on THIS forum.



Having said on April 15th,

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1258.msg35674#msg35674

Quote
Was this forum created as a kind of abuse repairing ? You see, I don't follow nobody related to the McCann case on Twitter, I don't do FB, I don't know those anti or pro sites, which means I can't help !

Anne Guedes now says,

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1448.msg41823#msg41823

Quote
I post sometimes on another forum where most suspect me to be "pro", possibly because I once said Mrs McCann was a beautiful woman ! One admin picks on me every time I post. She might be ugly, who knows ;) Fortunately another admin knows I'm neither the pro nor the anti type, rather a sceptic as some call it here.


These statements, both made on this forum, cannot both be true. So which is true?

It is a perfect example of the difference between being interested in what a poster says about themself here and your unfettered nosiness about what posters do elsewhere.



Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 03, 2013, 01:29:31 AM

Please, Gilet, stop it ! I'm not the ennemy you think I am. I don't build intrigues and incentive fights. I hate this. I try to understand what could have happened, why people reacted as they did and how we can learn about ourselves though this story.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: icabodcrane on May 03, 2013, 01:31:08 AM

These statements, both made on this forum, cannot both be true. So which is true?

It is a perfect example of the difference between being interested in what a poster says about themself here and your unfettered nosiness about what posters do elsewhere.

Rubbish

You are harrassing a member because they will not disclose the kind of personal posting history you  will not disclose

Bully 

Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 03, 2013, 01:31:58 AM

Please, Gilet, stop it ! I'm not the enemy you think I am. I don't build intrigues and incentive fights. I hate this. I try to understand what could have happened, why people reacted as they did and how we can learn about ourselves though this story.

I have never called you the enemy. I have not discussed intrigues and incentive fights.

I would simply like to know which of your two posts is the truth.

Till I know that I cannot fully trust what you post.

Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 03, 2013, 01:32:07 AM
And besides the forum where I post sometimes is neither pro nor anti.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: gilet on May 03, 2013, 01:32:58 AM

I repeat. You are wrong. I am not remotely bothered (as you seem to be) about people posting elsewhere.

I am, however, interested in whether people are posting the truth here.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 03, 2013, 01:34:17 AM
Gilet, I can't force you to trust me ! Do as you like it.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 03, 2013, 09:48:19 AM
*partly snipped from an earlier post*

Six years ago tomorrow a young British girl, Madeleine McCann disappeared without trace from apartment 5A, The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz.


Not one person here, irregardles of how they put their point across can prove exactly what happened 6 years ago tomorrow evening !
We are all entitled to our opinion and we are all entitled to express that opinion as long as we do not slander or suggest wrongdoing on behalf of the principle persons in this sad case.

Mature and logical discussion / debate is always welcome and enlightening, it is a shame when that mature debate descends into petty name calling and personal insults.

I am aware that there are so called Pro & Anti fora that trawl the dregs of perceived righteousness, I prefer to liken them to sad lifeless souls who have no interests in their lives other than to sit at a keyboard hurling insults, threats and childish name calling across the battlefields, these individuals are so called adults !

Sadly there are some of their ilk amongst us here on this forum who go scuttling back to their respective cess pits looking for plaudits and adulation from their peers for disrupting debate.

I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Now why don't I believe you?
I have followed this case for many years.
Indeed  I have posted on fora about this case.
Some folks on here post with different names . Why I don't know.
What I do know is I can, within a day or so, recognise members posting styles and therefore identify them.


You , IMO, are not new to posting about this case.

With respect Neeley, whether you believe me or not is wholly irrelevant to me, that is a decision you choose to make.
What I can tell you is that I am new to posting on sites and the main reason for that is that I have read both so called pro & anti sites in the past but the sheer venom and bile being spewed forth from the members of both sides decided my mind for me that I did not wish to take part in their debates.

It is interesting that your post does exactly as I  had stated in the OP, disrupts debate, I wonder why ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 03, 2013, 09:53:26 AM
*partly snipped from an earlier post*

Six years ago tomorrow a young British girl, Madeleine McCann disappeared without trace from apartment 5A, The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz.


Not one person here, irregardles of how they put their point across can prove exactly what happened 6 years ago tomorrow evening !
We are all entitled to our opinion and we are all entitled to express that opinion as long as we do not slander or suggest wrongdoing on behalf of the principle persons in this sad case.

Mature and logical discussion / debate is always welcome and enlightening, it is a shame when that mature debate descends into petty name calling and personal insults.

I am aware that there are so called Pro & Anti fora that trawl the dregs of perceived righteousness, I prefer to liken them to sad lifeless souls who have no interests in their lives other than to sit at a keyboard hurling insults, threats and childish name calling across the battlefields, these individuals are so called adults !

Sadly there are some of their ilk amongst us here on this forum who go scuttling back to their respective cess pits looking for plaudits and adulation from their peers for disrupting debate.

I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Now why don't I believe you?
I have followed this case for many years.
Indeed  I have posted on fora about this case.
Some folks on here post with different names . Why I don't know.
What I do know is I can, within a day or so, recognise members posting styles and therefore identify them.


You , IMO, are not new to posting about this case.

I notice that there is no claim not to have posted before elsewhere. Merely a claim not to be doing so currently. Interesting!

Hello gilet, please read my reply to Neeley in response to your query.
May I ask why you exclaim that I have not specifically claimed to have posted previously on other fora "interesting" ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 03, 2013, 02:16:17 PM
Quote
DevilsAdvocate
I am aware that there are so called Pro & Anti fora that trawl the dregs of perceived righteousness, I prefer to liken them to sad lifeless souls who have no interests in their lives other than to sit at a keyboard hurling insults, threats and childish name calling across the battlefields, these individuals are so called adults !

or alternatively you can watch it live

Quote
DevilsAdvocate
Hi Icabod, I was outside the police station in Portimao when Kate arrived the second time, there was a lot of unpleasant hecklin and name calling which the TV crews didn't pick up on, I personally found it a very intimidating atmosphere and I was only a bystander.

Yes, I was vacationing on the Algarve at the time and happened to be in Portimao that day. Like so many other by-standers my family and I were drawn to the scene by the large number of OB TV crews present.
 
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Luz on May 03, 2013, 04:46:09 PM
*partly snipped from an earlier post*

Six years ago tomorrow a young British girl, Madeleine McCann disappeared without trace from apartment 5A, The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz.

/snipped/

I hope that today, of all days in the year, people remember the little child and keep her alive as a motto to try to find out what really happened to her.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Lace on May 03, 2013, 05:39:04 PM
I hope today that people remember the little girl who went missing in Portugal.   

If they know anything about her disappearance they will speak up.

Put an end to the pain and torture her family are going through.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 03, 2013, 05:41:31 PM
I hope today that people remember the little girl who went missing in Portugal.   

If they know anything about her disappearance they will speak up.

Put an end to the pain and torture her family are going through.

 8@??)(
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 03, 2013, 06:23:17 PM
*partly snipped from an earlier post*

Six years ago tomorrow a young British girl, Madeleine McCann disappeared without trace from apartment 5A, The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz.

/snipped/

I hope that today, of all days in the year, people remember the little child and keep her alive as a motto to try to find out what really happened to her.

I agree with you for once.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 03, 2013, 06:45:17 PM
I know other forums are not open for discussion here  (  and I'm glad, really  )

It would be interesting, though, if forum members here came clean about whether they have  some sort of   'home base' forum  that they report back to,  looking for praise for having been good faithful foot-soldiers,  and seeking back-slaps for scalps taken

Are any of you doing that ? ... just out of curiousity

If anyone other than you had asked that - I may have answered.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 03, 2013, 07:11:07 PM
Some people (me included) have been following the case right from the very start.

They have discussed the case in forums and been banned from forums for not following the forum line.

Eventually this has turned into pro forums and anti forums.

There is a lot of watching and mud slinging between the two factions.

My conscience is clear - I know which side of the fence I am on and am happy to announce that (it should be clear by now)

IF I am wrong - my conscience will still be clear.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 03, 2013, 07:26:55 PM
Some people (me included) have been following the case right from the very start.

They have discussed the case in forums and been banned from forums for not following the forum line.

Eventually this has turned into pro forums and anti forums.

There is a lot of watching and mud slinging between the two factions.

My conscience is clear - I know which side of the fence I am on and am happy to announce that (it should be clear by now)

IF I am wrong - my conscience will still be clear.

 8@??)(

Six years ago today a 3 year old girl went missing.  Madeleine's Mum and Dad have not only had to bear this loss, but there was also an attempt by the PT police to stitch them up.  There are those who have sympathy and compassion for Kate and Gerry McCann.  There are those who seek to pile further pain onto this family who are clearly struggling with their terrible loss.

I also know which side of the fence I am on.  My conscience will always be clear also.  I have only compassion and sympathy for this struggling family.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 06:28:50 PM
Quote
I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Do you have a blog, or are you a member of a FB group that discusses the case?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 06:38:58 PM
Quote
I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Do you have a blog, or are you a member of a FB group that discusses the case?

As I have stated previously, this is the only forum that I debate this case on, I have not previously contributed to any other forum, though I have read many fora both pro and anti. The level of animosity to opposing views and mockery of any poster who dared put their head above the parapet with an opposing standpoint lead me to exclude myself from  those debates.
I am not a member of any Facebook group and I neither have a 'blog !

Why do you ask ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: debunker on May 04, 2013, 06:39:58 PM
Quote
I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Do you have a blog, or are you a member of a FB group that discusses the case?

As I have stated previously, this is the only forum that I debate this case on, I have not previously contributed to any other forum, though I have read many fora both pro and anti. The level of animosity to opposing views and mockery of any poster who dared put their head above the parapet with an opposing standpoint lead me to exclude myself from  those debates.
I am not a member of any Facebook group and I neither have a 'blog !

Why do you ask ?

You seem to have very familiar ideas. Strange for someone who has not been through the Mccann forum wringer.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 06:40:23 PM
because you asked a member on here

Quote
Just by way of observation, may I ask are you the same Martha who posts on the just a thought forum perchance ?

and because I found the following very strange

Quote
(thanks to my fellow member here who sent it to me)
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 06:55:02 PM
because you asked a member on here

Quote
Just by way of observation, may I ask are you the same Martha who posts on the just a thought forum perchance ?

and because I found the following very strange

Quote
(thanks to my fellow member here who sent it to me)

And your point is what exactly ?

Yes I asked a question, which remains unanswered for whatever reason.
And furthermore, yes I received a message which highlighted that I was being discussed on a cesspit site.
Again I ask, your point is what exactly ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 06:58:11 PM
I asked a question and you answered it.

You asked a question and I answered it.

Now this could go on for a long time.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 07:01:58 PM
Quote
I as a member of this forum can categorically state that I am not a member of any pro or anti site, and that this is the only forum on which I discuss this case.

Do you have a blog, or are you a member of a FB group that discusses the case?

As I have stated previously, this is the only forum that I debate this case on, I have not previously contributed to any other forum, though I have read many fora both pro and anti. The level of animosity to opposing views and mockery of any poster who dared put their head above the parapet with an opposing standpoint lead me to exclude myself from  those debates.
I am not a member of any Facebook group and I neither have a 'blog !

Why do you ask ?

You seem to have very familiar ideas. Strange for someone who has not been through the Mccann forum wringer.

Do please enlighten me as to what exactly the "McCann forum wringer" is debunker !
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 07:04:41 PM
I asked a question and you answered it.

You asked a question and I answered it.

Now this could go on for a long time.

No, I asked what your point was in asking the question, it remains unanswered as does the question I asked of Martha !
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:06:09 PM
My point was that I wanted to know

it is very interesting that you remembered a pornographic animated gif avatar from years ago.

I am trying to remember if non-members would have been able to see that.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 07:11:44 PM
My point was that I wanted to know

it is very interesting that you remembered a pornographic animated gif avatar from years ago.

I am trying to remember if non-members would have been able to see that.

Maybe I have been blessed with one or two more memory cells and by such a better recall facility than you !
Or maybe it has been through years of a college education that I have acquired the capacity to remember and recall relevant articles to suit a debate !
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:12:44 PM
My point was that I wanted to know

it is very interesting that you remembered a pornographic animated gif avatar from years ago.

I am trying to remember if non-members would have been able to see that.

Maybe I have been blessed with one or two more memory cells and by such a better recall facility than you !
Or maybe it has been through years of a college education that I have acquired the capacity to remember and recall relevant articles to suit a debate !

I have to agree with you there - maybe you are blessed.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:13:49 PM
Incidentally - I flew through college very quickly - maybe I should have taken years.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:15:27 PM
Quote
I have acquired the capacity to remember and recall relevant articles to suit a debate !

odd about your memory of Levy isn't it?

you know - the potential charlatan?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 07:24:35 PM
Incidentally - I flew through college very quickly - maybe I should have taken years.
A PhD takes longer !
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:25:10 PM
Incidentally - I flew through college very quickly - maybe I should have taken years.
A PhD takes longer !

for some yes.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:26:56 PM
hey - I'm pulling your leg - OK?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 07:28:05 PM
Quote
I have acquired the capacity to remember and recall relevant articles to suit a debate !

odd about your memory of Levy isn't it?

you know - the potential charlatan?

My questions in relation to Duarte Levy were just that, questions !
From the little research I did on him I could find not much information, hence my question !

Now are we going to continue this pedantic baiting or shall you retire to what you do best ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:33:43 PM
Quote
I have not read up too much on this character !
Enlighten me please.

you were around enough to remember an animated pornographic gif avatar on 3As.

Levy was a major player in the Mccann case in the early years.

Levy was the person who posted the dog videos.

Yet you say
Quote
From the little research I did on him I could find not much information, hence my question !

Now call me a sceptic (or even septic if you want), but I am finding it very difficult to believe anything you post in your "innocent I don't know anything style"
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 07:37:45 PM
Incidentally I am taking into account that you have never posted on Mccann related forums before and you are a little tetchy about your user name.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 08:02:43 PM
Quote
In common parlance, a devil's advocate is someone who, given a certain argument, takes a position he or she does not necessarily agree with, for the sake of debate. In taking this position, the individual taking on the devil's advocate role seeks to engage others in an argumentative discussion process
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: DevilsAdvocate on May 04, 2013, 08:08:24 PM
Quote
I have not read up too much on this character !
Enlighten me please.

you were around enough to remember an animated pornographic gif avatar on 3As.

Levy was a major player in the Mccann case in the early years.

Levy was the person who posted the dog videos.

Yet you say
Quote
From the little research I did on him I could find not much information, hence my question !

Now call me a sceptic (or even septic if you want), but I am finding it very difficult to believe anything you post in your "innocent I don't know anything style"

Is there a specific question you are asking here (and in the following two posts) ?
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 08:10:17 PM
No - unlike you I don't ask questions to answer a question.

You will notice my expression of doubt - that is all it is.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Eleanor on May 05, 2013, 08:34:17 AM

So, if Just a Thought You Know is a cess pit, where no one ever abuses the family of a missing child, or the child herself, one might wonder what on earth description one could give to Havern's where no one ever does anything else?

PS.  I never scuttle anywhere.  And everybody knows who I am anyway.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: muratfan on May 05, 2013, 10:04:20 AM

My questions in relation to Duarte Levy were just that, questions !
From the little research I did on him I could find not much information, hence my question !

Now are we going to continue this pedantic baiting or shall you retire to what you do best ?

There are loads on Levy , if you just Google him.
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Cudge on May 05, 2013, 11:11:47 AM

So, if Just a Thought You Know is a cess pit, where no one ever abuses the family of a missing child, or the child herself, one might wonder what on earth description one could give to Havern's where no one ever does anything else?

PS.  I never scuttle anywhere.  And everybody knows who I am anyway.

Indeed being a reader of  rather than a contributor to Haverns, MM and ..... I would say there is only one cesspit and it most certainly is not ..... . The amount of hate and bile that is spewed out on a daily basis on the former two sites  is beyond any normal rationale. Any opposing thoughts to the party line being treated with contempt and requests for banning to be made.

This site is extremely good and allows both sides of the argument to be posted with fair moderation
Title: Re: Six years !
Post by: Eleanor on May 05, 2013, 12:08:55 PM

So, if Just a Thought You Know is a cess pit, where no one ever abuses the family of a missing child, or the child herself, one might wonder what on earth description one could give to Havern's where no one ever does anything else?

PS.  I never scuttle anywhere.  And everybody knows who I am anyway.

Indeed being a reader of  rather than a contributor to Haverns, MM and ..... I would say there is only one cesspit and it most certainly is not ..... . The amount of hate and bile that is spewed out on a daily basis on the former two sites  is beyond any normal rationale. Any opposing thoughts to the party line being treated with contempt and requests for banning to be made.

This site is extremely good and allows both sides of the argument to be posted with fair moderation

You are right.  Just a Thought You Know is most definitely not a cess pit.  Far from it.

And yes, this is a good Site, although I sometimes wonder why I bother.  But at least you don't get banned for telling the truth.