UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 10:09:26 PM
-
The McCanns wanted test to be run to show whether sedatives had been used on the kids, so even when they asked for tests it didn't get acted on.
25
-
The McCanns wanted test to be run to show whether sedatives had been used on the kids, so even they asked for tests it didn't get acted on.
They could gave taken them for testing Rob.
After all, they should have some experience of forensic science and techniques used in analysis.
-
The McCanns wanted test to be run to show whether sedatives had been used on the kids, so even when they asked for tests it didn't get acted on.
It might have helped if they had told the PJ, don't you think? I have seen no evidence that they did so.
-
It might have helped if they had told the PJ, don't you think? I have seen no evidence that they did so.
The CSI sniffed Madeleine's pillow for the scent of chloroform. The twins had seemed unusually sleepy. Did not one officer think to sniff the twins bedding or clothing?
-
In my opinion the time of most concern that the children might have been drugged was in the immediate aftermath of Madeleine's disappearance when despite the resultant disruption the twins slept soundly through it all.
They were fine ... so it was probably decided there was no threat to their health and just to keep an eye on them.
If you recall, a myriad of disinformation and false allegations had been printed in the Portuguese press and picked up worldwide; one of the many lies put into the public domain was that the McCanns had drugged their children.
This is borne out by reports such as the following ...
Syringe found in Madeleine's room, newspaper says
August 30, 2007 • 10:51 AM • Updated at 11:07 AM
Portuguese police investigating the disappearance of British girl Madeleine McCann found a syringe in the hotel room where her family was staying in Praia da Luz, Portugal, according to the Portuguese newspaper Correio da Manhã .
Detectives would have found the syringe in a closet in the bedroom, where Madeleine was last seen on May 3.
According to the newspaper, the police are examining whether the syringe and the needle were used by the McCanns to administer sedatives at the very least to make her sleep so they could go out to eat with friends at a nearby restaurant.
Portuguese media have reported that police sources suspect the McCanns accidentally murdered their daughter because of overdose of painkillers.
The McCanns vehemently denied the allegations, according to the Daily Mail . The family spokeswoman said the couple never gave their children any sedatives.
Today marks 119 days since Madeleine disappeared and would be the day the girl would return to Catholic primary school in Thurmaston, Leicester.
http://noticias.terra.com.br/mundo/noticias/0,,OI1868666-EI8142,00-Seringa+foi+achada+em+quarto+de+Madeleine+diz+jornal.html
The only way to refute the false allegations circulating worldwide was to disprove them scientifically ... and this is what the parents of a missing child were forced to do:
Quote
Edward Smethurst, the lawyer coordinating the McCanns' defence, said: "Hair grows by about a centimetre a month so if you have eight centimetres of hair, you can test for drugs going back eight months.
"With the appropriate, fully-accredited experts, hair samples were taken from Sean, Amelie and Kate and the conclusion was no evidence of sedatives or drugs were found.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1570315/Madeleine-McCanns-mother-takes-drug-test.html
The Policia Judiciaria obviously must have decided not to check the twins and rule out the chance that Madeleine might have been drugged to facilitate a kidnapping ... I say obviously ... or they would have done so.
How sad is it that her mother felt it necessary at a later date to have to take steps to silence the lies; at this point I would have added 'once and for all' but that didn't happen in some quarters, did it?
-
OK can someone clearly tell me whether a "Syringe was found in Madeleine's room" or not?
-
The CSI sniffed Madeleine's pillow for the scent of chloroform. The twins had seemed unusually sleepy. Did not one officer think to sniff the twins bedding or clothing?
You know the twins were unusually, but AFAIK the police didn't so the forensic people didn't.
-
OK can someone clearly tell me whether a "Syringe was found in Madeleine's room" or not?
No.
-
In my opinion the time of most concern that the children might have been drugged was in the immediate aftermath of Madeleine's disappearance when despite the resultant disruption the twins slept soundly through it all.
They were fine ... so it was probably decided there was no threat to their health and just to keep an eye on them.
If you recall, a myriad of disinformation and false allegations had been printed in the Portuguese press and picked up worldwide; one of the many lies put into the public domain was that the McCanns had drugged their children.
According to the PJ Kate only mentioned the possibility that the children had been drugged three months after the disappearance. In her book she claims to have told the GNR on 3rd May but they do not confirm that and neither does the translator.
I can find no evidence that anyone was told about Kate's 'sedation theory' before then. She could have told the PJ on 3rd/4th. She could have told them when being interviewed. She could have told Control Risks on 11th May.
-
According to the PJ Kate only mentioned the possibility that the children had been drugged three months after the disappearance. In her book she claims to have told the GNR on 3rd May but they do not confirm that and neither does the translator.
I can find no evidence that anyone was told about Kate's 'sedation theory' before then. She could have told the PJ on 3rd/4th. She could have told them when being interviewed. She could have told Control Risks on 11th May.
It would appear some myths have been propagated.
-
In my opinion the time of most concern that the children might have been drugged was in the immediate aftermath of Madeleine's disappearance when despite the resultant disruption the twins slept soundly through it all.
They were fine ... so it was probably decided there was no threat to their health and just to keep an eye on them.
If you recall, a myriad of disinformation and false allegations had been printed in the Portuguese press and picked up worldwide; one of the many lies put into the public domain was that the McCanns had drugged their children.
This is borne out by reports such as the following ...
Syringe found in Madeleine's room, newspaper says
August 30, 2007 • 10:51 AM • Updated at 11:07 AM
Portuguese police investigating the disappearance of British girl Madeleine McCann found a syringe in the hotel room where her family was staying in Praia da Luz, Portugal, according to the Portuguese newspaper Correio da Manhã .
Detectives would have found the syringe in a closet in the bedroom, where Madeleine was last seen on May 3.
According to the newspaper, the police are examining whether the syringe and the needle were used by the McCanns to administer sedatives at the very least to make her sleep so they could go out to eat with friends at a nearby restaurant.
Portuguese media have reported that police sources suspect the McCanns accidentally murdered their daughter because of overdose of painkillers.
The McCanns vehemently denied the allegations, according to the Daily Mail . The family spokeswoman said the couple never gave their children any sedatives.
Today marks 119 days since Madeleine disappeared and would be the day the girl would return to Catholic primary school in Thurmaston, Leicester.
http://noticias.terra.com.br/mundo/noticias/0,,OI1868666-EI8142,00-Seringa+foi+achada+em+quarto+de+Madeleine+diz+jornal.html
The only way to refute the false allegations circulating worldwide was to disprove them scientifically ... and this is what the parents of a missing child were forced to do:
Quote
Edward Smethurst, the lawyer coordinating the McCanns' defence, said: "Hair grows by about a centimetre a month so if you have eight centimetres of hair, you can test for drugs going back eight months.
"With the appropriate, fully-accredited experts, hair samples were taken from Sean, Amelie and Kate and the conclusion was no evidence of sedatives or drugs were found.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1570315/Madeleine-McCanns-mother-takes-drug-test.html
The Policia Judiciaria obviously must have decided not to check the twins and rule out the chance that Madeleine might have been drugged to facilitate a kidnapping ... I say obviously ... or they would have done so.
How sad is it that her mother felt it necessary at a later date to have to take steps to silence the lies; at this point I would have added 'once and for all' but that didn't happen in some quarters, did it?
Who were these fully acredited experts Brietta ?
Have you done any research as to how drug tests can be overridden ?
For example try typing 'can hair treatments remove drugs'.
https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=can+hair+treatments+remove+drugs&oq=can+hair&aqs=chrome.1.69i57j35i39l2j0l3.10378j0j8&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
-
According to the PJ Kate only mentioned the possibility that the children had been drugged three months after the disappearance. In her book she claims to have told the GNR on 3rd May but they do not confirm that and neither does the translator.
I can find no evidence that anyone was told about Kate's 'sedation theory' before then. She could have told the PJ on 3rd/4th. She could have told them when being interviewed. She could have told Control Risks on 11th May.
According to a FLO - one of the questions they were asked to put to the PJ by Kate and Gerry was in relation to sedation.
Quote from Jim McGarvey
Gerry and Kate also questioned whether there was any suggestion that pointed to the use of drugs to facilitate Madeleine's abduction.
End quote
That was on 5th May.
It couldn't be more clear imo.
-
According to the PJ Kate only mentioned the possibility that the children had been drugged three months after the disappearance. In her book she claims to have told the GNR on 3rd May but they do not confirm that and neither does the translator.
I can find no evidence that anyone was told about Kate's 'sedation theory' before then. She could have told the PJ on 3rd/4th. She could have told them when being interviewed. She could have told Control Risks on 11th May.
If that is true then the FLO did not pass on Kate's concern to the PJ.
-
According to a FLO - one of the questions they were asked to put to the PJ by Kate and Gerry was in relation to sedation.
Quote from Jim McGarvey
Gerry and Kate also questioned whether there was any suggestion that pointed to the use of drugs to facilitate Madeleine's abduction.
End quote
That was on 5th May.
It couldn't be more clear imo.
Ah yes, the questions asked of the liaison officers after they had been altered by Stuart Prior. His colleague is a little more precise;
They also wanted to know whether the PJ had any evidence that would suggest that the person who took Madeleine had used any substance to facilitate the abduction.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN_MARKLEY.htm
No mention of any worries about the twins, no request for them to be tested, just trying to find out if any evidence
of sedation had been found. Were the questions put to the PJ? We don't know what the liaison officers did.
I see that on 5th it was still the twins who had cried on Wednesday night; Madeleine had not yet been added in;
Madeleine's revelation about Wednesday night, when she said that she was left alone during the night. She told Kate and Gerry that she remembered the twins crying and that she wanted to know why neither her mother nor her father had gone to the room to see what was happening.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN_MARKLEY.htm
-
Ah yes, the questions asked of the liaison officers after they had been altered by Stuart Prior. His colleague is a little more precise;
They also wanted to know whether the PJ had any evidence that would suggest that the person who took Madeleine had used any substance to facilitate the abduction.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN_MARKLEY.htm
No mention of any worries about the twins, no request for them to be tested, just trying to find out if any evidence
of sedation had been found. Were the questions put to the PJ? We don't know what the liaison officers did.
I see that on 5th it was still the twins who had cried on Wednesday night; Madeleine had not yet been added in;
Madeleine's revelation about Wednesday night, when she said that she was left alone during the night. She told Kate and Gerry that she remembered the twins crying and that she wanted to know why neither her mother nor her father had gone to the room to see what was happening.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN_MARKLEY.htm
If they were asked ".... whether the PJ had any evidence that would suggest that the person who took Madeleine had used any substance to facilitate the abduction" they could not have found the syringe then.
Several pages mention the syringe and found in different places but I'd also like to know when it was found (Imagine the importance of figure prints found on a syringe!)
-
If they were asked ".... whether the PJ had any evidence that would suggest that the person who took Madeleine had used any substance to facilitate the abduction" they could not have found the syringe then.
Several pages mention the syringe and found in different places but I'd also like to know when it was found (Imagine the importance of figure prints found on a syringe!)
Quite true, but it is all academic now.
Also , why would an 'abductor' leave evidence behind ?
-
Ah yes, the questions asked of the liaison officers after they had been altered by Stuart Prior. His colleague is a little more precise;
They also wanted to know whether the PJ had any evidence that would suggest that the person who took Madeleine had used any substance to facilitate the abduction.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN_MARKLEY.htm
No mention of any worries about the twins, no request for them to be tested, just trying to find out if any evidence
of sedation had been found. Were the questions put to the PJ? We don't know what the liaison officers did.
I see that on 5th it was still the twins who had cried on Wednesday night; Madeleine had not yet been added in;
Madeleine's revelation about Wednesday night, when she said that she was left alone during the night. She told Kate and Gerry that she remembered the twins crying and that she wanted to know why neither her mother nor her father had gone to the room to see what was happening.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN_MARKLEY.htm
We can have no idea of the full extent of any conversations between the FLOs and the McCanns and so your claims are speculation imo. We would need verbatim statements not brief summaries in order to do that.
-
Syringe that 'knocked out' Maddie found
Daily Star
by Jerry Lawton
30 August 2007
Family fury at new claims
POLICE found a syringe in the holiday apartment where Madeleine McCann vanished, it was claimed last night.
Detectives are probing whether it was used to administer sedatives to the four-year-old and her twin siblings Sean and Amelie, according to a Portuguese newspaper.
Last night Madeleine's heart surgeon dad Gerry and GP mum Kate, both 39, were unavailable for comment on the alleged discovery.
But their spokesman Justine McGuinness said: "This is yet another piece of ridiculous speculation without any base in fact.
"Kate and Gerry are responsible and loving parents.
"They have said in the past they have never used sedatives on their children." Police declined to comment on the paper's claims.
Though they have stated the McCanns are not suspects, detectives are baffled that their twins never stirred the night Madeleine vanished from the apartment in the Algarve resort of Praia da Luz.
They had hoped the two-year-olds, who were asleep in cots either side of their sister's bed, could be key witnesses.
But the pair were carried still sleeping from the apartment by police officers." http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic14571.html
Since the article is around 30th August just days before they were made arguidos one would think this could be another ruse to put pressure on the McCanns to confess.
Quite true, but it is all academic now.
Also , why would an 'abductor' leave evidence behind ?
Was it found on the 3rd or 4th? When was it found and whose finger prints were on it and what was in it?
-
This might be nearer the truth "Thursday, 30 August 2007
CID does not confirm reports about a syringe found in McCann’s room
The spokesman of the Polícia Judiciária (Criminal Investigation Department), Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa, contacted by S.O.S Madeleine, said that Police does not confirm news published by Portuguese newspaper Correio da Manhã, referring that a syringe and tranquillizers were found in the room of McCann family, after the disappearance of Madeleine."
Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa was he the one who resigned from the PJ in disgust.
"Olegário de Sousa: “Mr Martin Brunt story about my alleged resignation is completely false”
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa is said to have quit in disgust at the way the missing girl's parents have been treated, according to Martin Brunt, from Sky News. Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa denies those allegations: “Mr. Martin Brunt's story, once again, is completely false. The last time I talked with Mr. Martin Brunt was on September 11, the day when Mr. Martin Brunt had another utterly false story, about a 100% DNA match being found, by Police, on the McCann's hired car. On that day, before he put that false story on the air, we talked, around 7.00 pm, and he didn't asked me any question about DNA, that subject wasn't even mentioned,” Olegário de Sousa told us, a few minutes ago. (14h54, September 17, 2007) " http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.nz/2007/09/olegrio-de-sousa-mr-martin-brunt-story.html
But the well researched book by Summers and Swan repeat a claim of a reason similar to disgust.
-
We can have no idea of the full extent of any conversations between the FLOs and the McCanns and so your claims are speculation imo. We would need verbatim statements not brief summaries in order to do that.
What did your quote make clear then? Nothing is the answer.
-
This might be nearer the truth "Thursday, 30 August 2007
CID does not confirm reports about a syringe found in McCann’s room
The spokesman of the Polícia Judiciária (Criminal Investigation Department), Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa, contacted by S.O.S Madeleine, said that Police does not confirm news published by Portuguese newspaper Correio da Manhã, referring that a syringe and tranquillizers were found in the room of McCann family, after the disappearance of Madeleine."
Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa was he the one who resigned from the PJ in disgust.
"Olegário de Sousa: “Mr Martin Brunt story about my alleged resignation is completely false”
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa is said to have quit in disgust at the way the missing girl's parents have been treated, according to Martin Brunt, from Sky News. Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa denies those allegations: “Mr. Martin Brunt's story, once again, is completely false. The last time I talked with Mr. Martin Brunt was on September 11, the day when Mr. Martin Brunt had another utterly false story, about a 100% DNA match being found, by Police, on the McCann's hired car. On that day, before he put that false story on the air, we talked, around 7.00 pm, and he didn't asked me any question about DNA, that subject wasn't even mentioned,” Olegário de Sousa told us, a few minutes ago. (14h54, September 17, 2007) " http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.nz/2007/09/olegrio-de-sousa-mr-martin-brunt-story.html
But the well researched book by Summers and Swan repeat a claim of a reason similar to disgust.
Had a syringe been found surely it would have been photographed and tested and that information would have appeared in the PJ files. Is this story yet another media invention aimed solely at selling stories to the MSM?
-
This might be nearer the truth "Thursday, 30 August 2007
CID does not confirm reports about a syringe found in McCann’s room
The spokesman of the Polícia Judiciária (Criminal Investigation Department), Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa, contacted by S.O.S Madeleine, said that Police does not confirm news published by Portuguese newspaper Correio da Manhã, referring that a syringe and tranquillizers were found in the room of McCann family, after the disappearance of Madeleine."
Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa was he the one who resigned from the PJ in disgust.
"Olegário de Sousa: “Mr Martin Brunt story about my alleged resignation is completely false”
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa is said to have quit in disgust at the way the missing girl's parents have been treated, according to Martin Brunt, from Sky News. Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa denies those allegations: “Mr. Martin Brunt's story, once again, is completely false. The last time I talked with Mr. Martin Brunt was on September 11, the day when Mr. Martin Brunt had another utterly false story, about a 100% DNA match being found, by Police, on the McCann's hired car. On that day, before he put that false story on the air, we talked, around 7.00 pm, and he didn't asked me any question about DNA, that subject wasn't even mentioned,” Olegário de Sousa told us, a few minutes ago. (14h54, September 17, 2007) " http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.nz/2007/09/olegrio-de-sousa-mr-martin-brunt-story.html
But the well researched book by Summers and Swan repeat a claim of a reason similar to disgust.
The media made many wild and inaccurate claims. Unless there is evidence to support them what do you hope to gain by repeating them here?
-
This might be nearer the truth "Thursday, 30 August 2007
CID does not confirm reports about a syringe found in McCann’s room
The spokesman of the Polícia Judiciária (Criminal Investigation Department), Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa, contacted by S.O.S Madeleine, said that Police does not confirm news published by Portuguese newspaper Correio da Manhã, referring that a syringe and tranquillizers were found in the room of McCann family, after the disappearance of Madeleine."
Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa was he the one who resigned from the PJ in disgust.
"Olegário de Sousa: “Mr Martin Brunt story about my alleged resignation is completely false”
Chief Inspector Olegario Sousa is said to have quit in disgust at the way the missing girl's parents have been treated, according to Martin Brunt, from Sky News. Chief-Inspector Olegário de Sousa denies those allegations: “Mr. Martin Brunt's story, once again, is completely false. The last time I talked with Mr. Martin Brunt was on September 11, the day when Mr. Martin Brunt had another utterly false story, about a 100% DNA match being found, by Police, on the McCann's hired car. On that day, before he put that false story on the air, we talked, around 7.00 pm, and he didn't asked me any question about DNA, that subject wasn't even mentioned,” Olegário de Sousa told us, a few minutes ago. (14h54, September 17, 2007) " http://gazetadigitalmadeleinecase.blogspot.co.nz/2007/09/olegrio-de-sousa-mr-martin-brunt-story.html
But the well researched book by Summers and Swan repeat a claim of a reason similar to disgust.
They rehashed existing material and added nothing new.
The opening chapter of their book says everything about it.
-
I would have thought that had a syringe been left in the bedroom that Kate and Gerry or one of the others would have found it long before the cops arrived.
-
What did your quote make clear then? Nothing is the answer.
It made it clear that the McCanns had asked the FLOs to bring up the subject of sedation with the PJ on 5th May.
The FLO also said the following:
Quote
]In relation to the above I would like to mention that at approximately 20.00 on the 5th May, I arrived at the McCann apartment with other family communications officers. We were asked several times during this meeting about questions that Gerald and Kate would like to have followed up and responded to by the PJ.
IMO It is clear from that that not everything they discussed has been recorded in that particular statement. However at that time the main purpose of interviewing FLO officers was to confirm whether or not they had observed any suspicious behaviour by the McCanns during the time they spent with them. They all said 'NO'. Other info was secondary imo and so no precise details were given. This doesn't mean precise details had not been given in previous reports to their superiors.
IMO
-
It made it clear that the McCanns had asked the FLOs to bring up the subject of sedation with the PJ on 5th May.
The FLO also said the following:
Quote
]In relation to the above I would like to mention that at approximately 20.00 on the 5th May, I arrived at the McCann apartment with other family communications officers. We were asked several times during this meeting about questions that Gerald and Kate would like to have followed up and responded to by the PJ.
IMO It is clear from that that not everything they discussed has been recorded in that particular statement. However at that time the main purpose of interviewing FLO officers was to confirm whether or not they had observed any suspicious behaviour by the McCanns during the time they spent with them. They all said 'NO'. Other info was secondary imo and so no precise details were given. This doesn't mean precise details had not been given in previous reports to their superiors.
IMO
The PJ sent a list of questions to be asked. Those questions weren't asked because Stuart Prior changed it to the one question they were actually asked.
The McCanns didn't tell the FLO's about any concerns about the twins or about getting them tested. The FLO's don't say they spoke to the PJ. The PJ don't say the FLO's asked any questions.
All else is speculation.
-
The media made many wild and inaccurate claims. Unless there is evidence to support them what do you hope to gain by repeating them here?
Clues. Looking for clues to support my theory.
-
I would have thought that had a syringe been left in the bedroom that Kate and Gerry or one of the others would have found it long before the cops arrived.
Yes if they had used it.
-
OK can someone clearly tell me whether a "Syringe was found in Madeleine's room" or not?
Just as the "six dead bodies" was an invention ... the existence of the "syringe" was yet another invention.
-
It made it clear that the McCanns had asked the FLOs to bring up the subject of sedation with the PJ on 5th May.
The FLO also said the following:
Quote
]In relation to the above I would like to mention that at approximately 20.00 on the 5th May, I arrived at the McCann apartment with other family communications officers. We were asked several times during this meeting about questions that Gerald and Kate would like to have followed up and responded to by the PJ.
IMO It is clear from that that not everything they discussed has been recorded in that particular statement. However at that time the main purpose of interviewing FLO officers was to confirm whether or not they had observed any suspicious behaviour by the McCanns during the time they spent with them. They all said 'NO'. Other info was secondary imo and so no precise details were given. This doesn't mean precise details had not been given in previous reports to their superiors.
IMO
The question arising from that suggests that this an indication that the police were not communicating directly with and keeping keeping Madeleine's family as informed as they were able about what was going on.
They were being kept in the dark?
Why else would the family ask the British liaison officers to get information for them?
-
The question arising from that suggests that this an indication that the police were not communicating directly with and keeping keeping Madeleine's family as informed as they were able about what was going on.
They were being kept in the dark?
Why else would the family ask the British liaison officers to get information for them?
Does any police force communicate? Do they tell people what they are doing? Not in my experience with the UK police. You can ask questions and you can pass information on via a liaison officer. He or she will not necessarily give you any feedback though. They tell you what they want to tell you and nothing else. No running commentaries are provided.
-
The question arising from that suggests that this an indication that the police were not communicating directly with and keeping keeping Madeleine's family as informed as they were able about what was going on.
They were being kept in the dark?
Why else would the family ask the British liaison officers to get information for them?
If I remember correctly Kate did write a letter asking to be kept up to date.
Sorry I cannot remember to whom she wrote the letter.
-
If I remember correctly Kate did write a letter asking to be kept up to date.
Sorry I cannot remember to whom she wrote the letter.
It isn't normal practice as far as I know for police to share details of an investigation with anyone.
-
It isn't normal practice as far as I know for police to share details of an investigation with anyone.
Perhaps not in other types of police work but hopefully in the case of a missing child the police would keep the parents informed of their progress.
Perhaps not the finer details.
-
http://library.college.police.uk/docs/acpo/FLO-guidance-2008.pdf
4.13 & 4.15 are informative.
-
The PJ sent a list of questions to be asked. Those questions weren't asked because Stuart Prior changed it to the one question they were actually asked.
The McCanns didn't tell the FLO's about any concerns about the twins or about getting them tested. The FLO's don't say they spoke to the PJ. The PJ don't say the FLO's asked any questions.
All else is speculation.
As the whole purpose of the FLOs was to liaise between the McCanns and the police as communications officers - I find it difficult to believe that they would deliberately ignore the McCanns specific requests to ask questions on their behalf.
Whether they got answers or not is another matter. IIRC they couldn't even get an interpreter on one of the days.
Quote from Kates book.
The local police, not used to disclosing the details of an investigation were clearly wary of answering all the questions they were being asked.
unquote
Pages 130 and 131 in the paperback edition give more details and explanations of the relationship between UK and Portuguese officers.
-
Perhaps not in other types of police work but hopefully in the case of a missing child the police would keep the parents informed of their progress.
Perhaps not the finer details.
Unless someone knows what normal practice is it's all guesswork, isn't it? The McCanns may have been asking for something which no police force would have been able or willing to give them.
UK Family liaison officers give out factual details such as;
An arrest being made
Dates of Court proceedings
Outcome of Court appearances
They also provide information about other organisations which can help, such as victim support.
-
Does any police force communicate? Do they tell people what they are doing? Not in my experience with the UK police. You can ask questions and you can pass information on via a liaison officer. He or she will not necessarily give you any feedback though. They tell you what they want to tell you and nothing else. No running commentaries are provided.
Did my post mention "running commentaries"? ... absolutely not.
Did my post suggest anything other than, "keeping Madeleine's family as informed as they were able about what was going on"?
Yes the police do tell people what they are doing:
Quote
The Wells and Chapman families refused to comment on the suggestion that they had been targets, but Mr Wells said his family was being kept informed by the police. end quote
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/8619373/News-of-the-World-bereaved-relatives-of-77-victims-had-phones-hacked.html
However if you think the parents of a missing child have less right to be supported and kept informed of whatever the police can inform them of regarding the progress of their child's case ... that is a matter for you.
Fortunately it is a matter which has been addressed by British police one example of which is ...
Police actions in relation to support for families
The trauma associated with a missing person investigation may place families under immense pressure and stress. Investigators are likely to require them to provide detailed information and there may also be public and media interest.
The information required by families and carers of those reported missing will depend on the circumstances of the case, however police officers or staff with responsibility for investigating a missing person report are able to support their needs by: - providing a single point of contact (that is realistic for them to make contact with) and provide regular updates
- informing them of support services– this information may be provided as a leaflet or similar that includes details of the role of the Missing People charity
- listening and responding to any concerns that they may have about the investigation (recognising the importance of the incident and investigation to them)
- managing their expectations by giving realistic updates on what is being done and how an investigation is being conducted, (including any limitations that may be placed on it)
- ensure that they are made aware of any media releases/press conferences (before they take place)
- maintaining contact in long-term cases and informing them of reviews
- providing a family liaison officer (in appropriate cases).
https://www.app.college.police.uk/app-content/major-investigation-and-public-protection/missing-persons/missing-person-investigations/
I doubt you would find preference in the Amaral team's way of conducting business as opposed to the way it is normally done everywhere else ... now including the Algarve ... were one of your family to go missing.
-
Syringe that 'knocked out' Maddie found
Daily Star
by Jerry Lawton
30 August 2007
Family fury at new claims
POLICE found a syringe in the holiday apartment where Madeleine McCann vanished, it was claimed last night.
Detectives are probing whether it was used to administer sedatives to the four-year-old and her twin siblings Sean and Amelie, according to a Portuguese newspaper.
Last night Madeleine's heart surgeon dad Gerry and GP mum Kate, both 39, were unavailable for comment on the alleged discovery.
But their spokesman Justine McGuinness said: "This is yet another piece of ridiculous speculation without any base in fact.
"Kate and Gerry are responsible and loving parents.
"They have said in the past they have never used sedatives on their children." Police declined to comment on the paper's claims.
Though they have stated the McCanns are not suspects, detectives are baffled that their twins never stirred the night Madeleine vanished from the apartment in the Algarve resort of Praia da Luz.
They had hoped the two-year-olds, who were asleep in cots either side of their sister's bed, could be key witnesses.
But the pair were carried still sleeping from the apartment by police officers." http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic14571.html
Since the article is around 30th August just days before they were made arguidos one would think this could be another ruse to put pressure on the McCanns to confess.
Was it found on the 3rd or 4th? When was it found and whose finger prints were on it and what was in it?
Methinks the PR person doth protest too much. She seems to assume some suggestion of guilt and defend accordingly.
-
Methinks the PR person doth protest too much. She seems to assume some suggestion of guilt and defend accordingly.
Ah the amazingly ubiquitous Ms McGuiness. Prospective parliametary/MEP candidate for almost anywhere.
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2007/sep/13/marketingandpr.crime
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2785272/Bercow-s-taxpayer-funded-spin-doctor-quits-making-speech-Lib-Dem-conference-attacking-Labour-Tories-UKIP.html
http://www.dorsethealthcare.nhs.uk/join-us/governors/members-council-governors/justine-mcguinness-public-governor-dorset-england-wales
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1562995/Madeleine-McCann-Tycoons-withdraw-support.html
https://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2009/03/madeleine-mccann-fund-pr-justine.html
-
Methinks the PR person doth protest too much. She seems to assume some suggestion of guilt and defend accordingly.
The line "Detectives are probing whether it was used to administer sedatives to the four-year-old and her twin siblings Sean and Amelie" is certainly a suggestion of guilt. I think she should have found the source of the rumour or the truth whatever it was.
-
The syringe found in the McCann's residence was bait, to promote a possible confession. So if you can agree to that how many of the dog alerts were also bait?
I have previously proven on this forum the alert (so called) on Cuddle cat was a badly executed ruse, and that was shown to Kate and Gerry at their arguido interview/interrogation.
The alerts on Kate's clothing are also suspicious in that the dog didn't alert to them in the villa but only later when they were laid out in the garage. There was every possibility they had been doped with cadaver odour by the PJ.
The only thing the PJ can't fake is the actual forensic evidence.
-
Did my post mention "running commentaries"? ... absolutely not.
Did my post suggest anything other than, "keeping Madeleine's family as informed as they were able about what was going on"?
Yes the police do tell people what they are doing:
Quote
The Wells and Chapman families refused to comment on the suggestion that they had been targets, but Mr Wells said his family was being kept informed by the police. end quote
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/8619373/News-of-the-World-bereaved-relatives-of-77-victims-had-phones-hacked.html
However if you think the parents of a missing child have less right to be supported and kept informed of whatever the police can inform them of regarding the progress of their child's case ... that is a matter for you.
Fortunately it is a matter which has been addressed by British police one example of which is ...
Police actions in relation to support for families
The trauma associated with a missing person investigation may place families under immense pressure and stress. Investigators are likely to require them to provide detailed information and there may also be public and media interest.
The information required by families and carers of those reported missing will depend on the circumstances of the case, however police officers or staff with responsibility for investigating a missing person report are able to support their needs by: - providing a single point of contact (that is realistic for them to make contact with) and provide regular updates
- informing them of support services– this information may be provided as a leaflet or similar that includes details of the role of the Missing People charity
- listening and responding to any concerns that they may have about the investigation (recognising the importance of the incident and investigation to them)
- managing their expectations by giving realistic updates on what is being done and how an investigation is being conducted, (including any limitations that may be placed on it)
- ensure that they are made aware of any media releases/press conferences (before they take place)
- maintaining contact in long-term cases and informing them of reviews
- providing a family liaison officer (in appropriate cases).
https://www.app.college.police.uk/app-content/major-investigation-and-public-protection/missing-persons/missing-person-investigations/
I doubt you would find preference in the Amaral team's way of conducting business as opposed to the way it is normally done everywhere else ... now including the Algarve ... were one of your family to go missing.
It all depends on what the McCanns wanted to know. It may well be that they would have been told no more by another police force than they were told by the PJ.
-
The line "Detectives are probing whether it was used to administer sedatives to the four-year-old and her twin siblings Sean and Amelie" is certainly a suggestion of guilt. I think she should have found the source of the rumour or the truth whatever it was.
So you automatically discount an alleged abductor sedating the kids?
-
So you automatically discount an alleged abductor sedating the kids?
In my theory no abductor entered the apartment. Come to think of it the room (Apartment 5A) was open on more nights other than just the Thursday. Therefore one could not tell on what day the syringe was dropped there. I'm starting to sound like Stephen sorry.
-
In my theory no abductor entered the apartment. Come to think of it the room (Apartment 5A) was open on more nights other than just the Thursday. Therefore one could not tell on what day the syringe was dropped there. I'm starting to sound like Stephen sorry.
I really have nothing on you Rob, and your theories. 8((()*/
-
It all depends on what the McCanns wanted to know. It may well be that they would have been told no more by another police force than they were told by the PJ.
Madeleine McCann was missing without trace. At the time she was three years old. You wonder what her parents might have wanted to know ?????
Don't you think you may be being a bit insensitive?
-
In my theory no abductor entered the apartment. Come to think of it the room (Apartment 5A) was open on more nights other than just the Thursday. Therefore one could not tell on what day the syringe was dropped there. I'm starting to sound like Stephen sorry.
Robitty ... there was no syringe. It is a myth.
-
Robitty ... there was no syringe. It is a myth.
An esteemed poster currently posting from the (disputed) world's second longest river has asked me to tell folk on here that a plastic syringe of the type issued with infant Nurofen was apparently the type found. Please don't shoot the messenger. 8()-000(
-
An esteemed poster currently posting from the (disputed) world's second longest river has asked me to tell folk on here that a plastic syringe of the type issued with infant Nurofen was apparently the type found. Please don't shoot the messenger. 8()-000(
Ask him/her for a cite, Misty.
-
An esteemed poster currently posting from the (disputed) world's second longest river has asked me to tell folk on here that a plastic syringe of the type issued with infant Nurofen was apparently the type found. Please don't shoot the messenger. 8()-000(
Makes sense. I wonder if that needed a prescription?(https://healthy.kaiserpermanente.org/static/drugency/images/WAL00572.JPG)
No needle attached, for use by mouth. "Available
From your local Pharmacy in 100mL and 200mL bottles" So no prescription needed.
-
Ask him/her for a cite, Misty.
Have just done so & will post if I receive the info.
-
Madeleine McCann was missing without trace. At the time she was three years old. You wonder what her parents might have wanted to know ?????
Don't you think you may be being a bit insensitive?
I'll give you an example where Kate complains of a lack of information ;
Back at the police station we endured at least another ten minutes of torture in the waiting area before somebody showed us a photograph, clearly taken from CCTV, of a blonde child with a woman in a petrol-station shop. We weren’t told anything about this, just asked whether the little girl was Madeleine. She wasn’t. And that was that. [Madeleine]
What did she want them to tell her?
-
Have just done so & will post if I receive the info.
I'm sure Davel will post it.
-
I'll give you an example where Kate complains of a lack of information ;
Back at the police station we endured at least another ten minutes of torture in the waiting area before somebody showed us a photograph, clearly taken from CCTV, of a blonde child with a woman in a petrol-station shop. We weren’t told anything about this, just asked whether the little girl was Madeleine. She wasn’t. And that was that. [Madeleine]
What did she want them to tell her?
I think you may have missed the point G. Kate wasn't complaining about lack of information she was describing what a devastating let-down it was just to be asked to look at a photograph - when they had really believed it was momentous news about Madeleine that awaited them at the police station and that is why they had been told to return immediately. IMO so did the driver - which is why he drove like a bat out of hell to get them there.
-
I think you may have missed the point G. Kate wasn't complaining about lack of information she was describing what a devastating let-down it was just to be asked to look at a photograph - when they had really believed it was momentous news about Madeleine that awaited them at the police station and that is why they had been told to return immediately. IMO so did the driver - which is why he drove like a bat out of hell to get them there.
Why say 'We weren't told anything about this' then? That sounds to me like complaint about lack of information.
We were existing in an information vacuum. A big part of the problem was the fact that in Portugal all criminal cases are governed by the law of judicial secrecy, which means that once an investigation is under way, neither the police nor anyone else is allowed to reveal anything about it, including details of potential suspects, on the basis that this could jeopardize a trial. [Madeleine]
A potential suspect is just that; a potential suspect. I'm sure many people are suspected, investigated and eliminated during investigations. Telling relatives about these people wouldn't help them, it would just raise their hopes needlessly.
-
Why say 'We weren't told anything about this' then? That sounds to me like complaint about lack of information.
We were existing in an information vacuum. A big part of the problem was the fact that in Portugal all criminal cases are governed by the law of judicial secrecy, which means that once an investigation is under way, neither the police nor anyone else is allowed to reveal anything about it, including details of potential suspects, on the basis that this could jeopardize a trial. [Madeleine]
A potential suspect is just that; a potential suspect. I'm sure many people are suspected, investigated and eliminated during investigations. Telling relatives about these people wouldn't help them, it would just raise their hopes needlessly.
It was just a way of emphasising how 'short and insignificant' the reason for their return turned out to be - when compared to the massive news they had been expecting to hear.
Sorry G - I'm not sure what the connection is with that and the rest of your post.
-
It was just a way of emphasising how 'short and insignificant' the reason for their return turned out to be - when compared to the massive news they had been expecting to hear.
Sorry G - I'm not sure what the connection is with that and the rest of your post.
That's just your opinion of of why she wrote that.
You either trust the police to do their job or you don't. The McCanns mistrusted the police even before they arrived - perhaps because they thought they took a long time to arrive. That was, of course, due to a misunderstanding on their part, not to any delay by the police. From then on the police were criticised whatever they did or didn't do.
-
Why say 'We weren't told anything about this' then? That sounds to me like complaint about lack of information.
We were existing in an information vacuum. A big part of the problem was the fact that in Portugal all criminal cases are governed by the law of judicial secrecy, which means that once an investigation is under way, neither the police nor anyone else is allowed to reveal anything about it, including details of potential suspects, on the basis that this could jeopardize a trial. [Madeleine]
A potential suspect is just that; a potential suspect. I'm sure many people are suspected, investigated and eliminated during investigations. Telling relatives about these people wouldn't help them, it would just raise their hopes needlessly.
I think the nearest thing we have to Portuguese judicial secrecy in common law in Scotland is Contempt of Court.
Believe you me it is taken very seriously indeed by the courts.
Accompanying that are reporting restrictions which again are given the greatest respect.
I seriously doubt that the police would allow their statutory duties to interfere with keeping the parents of a missing child informed of developments in that child's case.
They are well enough informed on the law to avoid compromising their case by passing out inappropriate information regarding suspects which might prejudice their case.
Particularly in the early stages of elimination.
Kate McCann was telling of her experience as it happened to her. She was terrified at the time and desperate for news of her missing child. She didn't want to know anything about suspects ... she was explaining the law as it stood ... she only wanted to know what the police knew about Madeleine.
I agree with Benice.
I think the police thought they had cracked the case when viewing the garage CCTV so it was disappointment all round; I think it extraordinary that you seem to think the parents of a missing child had no right to be informed of developments.
Do you similarly think that the parents of the little British boy recently lost in the Algarve should have been kept in the dark about his welfare?
Or is that reserved just for the McCann's?
-
I think the nearest thing we have to Portuguese judicial secrecy in common law in Scotland is Contempt of Court.
Believe you me it is taken very seriously indeed by the courts.
Accompanying that are reporting restrictions which again are given the greatest respect.
I seriously doubt that the police would allow their statutory duties to interfere with keeping the parents of a missing child informed of developments in that child's case.
They are well enough informed on the law to avoid compromising their case by passing out inappropriate information regarding suspects which might prejudice their case.
Particularly in the early stages of elimination.
Kate McCann was telling of her experience as it happened to her. She was terrified at the time and desperate for news of her missing child. She didn't want to know anything about suspects ... she was explaining the law as it stood ... she only wanted to know what the police knew about Madeleine.
I agree with Benice.
I think the police thought they had cracked the case when viewing the garage CCTV so it was disappointment all round; I think it extraordinary that you seem to think the parents of a missing child had no right to be informed of developments.
Do you similarly think that the parents of the little British boy recently lost in the Algarve should have been kept in the dark about his welfare?
Or is that reserved just for the McCann's?
I don't think it's me who is making assumptions. Do you know what the McCanns expected to be told? Do you know if their expectations would have been met by other police forces? Unless you have those facts you can't know if their criticism of the PJ was justified or not.
-
That's just your opinion of of why she wrote that.
You either trust the police to do their job or you don't. The McCanns mistrusted the police even before they arrived - perhaps because they thought they took a long time to arrive. That was, of course, due to a misunderstanding on their part, not to any delay by the police. From then on the police were criticised whatever they did or didn't do.
Three opinions posted as fact.
-
I don't think it's me who is making assumptions. Do you know what the McCanns expected to be told? Do you know if their expectations would have been met by other police forces? Unless you have those facts you can't know if their criticism of the PJ was justified or not.
Was the Amaral investigation carried out to textbook standards? I did indeed assume there must have been Portuguese child protection units who had the expertise to conduct a competent inquiry into a missing child case.
I set out to find the responsible agencies in the belief that the Amaral team had been handed Madeleine's case by default and who might therefore not had have had a textbook for reference. Did even one person on that team have experience of working in child protection or human trafficking?
In my opinion there was plenty of experience in Portugal circa 2007 to fill the gap. For example ...
Unidade de polícia dedicada à proteção da criança em portugal 2007
www.otsh.mai.gov.pt/Noticias/Documents/Trafico%20DesHumano.pdf
file:///C:/Users/User/Downloads/Trafico%20DesHumano%20(1).pdf
So why did the bosses hand Madeleine's case to a team of drug busters and thief takers? Was that fair either to them or to Madeleine?
Just for background information which I thought illuminating regarding children's rights being abused and Portuguese Supreme Court of Justice rulings is the following:
Quote
In 2007, the Council of Europe condemned Portugal for violating children's rights after the Supreme Court of Justice found some corporal punishment inflicted on young people with disabilities in a home in Setubal to be "lawful" and "acceptable".
The European Committee of Social Rights of the Council of Europe concluded that Portugal violated Article 17 of the European Social Charter, which enshrines the right of children to social, legal, and economic protection.
http://noticias.sapo.tl/portugues/lusa/artigo/22392202.html
In my opinion, Madeleine went missing in a country where some of those in charge of affairs didn't give thought to the type of investigative skills that a missing child case might demand and a country with a Supreme Court yet to join the rest of us in this century.
That this might have led to friction and mutual misunderstanding is, in my opinion, self evident from subsequent comment from those involved
-
According to what Sofia Leal had to say, which is on record, Amaral was due to go on holiday that coming Friday. But he selflessly gave up his holiday with his wife and children to be The Coordinator of this investigation, despite the fact that he was primarily a drug buster whose only experience of missing children was Joana Cipriano.
Heaven knows who sanctioned this appointment. As it is he didn't even understand Calpol. And heaven knows where the finding of the syringe came from. I remember one Avatar of a massive great syring with a very big needle, as if this would have been possible
He was then made an Arguido on the very next day. What a mess.
-
It seems no-one knows what information the McCanns wanted be given. No-one knows if they would have been given that information by any other police force. Therefore no-one knows if their complaints of being kept in the dark were justified or not.
The 'syringe' story was probably made up. Nothing in the files suggests any such find.
-
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm
.....When they travelled on holiday to Portugal they brought several medicines, namely Calpol, Nurofen, for fevers and pains, both for adults and children..........
Rob has already posted the pic of the children's Nurofen which comes with a plastic syringe (no needle).
-
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm
.....When they travelled on holiday to Portugal they brought several medicines, namely Calpol, Nurofen, for fevers and pains, both for adults and children..........
Rob has already posted the pic of the children's Nurofen which comes with a plastic syringe (no needle).
There's no record of any syringe being found.
-
There's no record of any syringe being found.
There's no record of a half-empty Calpol bottle being found either but that didn't get in the way of a badly told hypothesis.
-
There's no record of a half-empty Calpol bottle being found either but that didn't get in the way of a badly told hypothesis.
Details of which can be found in the files, unlike this syringe.
-
Details of which can be found in the files, unlike this syringe.
Do the PJ files mention a measuring spoon for administering the liquid infant medicine?
-
Do the PJ files mention a measuring spoon for administering the liquid infant medicine?
The files don't mention seeing the medicines, let alone spoons.
-
The files don't mention seeing the medicines, let alone spoons.
As I said, the lack of actual evidence didn't get in the way of a badly told hypothesis. The PJ wouldn't have known about the medicine if K&G hadn't been honest & forthcoming with the information.
-
The files don't mention seeing the medicines, let alone spoons.
Were the search videos not entered in evidence?
-
I'm sure Davel will post it.
Davels gone with ferryman and Alfie. 8(8-))
All banned or forced out 8()(((@# .... as you must already know Slarti %&5%£
-
Davels gone with ferryman and Alfie. 8(8-))
All banned or forced out 8()(((@# .... as you must already know Slarti %&5%£
That rumour has been dispelled. No-one was forced to leave the forum.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8408.0
-
Davels gone with ferryman and Alfie. 8(8-))
All banned or forced out 8()(((@# .... as you must already know Slarti %&5%£
No Sadie.
-
That's just your opinion of of why she wrote that.
You either trust the police to do their job or you don't. The McCanns mistrusted the police even before they arrived - perhaps because they thought they took a long time to arrive. That was, of course, due to a misunderstanding on their part, not to any delay by the police. From then on the police were criticised whatever they did or didn't do.
Not so imo. The McCanns were very grateful for the regular informal meetings Guilhermino Encarnacao and Luis Neves had agreed to hold with them and also for the information those officers were prepared to share with them at those meetings. They also developed a good relationship - even a friendship with Ricardo Paiva their Portuguese FLO.
The fact that it all went pear-shaped months down the line doesn't change the fact that for a long time the McCanns genuinely believed they had a good and friendly relationship with those officers and were grateful to them for their assistance and trusted them. That's a far cry from your claim of constant criticism of the PJ from day one IMO.
-
Not so imo. The McCanns were very grateful for the regular informal meetings Guilhermino Encarnacao and Luis Neves had agreed to hold with them and also for the information those officers were prepared to share with them at those meetings. They also developed a good relationship - even a friendship with Ricardo Paiva their Portuguese FLO.
The fact that it all went pear-shaped months down the line doesn't change the fact that for a long time the McCanns genuinely believed they had a good and friendly relationship with those officers and were grateful to them for their assistance. That's a far cry from your claim of constant criticism of the PJ from day one IMO.
Ah, so that explains the language by the McCann's towards the officers doing their jobs.
-
Ah, so that explains the language by the McCann's towards the officers doing their jobs.
Your reply has nothing to do with the points made in my post regarding the McCann's initial good relationship with three PJ officers which lasted for months.
-
Your reply has nothing to do with the points made in my post regarding the McCann's initial good relationship with three PJ officers which lasted for months.
IYO.
-
Ah, so that explains the language by the McCann's towards the officers doing their jobs.
IYO
-
Okay. We are not going to fight and fall out today. Otherwise I will be deleting.
-
Not so imo. The McCanns were very grateful for the regular informal meetings Guilhermino Encarnacao and Luis Neves had agreed to hold with them and also for the information those officers were prepared to share with them at those meetings. They also developed a good relationship - even a friendship with Ricardo Paiva their Portuguese FLO.
The fact that it all went pear-shaped months down the line doesn't change the fact that for a long time the McCanns genuinely believed they had a good and friendly relationship with those officers and were grateful to them for their assistance and trusted them. That's a far cry from your claim of constant criticism of the PJ from day one IMO.
The evidence says otherwise. Relatives and friends voiced the criticisms, but were not the source.
BBC news Friday 4th May Patricia Campbell;
"We feel that what's been going on in Portugal has been ineffectual.
The Independent 4th May Jill Renwick;
"I spoke to them this morning and they said the police had done nothing overnight and they felt as if they'd been left on their own.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/Nigel/id121.htm#21
Express 6th May 2007
But despite the news of a prime suspect there was mounting criticism of the Portuguese police’s failure to respond quicker and more decisively when the youngster was first found to be missing at 10pm on Thursday.
Friends and relatives of the McCanns alleged yesterday that the search was only upgraded to a major investigation after the intervention of John Buck, Britain’s ambassador in Portugal.
Meanwhile, Gerry’s sister Philomena slammed Portuguese police for not doing enough to find Madeleine’s faster.
Speaking from her home in Glasgow she said Gerry was furious with the way the inquiry was being handled.
Reuters 9th May
Portuguese police have faced criticism in British news media for being too slow and releasing too little information in their investigation of the disappearance of three-year-old Madeleine McCann from her bed in a resort in the Algarve last week.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/REUTERS_09_05_07.htm
-
The evidence says otherwise. Relatives and friends voiced the criticisms, but were not the source.
BBC news Friday 4th May Patricia Campbell;
"We feel that what's been going on in Portugal has been ineffectual.
The Independent 4th May Jill Renwick;
"I spoke to them this morning and they said the police had done nothing overnight and they felt as if they'd been left on their own.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/Nigel/id121.htm#21
Express 6th May 2007
But despite the news of a prime suspect there was mounting criticism of the Portuguese police’s failure to respond quicker and more decisively when the youngster was first found to be missing at 10pm on Thursday.
Friends and relatives of the McCanns alleged yesterday that the search was only upgraded to a major investigation after the intervention of John Buck, Britain’s ambassador in Portugal.
Meanwhile, Gerry’s sister Philomena slammed Portuguese police for not doing enough to find Madeleine’s faster.
Speaking from her home in Glasgow she said Gerry was furious with the way the inquiry was being handled.
Reuters 9th May
Portuguese police have faced criticism in British news media for being too slow and releasing too little information in their investigation of the disappearance of three-year-old Madeleine McCann from her bed in a resort in the Algarve last week.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/REUTERS_09_05_07.htm
That was before the meetings with PJ officers were set up - and at a time when the McCanns felt they were being completely starved of information. The first meeting was 24th May and addressed those concerns. The McCanns were extremely grateful.
IMO
-
That was before the meetings with PJ officers were set up - and at a time when the McCanns felt they were being completely starved of information. The first meeting was 24th May and addressed those concerns. The McCanns were extremely grateful.
IMO
There was some back-pedalling as time went by, but the damage had been done.
Daily Record 25th May;
Maddie's parents finally lose patience with cops
THE parents of snatched tot Madeleine McCann are running out of patience at the lack of progress in finding her, friends revealed yesterday.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/DAILY_RECORD_25_05_07.htm
-
There was some back-pedalling as time went by, but the damage had been done.
Daily Record 25th May;
Maddie's parents finally lose patience with cops
THE parents of snatched tot Madeleine McCann are running out of patience at the lack of progress in finding her, friends revealed yesterday.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/DAILY_RECORD_25_05_07.htm
This was your original claim which I challenged:
. From then on the police were criticised whatever they did or didn't do.
Clearly that is not a correct statement as it totally ignores the McCann's relationship with the 3 PJ officers in whom they believed and trusted for a considerable length of time. In fact far from criticising them for setting up regular meetings with them - they were extremely grateful to them for agreeing to do that.
If you want to translate 'gratitude' as 'criticism' - that's not my problem.
AIMHO
-
This was your original claim which I challenged:
. From then on the police were criticised whatever they did or didn't do.
Clearly that is not a correct statement as it totally ignores the McCann's relationship with the 3 PJ officers in whom they believed and trusted for a considerable length of time. In fact far from criticising them for setting up regular meetings with them - they were extremely grateful to them for agreeing to do that.
If you want to translate 'gratitude' as 'criticism' - that's not my problem.
AIMHO
Perhaps the McCanns continued to say what they really thought through those 'friends' who were often quoted by the UK media?
Kate and Gerry McCann might not be able to talk, but their extended family and a network of friends can, and do.
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2007/sep/17/mondaymediasection13
Kate wasn't completely satisfied with her PJ contacts;
Encarnacao;
it’s probably fair to say that neither Gerry nor I ever felt entirely comfortable with him.
The meetings;
while they were better than nothing, they never repaid my hopes of them
[From Madeleine]
-
Can anyone explain how a ridiculous newspaper claim about a syringe has become yet another criticism of Kate and Gerry McCann?
Seems to be a bit of a fixation.
-
Can anyone explain how a ridiculous newspaper claim about a syringe has become yet another criticism of Kate and Gerry McCann?
Seems to be a bit of a fixation.
I would say Brietta, this syringe 'debate' is a compete red herring.
-
Can anyone explain how a ridiculous newspaper claim about a syringe has become yet another criticism of Kate and Gerry McCann?
Seems to be a bit of a fixation.
It sounds serious until you know what was in the syringe and who used it.
-
It sounds serious until you know what was in the syringe and who used it.
It is not serious, Robitty. It never existed as far as the McCann case is concerned.
Goodness gracious! Enough of a hoohah was made of Mr Healey's medication on internet fora ... imagine if they had had a syringe to play with too.
-
Perhaps the McCanns continued to say what they really thought through those 'friends' who were often quoted by the UK media?
Kate and Gerry McCann might not be able to talk, but their extended family and a network of friends can, and do.
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2007/sep/17/mondaymediasection13
Kate wasn't completely satisfied with her PJ contacts;
Encarnacao;
it’s probably fair to say that neither Gerry nor I ever felt entirely comfortable with him.
The meetings;
while they were better than nothing, they never repaid my hopes of them
[From Madeleine]
You seem to have missed their opinions on Neves and Paiva:
Quote from Kates book.
Luis Neves:
He seemed intelligent, personable and strong, open to suggestions and new ideas. My initial impressions of him were all positive. I wrote in my diary that night
A good fella, on the ball, humanitarian, sensitive.
unquote
Ricardo Paiva
Quote
We also became quite friendly with Ricardo Paiva.................... Both Gerry and I thought he seemed a decent enough guy, quiet but pleasant.
unquote
The meetings:
Quote
I longed for the meeting dates to come round. They gave me something to look forward to and somehow brought me a tiny bit closer to Madeleine.
unquote
Regardless of what happened in later months it is clear that at the time the McCanns genuinely appreciated those regular meetings with the Portuguese Police.
Therefore it is incorrect and also grossly unfair imo to make the serious claim that from day one the McCanns criticised the Police ''whatever they did or didn't do'' - when obviously that wasn't the case.
AIMHO
-
You seem to have missed their opinions on Neves and Paiva:
Quote from Kates book.
Luis Neves:
He seemed intelligent, personable and strong, open to suggestions and new ideas. My initial impressions of him were all positive. I wrote in my diary that night
A good fella, on the ball, humanitarian, sensitive.
unquote
Ricardo Paiva
Quote
We also became quite friendly with Ricardo Paiva.................... Both Gerry and I thought he seemed a decent enough guy, quiet but pleasant.
unquote
The meetings:
Quote
I longed for the meeting dates to come round. They gave me something to look forward to and somehow brought me a tiny bit closer to Madeleine.
unquote
Regardless of what happened in later months it is clear that at the time the McCanns genuinely appreciated those regular meetings with the Portuguese Police.
Therefore it is incorrect and also grossly unfair imo to make the serious claim that from day one the McCanns criticised the Police ''whatever they did or didn't do'' - when obviously that wasn't the case.
AIMHO
The Portuguese police were attacked by the McCanns immediately and reasonably openly. It was obviously them. You think they changed their minds and came to terms with the way things worked in Portugal. I think they continued with their campaign to discredit the Portuguese police but less openly than before.
P
Gerry told Vanity Fair when discussing media stories criticising the Portuguese police;
“we were relying on the Portuguese to find Madeleine, and it was not helpful at all.” However, since the media were, without a doubt, fed in part by the McCann camp, it is hard to know whom to blame.
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2008/02/mccanns200802?currentPage=1
-
The Portuguese police were attacked by the McCanns immediately and reasonably openly. It was obviously them. You think they changed their minds and came to terms with the way things worked in Portugal. I think they continued with their campaign to discredit the Portuguese police but less openly than before.
P
Gerry told Vanity Fair when discussing media stories criticising the Portuguese police;
“we were relying on the Portuguese to find Madeleine, and it was not helpful at all.” However, since the media were, without a doubt, fed in part by the McCann camp, it is hard to know whom to blame.
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2008/02/mccanns200802?currentPage=1
Your memory is very different to mine!
Gerry and kate bent over backwards to be polite to the PJ and to praise them in the earlier days. It was only when it became obvious that the PJ search was NOT for a living Madeleine but was to find stuff, any old stuff(!) in order to try and fit Kate and Gerry up that The Mccanns backed off from the praise.
They must have had their doubts about the PJ from a very early stage tho' but they kept everything very sweet for a long time. I can remember getting very angry and upset about all the disinformation and propaganda that was flying around against The Mccanns, but they still strove to be upbeat about the PJ. They must have beenn angry as hell inside that the PJ were not looking for a living Madeleine, but The Mccanns somehow kept it sweet.
Gawd knows how!
I guess they realised that it would be a bad policy to fall out with the Police
-
Your memory is very different to mine!
Gerry and kate bent over backwards to be polite to the PJ and to praise them in the earlier days. It was only when it became obvious that the PJ search was NOT for a living Madeleine but was to find stuff, any old stuff(!) in order to try and fit Kate and Gerry up that The Mccanns backed off from the praise.
They must have had their doubts about the PJ from a very early stage tho' but they kept everything very sweet for a long time. I can remember getting very angry and upset about all the disinformation and propaganda that was flying around against The Mccanns, but they still strove to be upbeat about the PJ. They must have beenn angry as hell inside that the PJ were not looking for a living Madeleine, but The Mccanns somehow kept it sweet.
Gawd knows how!
I guess they realised that it would be a bad policy to fall out with the Police
I provided cites showing the criticism of the PJ. Could you provide yours showing their praise of them?
-
I provided cites showing the criticism of the PJ. Could you provide yours showing their praise of them?
A few biased reports.
No Gunit, I dont intend to waste the time searching for them
But loads on here will remember what i remember.
My blood ran cold at the disinformation and propaganda against The Mccanns and I could not rationalise the way that the Mccanns were ignoring it and carried on being positive and polite to the PJ. Until I realised why. For the sake of Madeleine they wanted desperately to keep on the right side of the PJ, so ignored the untruths against themselves and constantly encouraging the PJ by praising them
Until it became clear as crystal that the PJ were not attempting to look for a living Madeleine and that all they wanted was to fit Kate and Gerry up.
AIMHO
-
A few biased reports.
No Gunit, I dont intend to waste the time searching for them
But loads on here will remember what i remember.
My blood ran cold at the disinformation and propaganda against The Mccanns and I could not rationalise the way that the Mccanns were ignoring it and carried on being positive and polite to the PJ. Until I realised why. For the sake of Madeleine they wanted desperately to keep on the right side of the PJ, so ignored the untruths against themselves and constantly encouraging the PJ by praising them
Until it became clear as crystal that the PJ were not attempting to look for a living Madeleine and that all they wanted was to fit Kate and Gerry up.
AIMHO
Your statement that the McCanns praised the PJ is just your opinion in the meantime then.
-
Your statement that the McCanns praised the PJ is just your opinion in the meantime then.
No, it is not opinion. It is what I witnessed and was shocked by.
Despite awful disinformation put out about them, the Mccanns always praised the PJ until it became obvious that the PJ under Amarals lead were not looking for a living Madeleine.
They were looking for anything to confirm Amarals unsubstantiated 'theory' that The Mccanns 'dunit'
-
No, it is not opinion. It is what I witnessed and was shocked by.
Despite awful disinformation put out about them, the Mccanns always praised the PJ until it became obvious that the PJ under Amarals lead were not looking for a living Madeleine.
They were looking for anything to confirm Amarals unsubstantiated 'theory' that The Mccanns 'dunit'
It is unconfirmed opinion.
-
It is unconfirmed opinion.
It is a fact. It is what I witnessed
I was shocked at such awful disinformation coming out about the Mccanns and to begin with astounded that Gerry and Kate still managed to praise and encourage the PJ. I soon realised that it was in an effort to not fall out with the PJ because they needed them to look for Madeleine.
-
... back to topic please ... 'elusive syringe'.
-
I provided cites showing the criticism of the PJ. Could you provide yours showing their praise of them?
No need to, everyone will remember how they were upbeat, polite and praised the PJ.
That is everyone who wasn't biased.
-
The forensic examiners checked Madeleine's bedding on 4th May and found nothing suspicious. Neither of the parents raised the question of drugging or sedation with the Portuguese police on 3rd/4th May. On 5th May they raised the subject with the LP FLO's, but only seemed interested in what the PJ had found. So the subject of sedation was raised by the McCanns initially. No syringe was ever mentioned officially, so it's probably just a rumour.
-
No need to, everyone will remember how they were upbeat, polite and praised the PJ.
That is everyone who wasn't biased.
That comment is biased..
-
That comment is biased..
Don't we all have a particular point of view ~ else why do we post? Does difference = bias? 8**8:/:
-
Don't we all have a particular point of view ~ else why do we post? Does difference = bias? 8**8:/:
We all come on here with a bias.
However, I feel sure Brietta, that you would feel that a bias shouldn't be posted as fact, and with the underlying assumption others will agree.
-
The forensic examiners checked Madeleine's bedding on 4th May and found nothing suspicious. Neither of the parents raised the question of drugging or sedation with the Portuguese police on 3rd/4th May. On 5th May they raised the subject with the LP FLO's, but only seemed interested in what the PJ had found. So the subject of sedation was raised by the McCanns initially. No syringe was ever mentioned officially, so it's probably just a rumour.
Once photographs had been taken, the bedding should have been immediately bagged up and sent off for meticulous forensic testing simply as a matter of course. Just sniffing the pillow was hardly adequate to come to any definite conclusions. Surely even the most avid sceptic would agree that failing to do that was a major oversight by the PJ. Who knows what evidence may have emerged if that had been done.
AIMHO
-
No need to, everyone will remember how they were upbeat, polite and praised the PJ.
That is everyone who wasn't biased.
I don't. I remember them instigating the criticism of the Portuguese police as I have demonstrated with cites. They never asked for restraint during the disgraceful UK media campaign which followed either. Perhaps those who failed to notice those things were biased?
-
I don't. I remember them instigating the criticism of the Portuguese police as I have demonstrated with cites. They never asked for restraint during the disgraceful UK media campaign which followed either. Perhaps those who failed to notice those things were biased?
Did those who actually wielded the power to 'control' the excesses of the media from the word go ... that is the Portuguese Judiciary ... ever once call for restraint?
Here would perhaps have been as good a starting point as any to apply the law for the discouragement of others, if they had ... how different might the outcome have been?
"This is a very badly told story"
by José Manuel Oliveira and Paula Castanheira, 05May2007
... the resort's administration and the GNR assert that "there were no signs of a break-in whatsoever".
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic133.html
-
The forensic examiners checked Madeleine's bedding on 4th May and found nothing suspicious. Neither of the parents raised the question of drugging or sedation with the Portuguese police on 3rd/4th May. On 5th May they raised the subject with the LP FLO's, but only seemed interested in what the PJ had found. So the subject of sedation was raised by the McCanns initially. No syringe was ever mentioned officially, so it's probably just a rumour.
The bedding wasn't taken away and forensically tested, and it cannot have been done on the spot.
-
Once photographs had been taken, the bedding should have been immediately bagged up and sent off for meticulous forensic testing simply as a matter of course. Just sniffing the pillow was hardly adequate to come to any definite conclusions. Surely even the most avid sceptic would agree that failing to do that was a major oversight by the PJ. Who knows what evidence may have emerged if that had been done.
AIMHO
I agree Benice, not sending the bedding away to forensics was a huge error. We all shed skin cells, they could have been tested for skin cells.
-
Don't we all have a particular point of view ~ else why do we post? Does difference = bias? 8**8:/:
Given your interest in cites I'm surprised you haven't noticed the complete lack of them in recent posts. Lots of certain opinions posted as if they are accepted facts!
-
I agree Benice, not sending the bedding away to forensics was a huge error. We all shed skin cells, they could have been tested for skin cells.
Well they would probably have found out Madeleine was there, the cleaners, anyone who was known to have been in the apartment, cells carried in by others....
-
Well they would probably have found out Madeleine was there, the cleaners, anyone who was known to have been in the apartment, cells carried in by others....
Tis the extra unaccounted for cells that might provide DNA, which are of interest
Are you unable to see that?
-
Once photographs had been taken, the bedding should have been immediately bagged up and sent off for meticulous forensic testing simply as a matter of course. Just sniffing the pillow was hardly adequate to come to any definite conclusions. Surely even the most avid sceptic would agree that failing to do that was a major oversight by the PJ. Who knows what evidence may have emerged if that had been done.
AIMHO
What could the laboratory have done with the bedding then? Can you describe the process?
-
What could the laboratory have done with the bedding then? Can you describe the process?
https://www.forensicmag.com/article/2010/12/touch-dna
http://what-when-how.com/forensic-sciences/presumptive-chemical-tests/
-
BUMPED
« Reply #118 on: Today at 11:32:03 AM »
But I broke no rules. Tell me precisely what I said that was supposed to be breaking the rules?
Quote my exact words pls.
We do not post things that have been removed because they broke the rules. Please desist from this attack on moderation.
Rules are Opinion as Fact and Abuse.
-
https://www.forensicmag.com/article/2010/12/touch-dna
http://what-when-how.com/forensic-sciences/presumptive-chemical-tests/
Was testing for touch DNA routinely done in 2007? I'm not sure what the other link shows; testing bodies for drugs I think.
-
Was testing for touch DNA routinely done in 2007? I'm not sure what the other link shows; testing bodies for drugs I think.
Touch DNA was not routinely tested for in 2007 but had the bedding been bagged it could have been carried out in the following years, possibly before the case was archived. That type of test was used in 2008 to clear the family of JonBenet Ramsay of involvement in her death. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/experts-touch-dna-jonbenet-ramsey/ Clearly material evidence had been kept by the US police. Like LCN testing, though, Touch DNA has its flaws.
Here is the introductory paragraph in the other link.
Introduction
Different types of evidence may be presented to a forensic chemistry laboratory for analysis. This includes solid or liquid material such as powders, tablets, capsules, plant material or solutions and paraphernalia such as syringes, cookers, spoons, cigarettes and pipes. Although some of the components of the evidence may be suggested by external appearance, the forensic chemist is still required to perform analytical testing on the submitted evidence. The material may contain ‘active’drug or drugs as well as inactive substances used to dilute the potency of the preparation. As workload for the forensic chemist increases, it would be impractical to subject all submitted evidence to sophisticated and time-consuming extraction and instrumental techniques. Therefore, there is a need for a battery of relatively simple screening tests that the chemist can perform to assist in directing toward an ultimate identification.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think syringes. cookers, spoons etc can be considered parts of a body but they can be tested for traces of sedating drugs, just as highly absorbent cotton bedding can.
-
Touch DNA was not routinely tested for in 2007 but had the bedding been bagged it could have been carried out in the following years, possibly before the case was archived. That type of test was used in 2008 to clear the family of JonBenet Ramsay of involvement in her death. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/experts-touch-dna-jonbenet-ramsey/ Clearly material evidence had been kept by the US police. Like LCN testing, though, Touch DNA has its flaws.
Here is the introductory paragraph in the other link.
Introduction
Different types of evidence may be presented to a forensic chemistry laboratory for analysis. This includes solid or liquid material such as powders, tablets, capsules, plant material or solutions and paraphernalia such as syringes, cookers, spoons, cigarettes and pipes. Although some of the components of the evidence may be suggested by external appearance, the forensic chemist is still required to perform analytical testing on the submitted evidence. The material may contain ‘active’drug or drugs as well as inactive substances used to dilute the potency of the preparation. As workload for the forensic chemist increases, it would be impractical to subject all submitted evidence to sophisticated and time-consuming extraction and instrumental techniques. Therefore, there is a need for a battery of relatively simple screening tests that the chemist can perform to assist in directing toward an ultimate identification.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think syringes. cookers, spoons etc can be considered parts of a body but they can be tested for traces of sedating drugs, just as highly absorbent cotton bedding can.
I can imagine touch DNA being found on certain items where you might expect it; the handle of a cup, say, but bedding is a large area with many skin cells. A big job, that.
I'm not sure about the drug testing either. So many different tests for so many substances.
I expect the forensics team did what was expected at the time, guided by their laboratory.
-
I can imagine touch DNA being found on certain items where you might expect it; the handle of a cup, say, but bedding is a large area with many skin cells. A big job, that.
I'm not sure about the drug testing either. So many different tests for so many substances.
I expect the forensics team did what was expected at the time, guided by their laboratory.
The lab can't test what the CSI/police don't send them. The bedding needed only to be tested for sedating drugs & skin cells.
That "big job" may have saved a family years of heartache & the UK tax payer £11m. IMO.
-
The lab can't test what the CSI/police don't send them. The bedding needed only to be tested for sedating drugs & skin cells.
That "big job" may have saved a family years of heartache & the UK tax payer £11m. IMO.
I have no idea what normal practice was in 2007, whether in Portugal or elsewhere. Criticising what was done is all very well if guidelines weren't followed, but otherwise it's just nit-picking with hindsight.
Why would traces of sedating drugs be on the bedding? According to Kate it was the twins excessive sleepiness which aroused her suspicions. As far as I know any sedative lasting for hours has to be administered orally or by injection. I really can't see an abductor going from bed to bed dosing or injecting three children.
-
I have no idea what normal practice was in 2007, whether in Portugal or elsewhere. Criticising what was done is all very well if guidelines weren't followed, but otherwise it's just nit-picking with hindsight.
Why would traces of sedating drugs be on the bedding? According to Kate it was the twins excessive sleepiness which aroused her suspicions. As far as I know any sedative lasting for hours has to be administered orally or by injection. I really can't see an abductor going from bed to bed dosing or injecting three children.
Hypothetically, when the CSI team attended 5A on 4th May it could have been a potential murder site. Are you suggesting that the PJ did not have either guide lines or the common sense to treat it as such?
Any attempt at injecting an IV drug without a cannula could have resulted in a sedating liquid dripping onto surfaces between one child & another. Any oral sedation could have leaked onto bedding. A soaked chloroform rag could have left contact residue. If no forensic tests were requested the evidence would never be found.
For the record, I'm not of the opinion the twins were sedated.
-
Hypothetically, when the CSI team attended 5A on 4th May it could have been a potential murder site. Are you suggesting that the PJ did not have either guide lines or the common sense to treat it as such?
Any attempt at injecting an IV drug without a cannula could have resulted in a sedating liquid dripping onto surfaces between one child & another. Any oral sedation could have leaked onto bedding. A soaked chloroform rag could have left contact residue. If no forensic tests were requested the evidence would never be found.
For the record, I'm not of the opinion the twins were sedated.
There was that unexplained stain on Madeleine's pyjamas that was washed off on the Thursday morning.
-
There was that unexplained stain on Madeleine's pyjamas that was washed off on the Thursday morning.
...and ?
-
...and ?
And that remains a mystery. If Kate had spilt the "drugs" on the pyjamas I don't think she would have mentioned it. IMO.
-
Hypothetically, when the CSI team attended 5A on 4th May it could have been a potential murder site. Are you suggesting that the PJ did not have either guide lines or the common sense to treat it as such?
Any attempt at injecting an IV drug without a cannula could have resulted in a sedating liquid dripping onto surfaces between one child & another. Any oral sedation could have leaked onto bedding. A soaked chloroform rag could have left contact residue. If no forensic tests were requested the evidence would never be found.
For the record, I'm not of the opinion the twins were sedated.
You are suggesting that they were lax in some way. What standards, in place in 2007, are you comparing their work to?
I can't imagine anyone attempting to inject or feed sedatives to three children that night, sorry. Chloroform works for a few minutes and leaves a distinctive smell which wasn't there.
-
You are suggesting that they were lax in some way. What standards, in place in 2007, are you comparing their work to?
I can't imagine anyone attempting to inject or feed sedatives to three children that night, sorry. Chloroform works for a few minutes and leaves a distinctive smell which wasn't there.
What would have changed in 10 years? Surely they had standards to operate to even then.
-
And that remains a mystery. If Kate had spilt the "drugs" on the pyjamas I don't think she would have mentioned it. IMO.
Spilt food Rob.
Kids do that.
-
You are suggesting that they were lax in some way. What standards, in place in 2007, are you comparing their work to?
I can't imagine anyone attempting to inject or feed sedatives to three children that night, sorry. Chloroform works for a few minutes and leaves a distinctive smell which wasn't there.
Goncalo Amaral could, did. then put his thoughts in writing.
It would only have needed a few minutes to sedate Madeleine & remove her from the apartment. The open window & breeze would have quickly dispersed any remnant odour.
As far as standards were concerned - I have no idea how a country faced with EU fiscal stimulus cuts corners in expensive criminal investigations.
-
There was that unexplained stain on Madeleine's pyjamas that was washed off on the Thursday morning.
I wonder what time exactly? All she says is 'a little later that same morning'. Was it after Gerry's lesson ended at 11.15?
When her lesson ended at 10:15, she went to the recreation area next to the swimming pool to talk to Russell until Gerry's lesson was over. Afterwards, she is not sure, they went back together to the apartment until close to 12:15
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
I'm surprised, given the temperatures, that the top dried so quickly;
She hung it to dry on a small stand, and it was dry by the afternoon
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
What time was it found to be dry? When they all came back at 5.30pm?
-
Split food Rob.
Kids do that.
In Kate's eyes from what I can recall it seemed odd to Kate. If it was regular occurrence I don't see why Kate would raise it.
-
In Kate's eyes from what I can recall it seemed odd to Kate. If it was regular occurrence I don't see why Kate would raise it.
Really.
It's what children do.
-
Really.
It's what children do.
The type of stain didn't seem to fit in with what the McCanns had fed to their children. From Kate's arguido statement 6th Sept. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
"During breakfast the 'crying episode', already described, took place. She noticed a stain, supposedly of tea, on Madeleine's pyjama top, which she washed a little later that same morning. She hung it to dry on a small stand, and it was dry by the afternoon. Madeleine sometimes drank tea; the stain did not appear during breakfast, maybe it happened another day, as Madeleine did not have tea the previous night and the stain was dry."
It has been said by Kate that this may have been evidence that someone had been in the apartment the night before.
-
The type of stain didn't seem to fit in with what the McCanns had fed to their children. From Kate's arguido statement 6th Sept. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
"During breakfast the 'crying episode', already described, took place. She noticed a stain, supposedly of tea, on Madeleine's pyjama top, which she washed a little later that same morning. She hung it to dry on a small stand, and it was dry by the afternoon. Madeleine sometimes drank tea; the stain did not appear during breakfast, maybe it happened another day, as Madeleine did not have tea the previous night and the stain was dry."
It has been said by Kate that this may have been evidence that someone had been in the apartment the night before.
Sometimes words really do fail.
-
I wonder what time exactly? All she says is 'a little later that same morning'. Was it after Gerry's lesson ended at 11.15?
When her lesson ended at 10:15, she went to the recreation area next to the swimming pool to talk to Russell until Gerry's lesson was over. Afterwards, she is not sure, they went back together to the apartment until close to 12:15
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
I'm surprised, given the temperatures, that the top dried so quickly;
She hung it to dry on a small stand, and it was dry by the afternoon
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
What time was it found to be dry? When they all came back at 5.30pm?
The balcony is south-facing & the sun was shining. It would have dried in a few hours.
-
What would have changed in 10 years? Surely they had standards to operate to even then.
The forensics team have been criticised for certain 'failings'. They are only failings if they fell short of standards in place at the time. Unless we know the standards we don't know if they failed to meet them or not, do we?
-
The forensics team have been criticised for certain 'failings'. They are only failings if they fell short of standards in place at the time. Unless we know the standards we don't know if they failed to meet them or not, do we?
Had the PJ team been left to their own devices by the UK authorities one can only speculate how they would have managed to successfully prosecute any suspects.
-
Had the PJ team been left to their own devices by the UK authorities one can only speculate how they would have managed to successfully prosecute any suspects.
Had the UK authorities kept out of it we would have found out, wouldn't we?
-
Had the UK authorities kept out of it we would have found out, wouldn't we?
There would have been no dog alerts, the McCanns would have left Portugal far earlier than they did & Madeleine would still be missing (unless that blue bag or fridge turned up). We wouldn't be here discussing it all.
-
There would have been no dog alerts, the McCanns would have left Portugal far earlier than they did & Madeleine would still be missing (unless that blue bag or fridge turned up). We wouldn't be here discussing it all.
You got a crystal ball there?
-
You got a crystal ball there?
Lol, no, I don't believe in that clap-trap.
-
Sorry, not having any more of this. Stop now.
-
Sometimes words really do fail.
Does that advance the discussion? Fail IMO.