UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pathfinder73 on September 13, 2017, 03:24:28 PM

Title: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 13, 2017, 03:24:28 PM
Daily Star Online visited Praia da Luz and recreated the sighting 10 years after Maddie vanished.

At the same time of night and with similar lighting, we discovered how hard it was to get a good look at a face.

The street, Rua da Escola Primaria, is lit dimly lit by just a few street lamps, a sign from a nearby clinic and moonlight.

(http://cdn.images.dailystar.co.uk/dynamic/1/photos/748000/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007-1057748.jpg)

(http://cdn.images.dailystar.co.uk/dynamic/1/photos/750000/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007-1057750.jpg)

Photos of a model, which were taken at the scene and brightened afterwards to better simulate the view, show a face shrouded in shadow.

It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.

The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.

On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.

Full article here
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007

29
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 14, 2017, 08:29:17 AM
the ending bit is a bit weird  "One local man with knowledge of the case said that, whether the man is innocent or not, "the e-fits almost certainly look nothing like him"

He told Daily Star Online: "I happen to believe he is Portuguese and innocent, but that’s not how he's depicted in Portuguese media.

"They showed the e-fits, but called him Scotland Yard’s chief suspect. They did not include that he might be totally innocent."

Did this person actually know the person to say this or not?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 14, 2017, 10:56:55 AM
Daily Star Online visited Praia da Luz and recreated the sighting 10 years after Maddie vanished.

At the same time of night and with similar lighting, we discovered how hard it was to get a good look at a face.

The street, Rua da Escola Primaria, is lit dimly lit by just a few street lamps, a sign from a nearby clinic and moonlight.

(http://cdn.images.dailystar.co.uk/dynamic/1/photos/748000/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007-1057748.jpg)

(http://cdn.images.dailystar.co.uk/dynamic/1/photos/750000/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007-1057750.jpg)

Photos of a model, which were taken at the scene and brightened afterwards to better simulate the view, show a face shrouded in shadow.

It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.

The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.

On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.

Full article here
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007

Amazing how the model is always posed with no lights in front iof him but plenty behind.   Where Peter Smith stood was in R.de Abril 25 (something like that) and that road is well lit.  The man would be bathed in light asd he passed Peter.

Also Aofie, same road and the crossing was lit by a monster light.

Not sure of Martins position higher up R.de Escola, but they were paused waiting for the rest.  People usually chose to stand near lights rather than away from them, so likely that that spot was also illuminated by a street lamp



Seems to me that is a photo set up to give a very stilted impression.  More propaganda ?   

Look on GE street scene and work out where the shadows from Aofies massive street lamp would fall and that guy/model would just be on the cusp of the shadow into light.

One step forward and the guy would be bathed in light from Aofies massive street light and beautifully illumunated for both Peters group and Aofies group to see.


Probably Martins group saw a well lit man too.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 14, 2017, 10:57:29 AM
They forgot to do a reconstruction at the Aoife Smith position (under the light by the steps) where she saw Smithman's face. Lost opportunity!
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 14, 2017, 11:15:41 AM
They forgot to do a reconstruction at the Aoife Smith position (under the light by the steps) where she saw Smithman's face. Lost opportunity!
They wouldn't want to do a reconstruction there.  A massive street lamp was immediately above the crossing place where she was and it would have beamed straight on his face as he walked down ... for Peters group and Aofies group to get a very clear view of his features
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 14, 2017, 11:20:51 AM
She saw his face by that light so I would have shown her suspect photos to help recap her memory. She may have picked one as being the man she saw. We will have to wait and see.

"At the time she saw his face but now cannot remember it." Aoife Smith 26 May 2007
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 14, 2017, 11:29:50 AM
She saw his face by that light so I would have shown her suspect photos to help recap her memory. She may have picked one as being the man she saw. We will have to wait and see.

"At the time she saw his face but now cannot remember it." Aoife Smith 26 May 2007
I have been at a police recap and although I have a well above normal ability to draw faces, I couldn't have drawn the thiefs face who stole my purse
.
They have techiques which help you find or reconstruct the image.  In my case they showed me images of previous offenders and i picked him out easily.

However as i was honest and only 99.9% sure, they wouldn't proceed.


I must be a sucker becos twice now i have allowed criminals to get away with theft. because I will not verify 100% when I am only 99.9% certain.    Others with as much certainty would have said 100%
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 14, 2017, 12:30:40 PM
I have been at a police recap and although I have a well above normal ability to draw faces, I couldn't have drawn the thiefs face who stole my purse
.
They have techiques which help you find or reconstruct the image.  In my case they showed me images of previous offenders and i picked him out easily.

However as i was honest and only 99.9% sure, they wouldn't proceed.


I must be a sucker becos twice now i have allowed criminals to get away with theft. because I will not verify 100% when I am only 99.9% certain.    Others with as much certainty would have said 100%
Well how reliable was Martin Smith with his 60% certainty.  I'm not even sure how you judge your own reliability?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Mr Moderator on September 14, 2017, 12:57:31 PM
Well how reliable was Martin Smith with his 60% certainty.  I'm not even sure how you judge your own reliability?

He seemed pretty convinced otherwise why make a complete fool of himself by contacting the Garda?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 14, 2017, 01:04:57 PM
He seemed pretty convinced otherwise why make a complete fool of himself by contacting the Garda?

For the simple reason that, whoever he allegedly saw, it "definitely wasn't Murat".
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Brietta on September 14, 2017, 02:14:52 PM
He seemed pretty convinced otherwise why make a complete fool of himself by contacting the Garda?

I think the answer to that is simple when a comparison is made with what Mr McCluskey thought he saw.

Benice has also posted quite a bit about the effect of false memory.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 14, 2017, 02:30:37 PM
For the simple reason that, whoever he allegedly saw, it "definitely wasn't Murat".

"He had an average build, a bit on the thin side." Martin Smith

"Average build, in good shape." Peter Smith

100% not Robert Murat  @)(++(*
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 14, 2017, 03:09:40 PM
"He had an average build, a bit on the thin side." Martin Smith

"Average build, in good shape." Peter Smith

100% not Robert Murat  @)(++(*

Considering that the child being carried covered enough of the man's upper body to conceal the type of top he was wearing, it amazes me that PS could see what sort of shape Smithman was in. A fleece can disguise a thousand sins.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Brietta on September 14, 2017, 07:29:38 PM
Did the Smithman portrayed in the efits ever exist?

The three witness statements given to the Policia Judiciaria - Date of Diligence: 2007.05.26 10H40 - agree that only one witness could identify the facial features of the man seen ... and that was an affirmation that he was not Murat.

On this occasion I think the STAR journalist, Michael Havis,  is spot on when he says: "It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.

The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.

On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007

Association claimed by a detective from a firm the boss of which apparently had excited the interest of American law enforcement to the extent that they went to the bother of extraditing him to face trial, does not in my opinion do anything to enhance the value.

There is perhaps a lot more to the smithman episode than meets the eye ... maybe HOLMES worked it out.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 14, 2017, 07:40:56 PM
Did the Smithman portrayed in the efits ever exist?

The three witness statements given to the Policia Judiciaria - Date of Diligence: 2007.05.26 10H40 - agree that only one witness could identify the facial features of the man seen ... and that was an affirmation that he was not Murat.

On this occasion I think the STAR journalist, Michael Havis,  is spot on when he says: "It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.

The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.

On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007

Association claimed by a detective from a firm the boss of which apparently had excited the interest of American law enforcement to the extent that they went to the bother of extraditing him to face trial, does not in my opinion do anything to enhance the value.

There is perhaps a lot more to the smithman episode than meets the eye ... maybe HOLMES worked it out.

I think you'd need to ask the Met; they seemed to take those e fits seriously. Surely a properly trained professional police force wouldn't use e fits if they weren't properly produced?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: faithlilly on September 14, 2017, 08:43:22 PM
Did the Smithman portrayed in the efits ever exist?

The three witness statements given to the Policia Judiciaria - Date of Diligence: 2007.05.26 10H40 - agree that only one witness could identify the facial features of the man seen ... and that was an affirmation that he was not Murat.

On this occasion I think the STAR journalist, Michael Havis,  is spot on when he says: "It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.

The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.

On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007

Association claimed by a detective from a firm the boss of which apparently had excited the interest of American law enforcement to the extent that they went to the bother of extraditing him to face trial, does not in my opinion do anything to enhance the value.

There is perhaps a lot more to the smithman episode than meets the eye ... maybe HOLMES worked it out.

Wasn't Tannerman drawn several months later too Brietta?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 14, 2017, 08:58:50 PM
I think you'd need to ask the Met; they seemed to take those e fits seriously. Surely a properly trained professional police force wouldn't use e fits if they weren't properly produced?

Those efits were the only other things the Met had from the witnesses in the Smith family besides their statements. To ask the witnesses to reproduce their memories more than a couple of years later would have resulted in unreliable efits.
After almost ruling out Tannerman, the only other unidentified person walking in Luz & carrying a child at the crucial time around the discovery of Madeleine's disappearance was Smithman. Had I been a detective on the case, finding out who he was would have been my number one priority. However the PJ seemed to have lost interest as soon as the Smiths all said they wouldn't recognise him again. Would that have been because he had been ruled out as the arguido they were investigating at the time?
It was all so clever. For as long as Smithman remained unidentified, the similarly-dressed Tannerman, if he was ever positively identified, would always have a get-out-of-jail-free card. No-one could ever prove that Smithman didn't exist -  only that he did through identification. The Smith family broke no laws because they didn't produce efits for either police force - it was the Met's decision to use them.

All my own opinion
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 14, 2017, 09:06:30 PM
Did the Smithman portrayed in the efits ever exist?

The three witness statements given to the Policia Judiciaria - Date of Diligence: 2007.05.26 10H40 - agree that only one witness could identify the facial features of the man seen ... and that was an affirmation that he was not Murat.

On this occasion I think the STAR journalist, Michael Havis,  is spot on when he says: "It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.

The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.

On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007

Association claimed by a detective from a firm the boss of which apparently had excited the interest of American law enforcement to the extent that they went to the bother of extraditing him to face trial, does not in my opinion do anything to enhance the value.

There is perhaps a lot more to the smithman episode than meets the eye ... maybe HOLMES worked it out.

HOLMES is not as good as the system the PJ used though...... as used by the US Military and police forces throughout the world. The idea the PJ used only excel or Lotus Notes and knotted string was a myth.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 14, 2017, 09:38:16 PM
HOLMES is not as good as the system the PJ used though...... as used by the US Military and police forces throughout the world. The idea the PJ used only excel or Lotus Notes and knotted string was a myth.
You forgot about smoke signals and secret handshakes.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 14, 2017, 09:46:14 PM
HOLMES is not as good as the system the PJ used though...... as used by the US Military and police forces throughout the world. The idea the PJ used only excel or Lotus Notes and knotted string was a myth.

What system would that be, given the quality of the documents in the PJ files?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 14, 2017, 09:48:22 PM
What system would that be, given the quality of the documents in the PJ files?

You dug it up and posted it recently.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 14, 2017, 09:51:53 PM
You dug it up and posted it recently.
Clay tablets?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 14, 2017, 10:22:11 PM
You dug it up and posted it recently.

I posted about US satellites recently but not about computer systems. One of us is crazy so would you provide the link, please?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 14, 2017, 10:40:09 PM
A fleece on anyone can disguise a thousand sins. None of the Smiths could even recall the colour, let alone the type, of top, Smithman was wearing. How could one possibly tell the man was "in good shape" when they couldn't even see all his torso?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: faithlilly on September 14, 2017, 11:17:00 PM
A fleece on anyone can disguise a thousand sins. None of the Smiths could even recall the colour, let alone the type, of top, Smithman was wearing. How could one possibly tell the man was "in good shape" when they couldn't even see all his torso?

Possibly the same way Tanner could describe the pattern on the child's pyjama bottoms yet completely missed the rather large Eyore appliqué.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 14, 2017, 11:58:10 PM
A fleece on anyone can disguise a thousand sins. None of the Smiths could even recall the colour, let alone the type, of top, Smithman was wearing. How could one possibly tell the man was "in good shape" when they couldn't even see all his torso?

The way someone moves can say a lot about their size and fitness. He was also described as;

average build, a bit on the thin side..........normal build.........Average build, in good shape

Adds further that his son TA*** was questioned in Ireland and said that the individual was dressed in a long-sleeved coat/jacket, black in colour, (Peter)
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm


Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 15, 2017, 12:11:39 AM
Possibly the same way Tanner could describe the pattern on the child's pyjama bottoms yet completely missed the rather large Eyore appliqué.
The eyeore applique was on the chest, wasn't it?   Jane couldn't see the little ones chest.

So that is your reason.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 15, 2017, 12:31:42 AM
One Smith said it was black jacket which looks like one on the sofa at the crime scene.

"Gerry was wearing blue denim trousers and trainers (tennis shoes). She doesn't remember what else he was wearing."

"After leaving Madeleine around 2:50 PM, they both had, this one time, an individual tennis lesson just for the two of them, and as the court was empty, they began hitting some balls until it was time for their lesson.

She doesn't remember if they were wearing appropriate clothes or if they went to the apartment to change." KM about 3 May 2007

Amazing how witnesses are so forgetful about that fateful day (I think a jacket or fleece worn would be easiest thing to remember being with that person all night?) but remember the position of doors with absolute certainty. I suppose you wouldn't want to say something you may regret  ?{)(**

You'd think the PJ would have asked Carpenter & Wilkins what Gerry was wearing when they sent the questions to the UK police re. rogatory interviews, wouldn't you?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Brietta on September 15, 2017, 01:13:53 AM
One Smith said it was black jacket which looks like one on the sofa at the crime scene.

"Gerry was wearing blue denim trousers and trainers (tennis shoes). She doesn't remember what else he was wearing."

"After leaving Madeleine around 2:50 PM, they both had, this one time, an individual tennis lesson just for the two of them, and as the court was empty, they began hitting some balls until it was time for their lesson.

She doesn't remember if they were wearing appropriate clothes or if they went to the apartment to change." KM about 3 May 2007

Amazing how witnesses are so forgetful about that fateful day (I think a jacket or fleece worn would be easiest thing to remember being with that person all night?) but remember the position of doors with absolute certainty. I suppose you wouldn't want to say something you may regret  ?{)(**

We have seen three Smith statements.
Which one of the three witnesses states smithman was wearing a black jacket?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: John on September 15, 2017, 02:55:53 AM
The Smiths passed so close to the mystery man that Mary Smith even asked him a question which attracted no response. The Daily Star's attempt to confuse the sighting is rather pathetic really but in reality what we have come to expect from a London based tabloid. 
A shit effort Michael Havis and The Daily Star.   %56&
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Brietta on September 15, 2017, 03:50:14 AM
The Smiths passed so close to the mystery man that Mary Smith even asked him a question which attracted no response. The Daily Star's attempt to confuse the sighting is rather pathetic really but in reality what we have come to expect from a London based tabloid. 
A shit effort Michael Havis and The Daily Star.   %56&

Far be it from me to defend a tabloid but I think it is a good effort by Havis and especially by the photographer.

Shining made a similar attempt on a couple of occasions for us, if memory serves me well also with a model? but an unfamiliar camera played havoc with his core plan.
I stand to be corrected on that ... but without searching through loads of posts ... that is my memory. I know he did post some shots of the area but not the ones he wanted to.

I honestly don't think it takes much to make the Smith sighting confused.  I have always been perplexed that it took the Smiths a fortnight before Peter checking out with the others if he had dreamt it all brought it all back to mind.

Even if some of the party flew home the following day ... some remained in the 'media circus' that became Luz and Madeleine's disappearance had world wide publicity particularly in Britain.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 15, 2017, 08:13:38 AM
Rather than wondering why the Smiths didn't associate their sighting with the child's disappearance it might be sensible to wonder why they should have.

Peter Smith said;

At that time he did not associate the said individual with the disappearance, only after thinking on the subject and the coincidence of the time did he infer that MADELEINE could have been the child carried by the individual that he had seen.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm

Why not? Because it wasn't an unusual sight;

Martin Smith said;

he saw an individual carrying a child, who walked normally and fitted in perfectly in that area, in that it is common to see people carrying children, at least during the holiday season........He assumed it was a father and daughter, not raising any suspicion.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 08:19:52 AM
Rather than wondering why the Smiths didn't associate their sighting with the child's disappearance it might be sensible to wonder why they should have.

Peter Smith said;

At that time he did not associate the said individual with the disappearance, only after thinking on the subject and the coincidence of the time did he infer that MADELEINE could have been the child carried by the individual that he had seen.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm

Why not? Because it wasn't an unusual sight;

Martin Smith said;

he saw an individual carrying a child, who walked normally and fitted in perfectly in that area, in that it is common to see people carrying children, at least during the holiday season........He assumed it was a father and daughter, not raising any suspicion.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
That excuse only makes sense if they and the man were carrying a living child.  Had she been deceased long enough to release cadaver odour back in the apartment there is no way she would look normal or for him to act normal.
So do you accept this girl being carried was in all probability alive?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 15, 2017, 08:36:30 AM
Deleted
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 15, 2017, 08:50:44 AM
That excuse only makes sense if they and the man were carrying a living child.  Had she been deceased long enough to release cadaver odour back in the apartment there is no way she would look normal or for him to act normal.
So do you accept this girl being carried was in all probability alive?

I have no idea who they saw or who he was carrying. Your assumption that a person who died hours ago would not look like they were just asleep is wrong. As to how, when and whether people can act normally it would depend on the person, I expect.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Benice on September 15, 2017, 09:06:50 AM
That excuse only makes sense if they and the man were carrying a living child.  Had she been deceased long enough to release cadaver odour back in the apartment there is no way she would look normal or for him to act normal.
So do you accept this girl being carried was in all probability alive?

Also  - if she had been dead for some time -  'rigor mortis'  could have been a problem.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: barrier on September 15, 2017, 09:48:34 AM
Excellent point Rob.   8@??)(

Come in Pathfinder, what do you think of this? 
 
Which beliefs are you going to let go?
The claims by Amaral that Madeleine lay dead in the apartment long enough to produce Cadaver odour.
or
That the child being carried was dead, and was being carried by someone who loved her


You cant have it both ways

That is dependent upon how long cadaver odour takes to form in an infant as opposed to an adult.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 15, 2017, 09:49:46 AM
Crecheman may have been around with his child that night, but we all know that Redwood's story didn't make sense. If Crecheman was collecting his child from the night creche he was going the wrong way.

Did Operation Grange know this but hoped that no-one else would notice, or did they not realise their mistake?

In other words did they knowingly mislead the public or did they fail to spot the problem with their own story?




Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 10:02:36 AM
Crecheman may have been around with his child that night, but we all know that Redwood's story didn't make sense. If Crecheman was collecting his child from the night creche he was going the wrong way.

Did Operation Grange know this but hoped that no-one else would notice, or did they not realise their mistake?

In other words did they knowingly mislead the public or did they fail to spot the problem with their own story?

I find it difficult to believe that.
Perhaps they thought it didn't really matter as they had decided that Tanner/crecheman was a red herring  and they wanted to place the emphasis on Smithman.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 15, 2017, 10:05:46 AM
Also  - if she had been dead for some time -  'rigor mortis'  could have been a problem.

Rigor mortis begins between two and six hours after death in  the eyelids, jaw and neck. It takes between eight and twelve hours for the whole body to become stiff. Rigor mortis may not be perceivable in many infant and child corpses due to their smaller muscle mass
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rigor_mortis

Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Benice on September 15, 2017, 10:08:26 AM
Crecheman may have been around with his child that night, but we all know that Redwood's story didn't make sense. If Crecheman was collecting his child from the night creche he was going the wrong way.

Did Operation Grange know this but hoped that no-one else would notice, or did they not realise their mistake?

In other words did they knowingly mislead the public or did they fail to spot the problem with their own story?

I think it's safe to assume that SY interviewed crecheman at length and were satisfied with whatever explanation he gave for ..'going the wrong way'.    The fact that they didn't share that info with the public is irrelevant - unless you are a sceptic of course and are looking to find fault.

The idea that SY would deliberately set out to mislead the public  - and that they wouldn't notice - is ridiculous beyond words IMO.    How would doing that advance the search for Madeleine?

AIMHO

Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: faithlilly on September 15, 2017, 10:15:26 AM
The eyeore applique was on the chest, wasn't it?   Jane couldn't see the little ones chest.

So that is your reason.

http://gerrymccan-abuseofpower-humanrights.blogspot.co.uk/2016/03/dr-martin-roberts-nightwear-job.html
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Brietta on September 15, 2017, 10:17:46 AM
I find it difficult to believe that.
Perhaps they thought it didn't really matter as they had decided that Tanner/crecheman was a red herring  and they wanted to place the emphasis on Smithman.

It was early days into the re-opened investigation ... whatever the motivation ... I am sure DCi Redwood knew exactly where he was coming from and where he was going to ... and as far as an active investigation goes I have no desire to know anything about that reasoning.

It remains my opinion that Tannerman was an abductor.  Innocentdad walking his reverse route home could have walked Tannerman's route two minutes before or two minutes after.

The relevant sighting was and is Jane Tanner's.
I think the Policia Judiciaria thought so too as Smithman only became of interest to them when Mr Smith misidentified Gerry on his return home ... exactly as Mr McCluskey before him had done.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 15, 2017, 10:20:10 AM
I find it difficult to believe that.
Perhaps they thought it didn't really matter as they had decided that Tanner/crecheman was a red herring  and they wanted to place the emphasis on Smithman.

It probably didn't matter to most of those watching, but there were other people who had enough knowledge to notice the contradiction. Redwood may have thought those people didn't matter, but his carelessness made Crecheman look like a red herring and allowed the McCanns and their supporters to continue to favour Tannerman imo. .
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: faithlilly on September 15, 2017, 10:23:44 AM
I think it's safe to assume that SY interviewed crecheman at length and were satisfied with whatever explanation he gave for ..'going the wrong way'.    The fact that they didn't share that info with the public is irrelevant - unless you are a sceptic of course and are looking to find fault.

The idea that SY would deliberately set out to mislead the public  - and that they wouldn't notice - is ridiculous beyond words IMO.    How would doing that advance the search for Madeleine?

AIMHO

If Crecheman was of no interest to the investigation, the way he was heading was of no interest either and has no bearing on the investigation. I just think they wanted rid and had to work ŵith what they had. Must have been a sicker though for the McCanns who had spent all that money on allegedly chasing Crecheman.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 10:24:12 AM
Not that it really matters anyway as none of us have any influence on the outcome of the investigation.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 10:40:21 AM
That is dependent upon how long cadaver odour takes to form in an infant as opposed to an adult.
It would be slower IMO as the body mass is lower.  All other things being equal.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Benice on September 15, 2017, 10:56:36 AM
If Crecheman was of no interest to the investigation, the way he was heading was of no interest either and has no bearing on the investigation. I just think they wanted rid and had to work ŵith what they had. Must have been a sicker though for the McCanns who had spent all that money on allegedly chasing Crecheman.

Obviously Crecheman was of extreme importance to the investigation -  as if he was the man JT saw - then that drastically lengthened the 'window of opportunity' for Madeleine to have been taken. 

The suggestion that none of the SY police officers working exclusively on this case didn't notice that he was apparently 'going the wrong way' is too daft for words IMO.

Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 11:26:56 AM
While a dog can detect cadaver scent at a couple of hours, not sure a human would while just passing by in the street.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 15, 2017, 11:54:43 AM
Crecheman may have been around with his child that night, but we all know that Redwood's story didn't make sense. If Crecheman was collecting his child from the night creche he was going the wrong way.

Did Operation Grange know this but hoped that no-one else would notice, or did they not realise their mistake?

In other words did they knowingly mislead the public or did they fail to spot the problem with their own story?
Or do they have some information that we are not aware of, such as
-  Crecheman was given a lift back part of the way up Rua Primerio MaioRua Agostinho de Silva and only had to walk along Rua Agostinho de Silva
-  or, he got completely lost as he walked back

However, I dont think either of these options is likely because he would be worn out carrying his child as Janr saw.  Instead, he would have her over his shoulder, which is much easier and also warmer for her.

AIMO
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 12:12:41 PM
Or do they have some information that we are not aware of, such as
-  Crecheman was given a lift back part of the way up Rua Primerio MaioRua Agostinho de Silva and only had to walk along Rua Agostinho de Silva
-  or, he got completely lost as he walked back

However, I dont think either of these options is likely because he would be worn out carrying his child as Janr saw.  Instead, he would have her over his shoulder, which is much easier and also warmer for her.

AIMO
  Thinking outside of the square.  I like it.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 15, 2017, 12:35:49 PM
I posted about US satellites recently but not about computer systems. One of us is crazy so would you provide the link, please?

You I think.
You posted this to Brietta a few days ago.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/OUSTROS_APENSOS_11_VOLUMES.htm
If you read far enough you will find it says that the PJ used IBM Analysts Notebook v.6, as used by the US Military  and several police forces world wide, as their software package for analysis of data.
Also in the document you linked there are graphics some of which look remarkably like they are related to timeway diagrams. I wonder what that was about?
I have always found it a bit risky to assume that someone does not know how to use something they have.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 15, 2017, 01:06:15 PM
Excellent point Rob.   8@??)(

Come in Pathfinder, what do you think of this? 
 
Which beliefs are you going to let go?
The claims by Amaral that Madeleine lay dead in the apartment long enough to produce Cadaver odour.
or
That the child being carried was dead, and was being carried by someone who loved her


You cant have it both ways

2.1. The hypothesis of death is based on the following:

a) The witness Silvia Batista, page 1977, refers that at 3:00 h, May 4th, the couple asked for a priest, which she found strange since there was at that time any indication that the child was dead, and it is 'under those circumstances that usually the presence of a priest is demanded' (sic).

b) The search dog 'Eddie' (dog that signals the presence of cadaver odour) 'marked' (gave a signal) in the couples bedroom, at the apartment 5A, on an area close to the wardrobe (page 2054, and/or annex 88)

c) That same dog 'marked', in the same apartment, an area close to the window of the living room, which has a direct access to the street, behind the sofa (page. 2054 and/or annex 88)

d) Still in the apartment, the dog 'marked' an area in the garden, at the corner, down the vertical from the veranda (page 2054 and/or annex 88).

e) At the villa 'Vista do Mar', the house rented by the McCann after leaving the Ocean Club, the dog 'marked' the area of the closet that contained in its interior the soft toy belonging to Madeleine (cf. page. 2099 and/or annex 88)

f) From the exam to the clothing performed in a pavilion in Lagos, this same dog 'marked' some pieces of clothes that belonged to Kate Healy (pag 2101 and /or annex 88)

g) This dog signalled the exterior and interior parts, of the driver's door, of the Renault 59-DA-27 ' rented by the McCann (page. 2187 and /or annex 88)

h) Finally he 'marked' the key/card of this vehicle when hidden in a sand box (pag 2187 and/or annex 88)

i) The search dog, named 'Keela' (a she dog that detects the presence of human blood) 'marked' an area in the living room, in the apartment 5A, that had been 'marked' by the dog 'Eddy' (pag. 2054 and/or annex 88)

j) After the mosaics that this dog signalled had been retired, on a first inspection, and mentioned previously, she marked that same area once more (pag 2190 and/or annex 88)

k) She 'marked' also the inferior side of the left side curtains, of the window referred above (page 2190 and/or annex 88)

l) She 'marked' the inferior lateral right side, in the inside of the booth of the car 59-DA-27 (page 2187 and/or anex 88)

m) In what concerns the vehicle, 'Keela' 'marked' the little compartment of the driver's door, that contained the key/card of the vehicle (pag 2187 and/or annex 88)

n) This dog also 'marked' the key/card when the same was hidden into a sand box.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/OUSTROS_APENSOS_11_VOLUMES.htm
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 15, 2017, 01:13:01 PM
We have seen three Smith statements.
Which one of the three witnesses states smithman was wearing a black jacket?

Adds further that his son TA*** was questioned in Ireland and said that the individual was dressed in a long-sleeved coat/jacket, black in colour, and that the child was barefoot. (Peter Smith statement)
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 15, 2017, 01:16:18 PM
You'd think the PJ would have asked Carpenter & Wilkins what Gerry was wearing when they sent the questions to the UK police re. rogatory interviews, wouldn't you?

Yes very strange they weren't asked and Jez was questioned a few times and still they didn't ask that question. Shoddy police work.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 15, 2017, 01:20:33 PM
Or do they have some information that we are not aware of, such as
-  Crecheman was given a lift back part of the way up Rua Primerio MaioRua Agostinho de Silva and only had to walk along Rua Agostinho de Silva
-  or, he got completely lost as he walked back

However, I dont think either of these options is likely because he would be worn out carrying his child as Janr saw.  Instead, he would have her over his shoulder, which is much easier and also warmer for her.

AIMO

In my opinion it's similar to police releasing CCTV footage of someone they wish to trace because this person was heading towards a crime scene. The CCTV footage, however, shows that the person is actually heading away from the crime scene. The police may have a good explanation for the anomaly but they would still have caused confusion.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 15, 2017, 01:34:40 PM
That excuse only makes sense if they and the man were carrying a living child.  Had she been deceased long enough to release cadaver odour back in the apartment there is no way she would look normal or for him to act normal.
So do you accept this girl being carried was in all probability alive?

No.

"He adds that he did not hold the child in a comfortable position, suggesting [the carrying] not being habitual." MS

"There was nothing covering the child, a comforter/blanket or any other piece of clothing but she only saw her back." AS

The dogs outsmarted the mute. Can the police do the same?

Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 15, 2017, 01:53:14 PM
You I think.
You posted this to Brietta a few days ago.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/OUSTROS_APENSOS_11_VOLUMES.htm
If you read far enough you will find it says that the PJ used IBM Analysts Notebook v.6, as used by the US Military  and several police forces world wide, as their software package for analysis of data.
Also in the document you linked there are graphics some of which look remarkably like they are related to timeway diagrams. I wonder what that was about?
I have always found it a bit risky to assume that someone does not know how to use something they have.

I would be grateful if you would provide the link from the last few days as the only page highlighted on my computer on OA11 is page 79 & that was in relation to Murat phone traffic (from many weeks ago)
I can see how the IBM Notebook was used for the analysis of phone pings but the phone records were put onto Excel spreadsheets which surely must have been unnecessary/counterproductive if the IBM software had been fully utilised.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 15, 2017, 02:34:45 PM
I would be grateful if you would provide the link from the last few days as the only page highlighted on my computer on OA11 is page 79 & that was in relation to Murat phone traffic (from many weeks ago)
I can see how the IBM Notebook was used for the analysis of phone pings but the phone records were put onto Excel spreadsheets which surely must have been unnecessary/counterproductive if the IBM software had been fully utilised.


It does not detract from my point. The supporters and the PR machine made out quite erroneously it would seem that the PJ used wet pencil ends with notebooks and generally didn't know gee from haw. It would seem that is a complete myth adequatley demonstrated by the software they used.
your only argument seemingly is "well they didn't know how to use it".

ETA
Quote from: misty on August 13, 2017, 07:32:36 PM

    Is this part of it Brietta? (Scroll down for English)
    http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/OUSTROS_APENSOS_11_VOLUMES.htm


I've not seen that before, Misty.
If I've been on that page before I've not bothered to scroll down as far as the English script.  Will need to read it.

Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: misty on September 15, 2017, 03:07:47 PM

It does not detract from my point. The supporters and the PR machine made out quite erroneously it would seem that the PJ used wet pencil ends with notebooks and generally didn't know gee from haw. It would seem that is a complete myth adequatley demonstrated by the software they used.
your only argument seemingly is "well they didn't know how to use it".

I have personally made any comment on what software they did or didn't use, apart from the fact that they never requested or were denied the use of intelligence from US spy satellites.
The higgledy-piggledy presentation of the witness statements & other reports etc. in the files suggests that no software was used to cross-reference anything.
(Do I take it you cannot find whatever I apparently posted to support your point & you is really the crazy one?) 8)--))
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 06:47:23 PM
Excellent point Rob.   8@??)(

Come in Pathfinder, what do you think of this? 
 
Which beliefs are you going to let go?
The claims by Amaral that Madeleine lay dead in the apartment long enough to produce Cadaver odour.
or
That the child being carried was dead, and was being carried by someone who loved her


You cant have it both ways
Saddie did you drop the word NOT from the second option or am I misunderstanding you?
I thought the options needed to be:

1. The claims by Amaral that Madeleine lay dead in the apartment long enough to produce Cadaver odour.

or

2.  That the child being carried was NOT dead, and was being carried by someone who loved her
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 06:57:16 PM
I have no idea who they saw or who he was carrying. Your assumption that a person who died hours ago would not look like they were just asleep is wrong. As to how, when and whether people can act normally it would depend on the person, I expect.
Well I'm willing to be corrected on this aspect.  I'm sure it could be a good subject to attempt in a PJ reconstruction at sometime.  Where they vary the time of death and notice the ease of carrying a dead cadaver over the perpetrator's shoulder.  In all my years I can't recall anyone carrying a cadaver over one's shoulder as you might a sleeping child.  Can you?  It would have to be in some horror movie and I don't watch them as a choice.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:00:00 PM
While a dog can detect cadaver scent at a couple of hours, not sure a human would while just passing by in the street.
If it was more than a day you might notice something akin to soiled underwear.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 07:01:55 PM
If it was more than a day you might notice something akin to soiled underwear.

I don't think that Smithman was carrying a 2 day old stiff.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 15, 2017, 07:14:09 PM
I have personally made any comment on what software they did or didn't use, apart from the fact that they never requested or were denied the use of intelligence from US spy satellites.
The higgledy-piggledy presentation of the witness statements & other reports etc. in the files suggests that no software was used to cross-reference anything.
(Do I take it you cannot find whatever I apparently posted to support your point & you is really the crazy one?) 8)--))

Oh totally deranged I shouldn't wonder.
You posted a link to Brietta which I have highlighted in my post above.
In the document linked it states the PJ used IBM Analysts Notes which you will find if you care to research is a powerful tool. Probably better than HOLMES but let's not go there. All we need to know is that a document linked by you confirms that the PJ used a state of the art software package for crime analysis and was not behind the times as was always intimated.
Out.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:20:50 PM
No.

"He adds that he did not hold the child in a comfortable position, suggesting [the carrying] not being habitual." MS

"There was nothing covering the child, a comforter/blanket or any other piece of clothing but she only saw her back." AS

The dogs outsmarted the mute. Can the police do the same?
Well that is completely at odds with his later statement about seeing Gerry return to England where he is carrying Sean over his shoulder in a very comfortable position.  Yet the two observations were 60% certainty of being the same person based on that carrying position. 
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:22:55 PM
I don't think that Smithman was carrying a 2 day old stiff.
Well it would depend on when Madeleine was last seen alive.  There are some outrageous theories out there.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 07:30:04 PM
Well it would depend on when Madeleine was last seen alive.  There are some outrageous theories out there.

Indeed there are, but if Madeleine had died earlier than Thursday teatime, then it wasn't her that Smithman was carrying.  IMO
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:35:15 PM
Indeed there are, but if Madeleine had died earlier than Thursday teatime, then it wasn't her that Smithman was carrying.  IMO
If you were wrong why would Gerry leave to the very last minute to carry Madeleine away?   I think I have got that right.  If Madeleine had died earlier  in the week why would they delay disposing of the cadaver?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 07:39:47 PM
If you were wrong why would Gerry leave to the very last minute to carry Madeleine away?   I think I have got that right.  If Madeleine had died earlier  in the week why would they delay disposing of the cadaver?

Who said they did?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:41:36 PM
Who said they did?
Researchers like Richard D Hall and his millions of followers.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 07:45:10 PM
Wow, if he has millions of followers, you supporters must be very much in the minority.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:48:40 PM
Wow, if he has millions of followers, you supporters must be very much in the minority.
We are.  If there is anyone who has done more damage to this case after the likes of Amaral I would say RDH is the next worst.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: jassi on September 15, 2017, 07:49:45 PM
Strange that the McCanns haven't taken him to court in that case.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 07:52:41 PM
Strange that the McCanns haven't taken him to court in that case.
Richard makes it very clear he is just proposing a theory whereas Amaral seemed to propose his theory as fact.  Big difference when it comes to legality.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: slartibartfast on September 15, 2017, 08:00:59 PM
Richard makes it very clear he is just proposing a theory whereas Amaral seemed to propose his theory as fact.  Big difference when it comes to legality.

No, I think you will find they were doing the same, as did the SC.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 08:56:39 PM
No, I think you will find they were doing the same, as did the SC.
That is the question isn't it.  One day I might be able to answer it.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 15, 2017, 10:08:20 PM
Saddie did you drop the word NOT from the second option or am I misunderstanding you?
I thought the options needed to be:

1. The claims by Amaral that Madeleine lay dead in the apartment long enough to produce Cadaver odour.

or

2.  That the child being carried was NOT dead, and was being carried by someone who loved her
Actually Rob, I think I made a bit of a mess with that post

For number 2, I think I should have said that the child being carried was being carried by someone who loved her (Pathfinders theory), but that if she had produced cadavar odour in the apartment she would be looking a bit stiff and definitely pale. I dont think that someone who had been dead long enough to produce cadaver odour would have draped herself on Smithmans shoulder in the way that S**n was draped on Gerrys shoulder as he came down the plane steps.

I am not an expert and I have tried to find out which comes first, rigor mortice or cadaver odour, but without success.   I am thinking that they come at the same time, but I could be wrong

IMO
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: slartibartfast on September 15, 2017, 10:17:56 PM
Actually Rob, I think I made a bit of a mess with that post

For number 2, I think I should have said that the child being carried was being carried by someone who loved her (Pathfinders theory), but that if she had produced cadavar odour in the apartment she would be looking a bit stiff and definitely pale.  I dont think that someone who had been dead long enough to produce cadaver odour would have draped herself on Smithmans shoulder in the way that S**n was draped on Gerrys shoulder as he came down the plane steps.

I am not an expert and I have tried to find out which comes first, rigor mortice or cadaver odour, but without success.   I am thinking that they come at the same time, but I could be wrong

IMO

See post #39
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 10:21:55 PM
Actually Rob, I think I made a bit of a mess with that post

For number 2, I think I should have said that the child being carried was being carried by someone who loved her (Pathfinders theory), but that if she had produced cadavar odour in the apartment she would be looking a bit stiff and definitely pale.  I dont think that someone who had been dead long enough to produce cadaver odour would have draped herself on Smithmans shoulder in the way that S**n was draped on Gerrys shoulder as he came down the plane steps.

I am not an expert and I have tried to find out which comes first, rigor mortice or cadaver odour, but without success.   I am thinking that they come at the same time, but I could be wrong

IMO
All I know from experience of having worked in the meat industry, rigour mortis sets in within 30 minutes or so.  Butchers have to work on slaughtered animals within that first 45 minutes or the muscles begin to tighten and it becomes hard work. 
I also know from personal experience a child who has just died is so floppy to such the extent you think you are picking up a fluid not a solid. 
So I always think Tanner saw a deceased child for she described it as limp, whereas Smith describe a relaxed but living child over the shoulder. All IMO of course but it is an opinion based on considerable experience.

Cadaver odour would develop from the inside out of a deceased body.  The internal organs develop off odours quicker than flesh nearer the skin, for the outside regions cool quicker.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 10:30:13 PM
Rigor mortis begins between two and six hours after death in  the eyelids, jaw and neck. It takes between eight and twelve hours for the whole body to become stiff. Rigor mortis may not be perceivable in many infant and child corpses due to their smaller muscle mass
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rigor_mortis
The rigor mortis I'm speaking of is the initial stages not the completed process.  I'm basing my experience on slaughtered animals.  I'm not sure why humans seem slower than I'd expect.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 15, 2017, 10:46:01 PM
See post #39
Oh, how interesting.  Thankyou Slarti and Gunit.  Seems that I was wrong.

I was looking for comparisons of times for the development of Cadaver odour and the start of Rigor Mortice and couldn't find it anywhere.


Rob, I have deleted my original post that you quoted altho I have left up an ammended response to you
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: ShiningInLuz on September 16, 2017, 12:25:35 AM
I have just posted an explanation on my blog of Michael Havis' photo essay on the Smithman sighting.  This is first-hand, as I was present when it was being done.

Please take it or leave it as you will.  I do not wish to engage in debate on this, so I will not be responding to comments or questions.

Bye.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 16, 2017, 11:11:44 AM
This image of the Aoife Smith's sighting position is completely wrong (that's why I never posted it on the start of this thread). Smithman was at the top of the steps (to Aoife's left) when seen not across the road.

The deponent remembers that upon reaching the top of the stairs, she looked to her left and saw a man (1) with a female child (2) in his arms, walking along the pavement of Rua 25 de Abril. He was walking in her direction at a distance of, give or take, two metres. AS

(https://shininginluz.files.wordpress.com/2017/09/michael-havis-3.jpg)
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: G-Unit on September 16, 2017, 11:22:52 AM
I have just posted an explanation on my blog of Michael Havis' photo essay on the Smithman sighting.  This is first-hand, as I was present when it was being done.

Please take it or leave it as you will.  I do not wish to engage in debate on this, so I will not be responding to comments or questions.

Bye.

Interesting.
https://shininginluz.wordpress.com/
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 16, 2017, 01:30:50 PM
"There is a quote in the article to the effect that a local source believes Smithman is Portuguese and innocent.

(but that is not how he is depicted). That local source is me. I am not going to explain why in this article, as it would divert from Mr Havis’ photo essay."

Would the same person also travel to Brazil?
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 16, 2017, 05:35:45 PM
"There is a quote in the article to the effect that a local source believes Smithman is Portuguese and innocent.

(but that is not how he is depicted). That local source is me. I am not going to explain why in this article, as it would divert from Mr Havis’ photo essay."

Would the same person also travel to Brazil?
Would the same person travel to Brazil?   What an interesting question £5%4%
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: stephen25000 on September 16, 2017, 06:06:04 PM
Would the same person travel to Brazil?   What an interesting question £5%4%

You mean like Marcos Correia ? 8)-)))
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 16, 2017, 07:22:58 PM
You mean like Marcos Correia ? 8)-)))
Not him. Well I don't think Marcos Correia looks like the Smithman e-fit.
I know nothing about him really.
"Controversy: Former coordinator says lawyer has hallucinations
 
Manuela Teixeira / Tânia Laranjo
15 June 2009 - 00h30
Thanks to Joana Morais for translation
 
The former coordinator of the PJ, Goncalo Amaral, will request from the Public Ministry of Faro a series of psychiatric examinations and assessments into the personality of Marcos Aragao Correia, suggesting even that he is committed. In the appendage to the criminal process for defamation against Leonor Cipriano's lawyer, Goncalo Amaral defends that the accused suffers from a 'pathological imbalance with traits of social dangerousness.'

They seem to get on really well.
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: sadie on September 16, 2017, 09:42:38 PM
You mean like Marcos Correia ? 8)-)))
No, I mean like some of the names of people connected with this case.

Oh and Brazil fits in several times with my theory sent to SY.


I find Brazil very interesting
Title: Re: Daily Star revisit the Smithman sighting
Post by: stephen25000 on September 16, 2017, 09:51:55 PM
No, I mean like some of the names of people connected with this case.

Oh and Brazil fits in several times with my theory sent to SY.


I find Brazil very interesting

A certain Aunt springs to mind. 8**8:/: