UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on January 24, 2016, 11:19:21 AM
-
From the first the McCanns endeavoured to push their friend's sighting of a man carrying a child to centre stage.
The PJ were less than convinced by Tanner's credibility as a witness yet the McCanns still pushed, using political channels, for the description to be circulated. Further the McCanns own private investigators also had little faith in Tanner's sighting, telling the McCanns that their limited funds would be better spent investigating the Smith sighting.
Of course we now know that, according to SY, Tannerman was almost certainly an ordinary dad carrying his child home from the night crèche yet untold police, private investigator and public hours have been wasted chasing a swarthy spectre who, in all reality, didn't exist.
My question is twofold. Firstly is it ever a good idea for victims of a crime to run a parallel investigation when there is already an official one in progress and secondly has the McCanns decision to try to steer the investigation by subtle manipulations behind the scenes and very public pronouncements in front in any way helped further the search for their daughter or have they in fact, innocently or otherwise, made it harder for the authorities to now ever learn the truth ?
159
-
From the first the McCanns endeavoured to push their friend's sighting of a man carrying a child to centre stage.
The PJ were less than convinced by Tanner's credibility as a witness yet the McCanns still pushed, using political channels, for the description to be circulated. Further the McCanns own private investigators also had little faith in Tanner's sighting, telling the McCanns that their limited funds would be better spent investigating the Smith sighting.
Of course we now know that, according to SY, Tannerman was almost certainly an ordinary dad carrying his child home from the night crèche yet untold police, private investigator and public hours have been wasted chasing a swarthy spectre who, in all reality, didn't exist.
My question is twofold. Firstly is it ever a good idea for victims of a crime to run a parallel investigation when there is already an official one in progress and secondly has the McCanns decision to try to steer the investigation by subtle manipulations behind the scenes and very public pronouncements in front in any way helped further the search for their daughter or have they in fact, innocently or otherwise, made it harder for the authorities to now ever learn the truth ?
Question. If OG shuts down and there is 750K in the Find Madeleine fund should the McCanns simply decide to hand this to charity ...
Or should they investigate?
-
Question. If OG shuts down and there is 750K in the Find Madeleine fund should the McCanns simply decide to hand this to charity ...
Or should they investigate?
I think that would be a decision very much for them to make ... they have said they will never give up on Madeleine and I do not believe they ever will.
-
Finding Smithman should definitely be left to the police.
-
From the first the McCanns endeavoured to push their friend's sighting of a man carrying a child to centre stage.
The PJ were less than convinced by Tanner's credibility as a witness yet the McCanns still pushed, using political channels, for the description to be circulated. Further the McCanns own private investigators also had little faith in Tanner's sighting, telling the McCanns that their limited funds would be better spent investigating the Smith sighting.
Of course we now know that, according to SY, Tannerman was almost certainly an ordinary dad carrying his child home from the night crèche yet untold police, private investigator and public hours have been wasted chasing a swarthy spectre who, in all reality, didn't exist.
My question is twofold. Firstly is it ever a good idea for victims of a crime to run a parallel investigation when there is already an official one in progress and secondly has the McCanns decision to try to steer the investigation by subtle manipulations behind the scenes and very public pronouncements in front in any way helped further the search for their daughter or have they in fact, innocently or otherwise, made it harder for the authorities to now ever learn the truth ?
Hmmm. I'm not sure how many of your premises are substantiated on that.
The LCD seems to be that Jane Tanner saw someone, within a plausible timeframe, who might have been carrying the missing child.
When she couldn't be sure if the person she saw was Murat or not, her account was deemed to be suspicious. She was even accused of being a liar, with all sorts of indirect sinister implications.
A simple question: did the PJ check the crèche records or make a public appeal for any innocent male carrying a child that evening to come forward?
-
From the first the McCanns endeavoured to push their friend's sighting of a man carrying a child to centre stage.
The PJ were less than convinced by Tanner's credibility as a witness yet the McCanns still pushed, using political channels, for the description to be circulated. Further the McCanns own private investigators also had little faith in Tanner's sighting, telling the McCanns that their limited funds would be better spent investigating the Smith sighting.
Of course we now know that, according to SY, Tannerman was almost certainly an ordinary dad carrying his child home from the night crèche yet untold police, private investigator and public hours have been wasted chasing a swarthy spectre who, in all reality, didn't exist.
My question is twofold. Firstly is it ever a good idea for victims of a crime to run a parallel investigation when there is already an official one in progress and secondly has the McCanns decision to try to steer the investigation by subtle manipulations behind the scenes and very public pronouncements in front in any way helped further the search for their daughter or have they in fact, innocently or otherwise, made it harder for the authorities to now ever learn the truth ?
I think that some of the things done by them or in their name is bordering on perverting the course of justice. The approaching of witnesses by them, Kennedy and their PI's could be described as intimidation;
Jeremy received calls from Gerry in relation to gaining permission from him to use his name in a portfolio of evidence being compiled by an organization employed by the McCanns. They were very persistent and made several attempts to contact him both at work and at home. They had no objection to being included but were concerned as to the method being used.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY_BRIGET.htm
want to add that since January this year I have received numerous phone calls, messages and visits from the press regarding the collector of donations, which in turn put me in contact with other people such as Brian Kennedy, Kate and Gerry McCann. I feel that this is a constraint that makes it difficult to take the more correct decision.
I tried always to cooperate with the police in every way possible, telephoning them at the first available opportunity as soon as the news broke about the disappearance of Madeleine. There are certain times when I feel like a pawn in chess.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAUL_GORDON.htm
He has been contacted by numerous tabloid press looking for stories. He has been contacted by Mr Brian Kennedy who is supporting the McCann family to take part in a photo fit exercise. He has given no stories or helped in any photo fits.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
-
Hmmm ... from the people who would have been 'battering down every door in Praia da luz' ... we bring you an exercise in hypocrisy.
-
Hmmm ... from the people who would have been 'battering down every door in Praia da luz' ... we bring you an exercise in hypocrisy.
If that was aimed at me, I don't recall ever using that phrase? Apologies if you were speaking of someone else, or if you have a cite.
Just to be clear, I would have searched and searched, but not battered down any doors or interfered with any witnesses. Door knocking and witness interviewing are jobs for the police, not amateurs.
-
the irony of the question posed in this thread title cannot go unremarked upon. There are dozens / hundreds of internet sleuths who have been busily beavering away trying to solve this case for years, all from a position of relative ignorance when compared to Operation Grange, but has that stopped them? No. There are thousands of people who believe that they are on a quest to bring "Justice 4 Maddie" who believe they know as much or more than the investigating team currently working on the case, which is both laughable and sad. So I say, yes - leave it to the police and those that DO have full access to the facts of the case and to those who were involved in the events of the night of 3rd May, you sleuths don't have the answers, and in most cases you're probably not even asking the right questions.
-
We should have free for all.
Everyone should be allowed to do what the hell they please.
Why bother with laws and social mores and all that haraz, they only get in the way.
Think of the money it would save not having a police force 'n' courts 'n' stuff.
My next career is worked out on that basis.
Firearms dealer 8(>((
I guess that's the way folk think it should go if they try to justify "parallel police forces".
-
the irony of the question posed in this thread title cannot go unremarked upon. There are dozens / hundreds of internet sleuths who have been busily beavering away trying to solve this case for years, all from a position of relative ignorance when compared to Operation Grange, but has that stopped them? No. There are thousands of people who believe that they are on a quest to bring "Justice 4 Maddie" who believe they know as much or more than the investigating team currently working on the case, which is both laughable and sad. So I say, yes - leave it to the police and those that DO have full access to the facts of the case and to those who were involved in the events of the night of 3rd May, you sleuths don't have the answers, and in most cases you're probably not even asking the right questions.
Why in heaven's name do you have to make everything so personal Alfie ? Couldn't you for once just try and answer the question posed ?-
-
We should have free for all.
Everyone should be allowed to do what the hell they please.
Why bother with laws and social mores and all that haraz, they only get in the way.
Think of the money it would save not having a police force 'n' courts 'n' stuff.
My next career is worked out on that basis.
Firearms dealer 8(>((
I guess that's the way folk think it should go if they try to justify "parallel police forces".
once again you totally miss the point and make a rather ridiculous post....no one is suggesting that anyone acts outside the law
-
From the first the McCanns endeavoured to push their friend's sighting of a man carrying a child to centre stage.
The PJ were less than convinced by Tanner's credibility as a witness yet the McCanns still pushed, using political channels, for the description to be circulated. Further the McCanns own private investigators also had little faith in Tanner's sighting, telling the McCanns that their limited funds would be better spent investigating the Smith sighting.
Of course we now know that, according to SY, Tannerman was almost certainly an ordinary dad carrying his child home from the night crèche yet untold police, private investigator and public hours have been wasted chasing a swarthy spectre who, in all reality, didn't exist.
My question is twofold. Firstly is it ever a good idea for victims of a crime to run a parallel investigation when there is already an official one in progress and secondly has the McCanns decision to try to steer the investigation by subtle manipulations behind the scenes and very public pronouncements in front in any way helped further the search for their daughter or have they in fact, innocently or otherwise, made it harder for the authorities to now ever learn the truth ?
I think it is a totally ridiculous post based entirely on your dislike of the McCanns. We live in a free society and individuals are entitled to do what they want within the law.....should a patient be able to seek alternative medical treatment whilst still undergoing NHS treatment...of course they should be able to
-
if the PJ had carried out anything like a proper investigation there would have been no need for the McCanns to have launched there own
-
if the PJ had carried out anything like a proper investigation there would have been no need for the McCanns to have launched there own
Well, the McCanns gave them lots of time didn't they? They complained abut the PJ n the night of 3rd-4th May and within nine days they were using CRG.
-
Well, the McCanns gave them lots of time didn't they? They complained abut the PJ n the night of 3rd-4th May and within nine days they were using CRG.
and many can see why
-
Well, the McCanns gave them lots of time didn't they? They complained abut the PJ n the night of 3rd-4th May and within nine days they were using CRG.
It could be argued that by undermining the police investigation at every opportunity via the media the McCanns did themselves what they had accused Amaral's book of doing, harming the search for their daughter. What sensible person would approach the police with information if they thought that that information would not be followed up, thrown in the waste paper basket or any of the other of the umpteen things the PJ were accused of doing with it ?
-
It could be argued that by undermining the police investigation at every opportunity via the media the McCanns did themselves what they had accused Amaral's book of doing, harming the search for their daughter. What sensible person would approach the police with information if they thought that that information would not be followed up, thrown in the waste paper basket or any of the other of the umpteen things the PJ were accused of doing with it ?
The Portuguese police didn't seem to have a problem a member of the local community collecting information on their behalf, despite having been made aware of suspicions about her son. One can only wonder what effect that had on anyone who was also holding potentially vital information.
-
It could be argued that by undermining the police investigation at every opportunity via the media the McCanns did themselves what they had accused Amaral's book of doing, harming the search for their daughter. What sensible person would approach the police with information if they thought that that information would not be followed up, thrown in the waste paper basket or any of the other of the umpteen things the PJ were accused of doing with it ?
I followed the case VERY carefuly buying more than one newspaper each day, sometimes several.
All I can say is that I am astounded that you accuse the Mccanns of undermining the PJ.
Rather the reverse seemed what happened to me. I was incensed by the propaganda put out.
Tbh, I felt sick inside every time the Mccanns said that they had every faith in the Police, cos I read the media info coming in as totally the reverse ... but I realised that the Mccanns had to appear as tho they were pleased with The PJ because at that time they thought that they were the only hope of finding Madeleine. It seemed to me that they could not afford to alienate them because of this.
-
The Portuguese police didn't seem to have a problem a member of the local community collecting information on their behalf, despite having been made aware of suspicions about her son. One can only wonder what effect that had on anyone who was also holding potentially vital information.
Not sure what that has to do with the McCanns undermining the police investigation via the media misty.
-
Not sure what that has to do with the McCanns undermining the police investigation via the media misty.
You referred to the PJ being accused of binning information given to them. That was a long time after the investigation began. The header for the topic is "should a police investigation be left to the police"? Was it OK for locals in Portugal to undermine the investigation as long as responsibility for that was not attributed to the PJ?
-
The Portuguese police didn't seem to have a problem a member of the local community collecting information on their behalf, despite having been made aware of suspicions about her son. One can only wonder what effect that had on anyone who was also holding potentially vital information.
That's unfair IMO to Mrs M who was making a genuine effort to help the investigation. What about all the information hundreds of people phoned to that coldline?
-
That's unfair IMO to Mrs M who was making a genuine effort to help the investigation. What about all the information hundreds of people phoned to that coldline?
After 40 years of living in Portugal, I'm sure Mrs M was fully aware of the way judicial secrecy worked & how the police operated. The filming of her stall was all over the TV. If the PJ had any problems with outside interference, their failure to remove her from the scene set a precedent as far as collecting information was concerned.
-
It could be argued that by undermining the police investigation at every opportunity via the media the McCanns did themselves what they had accused Amaral's book of doing, harming the search for their daughter. What sensible person would approach the police with information if they thought that that information would not be followed up, thrown in the waste paper basket or any of the other of the umpteen things the PJ were accused of doing with it ?
Could we please have some rock solid examples of the McCanns undermining the PJ via the media leading up to the case being shelved? Do you not agree that the media did a fair bit of undemining of the McCanns during this period?
-
Question. If OG shuts down and there is 750K in the Find Madeleine fund should the McCanns simply decide to hand this to charity ...
Or should they investigate?
They should keep on looking as long as they are able.
It is my belief that Madeleine is still alive.
-
I followed the case VERY carefuly buying more than one newspaper each day, sometimes several.
All I can say is that I am astounded that you accuse the Mccanns of undermining the PJ.
Rather the reverse seemed what happened to me. I was incensed by the propaganda put out.
Tbh, I felt sick inside every time the Mccanns said that they had every faith in the Police, cos I read the media info coming in as totally the reverse ... but I realised that the Mccanns had to appear as tho they were pleased with The PJ because at that time they thought that they were the only hope of finding Madeleine. It seemed to me that they could not afford to alienate them because of this.
What on earth are you on about ?
You only have to read what the mccanns said about the police investigating the case to see their attitude towards them.
So dont try whitewashing it Sadie, it won't work.
-
What on earth are you on about ?
You only have to read what the mccanns said about the police investigating the case to see their attitude towards them.
So dont try whitewashing it Sadie, it won't work.
Dont forget the timing stephen. It wasn't until after all the disinformation / propaganda against them was ?deliberatly leaked in the media and the Arguido status was dropped on them ... along with the absolute realisation that the PJ were NOT even looking for a living Madeleine that The Mccanns reacted in any way at all.
Prior to all these awful happenings and realisations the Mccanns were politeness and helpfulness personified.
-
once again you totally miss the point and make a rather ridiculous post....no one is suggesting that anyone acts outside the law
As there are no regulations yet in this country for private investigators it would be fatuous to assume some will not stray over the line. But then if you like the idea of uncontrolled, unlicensed persons carrying out criminal investigations in this country ......................
It doesn't pass the LBJ test.
-
You referred to the PJ being accused of binning information given to them. That was a long time after the investigation began. The header for the topic is "should a police investigation be left to the police"? Was it OK for locals in Portugal to undermine the investigation as long as responsibility for that was not attributed to the PJ?
There is a vast difference between supplying small pieces of information as the residents of PDL would have done to using political leverage to have a description released that neither the PJ, nor subsequent PIs, thought had any credibility. If you can't see that then there really is nothing else to say.
-
Sometimes people can be two-faced Sadie. The McCanns may have supported the PJ publicly, but they told a different tale privately;
he had spoken to the local police but they were not taking the situation seriously. I remember Gerry saying that they did not treat the matter with urgency and only stated that Madeleine must have left on her own and that she would be back later.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PATRICIA_CAMERON.htm
She was worried by the fact that there were only two police officers in the place and thought that the police were not helping her with anything.......I felt that Kate and Gerry were focused on the idea to find Madeleine in their own way, and the local police had not progressed.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/L-R-MCQUEEN.htm
Saturday, the 5th of May of 2007. Kate was still frustrated and anguished and felt that nobody was doing anything to help find Madeleine. She told me that the police had left in the morning and returned around 09H30 and that now only a few agents with sniffer dogs were in the locale.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/M_THOMPSON.htm
On the following night at about midnight, Kate contacted me by phone, she was devastated and appeared lost. She said that judging from the action of the local police, one would think that she "had lost a dog"
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/NICKY_GILL.htm
-
The PJ were NOT EVEN looking for a living Madeleine. Of course they would push, but publicly they supported and praused the PJ to the hilt until the PJ started getting really nasty and they realised that they were almost certainly being "fitted up"
-
The PJ were NOT EVEN looking for a living Madeleine. Of course they would push, but publicly they supported and praused the PJ to the hilt until the PJ started getting really nasty and they realised that they were almost certainly being "fitted up"
Your opinion.
Can you cite any proof for what you said ?
-
The PJ were NOT EVEN looking for a living Madeleine. Of course they would push, but publicly they supported and praused the PJ to the hilt until the PJ started getting really nasty and they realised that they were almost certainly being "fitted up"
The GNR searched PdL for a week hoping to find the child. All leave was cancelled. Dogs were used. I think it's untrue to suggest no-one searched for a living child. The PJ chased around following up sightings. The McCanns supported the PJ publicly and undermined them privately from the very beginning.
-
Could we please have some rock solid examples of the McCanns undermining the PJ via the media leading up to the case being shelved? Do you not agree that the media did a fair bit of undemining of the McCanns during this period?
One example is Kate phoning friends and family at the time she was made an arguida and giving them the green light to rubbish the PJ to the media.
-
After 40 years of living in Portugal, I'm sure Mrs M was fully aware of the way judicial secrecy worked & how the police operated. The filming of her stall was all over the TV. If the PJ had any problems with outside interference, their failure to remove her from the scene set a precedent as far as collecting information was concerned.
You criticise Mrs M who was just trying to help yet you make no mention of the UK private detective type peeps who commenced private investigations and witness interviews in Luz in May 2007
-
You criticise Mrs M who was just trying to help yet you make no mention of the UK private detective type peeps who commenced private investigations and witness interviews in Luz in May 2007
Are you sure of this?
I am not challenging. I have been thinking about the 'biggest PJ mistake thread' and a couple of interesting role-play viewpoints come to mind.
What would I have done if I headed the PJ investigation, at the end of Fri 4 May? The T9 statements were in and were confusing, to put it mildly. Two teams of forensics were saying no break-in. Three was a media maelstrom. It was emerging, I believe, in the UK press that the shutters had been jemmied, when quite clearly they had not. The vast bulk of OC guests would fly out tomorrow. If I were SIO, what would I have made of it all, and what should my priorities have been?
Then we have the McCann viewpoint, which must have been equally bewildering. No forensic reports. What appears to be broad consensus in the T9 about how the holiday in general went, and how Thu 3 May went. Kate saying the shutter and window were open, while the two gates and patio door were not. Evidence, Gerry, that the shutter could be opened from outside. Dianne trying the same and failing. A media maelstrom. Stories emerging from the UK that might or might not have an origin in Portugal. Why jemmied shutter if you can push it up without a jemmy? And the vast bulk of OC guests will fly out tomorrow.
Were there really witness interviews conducted by private individuals in Luz in May 2007?
-
One example is Kate phoning friends and family at the time she was made an arguida and giving them the green light to rubbish the PJ to the media.
Can we have a cite for that please?
-
You criticise Mrs M who was just trying to help yet you make no mention of the UK private detective type peeps who commenced private investigations and witness interviews in Luz in May 2007
Was JM "helping" at the behest of the PJ or the McCanns?
Who, outside the Tapas 9, was interviewed in Portugal by PIs which were brought in to assist the McCanns?
-
Was JM "helping" at the behest of the PJ or the McCanns?
Who, outside the Tapas 9, was interviewed in Portugal by PIs which were brought in to assist the McCanns?
Why would that be of consequence?
-
Why would that be of consequence?
In response to the allegation that the McCanns had immediately launched a parallel investigation using their own PI's to gather information for their own use.
-
In response to the allegation that the McCanns had immediately launched a parallel investigation using their own PI's to gather information for their own use.
So were the T9 interviewed by PIs in the employ of the McCann's or their backers ?
-
Can we have a cite for that please?
BILTON: Kate McCann is at the station for 13 hours, but from inside she and Trish text out updates. Even at this point the message is being controlled.
McGUINNESS: We were a bit naughty because we did have messages coming out of the police station which we weren't supposed to...
BILTON: How did that work.. what, the text messages?
McGUINNESS: Yeah.
BILTON: And were the texts saying? Talk us through.
McGUINNESS: Sort of updates from things that were happening.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
I don't have Kate's book but I think she says in it that they phoned relatives and friends and gave permission for them to publicise what was happening.
-
BILTON: Kate McCann is at the station for 13 hours, but from inside she and Trish text out updates. Even at this point the message is being controlled.
McGUINNESS: We were a bit naughty because we did have messages coming out of the police station which we weren't supposed to...
BILTON: How did that work.. what, the text messages?
McGUINNESS: Yeah.
BILTON: And were the texts saying? Talk us through.
McGUINNESS: Sort of updates from things that were happening.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
I don't have Kate's book but I think she says in it that they phoned relatives and friends and gave permission for them to publicise what was happening.
Yeah!
Jane Tanner another. Spoke on the panorama programme about the man she saw (and risked imprisonment for doing so).
But, you know, when the official police of the country investigating the crime couldn't abide by their own secrecy laws (at least until Rebelo took over, and I seem to recall there was even a leak on his watch) and when you have outright and flagrant lies such as Gerry not Madeleine's father being peddled, let's not be too selective ....
-
Yeah!
Jane Tanner another. Spoke on the panorama programme about the man she saw (and risked imprisonment for doing so).
But, you know, when the official police of the country investigating the crime couldn't abide by their own secrecy laws (at least until Rebelo took over, and I seem to recall there was even a leak on his watch) and when you have outright and flagrant lies such as Gerry not Madeleine's father being peddled, let's not be too selective ....
At this stage the investigation was not into Madeleine McCann's disappearance ... it was an investigation into her parents supposed culpability in the disappearance.
The Policia Judicairia had been using the media to promote the Amaral thesis since May 2007 ... how inconsiderate it was of the targets of this propaganda to have realised this and to have made sure the outside world was aware of where they were and what was happening to them.
Just as important ... they had a ringside seat and knew without doubt that while this nonsense was being visited upon them ... there was no official search or investigation taking place on behalf of Madeleine McCann.
One can only imagine the distress such knowledge must have engendered.
Thank God the incompetence which led to their being made arguidos led nowhere ... leaving them free to pursue looking for Madeleine and eventually having her case re-opened as a result of their efforts.
I cannot understand the attitude which makes resistance to that translate into the opprobrium it has ... takes all kinds, I suppose.
-
BILTON: Kate McCann is at the station for 13 hours, but from inside she and Trish text out updates. Even at this point the message is being controlled.
McGUINNESS: We were a bit naughty because we did have messages coming out of the police station which we weren't supposed to...
BILTON: How did that work.. what, the text messages?
McGUINNESS: Yeah.
BILTON: And were the texts saying? Talk us through.
McGUINNESS: Sort of updates from things that were happening.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
I don't have Kate's book but I think she says in it that they phoned relatives and friends and gave permission for them to publicise what was happening.
A specific cite regarding Kate's request for friends and family to start rubbishing the PJ please.
-
At this stage the investigation was not into Madeleine McCann's disappearance ... it was an investigation into her parents supposed culpability in the disappearance.
The Policia Judicairia had been using the media to promote the Amaral thesis since May 2007 ... how inconsiderate it was of the targets of this propaganda to have realised this and to have made sure the outside world was aware of where they were and what was happening to them.
Just as important ... they had a ringside seat and knew without doubt that while this nonsense was being visited upon them ... there was no official search or investigation taking place on behalf of Madeleine McCann.
One can only imagine the distress such knowledge must have engendered.
Thank God the incompetence which led to their being made arguidos led nowhere ... leaving them free to pursue looking for Madeleine and eventually having her case re-opened as a result of their efforts.
I cannot understand the attitude which makes resistance to that translate into the opprobrium it has ... takes all kinds, I suppose.
Full marks to the McCanns for thwarting the official police investigation. After all, isn't that how the parents of every missing child behaves?
-
A specific cite regarding Kate's request for friends and family to start rubbishing the PJ please.
A pleasure to help.
From Kate McCanns book - Madeleine.
17
ARGUIDOS
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.
-
Full marks to the McCanns for thwarting the official police investigation. After all, isn't that how the parents of every missing child behaves?
Not if the police are actually carrying out an investigation into the missing child ... however when police incompetence has squandered the golden hours and there is the despair of knowing they are wrongly trying to pin the disappearance in the wrong place entirely ... they have to take up the fight on behalf of their missing daughter.
With no evidence to the contrary ... Madeleine is out there and so is the person who took her.
-
At this stage the investigation was not into Madeleine McCann's disappearance ... it was an investigation into her parents supposed culpability in the disappearance.
The Policia Judicairia had been using the media to promote the Amaral thesis since May 2007 ... how inconsiderate it was of the targets of this propaganda to have realised this and to have made sure the outside world was aware of where they were and what was happening to them.
Just as important ... they had a ringside seat and knew without doubt that while this nonsense was being visited upon them ... there was no official search or investigation taking place on behalf of Madeleine McCann.
One can only imagine the distress such knowledge must have engendered.
Thank God the incompetence which led to their being made arguidos led nowhere ... leaving them free to pursue looking for Madeleine and eventually having her case re-opened as a result of their efforts.
I cannot understand the attitude which makes resistance to that translate into the opprobrium it has ... takes all kinds, I suppose.
The police would have been failing in their duty if they hadn't considered everyone as suspect including the parents, the rest of the tapas group and anyone else who was around the Ocean Club Garden complex on the night of the 3rd May 2007.
-
The police would have been failing in their duty if they hadn't considered everyone as suspect including the parents, the rest of the tapas group and anyone else who was around the Ocean Club Garden complex on the night of the 3rd May 2007.
We all agree that the mccanns should have been suspects but amaral misunderstood both the dogs and the dna and incorrectly decided they proved Maddie had died in the aprtment
-
Not if the police are actually carrying out an investigation into the missing child ... however when police incompetence has squandered the golden hours and there is the despair of knowing they are wrongly trying to pin the disappearance in the wrong place entirely ... they have to take up the fight on behalf of their missing daughter.
With no evidence to the contrary ... Madeleine is out there and so is the person who took her.
If the police are guilty of squandering the golden hours then the McCanns are guilty of squandering the first hour.
-
ARGUIDOS
FriARGUIDOS
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.day
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm.
oh,,,, how self centred and selfish ..can this woman get.......why do you have to know how much sleep she had...she is lucky to sleep at all
mind you they slept well from the off it seems
-
From the first the McCanns endeavoured to push their friend's sighting of a man carrying a child to centre stage.
The PJ were less than convinced by Tanner's credibility as a witness yet the McCanns still pushed, using political channels, for the description to be circulated. Further the McCanns own private investigators also had little faith in Tanner's sighting, telling the McCanns that their limited funds would be better spent investigating the Smith sighting.
Of course we now know that, according to SY, Tannerman was almost certainly an ordinary dad carrying his child home from the night crèche yet untold police, private investigator and public hours have been wasted chasing a swarthy spectre who, in all reality, didn't exist.
My question is twofold. Firstly is it ever a good idea for victims of a crime to run a parallel investigation when there is already an official one in progress and secondly has the McCanns decision to try to steer the investigation by subtle manipulations behind the scenes and very public pronouncements in front in any way helped further the search for their daughter or have they in fact, innocently or otherwise, made it harder for the authorities to now ever learn the truth ?
The McCanns crooked investigators Oakley and Metodo destroyed any chance the police had of unravelling the mystery of Maddie's disappearance. They harassed witnesses and created false leads all to fill their own pockets. What a dreadful mess the McCanns created.
-
If the police are guilty of squandering the golden hours then the McCanns are guilty of squandering most the first hour.
Strictly speaking the clock started to tick from the time of the last independent sighting of the child.
-
ARGUIDOS
FriARGUIDOS
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.day
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm.
oh,,,, how self centred and selfish ..can this woman get.......why do you have to know how much sleep she had...she is lucky to sleep at all
mind you they slept well from the off it seems
Its called padding Tina. Helps fill a book.
-
Strictly speaking the clock started to tick from the time of the last independent sighting of the child.
I agree Alice, anything could have occurred after 5.30pm. The totally conflicting statements have only made it worse.
-
I think it is a totally ridiculous post based entirely on your dislike of the McCanns. We live in a free society and individuals are entitled to do what they want within the law.....should a patient be able to seek alternative medical treatment whilst still undergoing NHS treatment...of course they should be able to
But that's the whole point, it wasn't within the law and that's why Kennedy employed a Spanish outfit. No Portuguese PI firm could get involved as such a private investigation conflicted with the official one and as such broke Portuguese Law. I believe Kate even admitted to knowing this in her book and before anyone asks, look it up yourself.
-
The Portuguese police didn't seem to have a problem a member of the local community collecting information on their behalf, despite having been made aware of suspicions about her son. One can only wonder what effect that had on anyone who was also holding potentially vital information.
Actually, the information desk set up by Jenny Murat was for people who didn't want to speak to the police. In those circumstances therefore I cannot see her handing over anything without prior consent. She is to be commended for her quick thinking and her search for the truth. Unfortunately, she and Robert paid an awful price for only wanting to help.
-
But that's the whole point, it wasn't within the law and that's why Kennedy employed a Spanish outfit. No Portuguese PI firm could get involved as such a private investigation conflicted with the official one and as such broke Portuguese Law. I believe Kate even admitted to knowing this in her book and before anyone asks, look it up yourself.
I have looked it up and do not believe she does
-
A pleasure to help.
From Kate McCanns book - Madeleine.
17
ARGUIDOS
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.
Thank you John. I knew it was mentioned in the book, but haven't got a copy of it myself.
-
If the police are guilty of squandering the golden hours then the McCanns are guilty of squandering most the first hour.
Not the phone calls again please, Angelo.
Ensuring that Madeleine had not wakened and wandered filled the time until the GNR arrived ... the apartment was searched ... Dr Gerry McCann ensured the carefully 'staged' raised shutter was lowered in his panic to ensure it could not be raised from outside, only to discover it did.
Many people were engaged in searching the vicinity of the apartment.
By the time the GNR arrived on site ... the initial diligence of searching the immediate area for the child was accomplished including MW search procedures ... it was time for the seriousness of the situation to be addressed by broadening the search using missing child protocols.
Adding to the mix thinking about trains and boats and planes and even vehicles on highways ... the McCann's couldn't do that ... they could and should.
-
Not the phone calls again please, Angelo.
Ensuring that Madeleine had not wakened and wandered filled the time until the GNR arrived ... the apartment was searched ... Dr Gerry McCann ensured the carefully 'staged' raised shutter was lowered in his panic to ensure it could not be raised from outside, only to discover it did.
Many people were engaged in searching the vicinity of the apartment.
By the time the GNR arrived on site ... the initial diligence of searching the immediate area for the child was accomplished including MW search procedures ... it was time for the seriousness of the situation to be addressed by broadening the search using missing child protocols.
Adding to the mix thinking about trains and boats and planes and even vehicles on highways ... the McCann's couldn't do that ... they could and should.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing. Trains, boats, planes and vehicles could have been miles away before the police got there. There was no evidence of an intruder. There was no evidence of a burglary. There was no evidence of a struggle. The child's siblings were sleeping peacefully. Very few police forces would have started manning borders, creating roadblocks and chasing boats and flights in those circumstances. I would guess that in the same circumstances in the UK a search would have been begun and the cadaver dogs would have been there very quickly to check things out.
-
Not the phone calls again please, Angelo.
Ensuring that Madeleine had not wakened and wandered filled the time until the GNR arrived ... the apartment was searched ... Dr Gerry McCann ensured the carefully 'staged' raised shutter was lowered in his panic to ensure it could not be raised from outside, only to discover it did.
Many people were engaged in searching the vicinity of the apartment.
By the time the GNR arrived on site ... the initial diligence of searching the immediate area for the child was accomplished including MW search procedures ... it was time for the seriousness of the situation to be addressed by broadening the search using missing child protocols.
Adding to the mix thinking about trains and boats and planes and even vehicles on highways ... the McCann's couldn't do that ... they could and should.
They allegedly find their young daughter missing at 10pm but don't bother to phone the police. Sounds like the Ciprianos all over again?
-
Full marks to the McCanns for thwarting the official police investigation. After all, isn't that how the parents of every missing child behaves?
It is, parents being targeted by the police who know darned well they are innocent, yeah!
And who can blame them?
No one with an ounce of nous or insight, certainly ....
-
A pleasure to help.
From Kate McCanns book - Madeleine.
17
ARGUIDOS
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.
Hmmm... &%+((£ Rubbishing the PJ? And why on earth shouldn't family and friends voice their outrage and despair, if that is indeed how they were feeling? Your nearest and dearest have been accused of a most heinous crime that you are certain they haven't committed and you think you should remain mute and smile on regardless?
-
It is, parents being targeted by the police who know darned well they are innocent, yeah!
And who can blame them?
No one with an ounce of nous or insight, certainly ....
And those who aren't innocent like the Ciprianos and ...
-
Hmmm... &%+((£ Rubbishing the PJ? And why on earth shouldn't family and friends voice their outrage and despair, if that is indeed how they were feeling? Your nearest and dearest have been accused of a most heinous crime that you are certain they haven't committed and you think you should remain mute and smile on regardless?
Certain? How do you work that one out??
-
Certain? How do you work that one out??
Because they were the McCanns' nearest and dearest, do you think any of them were uncertain about them? That suspected they actually had done away with Madeleine? Seriously??
-
They allegedly find their young daughter missing at 10pm but don't bother to phone the police. Sounds like the Ciprianos all over again?
Down to the sceptic allegations of the deep clean of apartment 5A ... there is a certain similarity of allegation.
However, in Madeleine's case it was believed that the Mark Warner receptionist had called the police immediately he was asked to ... I believe he said as much in his statement in the files.
We have discussed this (like everything else) to the nth degree.
-
Actually, the information desk set up by Jenny Murat was for people who didn't want to speak to the police. In those circumstances therefore I cannot see her handing over anything without prior consent. She is to be commended for her quick thinking and her search for the truth. Unfortunately, she and Robert paid an awful price for only wanting to help.
From what I have seen everyone who tried to help and who didn't fit in with their particular brand was quickly snubbed.
-
Yes, as she didn't refer to any relevant hard facts or statements, her post was opinion.
she referred to the FACT that the evidence used to make the McCanns arguidos was later found to be innoccuous...she was referring to the FACT that the PJ were leaking information to the press
-
And those who aren't innocent like the Ciprianos and ...
If the beating of Leonor Cipriano was an excercise in discovering what had been done with the body then it didn't work, obviously.
-
And those who aren't innocent like the Ciprianos and ...
the ciprianos may well be innocent...many innocent people have been convicted
-
There was no confusion. In his first statement, Gerry stated that he went through the front door using his key and a few days later he changes his mind, saying that he went through the glass sliding doors. So I do not see how he was confused by which door he used since they were so different.
Gerry was the first to be interviewed and the layout may not have been clear in the heads of the interpreter / police officer.
It is perfectly possible that notes had been taken that one door required a key and the other didn't. At least one would hope so.
However, there is no way of knowing what any of the three people involved in this conversation called the front as opposed to the back door.
If it had been deliberate on Gerry's part, why on earth didn't the officer seek clarification at that moment?
In any event, this was clarified in his later statement.
-
So in answer to the OP, yes, allegations of crime and criminal activity should always be left to police who have the legal right and wherewithal to investigate them properly. Sending in a bunch of crooks portraying themselves as professional PI's will only damage the investigation as seen with the Maddie McCann case. What really takes the biscuit though is the McCanns thereafter trying to place the blame with the police.
-
So in answer to the OP, yes, allegations of crime and criminal activity should always be left to police who have the legal right and wherewithal to investigate them properly. Sending in a bunch of crooks portraying themselves as professional PI's will only damage the investigation.
I obviously disagree
Were there not a bunch of crooks in the police force
-
No, I'm sure Brieta's post was her opinion stated as facts.
I'm sure you're wrong.
-
I obviously disagree
Were there not a bunch of crooks in the police force
Were the police filling their pockets from the Maddie Fund?
-
So in answer to the OP, yes, allegations of crime and criminal activity should always be left to police who have the legal right and wherewithal to investigate them properly. Sending in a bunch of crooks portraying themselves as professional PI's will only damage the investigation as seen with the Maddie McCann case. What really takes the biscuit though is the McCanns thereafter trying to place the blame with the police.
Can you explain how the McCanns' PIs damaged the search for Madeleine, and why in your opinion it was the PIs and not the PJ who were to blame for the failure of the investigation?
-
You don't have to know anything about this woman and what she was going through - unless you choose to. If you find her so disgusting and repugnant I suggest that further reading about the McCanns, Kate in particular, may cause you additional distress and so best to choose another subject to immerse yourself in.
find her so disgusting and repugnant
your words...not mine ......i called her selfish...self centered ...but if thats what you prefere to call her.....its fine by me ...... 8((()*/
-
I have looked it up and do not believe she does
Which just goes to prove you wrong again.
-
find her so disgusting and repugnant
your words ....not mine ......i called her selfish...self centered ...but if thats what you prefere to call her.....its fine by me ...... 8((()*/
Why do you imagine that I am calling her that?! Your post oozed with disgust - am I wrong to say you find Kate McCann disgusting?
-
No, I'm sure Brieta's post was her opinion stated as facts.
No, my post was entirely based on fact with almost every sentence capable of carrying a cite from different sources.
Trying to stifle debate using one liners with nothing to substantiate them when referring to my posts, which in my opinion you do on a fairly regular basis, does absolutely nothing to promote honest debate, which allegedly we all support.
Some might feel intimidated or even bullied by such unfair constant comment ... I'm not one.
-
Which just goes to prove you wrong again.
Have you forgotten we had a long discussion on the topic... Which was not resolved either way
-
Can you explain how the McCanns' PIs damaged the search for Madeleine, and why in your opinion it was the PIs and not the PJ who were to blame for the failure of the investigation?
We know much of what went on. Witnesses were interfered with, sightings invented and false leads promoted as being genuine. Boasts were made that they knew who took Maddie and promises made that she would be home by Christmas. Innocent families in Tunisia were threatened with having their own children taken from them.
What a bunch of tossers!!
-
We know much of what went on. Witnesses were interfered with, sightings invented and false leads promoted as being genuine.
... and yet among the files being used by Scotland Yard and no doubt the Policia Judiciaria are those from the private investigators employed on behalf of Madeleine.
-
... and yet among the files being used by Scotland Yard and no doubt the Policia Judiciaria are those from the private investigators employed on behalf of Madeleine.
Yes...they had to be seized by Spanish police.
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-N2xhBveYeP0/TuxWqwdFEqI/AAAAAAAAI_k/TjSoibXnbts/s1600/El%2BPeriodico%2BCataluna%2B14%2BDec%2B2011.png)
-
No, my post was entirely based on fact with almost every sentence capable of carrying a cite from different sources.
Trying to stifle debate using one liners with nothing to substantiate them when referring to my posts, which in my opinion you do on a fairly regular basis, does absolutely nothing to promote honest debate, which allegedly we all support.
Some might feel intimidated or even bullied by such unfair constant comment ... I'm not one.
However I would appreciate it if you moderated your tone when addressing my posts as in my opinion it is becoming an immensely tiresome regular event.
'However I would appreciate it if you moderated your tone when addressing my posts as in my opinion it is becoming an immensely tiresome regular event.'
-
Yes...they had to be seized by Spanish police.
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-N2xhBveYeP0/TuxWqwdFEqI/AAAAAAAAI_k/TjSoibXnbts/s1600/El%2BPeriodico%2BCataluna%2B14%2BDec%2B2011.png)
13 December 2011: Detectives from Scotland Yard and the Spanish National Police carry boxes with documents given by the detective agency Metodo 3, in Barcelona
Brief background
1) On 5 October 2011, the Met responds to a FOIA request concerning the terms of the case review. It states:
'High profile reviews, such as this one, are highly emotive and the manner in which they are conducted are usually kept in strict secrecy so that the tactics and lines of enquiry that are followed do not become public knowledge thereby rendering them useless.'
2) On 5 December 2011, it is revealed that three Scotland Yard detectives had travelled to Barcelona to meet with their Spanish counterparts. Scotland Yard refused to reveal what led them to Barcelona, between November 23 and 25, but this did not stop press speculation that the visit was connected to the 'Victoria Beckham-lookalike' incident.
3) On 14 December 2011, it is revealed that Scotland Yard detectives had visited the Barcelona HQ of Metodo 3 - the detective agency employed by the McCanns in 2007 - the previous day. It is reported that they took away 30 boxes of documents compiled by the private detectives.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id391.html
-
For Davel's benefit, there's an entire thread on it. Appears technically illegal is ok with the McC's.
From Madeleine.
"Our first investigators, the Spanish company Método 3, began working for us in October. With private investigations technically illegal in Portugal, we felt the closest we could get would be a firm from somewhere on the Iberian Peninsula, which would have the advantage of familiarity with local systems, culture and geography and the best network of contacts in the region."
www.miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4676.msg169484#msg169484
-
you do not know what Gerry stated...you only know w hat the interpreter wrote down
He signed his statements and admitted the change in his 10 May statement.
"Despite what he said in his previous statements, he states now and with certainty, that he left with KATE by the rear door which he consequently closed."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
-
We know much of what went on. Witnesses were interfered with, sightings invented and false leads promoted as being genuine. Boasts were made that they knew who took Maddie and promises made that she would be home by Christmas. Innocent families in Tunisia were threatened with having their own children taken from them.
What a bunch of tossers!!
FAO: Slartibartfast: is the above post fact or opinion?
-
For Davel's benefit, there's an entire thread on it. Appears technically illegal is ok with the McC's.
From Madeleine.
"Our first investigators, the Spanish company Método 3, began working for us in October. With private investigations technically illegal in Portugal, we felt the closest we could get would be a firm from somewhere on the Iberian Peninsula, which would have the advantage of familiarity with local systems, culture and geography and the best network of contacts in the region."
www.miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4676.msg169484#msg169484
I have already referred to the thread......rather than have the same debate again best just read it
-
FAO: Slartibartfast: is the above post fact or opinion?
So tell me Alfred, could metado3 have organized a piss up in a brewery, as they seemed incapable of doing any real detective work, and squandered money donated to the fund ?
-
Why do you imagine that I am calling her that?! Your post oozed with disgust - am I wrong to say you find Kate McCann disgusting?
i couldnt care less about her........i care about what happened to her little girl maddie.....some thing she d.......
k mcc ....and what i think of her is so far down my priority list ...she is not on the page ok 8**8:/:
-
she referred to the FACT that the evidence used to make the McCanns arguidos was later found to be innoccuous...she was referring to the FACT that the PJ were leaking information to the press
Not according to the Guardian, however;
Portuguese police, who have remained tight-lipped during the investigation, said yesterday they had new evidence to work on.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/sep/07/ukcrime.madeleinemccann
-
i couldnt care less about her........i care about what happened to her little girl maddie.....some thing she .......
k mcc ....and what i think of her is so far down my priority list ...she is not on the page ok 8**8:/:
And yet many (if not most) of your posts reek of contempt and disgust for the McCanns, they obviously occupy your thoughts quite a lot, and not in a good way...
-
And yet many (if not most) of your posts reek of contempt and disgust for the McCanns, they obviously occupy your thoughts quite a lot, and not in a good way...
They clearly occupy your thoughts too Alfred.
I wonder why. £4%4%
-
Not according to the Guardian, however;
Portuguese police, who have remained tight-lipped during the investigation, said yesterday they had new evidence to work on.
http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/sep/07/ukcrime.madeleinemccann
not what...this is an example of the pj leaking to the press...showing that brietta was not posting opinion but fact
-
No, my post was entirely based on fact with almost every sentence capable of carrying a cite from different sources.
Trying to stifle debate using one liners with nothing to substantiate them when referring to my posts, which in my opinion you do on a fairly regular basis, does absolutely nothing to promote honest debate, which allegedly we all support.
Some might feel intimidated or even bullied by such unfair constant comment ... I'm not one.
However I would appreciate it if you moderated your tone when addressing my posts as in my opinion it is becoming an immensely tiresome regular event.
Trying to stifle debate with opinion dressed in wordy, convoluted hyperbole does absolutely nothing to promote honest debate.
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child-selling
In Greece, "babies of ... young women are sometimes sold to adoptive parents before their mothers even leave the hospital."[58] In 2007, brokering was being investigated by Interpol in Greece.[59]
Worldwide, in modern years, according to reporter Barbara Bisantz Raymond, brokers steal and sell children.[60] In France, Italy, and Portugal, in 2007, brokering was being investigated by Interpol
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child-selling
In Greece, "babies of ... young women are sometimes sold to adoptive parents before their mothers even leave the hospital."[58] In 2007, brokering was being investigated by Interpol in Greece.[59]
Worldwide, in modern years, according to reporter Barbara Bisantz Raymond, brokers steal and sell children.[60] In France, Italy, and Portugal, in 2007, brokering was being investigated by Interpol
and what has that to do with this case ?
-
The McCanns (we hope, have) two daughters ...
Yes they do but Pamela Fenn said it was Madeleine crying and shouting Daddy.
"not a baby of two years of age or younger."
"the witness had no doubt that the noise came from the floor below."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAMELA_FENN.htm
-
Yes she did.
"She also said that she never told the McCann's that she had heard their daughter crying previously on 1st May because she thought it would just increase their suffering."
That's not in her witness statement. She was also upset at the media, and said that she had never spoken to a journalist.
-
Despite the media being camped outside her apartment block, Mrs Fenn seemed to escape the attention of the journalists & local police. Given her concern about the crying she heard on 1st May, having already expressed her feelings to a friend via telephone, can anyone offer a reasonable explanation as to why she would have withheld that information from the police until August?
-
Despite the media being camped outside her apartment block, Mrs Fenn seemed to escape the attention of the journalists & local police. Given her concern about the crying she heard on 1st May, having already expressed her feelings to a friend via telephone, can anyone offer a reasonable explanation as to why she would have withheld that information from the police until August?
It's an interesting question.
Equally, the question could be juxtaposed: Mrs Fenn was the witness in closest proximity to the crime at the time the crime was committed.
Why on earth did it take the PJ so long to get round to interviewing her?
-
Despite the media being camped outside her apartment block, Mrs Fenn seemed to escape the attention of the journalists & local police. Given her concern about the crying she heard on 1st May, having already expressed her feelings to a friend via telephone, can anyone offer a reasonable explanation as to why she would have withheld that information from the police until August?
Perhaps she did try. Perhaps a GNR officer visited and reported "no sign of the minor" and moved on. No way of knowing.
-
That's not in her witness statement. She was also upset at the media, and said that she had never spoken to a journalist.
"She also said that she never told the McCann's that she had heard their daughter crying previously on Tuesday (1st May) because she thought it would just increase their suffering."
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P9/09_VOLUME_IXa_Page_2414.jpg)
-
Can we have a cite for that please?
From Madeleine
'
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.'
-
Despite the media being camped outside her apartment block, Mrs Fenn seemed to escape the attention of the journalists & local police. Given her concern about the crying she heard on 1st May, having already expressed her feelings to a friend via telephone, can anyone offer a reasonable explanation as to why she would have withheld that information from the police until August?
Was the withholding of the information a conscious decision or simply that she didn't connect the crying two days earlier with the disappearance ?
-
Faith Lilly's signature
'Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa said Kate and Gerry McCann were not being considered as suspects following recent rumours they were under suspicion'. August 2007
'DCI Redwood said that neither her parents or any of the members of the group that were with her are either persons of interest or suspects'. October 2013
Key difference being that in August 2007, certain elements of the PJ had not scandalously misrepresented John Lowe's (then yet to be written) report.
So CI Inspector Susa's comment was probably true (at the time he made it), and was certainly true following the archiving dispatch of the Portuguese prosecutors ....
-
Was the withholding of the information a conscious decision or simply that she didn't connect the crying two days earlier with the disappearance ?
I don't know. She was concerned enough to talk about the crying during a phone conversation with her friend. Living where she did, the case must have been the main topic of conversation for days, with locals asking her questions at the shops,etc.
News of the crying was circulating on the internet in the July, well before she made her statement. If she didn't connect the crying at the outset, who or what prompted it at a much later stage but still she didn't go to the police?
I just find it very odd that an English ex-pat, living immediately above 5a, somehow escaped the initial media clamour for information & interviews & also appeared to have gone under the radar as far as the PJ investigation was concerned.
The answers will probably never be known unless we get to see Carole Tranmer's statement of 8th May.
-
From Madeleine
'
Friday 7 September. After a measly two hours’ sleep we got up and braced ourselves for the day ahead. I remained calm. For a good couple of hours we were on the phone, calling family and friends to make them aware of the situation and to give them the green light to voice their outrage and despair if they wanted to. Nobody needed a second invitation. They’d all been struggling to contain their concerns for a long time.'
I was looking for a cite to back up your allegation that Kate instructed her friends and family to "rubbish the PJ" - have you got one?
-
I was looking for a cite to back up your allegation that Kate instructed her friends and family to "rubbish the PJ" - have you got one?
Oh dear alfred, are you trying to pretend the PJ weren't being rubbished ?
Did you ever read what Alex Thomson of Channel 4 news said about the mccanns and the case ?
It sums it up very adequately.
-
Oh dear alfred, are you trying to pretend the PJ weren't being rubbished ?
Did you ever read what Alex Thomson of Channel 4 news said about the mccanns and the case ?
It sums it up very adequately.
Very, very surprising comment given that the Drs McCann were involved in a fight for their daughter from a man who was also involved in a fight for his son.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1167554/Autism-specialist-changed-diagnosis-newsreader-Alex-Thomsons-son-pressure-schools-chiefs.html
-
Very, very surprising comment given that the Drs McCann were involved in a fight for their daughter from a man who was also involved in a fight for his son.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1167554/Autism-specialist-changed-diagnosis-newsreader-Alex-Thomsons-son-pressure-schools-chiefs.html
No comparison whatsoever.
Alex Thomson is a newsreader of repute.
He could clearly see what was taking place in the mccann case, and got it spot on.
IMO, of course.
-
Oh dear alfred, are you trying to pretend the PJ weren't being rubbished ?
Did you ever read what Alex Thomson of Channel 4 news said about the mccanns and the case ?
It sums it up very adequately.
This one Stephen "July 2007: Alex Thomson, Channel 4 News: “I’ve been sickened by the way the media have allowed themselves to be taken for a full-scale ride by the #McCanns”
-
I was looking for a cite to back up your allegation that Kate instructed her friends and family to "rubbish the PJ" - have you got one?
What do you think 'express their outrage' meant ? Outrage towards who ?
-
Oh dear alfred, are you trying to pretend the PJ weren't being rubbished ?
Did you ever read what Alex Thomson of Channel 4 news said about the mccanns and the case ?
It sums it up very adequately.
Faithlilly claims Kate instructed friends and family to start rubbishing the PJ in September 2007. And your point is...?
-
Faithlilly claims Kate instructed friends and family to start rubbishing the PJ in September 2007. And your point is...?
I have made my point quite clear already, if you actually read through my posts on this, from this morning.
We already know kate mccanns views on the PJ.
The well used quotes from her say anything, and anybody who denies that her family and associates have tried to denigrate the PJ is clearly doing so, in the classic 'not me gov' mantra.
-
I have made my point quite clear already, if you actually read through my posts on this, from this morning.
We already know kate mccanns views on the PJ.
The well used quotes from her say anything, and anybody who denies that her family and associates have tried to denigrate the PJ is clearly doing so, in the classic 'not me gov' mantra.
Sorry "Mantravani" that won't do. Evidence that Kate instructed her friends and family to start rubbishing the PJ in September 2007 as claimed by Faithlilly is not supported by your "point". Try again.
-
Sorry "Mantravani" that won't do. Evidence that Kate instructed her friends and family to start rubbishing the PJ in September 2007 as claimed by Faithlilly is not supported by your "point". Try again.
Very poor alfred.
You will have to do a lot better than that.
Do you think repeated denials by mccann supporters will be believed by people reading this forum, who can research that for themselves ?
They only have to look up direct quotes from family members.
-
Make of my post what and as you will ... after all, that would be normal practice for you n'est-ce pas? Perish the thought you might actually wish to discuss.
Once upon a time did you not post that was not your raison d'etre on these threads? Or was that a WUM?
I don't think I ever said I am not here to debate. I probably said I was here for the craic or something similar.
Did you never belong to a debating society where one is told what topic to debate and whether you are debating for "the house" or against it ?
Whatever I am not here to be dictated to except by the management.
So let's debate your comments as your earlier post. My stance is "that way lies anarchy and vigil[ censored word]m". What is your argument to refute my contention?
-
I don't think I ever said I am not here to debate. I probably said I was here for the craic or something similar.
Did you never belong to a debating society where one is told what topic to debate and whether you are debating for "the house" or against it ?
Whatever I am not here to be dictated to except by the management.
So let's debate your comments as your earlier post. My stance is "that way lies anarchy and vigil[ censored word]m". What is your argument to refute my contention?
I would say there is absolutely nothing wrong with an individual mounting their own investigation within the law.... What is wrong with that
If someone is not happy with the way a police investigation is going in a free society they should have the right to act themselves
-
I would say there is absolutely nothing wrong with an individual mounting their own investigation within the law.... What is wrong with that
If someone is not happy with the way a police investigation is going in a free society they should have the right to act themselves
As long as that doesn't jeopardise any possible court case.
-
As long as that doesn't jeopardise any possible court case.
So these groups outing and catching on line paedophiles..doing a good job
-
I would say there is absolutely nothing wrong with an individual mounting their own investigation within the law.... What is wrong with that
If someone is not happy with the way a police investigation is going in a free society they should have the right to act themselves
In a free society they would have that right. However we do not live in a "free" society. We live in a society where there is a police force and judiciary mandated to act on behalf of its citizens wrt upholding the law.
The acid test for all this is whether or not you are prepared for some over zealous person other than the police to be knocking on your door at 3:00 am to ask questions in an aggressive and intimidatory manner. You may not even be the right person but the guy at the head of the chain is only exercising a right you think he should have because he thinks the police aren't doing a proper job.
-
8(*(d
In a free society they would have that right. However we do not live in a "free" society. We live in a society where there is a police force and judiciary mandated to act on behalf of its citizens wrt upholding the law.
The acid test for all this is whether or not you are prepared for some over zealous person other than the police to be knocking on your door at 3:00 am to ask questions in an aggressive and intimidatory manner. You may not even be the right person but the guy at the head of the chain is only exercising a right you think he should have because he thinks the police aren't doing a proper job.
No one knocks on my door as I have electric security gates
We do live in a free society and we do have the right to investigate privately if we wish
Anyone making a nuisance of themselves is liable to arrest
-
In a free society they would have that right. However we do not live in a "free" society. We live in a society where there is a police force and judiciary mandated to act on behalf of its citizens wrt upholding the law.
The acid test for all this is whether or not you are prepared for some over zealous person other than the police to be knocking on your door at 3:00 am to ask questions in an aggressive and intimidatory manner. You may not even be the right person but the guy at the head of the chain is only exercising a right you think he should have because he thinks the police aren't doing a proper job.
Some "sceptics" believe that this is what the McCanns should have been doing themselves in Portugal for the last 9 years - not you obviously!
-
In a free society they would have that right. However we do not live in a "free" society. We live in a society where there is a police force and judiciary mandated to act on behalf of its citizens wrt upholding the law.
The acid test for all this is whether or not you are prepared for some over zealous person other than the police to be knocking on your door at 3:00 am to ask questions in an aggressive and intimidatory manner. You may not even be the right person but the guy at the head of the chain is only exercising a right you think he should have because he thinks the police aren't doing a proper job.
I would agree with that in principle.
But what does that encompass?
Jez was apparently annoyed at one point over "persistent" calls from Gerry or whoever else "they" encompassed, but it seems to have just been to get his permission to use his name.
Several weeks later, Jeremy received calls from Gerry in relation to gaining permission from him to use his name in a portfolio of evidence being compiled by an organization employed by the McCanns. They were very persistent and made several attempts to contact him both at work and at home. They had no objection to being included but were concerned as to the method being used.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY_BRIGET.htm
There is also a point made by a police officer who'd talked to Martin Smith, but aside from having been contacted by Brian Kennedy, the complaint seems to concern the tabloid hacks.
He has been contacted by numerous tabloid press looking for stories. He has been contacted by Mr Brian Kennedy who is supporting the McCann family to take part in a photo fit exercise. He has given no stories or helped in any photo fits. He sent a solicitor's letter to six papers in relation material that was printed that was misquoted. The Evening Herald paid his solicitor's fees and all papers printed an apology. His photograph appeared in another tabloid paper and this matter is being pursued at the moment.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
Would you classfiy that as vigilante action?
How would you classify spamming the McCanns' village and Gerry's place of work with leaflets?
Or posting photos of people's homes, particularly at night?
Or threats of kidnapping the twins to make "Kate talk"?
Or a drunken threat involving the use of a Molotov cocktail?
-
Some "sceptics" believe that this is what the McCanns should have been doing themselves in Portugal for the last 9 years - not you obviously!
Odd, isn't it? How many times have "sceptics" posted the mantra that if it had been their child, they would have been banging on every door.
-
I would agree with that in principle.
But what does that encompass?
Jez was apparently annoyed at one point over "persistent" calls from Gerry or whoever else "they" encompassed, but it seems to have just been to get his permission to use his name.
Several weeks later, Jeremy received calls from Gerry in relation to gaining permission from him to use his name in a portfolio of evidence being compiled by an organization employed by the McCanns. They were very persistent and made several attempts to contact him both at work and at home. They had no objection to being included but were concerned as to the method being used.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY_BRIGET.htm
There is also a point made by a police officer who'd talked to Martin Smith, but aside from having been contacted by Brian Kennedy, the complaint seems to concern the tabloid hacks.
He has been contacted by numerous tabloid press looking for stories. He has been contacted by Mr Brian Kennedy who is supporting the McCann family to take part in a photo fit exercise. He has given no stories or helped in any photo fits. He sent a solicitor's letter to six papers in relation material that was printed that was misquoted. The Evening Herald paid his solicitor's fees and all papers printed an apology. His photograph appeared in another tabloid paper and this matter is being pursued at the moment.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
Would you classfiy that as vigilante action?
How would you classify spamming the McCanns' village and Gerry's place of work with leaflets?
Or posting photos of people's homes, particularly at night?
Or threats of kidnapping the twins to make "Kate talk"?
Or a drunken threat involving the use of a Molotov cocktail?
I would say that the direct acts, while unacceptable and a violation of basic human rights, falls short of "vigil[ censored word]m".
The threats (molotov cocktails and all the rest) certainly amounts to (threatened!) vigil[ censored word]m.
All of it is illegal activity ....
-
Odd, isn't it? How many times have "sceptics" posted the mantra that if it had been their child, they would have been banging on every door.
Can you provide a cite for that?
-
Can you provide a cite for that?
It has been said by sceptics many times
-
What would you do if the police claimed your child had been killed in an accident..... But you were sure it was murder
-
Can you provide a cite for that?
How many copy and pastes of various sceptics saying it would you require in order to be satisfied that it was an oft-voiced criticism levelled against the McCanns by the "sceptic" community? Have you genuinely never seen anyone express this sentiment before?
-
I would say that the direct acts, while unacceptable and a violation of basic human rights, falls short of "vigil[ censored word]m".
The threats (molotov cocktails and all the rest) certainly amounts to (threatened!) vigil[ censored word]m.
All of it is illegal activity ....
I don't see that phone calls to get someone's permission or cooperation in a desperate search for a missing child is in the same league at all.
-
What would you do if the police claimed your child had been killed in an accident..... But you were sure it was murder
Instruct a solicitor and tell them your story and why you disagree with the police. They are more likely to be able to get the police to discuss the case than you are.
-
I don't see that phone calls to get someone's permission or cooperation in a desperate search for a missing child is in the same league at all.
I don't think Jez was particularly annoyed about the contact ... "They had no objection to being included but were concerned as to the method being used." ... I think their concern centred on the method "being used" ie the private investigators.
At that time he would have had no idea at all of the way in which the case was being handled by the PJ.
-
I would agree with that in principle.
But what does that encompass?
Jez was apparently annoyed at one point over "persistent" calls from Gerry or whoever else "they" encompassed, but it seems to have just been to get his permission to use his name.
I don't know about you but I expect to say "no" or "yes" only once politely; I am apt to become very irritated at more than once
Several weeks later, Jeremy received calls from Gerry in relation to gaining permission from him to use his name in a portfolio of evidence being compiled by an organization employed by the McCanns. They were very persistent and made several attempts to contact him both at work and at home. They had no objection to being included but were concerned as to the method being used.
I don't know what method was used but I would expect to receive a letter , out of common courtesy, to which I could respond with a yay or nay. Then be left alone and see comment above if I wasn't.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY_BRIGET.htm
There is also a point made by a police officer who'd talked to Martin Smith, but aside from having been contacted by Brian Kennedy, the complaint seems to concern the tabloid hacks.
He has been contacted by numerous tabloid press looking for stories. He has been contacted by Mr Brian Kennedy who is supporting the McCann family to take part in a photo fit exercise. He has given no stories or helped in any photo fits. He sent a solicitor's letter to six papers in relation material that was printed that was misquoted. The Evening Herald paid his solicitor's fees and all papers printed an apology. His photograph appeared in another tabloid paper and this matter is being pursued at the moment. This seems to be getting out of order. On what basis was Kennedy approaching Smith to do a photo fit if he was ?. It sounds like tampering with a material witness. As for the tabloids they are out of order on many things
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
Would you classfiy that as vigilante action? probably under the definition : a member of a self-appointed group of citizens who undertake any kind of quasi legal action without legal authority, typically with the excuse that the legal agencies are thought to be inadequate.
How would you classify spamming the McCanns' village and Gerry's place of work with leaflets?
Unacceptable vigilante type action
Or posting photos of people's homes, particularly at night?
See above
Or threats of kidnapping the twins to make "Kate talk"?
See above
Or a drunken threat involving the use of a Molotov cocktail?
See above
Of course threats may just be drunken or even sober trapping off by people who would scream if you bent their little finger back a bit hard if you see what I mean.
It would be up to the cops to decide whether they represented credible threats. On balance I suspect that sort of threat is yobbish rather than vigilante.
-
Some "sceptics" believe that this is what the McCanns should have been doing themselves in Portugal for the last 9 years - not you obviously!
What they do is their business.
-
I don't think Jez was particularly annoyed about the contact ... "They had no objection to being included but were concerned as to the method being used." ... I think their concern centred on the method "being used" ie the private investigators.
At that time he would have had no idea at all of the way in which the case was being handled by the PJ.
That seems quite possible. It's quite likely that they were hassled by the tabloid hacks as well at the time.
-
Instruct a solicitor and tell them your story and why you disagree with the police. They are more likely to be able to get the police to discuss the case than you are.
And the police refuse to accept your concerns
-
Surely there might be an instance when an individual bias no choice but to carry out their own investigation
-
So getting back on topic are there any circumstances when it would be reasonable to mount an investigation independently of the police...I would say absolutely yes
-
And the police refuse to accept your concerns
Which they would. The UK police take a very dim view of anyone who questions their conclusions. To change their conclusions can take years. Read the Lee Balkwell thread.
-
Which they would. The UK police take a very dim view of anyone who questions their conclusions. To change their conclusions can take years. Read the Lee Balkwell thread.
Therefore there would be justification for starting your own investigation
-
So getting back on topic are there any circumstances when it would be reasonable to mount an investigation independently of the police...I would say absolutely yes
To what end? Only the police have the powers needed to investigate. They can investigate people's backgrounds, get telephone records, listen to telephone conversations, interview people, apply for search warrants, seize CCTV tapes, collect forensic evidence and have it tested and whatever else needs to be done.
Other investigators can do none of that. Their attempts to interview people can upset witnesses and warn perpetrators. We have a perfect example of attempts by PI's to investigate the McCann case and the resulting mess and confusion.
-
To what end? Only the police have the powers needed to investigate. They can investigate people's backgrounds, get telephone records, listen to telephone conversations, interview people, apply for search warrants, seize CCTV tapes, collect forensic evidence and have it tested and whatever else needs to be done.
Other investigators can do none of that. Their attempts to interview people can upset witnesses and warn perpetrators. We have a perfect example of attempts by PI's to investigate the McCann case and the resulting mess and confusion.
But if the police. Have given up...... Then why shouldn't an individual start there own investigation
-
To what end? Only the police have the powers needed to investigate. They can investigate people's backgrounds, get telephone records, listen to telephone conversations, interview people, apply for search warrants, seize CCTV tapes, collect forensic evidence and have it tested and whatever else needs to be done.
Other investigators can do none of that. Their attempts to interview people can upset witnesses and warn perpetrators. We have a perfect example of attempts by PI's to investigate the McCann case and the resulting mess and confusion.
So we can safely say that all the armchair detectives who've been investigating this case for the last nine years, taking holidays to PdL, photographing the crap out of every manhole cover and back street alley and forcing open shutters willy nilly have been completely wasting their time too then, at least we can agree on that.
-
But if the police. Have given up...... Then why shouldn't an individual start there own investigation
They can do what they like within the law, but are unlikely to get anywhere. In fact they are more likely to make things worse, as the McCann's PI's did imo.
-
They can do what they like within the law, but are unlikely to get anywhere. In fact they are more likely to make things worse, as the McCann's PI's did imo.
They can hardly do worse if the police have basically closed the case... Unlikely to get anywhere... Who could blame them for trying
-
They can hardly do worse if the police have basically closed the case... Unlikely to get anywhere... Who could blame them for trying
If you are discussing the McCann case it's rather unusual. Most people report something to the police and wait for the police to tell them what, if anything, they have discovered. I don't know how many people report something to the police and then inform them what crime has been committed and what they should be doing about it. I don't know how many people begin to cmplain about the police reaction within a few hours of calling them. I don't know how many people contact the press within hours of a crime being committed. I do know that anyone doing that in the UK would be spoken to quite firmly by the UK police.
-
If you are discussing the McCann case it's rather unusual. Most people report something to the police and wait for the police to tell them what, if anything, they have discovered. I don't know how many people report something to the police and then inform them what crime has been committed and what they should be doing about it. I don't know how many people begin to cmplain about the police reaction within a few hours of calling them. I don't know how many people contact the press within hours of a crime being committed. I do know that anyone doing that in the UK would be spoken to quite firmly by the UK police.
I'm thinking of another case
The police do not always get things right
In a free society individuals have the right to mount their own investigation
-
I'm thinking of another case
The police do not always get things right
In a free society individuals have the right to mount their own investigation
I haven't disputed that, just the effectiveness. If you solved it what then? You can't make an arrest, you can't charge the perp. You then have to go to the police and persuade them you're right and get them to act, unless you're suggesting a lynch mob type action. What if your perp does a bunk while you're trying to get the police to act? Far too many complications imo.
-
I haven't disputed that, just the effectiveness. If you solved it what then? You can't make an arrest, you can't charge the perp. You then have to go to the police and persuade them you're right and get them to act, unless you're suggesting a lynch mob type action. What if your perp does a bunk while you're trying to get the police to act? Far too many complications imo.
In your own words, you have just described exactly why the McCanns could not release the Smithman efits.
-
Alfie, what would you describe as the key differences between rubbishing the PJ and criticising them ?
-
In your own words, you have just described exactly why the McCanns could not release the Smithman efits.
Why not? They released others. What was special about those? Why didn't they get a full-length one done by their police artist like they did with Tannerman?
-
Alfie, what would you describe as the key differences between rubbishing the PJ and criticising them ?
Would you describe this as rubbishing or criticising?
NC: What do you think, errr... Philomena, of the Portuguese police?
PM: Well, I think that they should be looking for Madeleine alive; I don't want Madeleine lost in all of this; on these allegations and counter allegations of whatever else. I don't really care about, you know, what's been said, I just want them to get out there and find Madeleine; do their job, look for her; look for her alive. The abductor has her, or has passed her on to someone else. They need to be looking for her actively. That's what's important in all this, it's Madeleine.
-
I doubt anyone could legitimately criticise parents for using other avenues ... particularly if these were freeing up police resources by checking out sightings abroad etc ... unfortunately it is all part and parcel of the necessity for opprobrium and constant criticism directed at a couple desperate to find out what happened to their daughter.