UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Leshovik on June 22, 2014, 12:56:43 PM

Title: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Leshovik on June 22, 2014, 12:56:43 PM
Forgetting about emotional clap trap, justice in this instance will be seen to be done when the fate of Madeleine McCann is determined beyond doubt. Following on from that all those who played a part in it, presuming a criminal offence has been committed, before or after the fact are are charged, found guilty and sentenced according to the prevailing law. That will do me.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on June 22, 2014, 01:00:55 PM
Forgetting about emotional clap trap, justice in this instance will be seen to be done when the fate of Madeleine McCann is determined beyond doubt. Following on from that all those who played a part in it, presuming a criminal offence has been committed, before or after the fact are are charged, found guilty and sentenced according to the prevailing law. That will do me.
Not a fan of trial by social media then Les?  It must be galling for you to have to read the comments of so many who have already tried the McCanns in the court of public opinion and found them guilty.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 01:01:31 PM
Forgetting about emotional clap trap, justice in this instance will be seen to be done when the fate of Madeleine McCann is determined beyond doubt. Following on from that all those who played a part in it, presuming a criminal offence has been committed, before or after the fact are are charged, found guilty and sentenced according to the prevailing law. That will do me.

That's quite a reasonable suggestion but contains a major flaw. A court decision will not settle the case beyond doubt...only beyond reasonable doubt so even a court case..and conviction will not satisfy some
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on June 22, 2014, 01:32:19 PM
To Alfie and Davel.
We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue.
* To a Liverpool supporter the next best thing to Liverpool winning is Man U losing.

If you really were as morally superior as you like to pretend you would not reserve your put downs solely for those of us who think that trying the parents of a missing child in the court of public opinion and finding them guilty day after day is a bit of a shit thing to do.  Amaral has already been found guilty in a real court - of perjury.  The official court verdict tells us a lot about his methods and morals, and it's fair to draw some salient conclusions about his current (and past) conduct from this conviction imo.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on June 22, 2014, 02:17:00 PM
Where did I say I was morally superior?
You asked effectively about my beliefs you now have them.
Twist them any way you wish I am not biting.

Did you not write this?

"So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable".

You set yourself up as morally superior yet you do not behave in a way that gives any credence to your alleged views. 
Re; your Liverpool / ManU analogy This is not a game of football, however when something bad happens in football, like the Hillsborough Disaster, or the Munich Air Disaster, most decent football supporters of all teams offer support and condolence to the team and supporters of the side that has been afflicted.  It is only the few, mean troll-like ones who get pleasure by (for example) singing mocking songs about plane crashes and being trampled to death, or blaming the victims for their own fate.   Just sayin' like....
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 22, 2014, 06:31:42 PM
quote"We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue."unqoute.

Excellent post I agree 100%

I would add that many people see the persecution of Amaral as the conclusion to the case. There is no closure until little Maddie is found. Amaral is just one of the many people Team Mcs have set out to destroy-and keep themselves squeaky clean-denying any responsibility in their daughters fate (what ever that is).

There is also the other matter regarding this Amaral case; and that is the attack on Portuguese civil liberties and human right Act- denying freedom of speech and expression without fear or intimidation by state. But many forget that this is at the heart of this case-and my personal interest in it.

Amaral was vindicated and his book was un-banned- a victory for Justice. Check out the forum name in case you need reminding why YOU are here.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: gilet on June 22, 2014, 07:49:07 PM
To Alfie and Davel.
We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue.
* To a Liverpool supporter the next best thing to Liverpool winning is Man U losing.

Pseudo-intellectual claptrap.

An attempt to provide a logical and seemingly educated overview of the situation which unfortunately fails on one basic legal premise.

That premise is that there is a difference between innocence and guilt in the eyes of the law which you infer civilised society must recognise and which you have already mentioned earlier in the post.

"Lynching" (as in lynch mob behaviour) the McCanns when they are innocent of any crime is, quite naturally, illegal.

But "lynching" is completely unnecessary in the case of Amaral. He freely admitted his disgraceful behaviour in his own book (when he reports his conversation with the journalist which got him dismissed from the case), and he was convicted by the court in PT of the far more serious issue of perverting the course of justice whilst a serving police officer. It is simply stating facts about this man to describe him as a disgraced, criminal ex-cop.

No matter how florid the prose used, your failure to recognise that basic difference completely destroys his argument.

And I did so laugh when, having tried previously to rebuke me over my prose style, you come up with this post. The big difference between mine and yours though is that I don't rely on false premises to underpin the content of my posts.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 07:59:38 PM
Anything you say O wise one!

Indeed, she is the fount of no knowledge. 8(0(*
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: jassi on June 22, 2014, 08:03:32 PM
She even uses civil engineering technical terms. There must be no end to her talent.

It's the same with them all - knowledgeable beyond all understanding ( they think)  8(0(*
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 08:09:31 PM
To Alfie and Davel.
We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue.
* To a Liverpool supporter the next best thing to Liverpool winning is Man U losing.

I've thought about this and its not as clear cut as you think. how many websites have been set up to bash the mccanns ...there are many...several face book pages as well. How many websites have been set up to bash amaral...don't know if there are any

It was amaral who attacked the mccanns...quite falsely according to SY ...the PJ new investigation and shortly I expect the Portuguese libel court to agree...amaral is criticised because he has falsely accused the mccanns...but no one has gone to the trouble of setting up blogs to attack him day day out as we have seen by the McCann bashers

Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 08:11:19 PM
I've thought about this and its not as clear cut as you think. how many websites have been set up to bash the mccanns ...there are many...several face book pages as well. How many websites have been set up to bash amaral...don't know if there are any

It was amaral who attacked the mccanns...quite falsely according to SY ...the PJ new investigation and shortly I expect the Portuguese libel court to agree...amaral is criticised because he has falsely accused the mccanns...but no one has gone to the trouble of setting up blogs to attack him day day out as we have seen by the McCann bashers


No one has set up blogs to attack Amaral ???

Who are you trying to kid ?
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 08:21:55 PM

No one has set up blogs to attack Amaral ???

Who are you trying to kid ?

where are they
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 08:23:43 PM
where are they

As if you don't know.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:23:39 PM
No you haven't and yes it is!

I have and it isn't...
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:26:36 PM
No you haven't and yes it is!

IT raises an interesting point in that how many people here have been influenced to post by amarals book...a book that almost certainly will be declared libellous
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 09:41:24 PM
IT raises an interesting point in that how many people here have been influenced to post by amarals book...a book that almost certainly will be declared libellous

In your dreams.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:43:08 PM
In your dreams.

so you think it wont be declared libellous
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: gilet on June 22, 2014, 10:03:54 PM
Anything you say O wise one!

Yet again, you show no interest in actually addressing the issues presumably because you have no answer.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: gilet on June 22, 2014, 10:06:27 PM
Indeed, she is the fount of no knowledge. 8(0(*

A good job somebody is. Your mantra will never resolve anything.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: ferryman on June 23, 2014, 11:37:45 AM
To Alfie and Davel.
We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue.
* To a Liverpool supporter the next best thing to Liverpool winning is Man U losing.

 By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable.

Dr Amaral has written a book of provable and demonstrable lies which have been exposed.

In what sense would you say that is "lynching" Amaral?
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 23, 2014, 12:39:27 PM
By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable.

Dr Amaral has written a book of provable and demonstrable lies which have been exposed.

In what sense would you say that is "lynching" Amaral?

we could perhaps make a list of the lies told about amaral by the mccanns and visa versa.......amaral is quite at libert to sue the mccanns...he has no case of course
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 23, 2014, 12:41:29 PM
A good job somebody is. Your mantra will never resolve anything.

..and yours my dear lady is pure fantasy.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Mr Gray on June 23, 2014, 12:45:23 PM
Forgetting about emotional clap trap, justice in this instance will be seen to be done when the fate of Madeleine McCann is determined beyond doubt. Following on from that all those who played a part in it, presuming a criminal offence has been committed, before or after the fact are are charged, found guilty and sentenced according to the prevailing law. That will do me.
amaral has been found guilty by a criminal court..not social media...so please don't deny he is a disgraced ex cop
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 23, 2014, 12:53:35 PM
amaral has been found guilty by a criminal court..not social media...so please don't deny he is a disgraced ex cop

It does not mean dave, he got his basic thesis wrong, does it ?
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: carlymichelle on June 23, 2014, 12:54:57 PM
It does not mean dave, he got his basic thesis wrong, does it ?

and that  conviction had nothing to do with the mcanns did it?  imagine if GA had not suspected  kate and gerry the mcann supporters would have adored  him and lapped   up his every word hypocrties
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: stephen25000 on June 23, 2014, 12:56:32 PM
and that  conviction had nothing to do with the mcanns did it?  imagine if GA had not suspected  kate and gerry the mcann supporters would have adored  him and lapped   up his every word hypocrties

Precisely Carlymichelle.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Carana on June 23, 2014, 01:16:38 PM
quote"We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue."unqoute.

Excellent post I agree 100%

I would add that many people see the persecution of Amaral as the conclusion to the case. There is no closure until little Maddie is found. Amaral is just one of the many people Team Mcs have set out to destroy-and keep themselves squeaky clean-denying any responsibility in their daughters fate (what ever that is).

There is also the other matter regarding this Amaral case; and that is the attack on Portuguese civil liberties and human right Act- denying freedom of speech and expression without fear or intimidation by state. But many forget that this is at the heart of this case-and my personal interest in it.

Amaral was vindicated and his book was un-banned- a victory for Justice. Check out the forum name in case you need reminding why YOU are here.


It is indeed. My right to write or say anything about you ends when what I write or say infringes your rights. Wouldn't you agree?
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: ferryman on June 23, 2014, 01:30:32 PM
It does not mean dave, he got his basic thesis wrong, does it ?

His criminal conviction, in a separate  trial, for lying to cover up torture in another case he presided over, on its own, doesn't, no.

But his book compared with the official files certainly does ...

Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 23, 2014, 11:38:31 PM
Kate lied in her book!

She said so!

But I guess that's different because she isn't doing it for the money.... oh ...wait...


Oh and we all know there is more than one lie told.
Title: Re: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?
Post by: misty on June 24, 2014, 12:21:49 AM
IMO this case will be used to justify any challenges made against the existence of secret courts.