UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on September 22, 2016, 06:07:40 AM
-
Can we put Matthew Oldfield's statements under the microscope?
Certainly Goncalo Amaral felt his behaviour strange but can we make out what it was all about?
Matthew Oldfield's behaviour is perplexing. According to the two timelines, Gerald's statements and his own affirmations, he and Russell left the restaurant at around 9:30 pm to go their respective apartments. Matthew entered his accommodation by the front door, left again that way after glancing at his children, crossed the car park and walked round the building to go into the McCann's apartment by the rear patio door - the only one not to have been locked. He then went to the children's bedroom. In the first list, there is no mention of this visit: Matthew contented himself with listening at the windows; in the second, Russell notes that his friend saw the twins at 9:35 pm.
Page 94 Truth of the lie.
-
Rachael Mampilly, Matthew Oldfield partners.
-
One hour earlier, at around 1pm, the other members of the group of holiday-makers had arrived from London: the Oldfield couple - Matthew Oldfield (38), doctor, Rachael Mampilly (37) human resources manager, and their daughter Grace (19 months) - as well as the O'Brien couple - Russell O'Brien (37), doctor, Jane Tanner (36) marketing manager, and their daughters Ella and Evie (aged 3 and 1 respectively)
Also on that flight was Jeremy Wilkins and Bridget O'Donnell and their son and daughter.
During the morning, only Madeleine's father, Matthew Oldfield and Jane Tanner are interviewed. However, already contradictions and improbabilities are appearing from one to another of the statements, notably concerning access to the apartment.
Page 34
-
Right now for more of the knitty gritty brought up by GA
- 21.30: Matthew Oldfield: (goes into the apartment, but doesn't go into the bedroom. He only sees the twins);
- 22.00: Kate Healy (goes into the apartment, and finds that Madeleine has disappeared).
If, as Kate states, the window was open when she went into the apartment, how come Matthew didn't notice? At the time when the latter went in, Jane had already seen the alleged abductor with the child. So, logically, if the crime had already been committed, the window should have been open.
Matthew says that the bedroom door was half open, Kate that it was wide open. It can be concluded that Madeleine was already no longer in the room - which Matthew should have noticed, if the other witness statements are to be believed.
Page #35
Let's give GA the benefit of the doubt. Had creche man come forward the next day and told the PJ that he had passed that area the night before he wouldn't need to struggle over this.
Jane Tanner's memory would have been fresh and she would not have read the article in the Guardian on Saturday. It could have been quite different.
Was there some reason Creche man hesitated? (future thread possibly).
I don't know if I'd try and work out if the crime had been committed just considering the doors moving.
-
As if the memory of the McCann family's friends suddenly came back to them, all - Rachael Mampilly, wife of Matthew Oldfield, Fiona Payne, wife of David Payne, and Russell O'Brien Jane Tanner's partner - recall having seen Murat on the night of May 3rd, shortly after the announcement of the disappearance, in the immediate vicinity apartment 5A. Meanwhile, of course, Murat's picture has been shown on television and in certain newspapers. They themselves were in direct contact with him during the previous days. However, it is only on May 16th that they deliver this information to us. As for the officers of the National Guard who were on the spot, they didn't see him that night, only the next morning, when he came to offer his services as interpreter.
Page #73
OK GA seems to be blaming the Robert Murat fiasco on this section of the Tapas 9. Interesting.
How come he didn't use his powers of suspicion immediately in the discrepancy. I suppose such a clear divide is still possible.
-
I find Matthew's account of going to ask Reception to call the police strange. My conclusion is that either he didn't go [the receptionist never mentions him], he lacks any authority or conviction, or he wasn't convinced MM had been abducted;
Fiona, I think, asked me to go and phone the Police....and I asked the reception to phone the Police, and that must have been about five past, it's difficult to know what time it was at that time, but maybe about ten past ten, five past ten, ten past ten'......I said, you've got to phone the Police, you know, a child's been taken, and they went, oh no, she's probably just sort of woken up and he thought she's probably sort of wandered off or something like that and you thought, yeah, maybe you're right, maybe you're right, erm, can you please, it was sort of, it was kind of, it was sort a weird kind of lack of urgency, you know, he'd ring, but you had to sort and stand there and say, ring now, ring now, so I don't know if they rang at that point, but certainly, erm, you know, I certainly asked them to, about perhaps sort of maybe about ten past ten maybe.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm
-
Can we put Matthew Oldfield's statements under the microscope?
Certainly Goncalo Amaral felt his behaviour strange but can we make out what it was all about? Page 94 Truth of the lie.
I don't suppose it occurred to Amaral that perhaps Russell wasn't aware of Matt's 9:30 pm check at the time of his first attempt at collating input from various people.
-
I don't suppose it occurred to Amaral that perhaps Russell wasn't aware of Matt's 9:30 pm check at the time of his first attempt at collating input from various people.
I think you might be right. I think we should use that as a standard explanation: "Russell wasn't aware of Matt's 9:30 pm check at the time of his first attempt at collating input from various people."
So does that seem logical? Possible, that the two guys didn't talk about doing a check of the McCanns as they walked the distance.
-
I think you might be right. I think we should use that as a standard explanation: "Russell wasn't aware of Matt's 9:30 pm check at the time of his first attempt at collating input from various people."
So does that seem logical? Possible, that the two guys didn't talk about doing a check of the McCanns as they walked the distance.
Or he only remembered that detail a bit later when doing the updated list. People were in a panic that night.
Russell handed in both versions... that wouldn't make much sense if there had been an attempt to add checks that hadn't happened, would it?
-
Or he only remembered that detail a bit later when doing the updated list. People were in a panic that night.
Russell handed in both versions... that wouldn't make much sense if there had been an attempt to add checks that hadn't happened, would it?
So true. I like your reasoning. It makes sense and has helped me, for I tended to be a bit suspicious and I thought they were trying to avoid mentioning Matt's visit but your concept seems reasonable. If it was a devious attempt he would have destroyed the first incorrect timeline. Thanks.
-
Russell doesn't mention Kate or Matthew's check on 4th May;
At around 9.35/9.40, taking advantage of the lull [waiting pause] before being served with the first [main] course, the informant left the restaurant with Matthew to check the children. When he got there, his daughter **** was crying. He stayed in her bedroom with her. He supposes that Matthew checked his apartment. Matthew returned to the restaurant five minutes after leaving it. His partner came to take his place in ****'s bedroom around 15 minutes later after finishing dinner.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm
He's still hanging back on 11th;
Around 21h25, taking advantage of a pause in the service of the first plate, the deponent left the restaurant with Matthew Oldfield to check on the children. He arrived at his apartment and immediately heard his daughter Evie crying and stayed in the apartment. He believes that Matthew Oldfield went to his apartment, and is not aware if he was going to also check on the McCann children and went to the deponent's apartment and asked him if he needed help.
- Matthew Oldfield returned to the restaurant, having told Jane Tanner that the deponent stayed behind with Evie O'Brien because she was crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm
Kate doesn't mention Russell at all on 4th May in relation to 9.30pm, she says he went at 9pm, at the same time as Gerry;
Thus, at around 9pm, her husband went to the apartment to make sure the twins, as well as Madeleine, were OK.....At the same time, one of the group of friends, Russell, went to see his children, without checking on the interviewee's children.
Around 9.30pm was the time the interviewee should have gone to see her children, but her friend Matt (a member of the group) had just done a check in his apartment then gone to the interviewee's. He had entered the apartment by a glass sliding side door, that was always unlocked and once inside had not gone into the children's bedroom. He only looked through the door, and did not hear any noise. He went back to the restaurant and said that everything was fine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm
-
Russell doesn't mention Kate or Matthew's check on 4th May;
At around 9.35/9.40, taking advantage of the lull [waiting pause] before being served with the first [main] course, the informant left the restaurant with Matthew to check the children. When he got there, his daughter **** was crying. He stayed in her bedroom with her. He supposes that Matthew checked his apartment. Matthew returned to the restaurant five minutes after leaving it. His partner came to take his place in ****'s bedroom around 15 minutes later after finishing dinner.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm
He's still hanging back on 11th;
Around 21h25, taking advantage of a pause in the service of the first plate, the deponent left the restaurant with Matthew Oldfield to check on the children. He arrived at his apartment and immediately heard his daughter Evie crying and stayed in the apartment. He believes that Matthew Oldfield went to his apartment, and is not aware if he was going to also check on the McCann children and went to the deponent's apartment and asked him if he needed help.
- Matthew Oldfield returned to the restaurant, having told Jane Tanner that the deponent stayed behind with Evie O'Brien because she was crying.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm
Kate doesn't mention Russell at all on 4th May in relation to 9.30pm, she says he went at 9pm, at the same time as Gerry;
Thus, at around 9pm, her husband went to the apartment to make sure the twins, as well as Madeleine, were OK.....At the same time, one of the group of friends, Russell, went to see his children, without checking on the interviewee's children.
Around 9.30pm was the time the interviewee should have gone to see her children, but her friend Matt (a member of the group) had just done a check in his apartment then gone to the interviewee's. He had entered the apartment by a glass sliding side door, that was always unlocked and once inside had not gone into the children's bedroom. He only looked through the door, and did not hear any noise. He went back to the restaurant and said that everything was fine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm
The people interviewed were responding to the questions asked.... These aren't verbatim reports of Q & A.
-
It is interesting to see Kate saying Russell did the check that is later assigned to Jane. Jane and Russell had their substandard baby monitor. Were they getting something on it that made Jane to go up as well. (For the story is that Gerry had finished by the time Jane walked past.)
-
It is interesting to see Kate saying Russell did the check that is later assigned to Jane. Jane and Russell had their substandard baby monitor. Were they getting something on it that made Jane to go up as well. (For the story is that Gerry had finished by the time Jane walked past.)
Without double-checking yet again, upon returning, Matt told Jane that Russ was staying with the little one as she wasn't well. Jane then quickly finished her meal to take over so that Russ could have his dinner.
-
Without double-checking yet again, upon returning, Matt told Jane that Russ was staying with the little one as she wasn't well. Jane then quickly finished her meal to take over so that Russ could have his dinner.
That all happens between 9:30 to 10:00. What happens between 9:00 - 9:30 is a bit less defined.
-
Gerry thought that he had interrupted the abductor but given the evidence I think it more likely that it was Matt who did so. That period after 9.30pm until 10pm was the perfect window of opportunity.
-
The people interviewed were responding to the questions asked.... These aren't verbatim reports of Q & A.
Yes, of course, and did the interpreter's/policemen get the names and times wrong or was it the amateur biased translators or were the group too traumatised to remember?
Whatever, it couldn't possibly be the group making contradictory statements. %£&)**#
-
Yes, of course, and did the interpreter's/policemen get the names and times wrong or was it the amateur biased translators or were the group too traumatised to remember?
Whatever, it couldn't possibly be the group making contradictory statements. %£&)**#
There could be a combination of errors / misunderstandings made by any one or other parties. Or even a combination of several parties regarding the understanding of a particular detail or other.
-
There could be a combination of errors / misunderstandings made by any one or other parties. Or even a combination of several parties regarding the understanding of a particular detail or other.
Or no errors or misunderstandings at all. 8(>((
-
Or no errors or misunderstandings at all. 8(>((
Possibly, in some cases.
However, assuming that every detail had been accurately reported and that therefore every supposed discrepancy represents a lie would appear to be somewhat naive, IMO.
Anything serious should have been further investigated. Indeed, the question of whether Gerry entered via a locked door or the unlocked patio was clarified in his 10 May statement.
No one, to my knowledge has wondered why there was an apparent time warp across PdL - with some witnesses stating that all hell broke loose shortly after 10 pm, while others state virtually the same timeframe but an hour earlier.
-
Possibly, in some cases.
However, assuming that every detail had been accurately reported and that therefore every supposed discrepancy represents a lie would appear to be somewhat naive, IMO.
Anything serious should have been further investigated. Indeed, the question of whether Gerry entered via a locked door or the unlocked patio was clarified in his 10 May statement.
No one, to my knowledge has wondered why there was an apparent time warp across PdL - with some witnesses stating that all hell broke loose shortly after 10 pm, while others state virtually the same timeframe but an hour earlier.
I think your post would be more relevant to the 'What should the PJ have done better thread'. These problems probably should have been spotted, noted and clarified at the time. I suspect it's a hindsight thing, though. At the time they were trying to find information about an abductor. So we have what we have.
-
Gerry thought that he had interrupted the abductor but given the evidence I think it more likely that it was Matt who did so. That period after 9.30pm until 10pm was the perfect window of opportunity.
The abductors got their timing pretty wrong if they were in the building when two checks were being done.
-
The abductors got their timing pretty wrong if they were in the building when two checks were being done.
A brief reminder, abduction is a theory and unproven.
-
A brief reminder, abduction is a theory and unproven.
Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?
-
Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?
They are mighty big IFs. There is nothing to prove your assertion.
-
Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?
IF is the operative word, and not a jot of forensic test results to support it.
-
They are mighty big IFs. There is nothing to prove your assertion.
It was John who suggested it. We are only working off suggestions and not making assertions yet.
-
IF is the operative word, and not a jot of forensic test results to support it.
I was looking for a word to describe the (hypothetical) person.
"Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?"
I suppose you could call them unpaid babysitters, intruders, burglars, thieves. Unpaid child minders is my choice.
-
I was looking for a word to describe the (hypothetical) person.
"Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?"
A child.
-
A child.
was it three children or just the two? was it three children plus the unpaid child minder?
-
I was looking for a word to describe the (hypothetical) person.
"Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?"
I suppose you could call them unpaid babysitters, intruders, burglars, thieves. Unpaid child minders is my choice.
...and not one jot of evidence to show one ever existed.
-
was it three children or just the two? was it three children plus the unpaid child minder?
???
-
???
Rofl
We now have an unpaid childminder....who is that?
@)(++(*
-
was it three children or just the two? was it three children plus the unpaid child minder?
We are told that there were 3 at the beginning of the evening and 2 at the end, though this has never been corroborated by an independent witness.
-
Well if there was someone in the room while Gerry was there what would you call the other person?
Well if there was someone in the room while Matthew was there what would you call the other person?
In both cases I would call them an intruder. There is no real way to square the moving door to the children's bedroom, it could have been air movement or even Madeleine moving around just as much as it could have been an intruder. There is just is no way of being sure.
-
Rofl
We now have an unpaid childminder....who is that?
@)(++(*
If Gerry thought there was someone in the kids bedroom while he was doing his check what would that person be called?
-
If Gerry thought there was someone in the kids bedroom while he was doing his check what would that person be called?
A childminder in your mental universe i suppose
Got some grown up sane places to go to so see u later rofl
-
A childminder in your mental universe i suppose
Maybe we could say "an anonymous unpaid child minder".
-
Maybe we could say "an anonymous unpaid child minder".
Maybe we say, such an individual never existed. 8)-)))
-
Maybe we say, such an individual never existed. 8)-)))
Something like a haunted house where the poltergeist was able to move doors.
-
Maybe we say, such an individual never existed. 8)-)))
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=post;quote=356254;topic=7635.30;last_msg=356266
Intruder, OK we could debate whether or not there was an intruder, but if there was could we say the intruder was the abductor, or could there be an intruder and an abductor?
-
In both cases I would call them an intruder. There is no real way to square the moving door to the children's bedroom, it could have been air movement or even Madeleine moving around just as much as it could have been an intruder. There is just is no way of being sure.
Sorry John I hadn't noticed your post till later. I think "intruder" would be the correct technical term.
-
Something like a haunted house where the poltergeist was able to move doors.
Hearsay bittybob, and not verified.
-
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=post;quote=356254;topic=7635.30;last_msg=356266
Intruder, OK we could debate whether or not there was an intruder, but if there was could we say the intruder was the abductor, or could there be an intruder and an abductor?
We could also say an intruder is a figment of some peoples imagination.
-
Sorry John I hadn't noticed your post till later. I think "intruder" would be the correct technical term.
The witness never reached a conclusion as to why the door moved. It wasn't the child, she hadn't moved. He's sure he left it more closed than he found it though. Therefore someone or something must have moved it. Still, never mind, just go back to the restaurant, leaving the patio door open and your precious children alone in there. Really?
I was once alone in my house with my two children. I was heavily pregnant. I checked the children before going to bed and the attic opening, which was in their room, was open. In the room were two single beds and a cot. I never went to my bedroom, I slept in one of the beds directly under the attic opening just in case someone was somehow up there. No way was I leaving my children alone in that room that night.
-
The witness never reached a conclusion as to why the door moved. It wasn't the child, she hadn't moved. He's sure he left it more closed than he found it though. Therefore someone or something must have moved it. Still, never mind, just go back to the restaurant, leaving the patio door open and your precious children alone in there. Really?
I was once alone in my house with my two children. I was heavily pregnant. I checked the children before going to bed and the attic opening, which was in their room, was open. In the room were two single beds and a cot. I never went to my bedroom, I slept in one of the beds directly under the attic opening just in case someone was somehow up there. No way was I leaving my children alone in that room that night.
So how does something like that resolve itself. Did you go into the attic the next morning? Did you look around it? Did you work out how it opened? My cat moves doors here. She waits till I wake up and she will come in the bedroom and slam the door shut ..... or if it was closed she opens it.
-
What does Rachel say about her hubby?
Now the first thing to work out is it Rachael or as I have been using of late Rachel?
The Files have her name spelt Rachael "Rachael Mariamma Jean Mampilly Oldfield" Yet Wikipedia has it "Matthew and Rachel Oldfield"
Her 04/05/2007 statement reads like it was well translated for it still reads pretty fluently.
Between the starters and the main course, at around 9.30pm, her husband Matthew Oldfield and Russell O'Brien both went to check on the children. Kate was also planning to go and see the children, but they told her it was no trouble, that they would go and check. Kate, therefore, stayed at the restaurant. Four or five minutes later the interviewee's husband came back after having checked his apartment. He also checked the one where Madeleine was. He entered the apartment by the sliding door/window at the rear (the couple Gerry and Kate McCann left that access unlocked during dinner). The said patio door gives access to the apartment's lounge where two doors open into the respective bedrooms.
Her husband went into the main room and "peeped" into one of the bedrooms where the couple's three children were sleeping. He didn't switch any lights on. He could see the twins in their beds. The bedroom door was half-open. It was only later that he realised this was strange. At the time, he gave no importance to the fact. The interviewee's husband came back to the restaurant and said that everything was fine, that he hadn't heard any noise. He also said that Russell O'Brien was staying with his daughter, ****, who was crying.
The only sentence in there that I would question was "He didn't switch any lights on." Did she say that off the top of her head or was she asked, and how would she know any way? Had he actually told her: "I didn't turn on any lights" or had she interrogated him over whether he had turned on any lights? This the day after I'll remind you.
well maybe two for I think this is the bit Mercury keeps referring too "Her husband went into the main room and "peeped" into one of the bedrooms where the couple's three children were sleeping."
So in her knowledge he has admitted to her:
1. "I went into the main bedroom, Kate and Gerry's room".
2. "I "peeped" into the bedroom where the couple's three children were sleeping".
-
So let's look at any follow-up statements.
So the were two within the next two weeks (so she seems to be getting more attention than most).
"RACHAEL OLDFIELD'S 11&15 MAY 2007 STATEMENT" http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-11-MAY07.htm
The one sentence I want clarified is this one:The window shutters of the McCann's apartments were closed. The patio door that they used to enter the apartment also had its shutter closed. In order to enter they had to raise the shutter.
I can't recall anyone else saying they had to lift the shutters to get through the patio door. The bedroom shutters were raised from inside (some mechanism). Were the ones at the sliding door the same did they just lift them and climb underneath?
-
Rachel is wrong there
There is no way the shutters on the patio door were down and had to be lifted before entering, silly
-
The rogatory interview - they are so much fun to read!
TAPAS7 WEDNESDAY 09 APRIL 2008 10:23
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm
I laughed a little at this bit 1578 'And take as long as you like and tell us everything'.
Reply 'Mmm mmm'.
there seemed to be a lot of mmm mmms!
he said he'd just have a listen outside the windows of the apartments, just to make sure there was no crying or anything, erm so he, he passed them in the street, they came and sat at the table and you know a few minutes later, Matt came back and he'd listened outside our window and you know, Grace was quiet and he listened outside Madeleine and the twins bedroom and that was all quiet, you know and all the, you know all the shutters were down'.
01.08.18 1578 'Did he tell you that''
Reply 'Not at the time but afterwards, but I mean he said yeah everything was quiet, he listened at all the windows and also Ella and Evies I think, I mean I know he definitely listened at Graces and at Madeleine and Sean and Amelies windows
So would that mean he checked both sides of the building or just the northern side (the car park side)?
Which way round the building does Rachel think Matt took? so he went back round through the car park and out down the road, up the back steps into Gerry and Kates apartment, through the patio door
Which is not the shortest route and not the way around the forum thought he'd taken. Was she guessing or had Matt told her this specifically?
-
So let's look at any follow-up statements.
So the were two within the next two weeks (so she seems to be getting more attention than most).
"RACHAEL OLDFIELD'S 11&15 MAY 2007 STATEMENT" http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-11-MAY07.htm
The one sentence I want clarified is this one:I can't recall anyone else saying they had to lift the shutters to get through the patio door. The bedroom shutters were raised from inside (some mechanism). Were the ones at the sliding door the same did they just lift them and climb underneath?
Patio door shutters are usually only deployed ie lowered, when a property is left vacant. When a property with patio door shutters is occupied the shutter is normally raised. At least that is my experience in Spain.
-
Rachel is wrong there
There is no way the shutters on the patio door were down and had to be lifted before entering, silly
I was thinking maybe that is what Matt and Rachel had done in their apartment i.e. they had lowered and closed the shutters on their sliding door and she assumed the same for the McCanns but it would be very difficult to lift the shutters and to slide the sliding door. And not to explain the method one would have use to exit this way. If this was the case no abductor would carry a child out that way that's for sure.
But talking about this are we sure that these weren't the shutters that Kate was talking about? Are we sure Kate was talking about the bedroom shutters? Could Gerry have left the shutters up on his check by mistake? So he could exit via the sliding door on his own. For it would be possible to do this operation with two people but could it be done quietly on your own. So if the shutters had been left up Matt wouldn't need to climb underneath.
So I'm thinking maybe Rachel had noted the shutters were down when she went for the restaurant and assumed that is the situation facing everyone for the rest of the night.
-
The only shutters in any debate ARE the ones in the kids bedroom
-
The only shutters in any debate ARE the ones in the kids bedroom
Open your mind, mercury.
Robitty is exploring every angle ... and that is good practice ...the solution could be in the detail.
-
Patio door shutters are usually only deployed ie lowered, when a property is left vacant. When a property with patio door shutters is occupied the shutter is normally raised. At least that is my experience in Spain.
Would there be a curtain on the inside as well to pull across before closing the door?
-
The only shutters in any debate ARE the ones in the kids bedroom
Not any longer the case since Rachel has said the sliding door shutters were down as well.
Chronological Order of the statement http://www.mccannfiles.com/id261.html
-
Not any longer the case since Rachel has said the sliding door shutters were down as well.
Rachel is thick it seems
There is no way the mccanns checked their kids by raising the shutters on their patio doors ffs
-
Rachel is thick
There is no way the mccanns checked their kids by raisihg the patio doors ffs
Remember that Gerry on his first check stated he went in through the front door. Maybe that was true. I know everyone doubts it but I'd think it would be really difficult to open the sliding door behind shutters that were down in front of them. It may have been virtually impossible to do quietly, so does Gerry then goes around to the front door after his attempt to open the sliding door (suggestion only).
-
Remember that Gerry on his first check stated he went in through the front door. Maybe that was true. I know everyone doubts it but I'd think it would be really difficult to open the sliding door behind shutters that were down in front of them. It may have been virtually impossible to do quietly, so Gerry then goes around to the front door after his attempt to open the sliding door.
Yes so gerry said he went in the front door with the KEY so whats new
He never said he went via the patio doors and had t raise shuutters so thats why rachel is thick ..as thick as all of them
Scary when most of them were doctors....
-
Yes so gerry said he went in the front door with the KEY so whats new
He never said he went via the patio doors and had t raise shuutters so thats why rachel is thick ..as thick as all of them
Scary when most of them were doctors....
Did he maintain that throughout all his statements for I've read that they say Gerry changes his tune on that. Is that really true?
"The key that Mr. Gerald McCann alleges to have used had in fact been left in the kitchen, on the kitchen’s counter. Right away, the lies started."
There would be more than 1 set of keys.
When Gerald saw his daughter for the last time, at around 9.05pm, she was sleeping in the bedroom with the twins. He entered his apartment by the front door, using his key. No windows were open, but he cannot say if they were locked. On the other hand - everybody is in agreement in saying -, the patio door at the rear wasn't locked.
page #39
Does he change his mind?
You ask yourself why Gerald went into his apartment through the front door while the one at the back is closer to the restaurant and doesn't need a key. The parents insist that it was visible from the restaurant and that no one could have walked in without being noticed.
Does Gerry ever change his mind on this? I definitely read that GA doubts him.
-
What does Gerry say? 10/05/2007 http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
Referring to the front door, while he is certain that it was closed it is unlikely that it was locked as [because] they had left by the rear door.
I assume he means deadlocked not that it was still possible to open from the outside.
----- He followed the normal route up to the rear door, which being open he only had to move [slide] it, that being the way in which he entered [was entering] the lounge,
So that is a change, and no mention of having to lift the shutters. OK so had they been lifted by someone else then? He later thought someone could have been inside for the door had been moved so maybe they had raised the shutters by that stage.
In his arguido statement he does state how he got in. He remembers that once inside the apartment he thought strange only the fact of the door to the children's room being slightly more open than how the defendant had left it when he and Kate left for dinner.
afterward
leaving yet again through the rear door that he closed but did not lock.
Looking at Kate's statement assuming it has been translated correctly: At around 10pm, the interviewee went to check on the children. She went into the apartment by the side door, which was closed but not locked, as she said before. She noticed that the door to her children's bedroom was completely open, the window was also open, the shutters raised and the curtains open, while she was certain of having closed them all as she always did.
While there is some uncertainty I can't read that as she was expecting the outside shutter of the sliding door to be down. But it definitely reads that the bedroom was wide open and the shutters were up.
-
Back to the Truth of the Lie. by Goncalo Amaral. page #94
For a reason of which we are unaware, the friends have to state that Jane saw a man carrying a child at around 9.20 - 9.25pm, and between that time and the alert (towards 10pm), someone from the group went to the apartment, saw the twins in the bedroom, but cannot guarantee that Madeleine was still there. According to the second list, it is Matthew Oldfield, whom the first list says only listened at the windows of apartments 5A, 5B. and 5D; still according to that same list, he was allegedly accompanied by Russell O'Brien at around 9.30pm and saw the twins at around 9.35pm.
I can't say too much about that.
Matthew Oldfield's behaviour is perplexing. According to the two timelines, Gerald's statements and his own affirmations, he and Russell left the restaurant at around 9.30pm to go their respective apartments. Matthew entered his accommodation by the front door, left again that way after glancing at his children, crossed the car park and walked round the building to go into the McCanns' apartment by the rear patio door - the only one not to have been locked. He then went to the children's bedroom. In the first list, there is no mention of this visit: Matthew contented himself with listening at the windows; in the second, Russell notes that his friend saw the twins at 9.35pm.
Well as we've discussed if the list was made by Russell O'Brien he may have waited for confirmation the Matthew had checked the McCann's before putting it on the list.
In the course of the statement which he made to the PJ, Matthew certifies having gone to the McCann's apartment at 9.25pm, having definitely seen the twins and noticing a definite light. What he doesn't explain, is how he could pass the bedroom window twice without noticing that it was open. On the other hand, once inside, he noticed that it was. That happens to conveniently reinforce the hypothesis of an abduction and gives weight to Jane Tanner's witness statement.
Well reading that I can't help but think GA has made a mistake. He is saying Matthew noticed the window open Maybe he means that the shutter is up for the amount of light isn't going to be dependent on whether the window is open or not.
-
Truth of the Lie by Goncalo Amaral page 95
We deduce from this that the alert was bound to have been raised before 10pm. Matthew Oldfield's and Jane Tanner's witness statements contradict each other. Those of Matthew and Kate too: the latter insists that when she went into the apartment, the bedroom door banged shut, the window was wide open and the curtains were raised by the wind. However, Matthew said nothing about all of that, only "a definite light," in the bedroom. This is rather implausible: from his vantage point - the bedroom doorway -, the line of sight between the door and the window is limited to a straight line of close to 4 metres. Which means that if the window had been open, he would inevitably have noticed it. Why such vagueness? Another obvious mistake concerns the number of windows: he mentioned two, while in reality, there was only one. His wife repeated the same mistake when she stated that her husband had listened at two bedroom windows during his second round.
I noticed that too. Where did Matthew think there were two windows? There was only one window at the back of the apartment, one in the kids bedroom. To listen at this window he would have had to walk there from Russell's place but he doesn't say he did that. If one window has two panes of glass that is not usually called two windows.
-
So how does something like that resolve itself. Did you go into the attic the next morning? Did you look around it? Did you work out how it opened? My cat moves doors here. She waits till I wake up and she will come in the bedroom and slam the door shut ..... or if it was closed she opens it.
My husband returned, had a good look and concluded that the wind had somehow blown under the eaves. It never happened again. We used to have a dog who could open doors. Do cats have a curfew in New Zealand as they do in Australia? Some people are pushing for one here because they are decimating wildlife.
My point, by the way, was that what should have been a red flag was ignored.
-
My husband returned, had a good look and concluded that the wind had somehow blown under the eaves. It never happened again. We used to have a dog who could open doors. Do cats have a curfew in New Zealand as they do in Australia? Some people are pushing for one here because they are decimating wildlife.
My point, by the way, was that what should have been a red flag was ignored.
What could you do? He could have called the night off. I bet he wishes he had.
-
The witness never reached a conclusion as to why the door moved. It wasn't the child, she hadn't moved. He's sure he left it more closed than he found it though. Therefore someone or something must have moved it. Still, never mind, just go back to the restaurant, leaving the patio door open and your precious children alone in there. Really?
I was once alone in my house with my two children. I was heavily pregnant. I checked the children before going to bed and the attic opening, which was in their room, was open. In the room were two single beds and a cot. I never went to my bedroom, I slept in one of the beds directly under the attic opening just in case someone was somehow up there. No way was I leaving my children alone in that room that night.
Sounds like the premise of a horror movie. See, if it was me, I'd presume the catch had got loose and given way and think nothing more of it. But then I live in a detached house and there is no way into the roof except through the house and so any intruder would have had to get past me first. In Gerry's situation I'd have put the moving door down to air movement when I entered the apartment and given it no more thought unless of course one of my kids suddenly disappeared thereafter, and then I'd be wracking my brains searching for any evidence whatsoever that might suggest someone had come into the apartment and taken her and then I might remember the door.
-
Truth of the Lie by Goncalo Amaral page 95I noticed that too. Where did Matthew think there were two windows? There was only one window at the back of the apartment, one in the kids bedroom. To listen at this window he would have had to walk there from Russell's place but he doesn't say he did that. If one window has two panes of glass that is not usually called two windows.
There is one window opening but two glass panels, one fixed and one sliding.
This was touched on yesterday, the reason the door slammed with Kate but not with Matt was because when Matt entered the apartment the bedroom window was not open. This supports the idea that Madeleine disappeared after Matt's 9.30 check.
-
Truth of the Lie by Goncalo Amaral page 95I noticed that too. Where did Matthew think there were two windows? There was only one window at the back of the apartment, one in the kids bedroom. To listen at this window he would have had to walk there from Russell's place but he doesn't say he did that. If one window has two panes of glass that is not usually called two windows.
Another translation error per chance?
-
There is one window opening but two glass panels, one fixed and one sliding.
This was touched on yesterday, the reason the door slammed with Kate but not with Matt was because when Matt entered the apartment the bedroom window was not open. This supports the idea that Madeleine disappeared after Matt's 9.30 check.
in his rogatory interview he tries to explain why he thought there were two windows. I couldn't quite follow it.
The shutters, we didn't open all week, because there's kind of no point. I mean, we went in that bedroom for Grace to sleep during that day, it needed to be dark and kept it at an even temperature, there was no point putting it up and down. I know the, one of the things I said in my statement, when we talk about the Thursday, was where the two windows were only the one, and I thought the two were on this bedroom rather than this one and so, you know, I said, you go through, but there's actually two more, apparently two on those, they showed me a photograph of that. So that's something I know that I got mistaken by, I thought there were two on next door, because I don't think I'd ever noticed it because I think because we'd never pulled up the shutters, they were always sort of down, we just didn't interfere with those'.
-
.....
This was touched on yesterday, the reason the door slammed with Kate but not with Matt was because when Matt entered the apartment the bedroom window was not open. This supports the idea that Madeleine disappeared after Matt's 9.30 check.
I'm not sure about anything at the moment. It doesn't seem like he checked the state of the shutters while he was on the North side of the building. When he was on the inside with the curtains pulled across he would not be able to tell if the window was open or if the shutters were up at that stage.
The only way to check this would be to go across the room and check behind the curtain. But that could wake the kids. It isn't an easy situation to be in.
-
Certainly not an ideal method of child care - not bothering to check that they were all actually there.
I wonder if he was any more thorough when checking on his own children ?
-
Certainly not an ideal method of child care - not bothering to check that they were all actually there.
I wonder if he was any more thorough when checking on his own children ?
He was checking if the children were asleep. If only he and everyone else had paid more attention when they studied the exact science of hindsight when at school !!
-
He was checking if the children were asleep. If only he and everyone else had paid more attention when they studied the exact science of hindsight when at school !!
One cannot blame people on holiday for being relaxed and carefree. Something which doesn't sit square though was GM's comment that he wasn't there to enjoy himself?
If that was the case what was he there for?
-
He was checking if the children were asleep. If only he and everyone else had paid more attention when they studied the exact science of hindsight when at school !!
Was he wearing Joe 90 glasses and had a bionic ear?
-
Was he wearing Joe 90 glasses and had a bionic ear?
Your point is?
Please pop off and find someone else to tease ... I find your continual rejoinders incredibly boring and tiresome.
Thank you
-
Sounds like the premise of a horror movie. See, if it was me, I'd presume the catch had got loose and given way and think nothing more of it. But then I live in a detached house and there is no way into the roof except through the house and so any intruder would have had to get past me first. In Gerry's situation I'd have put the moving door down to air movement when I entered the apartment and given it no more thought unless of course one of my kids suddenly disappeared thereafter, and then I'd be wracking my brains searching for any evidence whatsoever that might suggest someone had come into the apartment and taken her and then I might remember the door.
There' more! I was in my early 20's at the time, there was no catch and what I knew about attics was nil. It was a semi-detached army house. Next door was an Irish family. He disappeared a few weeks earlier and the MP's kept driving past in case he returned coz he was AWOL. He was a violent man, we used to hear him. Earlier in the evening his wife came to my door asking to buy cigarettes. She told me he was in her house and he wouldn't let her go to the shop in case she told on him. As I knew nothing about attics I wondered if it was possible for him to cross from his to ours, and it was his escape route. It was 1968 and Ireland was just kicking off. He'd gone off to join the IRA according to his wife. The following year my husband was on standby to go at an hour's notice with the first troops. He wasn't called, which was lucky and he never did go.
As the wind was blowing from the north west it was unlikely to have moved the door as the patio door was on the south side of the building. The wind would have blown in Gerry's face as he walked up the road from the Tapas. The only reason he offered was that Madeleine may have gone into his bed, although he also insisted that she only ever did this late at night, not early evening.
-
There' more! I was in my early 20's at the time, there was no catch and what I knew about attics was nil. It was a semi-detached army house. Next door was an Irish family. He disappeared a few weeks earlier and the MP's kept driving past in case he returned coz he was AWOL. He was a violent man, we used to hear him. Earlier in the evening his wife came to my door asking to buy cigarettes. She told me he was in her house and he wouldn't let her go to the shop in case she told on him. As I knew nothing about attics I wondered if it was possible for him to cross from his to ours, and it was his escape route. It was 1968 and Ireland was just kicking off. He'd gone off to join the IRA according to his wife. The following year my husband was on standby to go at an hour's notice with the first troops. He wasn't called, which was lucky and he never did go.
As the wind was blowing from the north west it was unlikely to have moved the door as the patio door was on the south side of the building. The wind would have blown in Gerry's face as he walked up the road from the Tapas. The only reason he offered was that Madeleine may have gone into his bed, although he also insisted that she only ever did this late at night, not early evening.
The additional information you have given makes your fears / suspicions more understandable. In PdL there would not have been any of that such as worries about violent neighbours etc. Still doesn't excuse the not locking the doors IMO but still not enough grounds for being fearful or suspicious about a door that had moved slightly - yes, a child could have moved it, as could air movement, explanations which most people IMO would arrive at before lurking abductor.
-
The additional information you have given makes your fears / suspicions more understandable. In PdL there would not have been any of that such as worries about violent neighbours etc. Still doesn't excuse the not locking the doors IMO but still not enough grounds for being fearful or suspicious about a door that had moved slightly - yes, a child could have moved it, as could air movement, explanations which most people IMO would arrive at before lurking abductor.
Where would the air movement have come from? I find that suggestion hard to comprehend.
-
He was checking if the children were asleep. If only he and everyone else had paid more attention when they studied the exact science of hindsight when at school !!
There was only one (Grace), so if you hear the child breathing they are all there, not quite as easy when there are three of them (Madeleine, Sean and Amelie who was breathing?).
-
Where would the air movement have come from? I find that suggestion hard to comprehend.
The usual means I expect, ie changes in pressure or temperature.
-
The usual means I expect, ie changes in pressure or temperature.
But what windows were open to allow for that. Unless you are implying it happens when they open the sliding door?
-
The usual means I expect, ie changes in pressure or temperature.
The air movement issue is not as pedantic as it appears at first sight.
To cause door movement or whooshing curtains it requires not only an entry point but an exit point.
I cannot see within Kate's book or otherwise, what this exit might be.
Plus of course, we need gusty wind, and I'm not clear on that either.
-
Open your mind, mercury.
Robitty is exploring every angle ... and that is good practice ...the solution could be in the detail.
Open my mind to what exactly?
The possibility that the mccanns made their checks on their kids by raising the patio living room shutters? When not only is it stupid but no one has claimed this happened except for rachel LOL
-
Open my mind to what exactly?
The possibility that the mccanns made their checks on their kids by raising the patio living room shutters? When not only is it stupid but no one has claimed this happened except for rachel LOL
A lot of the case depends on the testimony of just one person in certain instances, so why should Rachel not be listened to? Matt says he didn't go across the threshold, yet I find that harder to understand. Be honest man, any person worth his salt would have peeped around the corner.
-
A lot of the case depends on the testimony of just one person in certain instances, so why should Rachel not be listened to? Matt says he didn't go across the threshold, yet I find that harder to understand. Be honest man, any person worth his salt would have peeped around the corner.
Ok, so why did he say he didn't do that? Did he not want to be the last known person to have seen her ?
-
A lot of the case depends on the testimony of just one person in certain instances, so why should Rachel not be listened to? Matt says he didn't go across the threshold, yet I find that harder to understand. Be honest man, any person worth his salt would have peeped around the corner.
Yea, why didnt he peek round the threshold but thats nothng to do with shutters
-
Yea, why didnt he peek round the threshold but thats nothng to do with shutters
Tricky - What options has he got left?
-
Tricky - What options has he got left?
Sorry, no comprende
-
Sorry, no comprende
I'm sure if he did peek and he didn't see her at all he would have raised the alarm. Agreed? If you agree that is what a decent friend would do we'll look at the options if he sees her there?
-
So you are introducing a scenario where matt couldnt find madeleine but told her parents all was well, dont buy it
-
I'm sure if he did peek and he didn't see her at all he would have raised the alarm. Agreed? If you agree that is what a decent friend would do we'll look at the options if he sees her there?
Well, if he did see her, but declined to admit it, for whatever reason, then it completely destroys the significance of the Tanner sighting, which was 15 minutes earlier.
-
Well, if he did see her, but declined to admit it, for whatever reason, then it completely destroys the significance of the Tanner sighting, which was 15 minutes earlier.
it might on the surface of it. But nothing is straightforward, but what you say is a vital consideration.
-
So you are introducing a scenario where matt couldnt find madeleine but told her parents all was well, dont buy it
I'd shoot Matt myself if he did that.
-
I'd shoot Matt myself if he did that.
Why suggest it in the first place?
-
But what windows were open to allow for that. Unless you are implying it happens when they open the sliding door?
I am not implying anything.
Air moves as the result of changes in temperature and pressure. It will always move from high pressure areas to low pressure areas. It can also move by being sucked in and blown out by a kin great blower.
If the reasons for air movement that have obtained since God was a lad don't fit your theory ............. &%+((£
-
I am not implying anything.
Air moves as the result of changes in temperature and pressure. It will always move from high pressure areas to low pressure areas. It can also move by being sucked in and blown out by a kin great blower.
If the reasons for air movement that have obtained since God was a lad don't fit your theory ............. &%+((£
Sorry what a strange and off track answer. We are discussing air movements within the apartment moving doors that are up to half open. It doesn't happen without the external doors and windows open everywhere.
-
Why suggest it in the first place?
I don't think I did. I said: "I'm sure if he did peek and he didn't see her at all he would have raised the alarm."
-
Sorry what a strange and off track answer. We are discussing air movements within the apartment moving doors that are up to half open. It doesn't happen without the external doors and windows open everywhere.
That statement is incorrect.
-
That statement is incorrect.
Of course you are going to get some air movement but nothing large enough to blow a door open.
-
@ Mercury - I said: "I'm sure if he did peek and he didn't see her at all he would have raised the alarm." You have not attempted a reply to this yet.
-
There is one window opening but two glass panels, one fixed and one sliding.
This was touched on yesterday, the reason the door slammed with Kate but not with Matt was because when Matt entered the apartment the bedroom window was not open. This supports the idea that Madeleine disappeared after Matt's 9.30 check.
I am not sure about that Angelo. Somewhere I read that it was a gusty night and that the winds were getting up, so conditions earlier on would have been different to the time that Kate looked into the apartment.
I am sorry, but I have no idea now where I read this.
-
I am not sure about that Angelo. Somewhere I read that it was a gusty night and that the winds were getting up, so conditions earlier on would have been different to the time that Kate looked into the apartment.
I am sorry, but I have no idea now where I read this.
I have experienced the slamming door effect Kate is talking about. It doesn't require a strong air flow. In fact when the door is open it won't slam shut but the air has to be able to go somewhere so not only would the window in the kid's bedroom be open but there would have to something else open as well. The air has to be able to go through the building. Was there any other window open? If not I'd say she did her check with the sliding door open too implying she was intending to go back to the Tapas Bar.
-
I have experienced the slamming door effect Kate is talking about. It doesn't require a strong air flow. In fact when the door is open it won't slam shut but the air has to be able to go somewhere so not only would the window in the kid's bedroom be open but there would have to something else open as well. The air has to be able to go through the building. Was there any other window open? If not I'd say she did her check with the sliding door open too implying she was intending to go back to the Tapas Bar.
Her book says she checked the patio door and it was closed.
-
Her book says she checked the patio door and it was closed.
She does too (page #93), but gets the physics a bit wrong. For she seems to suggest the breeze came in through the patio door. Whereas (if I understand the layout correctly the door closed toward her so the breeze was going in the window and out somewhere else and at quite a rate for the curtain flapped as well on reopening the door. If the patio door was closed as she says, it still has not explained how the air flowed through the building. Matt in one of his statements talks about the shutters of the main bedroom being raised but no one has ever mentioned that. Were the windows of both bedrooms opened?
At around 9.25pm, the interviewee went into his apartment and Madeleine's apartment to check on the children. He states that the door of the bedroom that was occupied by Madeleine and the twins, was open and that there was enough light in the bedroom for him to see the twins in their cots. That he couldn't see the bed occupied by Madeleine, but as it was all quiet, he deduced that she was sleeping. That the light was not from an artificial source inside the apartment, but perhaps something coming from outside through the bedroom window. That it seemed to him that the shutters of the Master' bedroom window were open without knowing if the window was also open.
In the rogatory statement he says 4078 'I am sorry, you already said how long you think you were in the apartment for, I have forgotten''
Reply 'It can't have been more than a couple of minutes, because, erm, I mean, there was no, you know, it was just sort of a check and then it was back really. I remember sort of being able to pivot here and be able to see this room door was open as well and those shutters weren't down, they were just curtains and that was fairly, fairly light as well. And I just sort of came back out really through the same way and shutting the patio doors'.
Nothing about the shutters in the 10th May statement.
It is odd that no one else mentions that the shutters to Gerry and Kates room were up.
There is nothing about checking the window in the main bedroom in the book. The other factor could be central airconditioning ducts may have allowed air to be drawn up and out.
-
Mercury
on September 23, 2016, 09:35:00 PM
Quite but i still dint get his odd statement and that of his wife
You don't understand it Mercury? Well we'd need to go through it and pull it apart then.
-
Are Matthew's and Rachel's statements that odd?
They could be a bit odd. What do you find odd about them?
-
Of course you are going to get some air movement but nothing large enough to blow a door open.
Would you care to back that up with some calculation ? .
I repeat : natural air flow is caused by changes in temperature and pressure. If you think it is caused by something else enlighten us do.
-
Would you care to back that up with some calculation ? .
I repeat : natural air flow is caused by changes in temperature and pressure. If you think it is caused by something else enlighten us do.
I would love to show you scientifically but we'd need to do the experiment in G5A and see if we can make the kid's bedroom door move. My previous role had a certain amount of emphasis on air movement around rooms so I'd say I know quite a bit about the subject in a practical sense.
Air flow could also be caused by fans. I don't know if the word natural is the right one for we are discussing the movement of air in a building (a man-made structure) so you have orientation, design, windows, doors, ventilation ducts and fans to consider as well as temperature and pressure.
-
I have experienced the slamming door effect Kate is talking about. It doesn't require a strong air flow. In fact when the door is open it won't slam shut but the air has to be able to go somewhere so not only would the window in the kid's bedroom be open but there would have to something else open as well. The air has to be able to go through the building. Was there any other window open? If not I'd say she did her check with the sliding door open too implying she was intending to go back to the Tapas Bar.
I wondered if
One of the windows in the sitting room was open?
Or just possibly the patio door to the parents bedroom was slightly open ?
Cos Kate believes that she checked the sitting room patio door and that was closed.
-
I would love to show you scientifically but we'd need to do the experiment in G5A and see if we can make the kid's bedroom door move. My previous role had a certain amount of emphasis on air movement around rooms so I'd say I know quite a bit about the subject in a practical sense.
Air flow could also be caused by fans. I don't know if the word natural is the right one for we are discussing the movement of air in a building (a man-made structure) so you have orientation, design, windows, doors, ventilation ducts and fans to consider as well as temperature and pressure.
Jolly good. You should find it easy then.
I used the term "natural" to differentiate from I.D.
-
Jolly good. You should find it easy then.
I used the term "natural" to differentiate from I.D.
What are you on about now "I.D."? Does that = man made design? There is no point in doing the experiment anywhere else is there?
-
What are you on about now "I.D."? Does that = man made design? There is no point in doing the experiment anywhere else is there?
You said you knew about air movement I.D is a common term in that field to indicate that which is not natural.
It would be easy to do a roughing in calculation without leaving one's armchair. Just to see if the proposition was a goer, like
-
You said you knew about air movement I.D is a common term in that field to indicate that which is not natural.
It would be easy to do a roughing in calculation without leaving one's armchair. Just to see if the proposition was a goer, like
Not for me it wouldn't. I wouldn't know where to start on a calculation like that.
@Alice - What do you think the I.D. stands for?
-
If Matthew Oldfield did peek around the corner and he didn't see Madeleine at all, would he have raised the alarm?
Why is no one offering an answer to this question? If Matthew Oldfield had peeked around the corner and he didn't see Madeleine at all, would he have raised the alarm?
-
Perhaps because there is no answer.
The question I would ask is why he did not look around the corner?
He had gone there with the specific intent on checking on the children so why didn't he eyeball them all?
-
Perhaps because there is no answer.
The question I would ask is why he did not look around the corner?
He had gone there with the specific intent on checking on the children so why didn't he eyeball them all?
Because he was listening out for any sounds that meant they were not asleep and not checking to see if all the children were still there? All being quiet he assumed they were all asleep and so all was well.
It's not uncommon for parents to listen from outside the bedroom door at times - without actually opening it IMO.
-
Because he was listening out for any sounds that meant they were not asleep and not checking to see if all the children were still there? All being quiet he assumed they were all asleep and so all was well.
It's not uncommon for parents to listen from outside the bedroom door at times - without actually opening it IMO.
He could hear the twins breathing, well what about Madeleine does she not breath?
-
Because he was listening out for any sounds that meant they were not asleep and not checking to see if all the children were still there? All being quiet he assumed they were all asleep and so all was well.
It's not uncommon for parents to listen from outside the bedroom door at times - without actually opening it IMO.
Totally agree, I wonder how many of the checks were listen only.
-
Totally agree, I wonder how many of the checks were listen only.
But doesn't he specifically say he could hear the twins breathing so you'd think you would hear the third person as well.
-
Totally agree, I wonder how many of the checks were listen only.
Clearly, Gerry wasn't happy about listening only.
Not only did he go to his apartment immediately after Matt had done is listening act at the window, but he actually set eyes on his children.
-
Clearly, Gerry wasn't happy about listening only.
Not only did he go to his apartment immediately after Matt had done is listening act at the window, but he actually set eyes on his children.
But doesn't even Amaral question whether this happened? Personally one can't tell, but if you are like him and start doubting Gerry's evidence, I'm just unsure, but I'd prefer to believe him.
I think he saw that she was OK and was really pleased about that at the 9:00 PM check.
-
But doesn't even Amaral question whether this happened? Personally one can't tell, but if you are like him and start doubting Gerry's evidence, I'm just unsure, but I'd prefer to believe him.
I think he saw that she was OK and was really pleased about that at the 9:00 PM check.
I'm not sure I believe all the guff about him looking down and thinking what a lucky chap he was, but I've no doubt he looked in on them, otherwise why bother going at all?
-
I'm not sure I believe all the guff about him looking down and thinking what a lucky chap he was, but I've no doubt he looked in on them, otherwise why bother going at all?
Maybe it was just a guilt feeling because he never looked in on them all week (his words) but on that night felt he had to cos the door was more open, you know, just to check theyre ok, cos the door being not more open would have proved they were
Duh
-
Maybe it was just a guilt feeling because he never looked in on them all week (his words) but on that night felt he had to cos the door was more open, you know, just to check theyre ok, cos the door being not more open would have proved they were
Duh
"his words"? Where can we see or hear this?
-
"his words"? Where can we see or hear this?
He told the world in his documentary called madeleine was here, have you not come across it at all?
Its free to google and its on here in the video section too, from memory part 4 but not certain, enjoy
Here your donkey work done
Listen from 4.30
https://youtu.be/na4aBr5PTYY
-
Maybe it was just a guilt feeling because he never looked in on them all week (his words) but on that night felt he had to cos the door was more open, you know, just to check theyre ok, cos the door being not more open would have proved they were
Duh
Unless it was a very alert abductor and he/she returned the door to the exact same spot as they left. But you are right all the other checks done by Gerry were listening checks at the door. I had heard that before. So as you say this 9:00 check Gerry did more than usual. What was the driver behind this check even after Matt had reported the results of his check earlier on the three ground floor apartments?
-
Unless it was a very alert abductor and he/she returned the door to the exact same spot as they left. But you are right all the other checks done by Gerry were listening checks at the door. I had heard that before. So as you say this 9:00 check Gerry did more than usual. What was the driver behind this check even after Matt had reported the results of his check earlier on the three ground floor apartments?
Gerry says the driver was the door being more open!!
-
Gerry says the driver was the door being more open!!
But why didn't he just accept that the Paynes had just came from there and Matt had done a listening check and that should have been enough parental checking at the 9:00 oclock mark.
-
But why didn't he just accept that the Paynes had just came from there and Matt had done a listening check and that should have been enough parental checking at the 9:00 oclock mark.
Errrrr cos it was an outside check not an indoor one duh
-
Errrrr cos it was an outside check not an indoor one duh
And someone had already entered his apartment despite the Paynes and Matt being around the apartments and while it was still light enough to see. I always find that strange that someone would enter at such a busy time and still light enough to be seen.
-
The kids bedroom had 2 single beds in it and two cots. I can't convince myself that Matt knew which bed Madeleine was asleep in, the one behind the cots or the one just around the corner.
At around 9.25pm, the interviewee went into his apartment and Madeleine's apartment to check on the children. He states that the door of the bedroom that was occupied by Madeleine and the twins, was open and that there was enough light in the bedroom for him to see the twins in their cots. That he couldn't see the bed occupied by Madeleine, but as it was all quiet, he deduced that she was sleeping.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD.htm
-
Does Matt mean windows or shutters, for the only way to tell if the windows were shut or locked would be to test them physically, or if the shutters were down to lift the shutters and test the security of the window. Lifting the shutters makes quite a racket so I can't imagine that being done. So what does Matt mean when he states"
That around 9.05pm, the interviewee went to the area of the apartments. Notably to the area near the windows of all the children's bedrooms. That he did not hear any noise. That he considered that all the children were sleeping. That all the children's bedroom windows were closed, notably the windows that gave access to the bedroom occupied by Madeleine."
How did he know they were closed if the shutters were down?
-
What exactly is he talking about? He says 'all the children's windows' - is he saying he was checking all the children of the group? The McCann children were all in one room with one window.
I take your point about not being able to know if the window was open or closed if the shutters were down.
-
How would Matt justify this statement?
The question asked, he was sure that, at the time of his first being in the vicinity of MBM's bedroom, reported as 21h05 in the course of which he had approached the the window of that bedroom from the outside for the purpose of an auditory check, the blinds were, in his view, fully closed.
If the shutters were down and the windows closed how did he know from the outside that the blinds were closed? That seems to be a little too far!
-
What exactly is he talking about? He says 'all the children's windows' - is he saying he was checking all the children of the group? The McCann children were all in one room with one window.
I take your point about not being about know if the window was open or closed if the shutters were down.
At his 9:00 PM check he did a outside listening check on three apartments.
I have a feeling Matt was concerned about something, so when some of the group were late he went back and checked up on them, but how far did his check go, how thorough was it? When I worked as a security guard we were taught how to check the security of a building, I can't even be sure that the McCann's front door was locked at all. No one checked it as they left by the patio door. No one like Matt who is supposedly around on that carpark side of the building says he checked the front door for security yet he says the blinds and the windows were closed.
I have a horrible feeling the McCann's front door wasn't locked.
-
How would Matt justify this statement?If the shutters were down and the windows closed how did he know from the outside that the blinds were closed? That seems to be a little too far!
By blinds, is he meaning curtains ?
-
By blinds, is he meaning curtains ?
I thought so, but now I'm changing my mind, maybe he is talking about the shutters! He started off calling the external blinds but later just blinds. He is comparing what he saw from the outside check to what he sees from the inside. That is really difficult assessment for anyone to make on the first visit to a room. Matt is making this visit to a room he hasn't been in before, how would he know what to expect, so he is comparing it to his own bedroom.
The question asked, he was sure that, at the time of his first being in the vicinity of MBM's bedroom, reported as 21h05 in the course of which he had approached the the window of that bedroom from the outside for the purpose of an auditory check, the blinds were, in his view, fully closed.
Consequently, he is convinced that at the time of the second check the blinds were more open than on the first check, given that he considers that the light inside the bedroom, undoubtedly coming from the outside, could not have been coming through it [the blinds] if they had been fully closed.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
Does that mean the external blinds were up then? Proves he didn't do a exterior check on the second visit. Otherwise he would know rather than guessing.
-
At his 9:00 PM check he did a outside listening check on three apartments.
I have a feeling Matt was concerned about something, so when some of the group were late he went back and checked up on them, but how far did his check go, how thorough was it? When I worked as a security guard we were taught how to check the security of a building, I can't even be sure that the McCann's front door was locked at all. No one checked it as they left by the patio door. No one like Matt who is supposedly around on that carpark side of the building says he checked the front door for security yet he says the blinds and the windows were closed.
I have a horrible feeling the McCann's front door wasn't locked.
It really would show a casual attitude towards security if that was the case.
However, I think photos show that there is no external door handle and that a key would be needed to open the latch from the outside. This would mean the door was 'locked', though maybe not deadlocked from the inside.
-
It really would show a casual attitude towards security if that was the case.
However, I think photos show that there is no external door handle and that a key would be needed to open the latch from the outside. This would mean the door was 'locked', though maybe not deadlocked from the inside.
Absolutely correct. The door could only be opened from outside with a key. According to previous occupants, even if it was deadlocked it could still be opened from outside.
**snip
We noticed that the cleaning personnel entered the apartment after one knock and did not give us time to respond. This was a bit bothersome and for this reason we would lock the door, and would leave the key in the inside lock.
After this precaution, the next day, the same thing happened and the cleaning woman entered even though the door was locked with the key in the lock.
We never found out how it was possible for a cleaning woman to enter after we had tried to prevent it.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CARLO-D_AMBROSIO.htm
-
OK so the door is closed it appears locked since there is no exterior door handle. Amaral showed that it wasn't possible to open the door using a card but from experience you can still do this with a point. But if you have a key you can get in no problem.
-
When I posted "I have a feeling Matt was concerned about something, so when some of the group were late he went back and checked up on them, but how far did his check go, how thorough was it?" Did you know I think there is reference to what he was concerned about, but they inserted a different word in to disguise it. Matt you beauty!
Look at Matt's statements and the reasons he goes to do the 9:00 PM check. [I'm going back to bed]
-
OK so the door is closed it appears locked since there is no exterior door handle. Amaral showed that it wasn't possible to open the door using a card but from experience you can still do this with a point. But if you have a key you can get in no problem.
There's a long thread somewhere on here on the card / door demonstration as shown in Amaral's "documentary", showing a PJ chap attempting to shove in an entire card for the camera and declaring that it wouldn't work, due to a screw in the way. I've no idea what screw that could have been unless there was an anomaly in the door. On the other hand, a card may not have been able to get across a bend.
If anyone is pals with a burglar, perhaps they could consult with them?
-
There's a long thread somewhere on here on the card / door demonstration as shown in Amaral's "documentary", showing a PJ chap attempting to shove in an entire card for the camera and declaring that it wouldn't work, due to a screw in the way. I've no idea what screw that could have been unless there was an anomaly in the door. On the other hand, a card may not have been able to get across a bend.
If anyone is pals with a burglar, perhaps they could consult with them?
No one here would be pals with a burglar, Carana.
We are all sweet clean-living, law-abiding folk.
Didn't you know?
-
There's a long thread somewhere on here on the card / door demonstration as shown in Amaral's "documentary", showing a PJ chap attempting to shove in an entire card for the camera and declaring that it wouldn't work, due to a screw in the way. I've no idea what screw that could have been unless there was an anomaly in the door. On the other hand, a card may not have been able to get across a bend.
If anyone is pals with a burglar, perhaps they could consult with them?
That screw would have been an add-on to prevent a card being slid in the gap to activate the bolt.
-
When I posted "I have a feeling Matt was concerned about something, so when some of the group were late he went back and checked up on them, but how far did his check go, how thorough was it?" Did you know I think there is reference to what he was concerned about, but they inserted a different word in to disguise it. Matt you beauty!
Look at Matt's statements and the reasons he goes to do the 9:00 PM check. [I'm going back to bed]
The following was the nearest to a criticism of some members within the group.
Matt's rogatory statement:
4078 "You've gone through when you saw them on the third of May and your arrival at the Tapas bar, who was already there' You already said it was Kate and Gerry and you think they may have been talking to somebody else but you can't clearly remember who.'
Reply "No.'
4078 "And then you just sat down, as far as you recall you sat down as normal.'
Reply "Yeah.'
4078 "And then everyone else duly arrived.'
Reply "Yeah, there was derogatory things about time keeping for Dave and Fiona.'
Derogatory things said amongst the group about Dave and Fiona? Those comments seems to initiate Matt's need to check the three lower apartments and possibly Gerry's internal check of his apartment so soon after arriving. But the strange thing is that even in that short period of time the door within the McCann's apartment had been moved.