Author Topic: Is trial by Social Media and the Court of Public Opinion to be condemned?  (Read 4511 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

stephen25000

  • Guest
IT raises an interesting point in that how many people here have been influenced to post by amarals book...a book that almost certainly will be declared libellous

In your dreams.

Offline Mr Gray

In your dreams.

so you think it wont be declared libellous

Offline gilet

Anything you say O wise one!

Yet again, you show no interest in actually addressing the issues presumably because you have no answer.

Offline gilet

Indeed, she is the fount of no knowledge. 8(0(*

A good job somebody is. Your mantra will never resolve anything.

ferryman

  • Guest
To Alfie and Davel.
We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue.
* To a Liverpool supporter the next best thing to Liverpool winning is Man U losing.

 By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable.

Dr Amaral has written a book of provable and demonstrable lies which have been exposed.

In what sense would you say that is "lynching" Amaral?
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 11:57:39 AM by Mr Moderator »

Offline Mr Gray

By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable.

Dr Amaral has written a book of provable and demonstrable lies which have been exposed.

In what sense would you say that is "lynching" Amaral?

we could perhaps make a list of the lies told about amaral by the mccanns and visa versa.......amaral is quite at libert to sue the mccanns...he has no case of course

stephen25000

  • Guest
A good job somebody is. Your mantra will never resolve anything.

..and yours my dear lady is pure fantasy.

Offline Mr Gray

Forgetting about emotional clap trap, justice in this instance will be seen to be done when the fate of Madeleine McCann is determined beyond doubt. Following on from that all those who played a part in it, presuming a criminal offence has been committed, before or after the fact are are charged, found guilty and sentenced according to the prevailing law. That will do me.
amaral has been found guilty by a criminal court..not social media...so please don't deny he is a disgraced ex cop

stephen25000

  • Guest
amaral has been found guilty by a criminal court..not social media...so please don't deny he is a disgraced ex cop

It does not mean dave, he got his basic thesis wrong, does it ?

Offline carlymichelle

It does not mean dave, he got his basic thesis wrong, does it ?

and that  conviction had nothing to do with the mcanns did it?  imagine if GA had not suspected  kate and gerry the mcann supporters would have adored  him and lapped   up his every word hypocrties

stephen25000

  • Guest
and that  conviction had nothing to do with the mcanns did it?  imagine if GA had not suspected  kate and gerry the mcann supporters would have adored  him and lapped   up his every word hypocrties

Precisely Carlymichelle.
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 01:02:44 PM by Mr Moderator »

Offline Carana

quote"We know guilty according to the law is not always reliable. Remember Mr Conlon who died yesterday.
Guilt and innocence are absolutes so we have for better or worse, guilty or not guilty in the eyes of law which is the best our society can do. If one believes in the higher power in the Biblical sense then maybe the absolutes will be dealt with in due course.
Trial by any kind of lynch mob is unacceptable, however one has to accept that the rule of law applies to those we don't like as well as the ones we do. So what galls me is the polarized extremists on either side of any argument for they are identical. Justice only for their friends and idols. So cutting to the chase I think lynching the McCanns in the press and on forums is undesirable in a society that considers itself civilised. By the same token lynching Dr Amaral in the press and on forums is equally undesirable. But as long as this forum is split into Liverpool supporters and Manchester United supporters* the lynchings and character assassinations will continue."unqoute.

Excellent post I agree 100%

I would add that many people see the persecution of Amaral as the conclusion to the case. There is no closure until little Maddie is found. Amaral is just one of the many people Team Mcs have set out to destroy-and keep themselves squeaky clean-denying any responsibility in their daughters fate (what ever that is).

There is also the other matter regarding this Amaral case; and that is the attack on Portuguese civil liberties and human right Act- denying freedom of speech and expression without fear or intimidation by state. But many forget that this is at the heart of this case-and my personal interest in it.

Amaral was vindicated and his book was un-banned- a victory for Justice. Check out the forum name in case you need reminding why YOU are here.


It is indeed. My right to write or say anything about you ends when what I write or say infringes your rights. Wouldn't you agree?

ferryman

  • Guest
It does not mean dave, he got his basic thesis wrong, does it ?

His criminal conviction, in a separate  trial, for lying to cover up torture in another case he presided over, on its own, doesn't, no.

But his book compared with the official files certainly does ...


Offline Miss Taken Identity

Kate lied in her book!

She said so!

But I guess that's different because she isn't doing it for the money.... oh ...wait...


Oh and we all know there is more than one lie told.
'Never underestimate the power of stupid people'... George Carlin

Offline misty

IMO this case will be used to justify any challenges made against the existence of secret courts.


« Last Edit: June 28, 2014, 04:26:35 AM by John »