UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on December 19, 2015, 11:53:11 AM
-
Following on from another thread on which there seemed to be little agreement with regards to a statement DCI Redwood made not long before retiring, I thought it may be interesting to get the thoughts of the forum members to what they thought the statement below actually meant
"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted. That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann."
-
Following on from another thread on which there seemed to be little agreement with regards to a statement DCI Redwood made not long before retiring, I thought it may be interesting to get the thoughts of the forum members to what they thought the statement below actually meant
"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted. That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann."
As Stephen already pointed out in the original thread it meant that Redwood hadn't a baldy clue what happened to her and as far as I can see his replacement Miss Walls is none the wiser either.
This inquiry will only move forward when something tangible turns up or someone comes forward with information.
-
As Stephen already pointed out in the original thread it meant that Redwood hadn't a baldy clue what happened to her and as far as I can see his replacement Miss Walls is none the wiser either.
This inquiry will only move forward when something tangible turns up or someone comes forward with information.
Stephen also pointed this out in another thread:
''After all, you are not privy to the investigation, so you wouldn't have a clue viz a viz, what is now going on''.
-
Let's give Redwood's quote its proper context shall we, Faithlilly, if that's alright with you?
"This is an offender who has got a very, very unhealthy interest in young, white, female children who he is attacking whilst they are on holiday in their beds," he said.
"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted.
"That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann. It is really critical for us to identify this offender and prove or disprove whether he was involved in Madeleine's disappearance."
Why would his meaning (now that you have the proper context) have anything whatsoever to do with any theory to do with the parents, which is what you are hoping and praying it means?
-
Let's give Redwood's quote its proper context shall we, Faithlilly, if that's alright with you?
"This is an offender who has got a very, very unhealthy interest in young, white, female children who he is attacking whilst they are on holiday in their beds," he said.
"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted.
"That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann. It is really critical for us to identify this offender and prove or disprove whether he was involved in Madeleine's disappearance."
Why would his meaning (now that you have the proper context) have anything whatsoever to do with any theory to do with the parents, which is what you are hoping and praying it means?
So no real difference then?
-
Anyone who thinks Redwood's statement implicate's the parents is living in cloud cuckoo land
-
Anyone who thinks Redwood's statement implicate's the parents is living in cloud cuckoo land
'cloud cuckoo land'
Is this the current residing place of the abduction thesis ? £4%4%
-
So no real difference then?
Context is everything. If you can't see that then there really is no hope for you.
-
Anyone who thinks Redwood's statement implicate's the parents is living in cloud cuckoo land
The "sceptics" seem to think that in the midst of appealing for information about a vile sex attacker on the Algarve who targeted young girls that Redwood inserted a sentence to say that the Met's thinking was that Madeleine's disappearance may have nothing to do with this man and that she may not have been abducted by him at all (inference - the parents dunnit). If anyone can explain why they think this is a logical assumption to make, kindly spell it out now.
-
The "sceptics" seem to think that in the midst of appealing for information about a vile sex attacker on the Algarve who targeted young girls that Redwood inserted a sentence to say that the Met's thinking was that Madeleine's disappearance may have nothing to do with this man and that she may not have been abducted by him at all (inference - the parents dunnit). If anyone can explain why they think this is a logical assumption to make, kindly spell it out now.
Sadly, this guy doesn't seem to have materialised, any more than Madeleine has.
-
Sadly, this guy doesn't seem to have materialised, any more than Madeleine has.
No, but unless you think several parents and children were making it up, he did or does exist and needs to be id'ed.
-
Context is everything. If you can't see that then there really is no hope for you.
You added nothing that wasn't inherent in the original.
-
You added nothing that wasn't inherent in the original.
In your opinion. In my opinion it gave context to the remarks which were made during an appeal for information about a vile sex attacker on the Algarve in an effort to ID him. No mention in the OP about a sex attacker on the Algarve with an unhealthy interest in young white girls nor the fact that Redwood made this appeal because he believed it was critical to the investigation to ID him. Redwood wasn't simply shooting the breeze and letting slip the view that the Met were considering accident and cover-up as a scenario, as is clearly the implication in this thread.
-
No, but unless you think several parents and children were making it up, he did or does exist and needs to be id'ed.
The fact that these excellent detectives haven't identified him (as far as we know, and I think we would know if they had), it is just possible that this figure is not as real as the police have been led to believe.
-
The fact that these excellent detectives haven't identified him (as far as we know, and I think we would know if they had), it is just possible that this figure is not as real as the police have been led to believe.
So you think it's credible that several families may have invented this man simply because the police have not yet found him? And they would have done this why?
-
So you think it's credible that several families may have invented this man simply because the police have not yet found him? And they would have done this why?
Certainly not invented, but perhaps exaggerated, or possibly misinterpreted if they made their complaints to the Portuguese police.
-
Certainly not invented, but perhaps exaggerated, or possibly misinterpreted if they made their complaints to the Portuguese police.
Maybe the translations left something to be desired ?
-
Maybe the translations left something to be desired ?
Methinks I've heard that before from McCann supporters. 8**8:/:
-
Certainly not invented, but perhaps exaggerated, or possibly misinterpreted if they made their complaints to the Portuguese police.
Why is it not conceivable to you that these attacks actually happened?
-
Why is it not conceivable to you that these attacks actually happened?
The fact that they happened supports the abdication theory therefore they have to be dismissed at all costs
Haven't these families given statements to Grange
-
The fact that they happened supports the abdication theory therefore they have to be dismissed at all costs
Haven't these families given statements to Grange
Pure speculation.
-
Why is it not conceivable to you that these attacks actually happened?
Not saying they didn't . Am saying that SY's finest appear not to have been able to identified anyone and bring them to justice, possibly because the cases were not exactly as reported.
-
Not saying they didn't . Am saying that SY's finest appear not to have been able to identified anyone and bring them to justice, possibly because the cases were not exactly as reported.
They happened in Portugal
-
Not saying they didn't . Am saying that SY's finest appear not to have been able to identified anyone and bring them to justice, possibly because the cases were not exactly as reported.
Do you accept that even the finest investigative agencies are sometimes unable to solve a crime, not because it didn't happen as reported but because there simply wasn't enough solid evidence or leads to lead to charges? For example no one has yet been charged with Claudia Lawrences's disappearance, does that mean she wasn't abducted and / or murdered?
-
Not saying they didn't . Am saying that SY's finest appear not to have been able to identified anyone and bring them to justice, possibly because the cases were not exactly as reported.
Isn't it blatantly obvious that SY do not have the jurisdiction or resources to investigate these crimes
-
Certainly not invented, but perhaps exaggerated, or possibly misinterpreted if they made their complaints to the Portuguese police.
Quote from Kate's book
These incidents had occurred within an hour's drive of Praia da Luz over the three years prior to Madeleine's disappearance. The PJ had never mentioned any of them to us. In fact, I gathered from the files some of them hadn't even been recorded by the authorities at the time they were reported (evidently they were not considered to be actual crimes). So they might never have been brought to light if the parents of these children hadn't been brave enough to come forward to the British police after Madeleine was taken and relive their nightmares . They did so in the belief that there could be a link between what had happened to their children and what had happened to her.
Unquote
So no translations necessary. Also when they reported it to the UK police - I doubt if any of those different parents were aware that other parents had had the same vile crime committed against their children whilst they were in Portugal - or that they had also come forward and reported it to the police in this country. That makes those parents completely credible witnesses IMO.
Sexual assault of a child by a stranger in their own bedroom - needs no exaggeration. It's already 100% totally horrific.
-
Quote from Kate's book
These incidents had occurred within an hour's drive of Praia da Luz over the three years prior to Madeleine's disappearance. The PJ had never mentioned any of them to us. In fact, I gathered from the files some of them hadn't even been recorded by the authorities at the time they were reported (evidently they were not considered to be actual crimes). So they might never have been brought to light if the parents of these children hadn't been brave enough to come forward to the British police after Madeleine was taken and relive their nightmares . They did so in the belief that there could be a link between what had happened to their children and what had happened to her.
Unquote
So no translations necessary. Also when they reported it to the UK police - I doubt if any of those different parents were aware that other parents had had the same vile crime committed against their children whilst they were in Portugal - or that they had also come forward and reported it to the police in this country. That makes those parents completely credible witnesses IMO.
Sexual assault of a child by a stranger in their own bedroom - needs no exaggeration. It's already 100% totally horrific.
But only British children. Very odd.
-
But only British children. Very odd.
You find British families reporting crimes to British police odd...
-
But only British children. Very odd.
Why is it very odd?
-
The fact that they happened supports the abdication theory therefore they have to be dismissed at all costs
Haven't these families given statements to Grange
??
-
??
There is some relatively new technology call predictive sex
Which sometimes causes problems with pests
-
There is some relatively new technology call predictive sex
Which sometimes causes problems with pests
Yeah, just ask Faithfully, when she was addressing her posts to Musty @)(++(*
-
Following on from another thread on which there seemed to be little agreement with regards to a statement DCI Redwood made not long before retiring, I thought it may be interesting to get the thoughts of the forum members to what they thought the statement below actually meant
"While I completely accept that there are differences (between the break-ins and the McCann case), there is no abduction that we can see, but the assumption from that is that Madeleine McCann has been abducted. That may not necessarily follow with all our thinking about what may have become of Madeleine McCann."
Its gobbledegook, plain and simple. Direct clear statements wouldnt go amiss
-
Its gobbledegook, plain and simple. Direct clear statements wouldnt go amiss
Redwood has been plain and simple
McCanns not suspects
What's plainer than that
-
Redwood has been plain and simple
McCanns not suspects
What's plainer than that
Interesting choice of words to describe Redwood's actions.
'Redwood said the assumption that Madeleine was abducted "may not follow with all our thinking" on the case.'
Meanwhile, all that money spent, Redwood retired, and nothing to show for it.
-
Okay, Fellers. Stay with the On Topic and Non Insulting. Otherwise I might get cross.
-
Redwood has been plain and simple
McCanns not suspects
What's plainer than that
Did Redwood say they had been questioned? Nope he cleared Tannerman and resurrected Amaral's Smithman and brought the dogs back. He wasn't looking for a living abducted child.
-
Did Redwood say they had been questioned? Nope he cleared Tannerman and resurrected Amaral's Smithman and brought the dogs back. He wasn't looking for a living abducted child.
I will be very interested to see exactly what SY have been doing...rather than all this speculation...we won't find out until they have completed their investigations...which could be some way off
-
I will be very interested to see exactly what SY have been doing...rather than all this speculation...we won't find out until they have completed their investigations...which could be some way off
It isn't that far off.
-
It isn't that far off.
do you have a cite for that
-
do you have a cite for that
April 2016, when funding runs out.
-
April 2016, when funding runs out.
the funding is until april 2016 when the situation for funding will be re assessed......
-
I would think financial assessment is well underway by now. Decisions like this are not just made on the spur of the moment, are they?
-
I would think financial assessment is well underway by now. Decisions like this are not just made on the spur of the moment, are they?
there has been no notice that this is the final funding...stephen has failed to provide a cite
-
the funding is until april 2016 when the situation for funding will be re assessed......
Is that a cite ?
-
Is that a cite ?
i dont have to provide a cite.....i made no claim...you did...and you cannot provide a cite