I think the fact that David Payne or his alleged visit to the McCann's apartment at 6.30 were not mentioned in the Crimewatch reconstruction is very telling.
In the sense of emphasising Crimewatch's discernment in omitting trivia, you mean?
Yes.
David Payne was a central character in the unfolding drama in PDL and his 6.30 visit was the last time anyone outside of the family saw Madeleine. His omission therefore is hardly ' trivial'.
David Payne was a central character in the unfolding drama in PDL and his 6.30 visit was the last time anyone outside of the family saw Madeleine. His omission therefore is hardly ' trivial'.OG was trying to get information on certain specifics - Smithman and the charity collectors being but two.
I think the fact that David Payne or his alleged visit to the McCann's apartment at 6.30 were not mentioned in the Crimewatch reconstruction is very telling.
David Payne confirms seeing Madeleine, alive and well at that time (the last independent (known) witness to see Madeleine alive and well (as the Portuguese prosecutors, to their credit, understood).
Beyond that, there is no significance to David Payne's visit
Except the obvious, that his version of events and a that of KMcC had little in common. How do you think two doctors could get it so wrong ferryman? What happened to change their recollections so drastically??
Except the obvious, that his version of events and a that of KMcC had little in common. How do you think two doctors could get it so wrong ferryman? What happened to change their recollections so drastically??
Snipped...
On Wednesday night, 2 May 2007, as well as he and his wife, he thinks that David Payne also went to his apartment to confirm that his children were well, not having reported to him any abnormal situation with the children.
During the afternoon of that day the rest of the group members, including the children, were at the beach, [they] having returned at 18H30, the time at which he saw David Payne next to the tennis court. DAVID went to visit KATE and the children and returned close to 19H00, trying to convince the deponent to continue to play tennis, to which [entreaty] he did not accede as he had already been plying for about an hour and had to go back to to his wife. Nevertheless, RUSSELL, DAVID and MATHEW stayed to play.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
Snipped.......
A 3 minute visit to 5A and his apartment doesn't take upto 30 minutes. How far away were their apartments Benice? Another interesting reconstruction wanted by the PJ from 5:30pm onwards on 3 May but it didn't happen!
00:41:00 1485 "Okay, so now what I'm gonna try and ask you to recollect, what everybody was wearing.'
Reply "I'm afraid that is, you know I'm, I cannot recall at all. I know that's, you'd think that'd be an obvious thing to remember, I cannot remember. As I say the, from the children point of view predominantly I can remember the, you know, white, but I couldn't say exactly what they were wearing. Err''
1485 "But could you remember what Kate was wearing for example''
Reply "I can't, no.'
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
According to Kate McCann she was naked and wrapped in a towel when David Payne arrived at the apartment yet when asked to describe how Kate was dressed he was unable to recall. Really?Not this again. How many times are we going to go over old ground such as this before it finally begins to lose its fascination? This particular (non) issue seems to bring out the sniggering schoolboy in some. What possible significance do you believe this trivial point holds to the investigation?
Not this again. How many times are we going to go over old ground such as this before it finally begins to lose its fascination? This particular (non) issue seems to bring out the sniggering schoolboy in some. What possible significance do you believe this trivial point holds to the investigation?
Not this again. How many times are we going to go over old ground such as this before it finally begins to lose its fascination? This particular (non) issue seems to bring out the sniggering schoolboy in some. What possible significance do you believe this trivial point holds to the investigation?
Because it undermines his status as a reliable witness.
Crap
And more libel.
(Whatever it is)
Simple Alf. Because it undermines his status as a reliable witness. Not only could he not recall what she was wearing but he failed to mention she wasn't wearing anything.
Because it undermines his status as a reliable witness.you think Madeleine's disappearance pivots on what Kate McCann was wearing when she greeted David Payne at the door of the apartment? Is what she was wearing of such great importance that a reliable witness would be able to recall it, but anyone unable to recall it must have their entire testimony thrown out? What utter rubbish.
Understandable really. The sight of Kate flaunting her bits is enough to reduce anyone to a gibbering idiot.
Understandable really. The sight of Kate flaunting her bits is enough to reduce anyone to a gibbering idiot.How old are you? Which bits was Kate flaunting that would have you reduced to the status of a gibbering idiot (or should I say more of one than you clearly already are)?
you think Madeleine's disappearance pivots on what Kate McCann was wearing when she greeted David Payne at the door of the apartment? Is what she was wearing of such great importance that a reliable witness would be able to recall it, but anyone unable to recall it must have their entire testimony thrown out? What utter rubbish.
Its fact actually. I can see now why Leicestershire Police officer DC 1485 MESSIAH asked that specific question.
Do you honestly think a man would forget such a trivial detail?
"Gerry said, were just absolutely knackered and Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
So why did her husband pop round to take them out? This period must be a record of contradictions and lapses in memory.
Was this the day after they fell out?
How old are you? Which bits was Kate flaunting that would have you reduced to the status of a gibbering idiot (or should I say more of one than you clearly already are)?
No at tennis on evening of 3 May when David Payne was visiting Kate.
Ta PF but what I was wondering was could GM sending Dave to the apartment have anything to do with the previous nights row?And now we are wondering what you are wondering about!
And now we are wondering what you are wondering about!
Ta PF but what I was wondering is could GM sending Dave to the apartment have anything to do with the previous nights row when according to Kate, Gerry stomped off from the tapas saying he was tired and left her behind.
If there were significant mistakes the witnesses wouldnt have said ok Ill signYes but the mistakes aren't picked up because it is read back by the person who did the initial translation. The better verifying principle of not rechecking your own work should have been applied.
If a statement is read back in English and the witness agrees its what they said, where is the problem?The problem is in the Portuguese version, it may not be correct.
Do you honestly think a man would forget such a trivial detail?How many times have we had this ridiculous discussion? I am currently on holiday. Most women are wearing next to nothing both by the pool and out of it. I couldn't tell you what any of them were actually wearing. No one is, as far as I know, in a constant state of titillation as a result. It's no biggie. Kate wrapped in a towel reveals bare shoulders and legs. Phwoarrrrrr.
I'm now wondering if Alfie is short for Alfreda. All the men I've ever met would have noticed and would have mentioned it to the male police interviewer.How many men have you met in your life? You know exactly how all think, behave and what they would notice in any given situation? Wow, that's impressive. Do men of your generation usually find the sight of a woman wrapped in a towel in a holiday resort so utterly remarkable that the sight of it would be seared on their retinas for the rest of their lives? My generation not so much...
According to anther doctor's testimony Mr Payne was quite capable of indulging in a bit of 'nudge nudge wink wink', but not on this occasion it seems.
I think the fact that David Payne or his alleged visit to the McCann's apartment at 6.30 were not mentioned in the Crimewatch reconstruction is very telling.It would seem that because DAvid Payne was unable to recall what Kate McCann was wearing when she appeared at the door that evening that this would invalidate his entire testimony and it is for that reason the Visit by DP to the apartment was not mentioned on Crimewatch. Simples imnit.
23
How many men have you met in your life? You know exactly how all think, behave and what they would notice in any given situation? Wow, that's impressive. Do men of your generation usually find the sight of a woman wrapped in a towel in a holiday resort so utterly remarkable that the sight of it would be seared on their retinas for the rest of their lives? My generation not so much...Is that an older or younger generation than G-unit?
Is that an older or younger generation than G-unit?Yeah, it's the only way to answer the door in our house. There's a whole sub-section of internet porn devoted to women wrapped in towels too didn't you know? For most men towel wrapped women are intensely alluring, far more so than naked women, or women in bikinis.
I tend to believe Kate that the visit would be short rather than long when wrapped in a towel. Have you ever answered the door wrapped in a towel?
I have probably mixed with more men than most women during my husband's years in the military. I worked with them, socialised with them and sometimes mothered them. On a beach or by a pool none of them would remember if they saw a woman wrapped in a towel because it wouldn't be unusual.So you ARE an expert on male behaviour, but claim it's got nothing to do with the sex of the observer anyway. OK then. So David Payne is what then, in your view? Stupid? Forgetful? Mendacious? Socially inept? Or are you as usual not going to proffer any opinion, and just be content to float the suspicion that "something's not quite right" ?
If they visited me, their friend's wife, and I answered the door wearing a towel they would notice immediately and apologise for getting me out of the shower or bath. So would a female visitor. I would guess most people's reaction would be the same, even yours. It's the social context Alfie, not the sex of the observer.
If you can remember if the children were standing or sitting it's peculiar if you don't remember that their mother was in the shower when you arrived. The police interviewer seems to have shared the view of the majority on here, hence his question as to what Kate was wearing.
I've listened another 3 times & I'm not convinced you are right.
If I'm mishearing what GM said, what chance for a Portuguese translator in a full interview?
If there were significant mistakes the witnesses wouldnt have said ok Ill sign
So you ARE an expert on male behaviour, but claim it's got nothing to do with the sex of the observer anyway. OK then. So David Payne is what then, in your view? Stupid? Forgetful? Mendacious? Socially inept? Or are you as usual not going to proffer any opinion, and just be content to float the suspicion that "something's not quite right" ?Well tell us how we handle the situation where the friends become suspects, how do we discuss them? If everything we say will be deemed libel how do we discuss the topics that need to be raised?
I have probably mixed with more men than most women during my husband's years in the military. I worked with them, socialised with them and sometimes mothered them. On a beach or by a pool none of them would remember if they saw a woman wrapped in a towel because it wouldn't be unusual.
If they visited me, their friend's wife, and I answered the door wearing a towel they would notice immediately and apologise for getting me out of the shower or bath. So would a female visitor. I would guess most people's reaction would be the same, even yours. It's the social context Alfie, not the sex of the observer.
If you can remember if the children were standing or sitting it's peculiar if you don't remember that their mother was in the shower when you arrived. The police interviewer seems to have shared the view of the majority on here, hence his question as to what Kate was wearing.
That is it. Normal human reaction.Somewhere he describes the kids as angels but doesn't notice that Kate is wearing just a towel. There seems to be something a little suspect in his attention/affection but I just can't put my finger on it.
Well tell us how we handle the situation where the friends become suspects, how do we discuss them? If everything we say will be deemed libel how do we discuss the topics that need to be raised?Don't ask me, ask the forum owner. Libel is apparently not permitted.
Don't ask me, ask the forum owner. Libel is apparently not permitted.And who is that? I have found you have to meet the requirements of the many moderators as well, even though it is quite lenient over all. It is actually a very good discussion forum.
I have probably mixed with more men than most women during my husband's years in the military. I worked with them, socialised with them and sometimes mothered them. On a beach or by a pool none of them would remember if they saw a woman wrapped in a towel because it wouldn't be unusual.The police office first asks:
If they visited me, their friend's wife, and I answered the door wearing a towel they would notice immediately and apologise for getting me out of the shower or bath. So would a female visitor. I would guess most people's reaction would be the same, even yours. It's the social context Alfie, not the sex of the observer.
If you can remember if the children were standing or sitting it's peculiar if you don't remember that their mother was in the shower when you arrived. The police interviewer seems to have shared the view of the majority on here, hence his question as to what Kate was wearing.
The last time he saw Madeleine only hours before she was reported missing and nothing corroborates with the other witness except they were both there. Wow!Quite a few things corroborate actually. He confirms Kate and that all three children were in the apartment alone at that time, which I would say was the most important detail.
So you ARE an expert on male behaviour, but claim it's got nothing to do with the sex of the observer anyway. OK then. So David Payne is what then, in your view? Stupid? Forgetful? Mendacious? Socially inept? Or are you as usual not going to proffer any opinion, and just be content to float the suspicion that "something's not quite right" ?
Quite a few things corroborate actually. He confirms Kate and that all three children were in the apartment alone at that time, which I would say was the most important detail.
The Brits are famed for apologising, even for apologising to someone who bumps into them! It would be normal for most people in David Payne's shoes to apologise for interrupting someone's shower. It would be normal for the other person to respond to the apology, probably to say it was OK as they'd finished anyway. Most people involved would probably remember. All that is my opinion.David Payne didn't interrupt her shower, she had already finished by the time he knocked. When you're staying at a resort, with pool, spa, sports facilities etc you tend to take more showers than you would at home. I have had 2 today already, maybe a 3rd by bedtime. Too much information I know, but funnily enough I am currently wrapped in a towel. It's not an uncommon sight when you're on holiday. Should one of my acquaintances or room service knock on the door to ask me a question, I doubt they'd remember my attire many months later, but perhaps this would only prove their lack of Britishness.... &%+((£
Because my opinion is that most people would have remembered, the fact that David Payne didn't confirm Kate's account leads me to wonder why. I can think of three possible explanations;
The visit didn't happen.
The visit happened and Kate was fully clothed.
The visit happened, Kate was in a towel and David Payne either forgot or didn't wish to mention it.
Ro be fair, David Payne's rog interview is interesting mainly because of how much he can't remember. In common with Kate and Fiona he wasn't interviewed on or around 10th May most other members of the group.
No important details corroborate so why should I believe anything is the truth?None of those details are the important details. The important details are the ones I have already mentioned. Don't believe a word of it, your prerogative, I know "not believing" has kept you entertained for years, and will no doubt do so for many more years to come.
1st Witness - Outside
2nd Witness - Definitely Inside
1st Witness - 30 seconds
2nd Witness - 3-5 minutes
1st Witness - Wearing a towel
2nd Witness - Can't remember what she was wearing.
1st Witness - Arrived to take kids out
2nd Witness - To do a check on Kate & the kids
1485 "Okay, and it was at what point that Gerry said to you go and, would you mind checking at Kate''
Reply "Well I mean coming back from the beach I'd got no equipment to play tennis you know, etcetera, so I had to go back to my room to you know change into stuff appropriate for playing tennis in, and err so he knew that I'd walk up that by and past so he said oh why don't you err, you know can you just pop in on the way, the way up, so it was on the way back from me picking the stuff up.'
1485 "Right, so you've walked past, you've walked past Gerry's apartment to get to yours.'
Reply "Mm.'
1485 "Got changed''
Reply "No, you know it was, again whether it was, in my mind it was on the way up that I'd popped in to Kate but it could have been on the way back, again, I'm sorry.'
1485 "No, it's okay.'
Reply "For my vagueness.'
What a muddle 8(0(*
p.s. David Payne was wearing shorts on CCTV. So what did he wear to play tennis?
According to Kate McCann she was naked and wrapped in a towel when David Payne arrived at the apartment yet when asked to describe how Kate was dressed he was unable to recall. Really?
David Payne didn't interrupt her shower, she had already finished by the time he knocked. When you're staying at a resort, with pool, spa, sports facilities etc you tend to take more showers than you would at home. I have had 2 today already, maybe a 3rd by bedtime. Too much information I know, but funnily enough I am currently wrapped in a towel. It's not an uncommon sight when you're on holiday. Should one of my acquaintances or room service knock on the door to ask me a question, I doubt they'd remember my attire many months later, but perhaps this would only prove their lack of Britishness.... &%+((£
David Payne didn't know what stage Kate had reached in her shower though, how could he unless he asked? She could have been about to enter the shower when he appeared.On a scale 1 to 10 - 1 being entirely irrelevant to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and 10 being absolutely critical to solving the case - where would you put this issue?
On a scale 1 to 10 - 1 being entirely irrelevant to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and 10 being absolutely critical to solving the case - where would you put this issue?It is like a chain, where every link in the chain is important so in a way it is just one link that is 10 out of 10.
This is nonsense. How could Kate be naked if she was wearing a towel?
I'm reminded of a comedian who announced to his audience that ...' Underneath these clothes I'm wearing - I stand here before you - stark naked!''. Can't remember his name - but I think he was the same comedian who said..... 'I came down this morning to find that a burglar had stolen all my furniture - and replaced it with identical furniture to cover his tracks'
Kate was not answering the door to a stranger Not only were the Paynes close friends - but they had stayed at one-another's homes and holidayed together over the years - so the families had probably seen eachother in various stages of undress at various times ? So what? The Victorian era ended a long time ago.
Also D.p. is a doctor and so the human body would not be something that would be even slightly unfamilar to him - or that the sight of a person covered by a towel would be so startling - that it would be seared into his memory for all eternity
I didn't have you down as one of those who take the 'sniggering schoolboy' approach John. I'm surprised.
AIMHO
Comparing the group's statements covering the time between 6.00 pm and 8.30 pm shows significant discrepancies in my opinion.And yet this is the same group that have been said to have got together to get their story straight. How do you account for this? Are they all a bit stupid in your opinion? Colluded, but too dumb to stick to the agreed narrative?
And yet this is the same group that have been said to have got together to get their story straight. How do you account for this? Are they all a bit stupid in your opinion? Colluded, but too dumb to stick to the agreed narrative?
You make it sound as if people have accused them of agreeing on their story Alfie, but we know they did because they said so.People have accused them of collusion, you were one of them thlugh you claimed at the time you didn't understand the meaning of the word. I don't recall the group admitting to colluding, that would be tantamount to admitting to cover up.
I have only looked at the Oldfield's statements at the moment. Their rogatory statements give times 30 minutes later than their 10th-11th May statements.
In Matthews early statement he played tennis until 7pm, but his later statement says that's when he began to play.
In both of their early statements Matthew returned to their apartment between 7pm and 7.15pm, A year later it was 7.45pm - 8pm. I wonder which ones are correct?
It could be argued that any collusion was not to agree on a particular narrative, but to deliberately cause uncertainty in times and actions.So you mean to deliberately arouse suspicion by giving statements that didn't support each others? What a great plan! @)(++(*
Certainly seems to have worked, doesn't it ? Nothing can be pinned down with any degree of accuracy.You'd expect accuracy between the statements of these 9 individuals on holiday would you? How then do you explain the fact that nothing in the statements of all the people NOT part of the McCanns' group can be pinned down with any degree of accuracy either?
People have accused them of collusion, you were one of them thlugh you claimed at the time you didn't understand the meaning of the word. I don't recall the group admitting to colluding, that would be tantamount to admitting to cover up.
You'd expect accuracy between the statements of these 9 individuals on holiday would you? How then do you explain the fact that nothing in the statements of all the people NOT part of the McCanns' group can be pinned down with any degree of accuracy either?
Once again we have this totally unrealistic expectation by some of what the McCanns and their friends should be able to remember. Apparently they are supposed to be able to recall every step they took, everywhere they went, and every word of every conversation - even other peoples conversations - which took place over a period of 5 days - and with total accuracy too.I've yet to see in my time of this forum anyone expect the T9 to be able to remember with perfect accuracy what they did and said over the 5 days in the lead-up to Madeleine's disappearance. Nor anyone expect perfect recall of every second.
It seems to me that folk forget that what we have in the files is only a tiny percentage of everything they all did and said during that holiday. To expect them to have perfect recall of every second of every day is just plain barmy IMO. They must have had thousands of conversations during that time.
Most of what they did/said was totally insignificant at the time they did/said it and only became significant AFTER Madeleine disappeared. So no-one had any reason to make a point of remembering exact times and exact conversations.
IMO this is yet another example of 'hindsight' being a wonderful thing.
And yet this is the same group that have been said to have got together to get their story straight. How do you account for this? Are they all a bit stupid in your opinion? Colluded, but too dumb to stick to the agreed narrative?Good post Alfie
You'd expect accuracy between the statements of these 9 individuals on holiday would you? How then do you explain the fact that nothing in the statements of all the people NOT part of the McCanns' group can be pinned down with any degree of accuracy either?
You'd expect accuracy between the statements of these 9 individuals on holiday would you? How then do you explain the fact that nothing in the statements of all the people NOT part of the McCanns' group can be pinned down with any degree of accuracy either?
http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PARAISO.htmMany thanks. So the 3 males were standing up to leave, at 18.14. And unfortunately the next image is timed at 18.36.
I've yet to see in my time of this forum anyone expect the T9 to be able to remember with perfect accuracy what they did and said over the 5 days in the lead-up to Madeleine's disappearance. Nor anyone expect perfect recall of every second.
But 3rd May, even barring Madeleine's disappearance, should have been memorable for the differences that occurred that day - the trip to the beach - the visit to the Paraíso - the men's tennis competition.
Payne's visit to 5A is critical because he is the last witness, other than the parents, to see Madeleine. Given that the disappearance occurred the same evening, this event should be fixed in his memory. We should know with some certainty the timing and duration of this, but it would appear that certainty is missing.
Is the Paraíso CCTV actually available? And if so can it be used to narrow the timing?
(https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cd/The_Roly-Poly_Pudding_Tom_Kitten.jpg)
I didn't say collusion, I said agreement.On April 13 2015 you wrote the following in reply to a post by me on this board:
Shown a typed time line typed on a lap top borrowed from female tennis coach Georgina, seven adults there when time line drawn up, then shown to the MC CANN’S afterwards for them to make any alterations or additions. Was written after the first weekend after Madeleine’s disappearance this was following David PAYNE’S suggestion. It was checked against initial draft, it was a group recollection and with the groups agreement. The document was typed on the laptop USB flash disk which was handed to the PJ when I went to complete my statement.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN_ROGATORY.htm
The building of the timeline was reactive. There was the core timeline as set down in the 10th May group statement and things got added, or indeed 'forgotten' as questions were asked. It did help that none of the group were ever seriously questioned over the changes in their statements.Of course building a timeline is reactive. Do you expect them to have built one proactively, before Madeleine was taken? Of course things get added, and clarified. Once something has been handed over to the police it cannot be "forgotten" as you put it. I note you didn't even begin to try and explain why there are also many glaring discrepancies in statements NOT belonging to the Tapas group.
An example of this is Gerry's migration to the opposite side of the road while speaking to Wilkins.
10th of May timeline :
2115: JT leaves table, and sees GM talking with fellow resident ("Jez" Wilkins) outside the patio gate of 5A. The two were standing just up the hill from the gate towards Rua A. da Silva Road. She did not speak to GM as she passed.
On April 13 2015 you wrote the following in reply to a post by me on this board:The word collaboration seemed to be acceptable yesterday, rather than "collusion" which today seems to only have evil connotations to it.
Which bit of "lets sit down and use the covers from this book to write the timeline' did you misunderstand? Information or deception it's still collusion.
Use advanced search for the source. I think you have used it once before as well. Clearly you do think the Tapas group colluded though you maybe choose your words more carefully these days.
(snip)... many glaring discrepancies in statements NOT belonging to the Tapas group.Precisely Alfie. An example, a witness stated that 5G was on a different floor to where it is. Obviously just an honest mistake. But if one of the T7 had said it, some here would be insisting it was deliberate lying or collusion.
Precisely Alfie. An example, a witness stated that 5G was on a different floor to where it is. Obviously just an honest mistake. But if one of the T7 had said it, some here would be insisting it was deliberate lying or collusion.
.....Just hypothetically speaking would you make us smile and name these people? I'd love to know who is for alien abduction. 8(>((
Some on here would believe certain people if they said they saw a spaceship hovering over block 5 which used a beam to open the bedroom shutters and window, pick up a child and transfer her up to the ship.
On April 13 2015 you wrote the following in reply to a post by me on this board:
Which bit of "lets sit down and use the covers from this book to write the timeline' did you misunderstand? Information or deception it's still collusion.
Use advanced search for the source. I think you have used it once before as well. Clearly you do think the Tapas group colluded though you maybe choose your words more carefully these days.
Would anyone like to hazard a guess as to why Dave's recollection of his visit to no 5a was so vague?
Would anyone like to hazard a guess as to why Dave's recollection of his visit to no 5a was so vague?
Some are choosing to ignore that very valid point about 3rd May 2007. I have no doubt that those who were there have gone over the details of that day a thousand times yet report a concerning number of inconsistencies.
D P claims in his rogatory interview by LP that he was in 5a for upwards of 5 minutes but when asked what KM and the three children were wearing his only response was 'white'. When asked what the children were doing he replies 'generally standing'.
Sorry, but if that passes for acceptable my name is Sherlock!
PS. Its a good job they never took part in a reconstruction as it would have ended up the farce of the century!
Hindsight is indeed a wonderful thing. Unfortunately D.P. couldn't see into the future.
IMO it could be because he's got a lousy memory generally - and because popping in on Kate for a few moments was of no significance at the time - and was then completely overshadowed by the tragedy which followed later that night.
In his certain knowledge that Madeleine had been abducted by a stranger - he would have no reason at that time to make any connection between that terrible crime and his own brief visit to 5A hours earlier.
It was only when Amaral decided that the parents - especially Kate - were guilty - and their friends had colluded with them that D.P.s visit was turned into a major issue. IMO he used it in an attempt to 'prove' a major discrepancy between KM, D.P. and GM in order to bolster his case against them. However in order to achieve that he made the claim that Gerry had said that D.P.s visit to 5A had lasted 30 mins. Gerry had made no such claim.
AIMHO
Would anyone like to hazard a guess as to why Dave's recollection of his visit to no 5a was so vague?It has to do with understanding what happened. If you can't understand what happened how will you explain it.
Hindsight is indeed a wonderful thing. Unfortunately D.P. couldn't see into the future.
IMO it could be because he's got a lousy memory generally - and because popping in on Kate for a few moments was of no significance at the time - and was then completely overshadowed by the tragedy which followed later that night.
In his certain knowledge that Madeleine had been abducted by a stranger - he would have no reason at that time to make any connection between that terrible crime and his own brief visit to 5A hours earlier.
It was only when Amaral decided that the parents - especially Kate - were guilty - and their friends had colluded with them that D.P.s visit was turned into a major issue. IMO he used it in an attempt to 'prove' a major discrepancy between KM, D.P. and GM in order to bolster his case against them. However in order to achieve that he made the claim that Gerry had said that D.P.s visit to 5A had lasted 30 mins. Gerry had made no such claim.
AIMHO
I think the Portuguese police achieved everything they wanted when it turned out in the end that the tapas group were unwilling to cooperate in a child disappearance investigation.Quite telling in some ways.
I think the Portuguese police achieved everything they wanted when it turned out in the end that the tapas group were unwilling to cooperate in a child disappearance investigation.
The tapas group had watched elements of the PJ attempt to pin this crime on their innocent friends and had themselves been the victims of character assassination in the media (swingers).
They would have to be insane to trust the motives of the PJ after that.
Anyone who can't see that has no ability to put themselves in someone else's shoes IMO.
IMO the PJ knew they would not attend for obvious reasons. In fact they were banking on it. Hence their instruction not to bring the children and their admission that they could give no guarantees re media presence. All intended to put the tapas off attending IMO.
IMO their decision not to attend was then used as a face-saving operation to explain the shelving of the case. Totally unnecessary IMO as all the PJ had to say was they they had done their best with limited resources and with no officially established directives on this particular crime - but unfortunately had not been able to solve the case thus far.
That would have been an acceptable reason for most people IMO.
AIMHO
I've yet to see in my time of this forum anyone expect the T9 to be able to remember with perfect accuracy what they did and said over the 5 days in the lead-up to Madeleine's disappearance. Nor anyone expect perfect recall of every second.
But 3rd May, even barring Madeleine's disappearance, should have been memorable for the differences that occurred that day - the trip to the beach - the visit to the Paraíso - the men's tennis competition.
Payne's visit to 5A is critical because he is the last witness, other than the parents, to see Madeleine. Given that the disappearance occurred the same evening, this event should be fixed in his memory. We should know with some certainty the timing and duration of this, but it would appear that certainty is missing.
Is the Paraíso CCTV actually available? And if so can it be used to narrow the timing?
Members of the T9 had the 'hindsight' to decide on that night/morning that the relevant timeline was 8.30 to 10.00 and included checks that appear to have nothing to do with 5A. Despite including Tannerman at 9.15 and with abduction being the key word, it still covered a time frame that proves of no value to Madeleine, but covers their checking routine.
D.P. had no way of knowing on that night whether or not anyone else had called in at 5A after his own visit. Therefore he did not know at that time that he was the last person outside the family to see Madeleine alive and well.
That's something which IMO could only have been established much later - as I cannot see any reason for D.P. to make any connection whatsoever in his belief that Madeleine had been abducted by a stranger and his own very brief visit to 5A hours before - or any reason to even mention it to anyone as a matter of urgency as it had no relevance because of the time lapse.
Neither did he have any way of knowing at that time that his own visit would become relevant in the future.
Once again hindsight is being used which D.P. did not have the benefit of at the time.
AIMHO
Please do not put thoughts in other people's mind.What thoughts have I put into G-Unit's mind that wasn't already there as evidenced by her own words?
Members of the T9 had the 'hindsight' to decide on that night/morning that the relevant timeline was 8.30 to 10.00 and included checks that appear to have nothing to do with 5A. Despite including Tannerman at 9.15 and with abduction being the key word, it still covered a time frame that proves of no value to Madeleine, but covers their checking routine.
Now who cares about that? If it was abduction, the key checks were GM around 9.05, JT around 5 mins later, MO around 9.30 and KM around 10.05.
It would appear the group was so intent on establishing their timeline that the simple question of - when did you last see Madeleine - a perfectly normal topic of discussion - did not arise. The focus was still the T9, not Madeleine, IMO.
Please do not put thoughts in other people's mind.
Nothing sinister, I just assumed the bad feeling from the previous evening had carried over to the next day. What well heeled man on holiday leaves their wife to cope with three children under four on their own?So Gerry sends his friend David to help Kate with the kids. Is that good enough?
If there were significant mistakes the witnesses wouldnt have said ok Ill signAre you sure about that?
Comparing the group's statements covering the time between 6.00 pm and 8.30 pm shows significant discrepancies in my opinion.Could you extend that time period to 9:00 PM
And yet this is the same group that have been said to have got together to get their story straight. How do you account for this? Are they all a bit stupid in your opinion? Colluded, but too dumb to stick to the agreed narrative?You used the colluded word and it wasn't moderated out? How did you do that?
People have accused them of collusion, you were one of them thlugh you claimed at the time you didn't understand the meaning of the word. I don't recall the group admitting to colluding, that would be tantamount to admitting to cover up.Whether or not they were "colluding" would depend on whether they were trying to synchronise an untruth into the timeline.
I think most intelligent people have a good idea where I stand by now Alfie. You seem to be the only one needing clarity.I may be the only one prepared to challenge mendacious statements such as "I've never accused anyone of lying".
David went to see Kate to find out if she intended to bring the children to the play area, according to Gerry;
Regarding the episode where he spoke to David on the 3rd of May, he says that he was playing tennis at 18:30 when David appeared near the tennis court and asked him if he was going to continue playing. G. said he didn't know because Kate might be needing help to look after the three children, because they intended to bring them to the recreation area after their showers. He thinks that David offered to check if Kate needed help, which he did, and returned minutes later.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm
Kate was under the impression that was the reason for David's visit;
David's visit was to help her to take the children to the recreation area. When David returned from the beach he was with Gerry at the tennis courts, and it was Gerry who asked him to help Kate with taking the children to the recreation area, which had been arranged but did not take place.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
She confirms in her book that taking the children to the play area was a possibility when Gerry left the apartment;
We decided we’d bath the children early, especially as they were all tired, and then I might take them down to the play area in their pyjamas for a little while, if they weren’t quite ready for their beds.....The others had met up with Gerry at the tennis courts and he’d mentioned we were thinking of bringing the kids to the play area. Dave
had nipped up to see if he could give me a hand taking them down.
So Gerry and Kate are quite clear about the purpose of David's visit. He, however, is his usual vague self;
I went over to see err Gerry at the err you know tennis courts, just to see you know what was happening, and err decided that we'd, you know I'd come, come back to play tennis and err Gerry had asked me just to pop in and check everything was alright err with Kate or you know again I can't remember the exact reason whether he was just making sure it was alright that he could stay there and you know more time but you know he'd asked me to pop in.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
David told Fiona all about it;
he was saying how angelic they all looked and he said to Kate when we all sat down at the Tapas table as well and he was sort of joking how they looked like perfect children, because they were all sat there, all clean in their pyjamas, having a story'.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Why would Kate think that David Payne was there to help her take the children to the recreation centre, when earlier on she had said that her and Gerry had decided not to take them?It could be how we read it, you read it differently to how we do. There is also "changing your mind", he might have played tennis. Kate may have said something earlier but she may have changed her mind later.
I think there is a bit of confusion as to what Kate said in the translation.
edited to add - Also David was going home to change to play tennis so how would he be able to take the children to the play area?
Why would Kate think that David Payne was there to help her take the children to the recreation centre, when earlier on she had said that her and Gerry had decided not to take them?
I think there is a bit of confusion as to what Kate said in the translation.
edited to add - Also David was going home to change to play tennis so how would he be able to take the children to the play area?
It could be how we read it, you read it differently to how we do. There is also "changing your mind", he might have played tennis. Kate may have said something earlier but she may have changed her mind later.
Do you have a cite for your assertion about what Kate said please?
One of my quotes was taken from her book, so the stock cry of 'translation errors' doesn't work in this instance, sorry.
David went from tennis to see Kate, back to tennis to report back to Gerry, then to his apartment to prepare for tennis, then back to tennis at 7pm, according to Gerry's arguido statement. David forgot about this double journey, as is his wont.
Why would Kate think that David Payne was there to help her take the children to the recreation centre, when earlier on she had said that her and Gerry had decided not to take them?
I think there is a bit of confusion as to what Kate said in the translation.
edited to add - Also David was going home to change to play tennis so how would he be able to take the children to the play area?
It contradicts her statement when they had already decided not to bring the kids out before Gerry left the tennis for at 6. So then D.P. goes to take them out. That doesn't add up and more importantly it's a routine change on the day she disappeared!
"Before bathing the children and because it was early, they had thought of taking them to the recreation area, but then decided against this because of tiredness."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
6:30 to 7 was normal kids bath time but they said they had bath time earlier that night before Gerry left at 6 &%+((£
Normal Daily Routine
"The dinner ended at 17h30 the time at which the employee supervision ended and the parents took over watching the children in the play area until 18h30. Following this they returned to the apartment, the deponent opened the main door with his key and, then, the rear door through which KATE and the children entered.
The hygiene done, the children were put to bed about 19h30."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
"So perhaps you go up around six thirty, seven o' clock, then they'd have you know the, most nights we liked to give ours baths because you know we just felt that we liked to get them into as much of a routine in a strange environment as possible."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
I wouldn't read anything into the fact that they were getting ready for bed earlier than usual, Madeleine was shattered by the sound of it and Gerry wanted to play a game of tennis, they were going home soon and he probably wanted to make the most of the time he had left.
They had decided NOT to take the kids out so why is D.P. coming round later to take them out after talking to Gerry who knew it?
They had decided NOT to take the kids out so why is D.P. coming round later to take them out after talking to Gerry who knew it?
Perhaps because it was impossible to contrive another plausible reason for the visit ?
Perhaps because it was impossible to contrive another plausible reason for the visit ?That is being naughty isn't it? When we are not allowed to say "collude", one would think "contrive" is just about as wicked.
I think there has been confusion with translation.Once again we are relying on a third party report here ... and also a translation
Did David Payne actually say he had come round to take them out? It is more likely that Gerry just asked him to pop in to see if Kate needed help with the children, he probably felt guilty about playing tennis.
Anyway, David Payne popped back to tell Gerry Kate was fine, then went to get changed for tennis, so what is the big deal about all this?
at 18H30, the time at which he saw DP next to the tennis court. DAVID went to visit KATE and the children and returned close to 19H00, trying to convince the deponent to continue to play tennis, to which [entreaty] he did not accede as he had already been playing for about an hour and had to go back to to his wife.That statement it sounds like David went by his own initiative to visit Kate.
Once again we are relying on a third party report here ... and also a translation
There is always room for errors in both sorts of report. So double possibility here.
How much better to have a verbatim statement, then we know that the words came directly from the statement maker.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htmThat statement it sounds like David went by his own initiative to visit Kate.Maybe, but maybe not.
Perhaps because it was impossible to contrive another plausible reason for the visit ?Eh? why is that the only plausible reason for the visit?
Was it to check if Gerry could stay and play tennis? Not believable being gone only 30 minutes.
Was it to take the kids out? Not believable if they had decided not to take them out.
Was it for another reason? Very likely.
Or did it simply not happen?That doesn't simplify the situation at all. What would we be saying then that the 3 of them are lying about the whole incident?
Or did it simply not happen?
Or did it simply not happen?
Despite the vagueness of his answers in his rog he did open up on one subject. /he was certainly a big fan of Madeleine's;
Mm, err Madeleine's err a very striking err beautiful child, I'd almost if I want a better phrase call her doll-like, you know she was very, you know I think, you know very unique looking child err, she'd got very pretty, you know blonde hair err in a bob, she was quite a petite err child and you know she was very bubbly, very err you know she was a very good child to, to interact with. She was very bright, you could have a lot of fun with Madeleine err and you know she, she was, you know Kate and Gerry's, you know pride and joy. They'd had a lot of trouble conceiving, you know with IVF and everything and you know Madeleine was their miracle. She was obviously very unique with the fact that she'd got the, you know the iris defect err but you know she was certainly a happy go lucky child you know she was, she would interact with the other children very well, as I said on the other, earlier recording, you know she played very happily with Lily and you know indeed the other children. She was, you know, very, she is a very beautiful child and good fun.'
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
They had decided NOT to take the kids out so why is D.P. coming round later to take them out after talking to Gerry who knew it?
For all Gerry knew the children may have perked up and she might have changed her mind about taking them out. Or - knowing they were tired - she may have needed his help if they were getting over tired. Once he knew D.P. was going back to his apartment - he simply asked him to pop in and check that she was OK.Who would determine whether it was significant or not? The only thing recorded there that alerts me is the part that says "D.P. reported that all was well and tried to persuade him to stay longer". Could there have been an ulterior motive?
It seems to me that by the time D.P. got back to the courts - Gerry had decided to go home anyway - even though D.P. reported that all was well and tried to persuade him to stay longer.
I can't believe people are making such a big deal out of such an insignificant occurrence. Or that any of them should be expected to remember with absolute accuracy - something so trivial at the time.
AIMHO
Who would determine whether it was significant or not? The only thing recorded there that alerts me is the part that says "D.P. reported that all was well and tried to persuade him to stay longer". Could there have been an ulterior motive?
... and? ...
Fiona Payne said David was at the apartment helping to get the children to bed before he went to play tennis, if there was an ulterior motive he didn't appear to have used it.What was the ulterior motive he had IYO? I didn't think of anything sinister.
Fiona Payne said David was at the apartment helping to get the children to bed before he went to play tennis, if there was an ulterior motive he didn't appear to have used it.
Did she? I don't remember seeing that. How much easier it is when cites are provided..................
Sorry AFTER he played tennis. So he had had a game of tennis, Fiona saw him playing when they came up from the beach.
Yes, thank you Lace. I'm working on a timeline from 17.30 onwards, because Gerry said David arrived back at the tennis courts at 19.00, but Fiona said he was playing at 18.45, plus another few differences.
Yes, thank you Lace. I'm working on a timeline from 17.30 onwards, because Gerry said David arrived back at the tennis courts at 19.00, but Fiona said he was playing at 18.45, plus another few differences.When you say you are working on a timeline, how is it looking so far?
This thread has now been edited.
A couple of points in passing. If members feel that a post or specific comment is unacceptable and has been As justificationmissed by the moderators they are free to report them in the usual way.
Some members have raised the question as to what is the point of this thread. I can only point to the rogatory statements relating to the period from 6pm to 8pm and ponder why LP were so interested in these movements?
I think the Portuguese police achieved everything they wanted when it turned out in the end that the tapas group were unwilling to cooperate in a child disappearance investigation.
With all the consular govt media and other support they had the excuse for not going back for a reconstruction in case they were fitted up is extremely hilarious at bestLet's have a go ourselves Mercury.
They just couldnt be bothered, thought their pis were the better in solving it, thought the pj were monkeys to have to jump whenever they tried
To date not even the highly lauded sy solved it
Theyre positively pathetic in their behaviours the lot of them
No stone unturned they all said, their actions said the opposite alot of the time