Did the Smithman portrayed in the efits ever exist?
The three witness statements given to the Policia Judiciaria - Date of Diligence: 2007.05.26 10H40 - agree that only one witness could identify the facial features of the man seen ... and that was an affirmation that he was not Murat.
On this occasion I think the STAR journalist, Michael Havis, is spot on when he says: "It’s also worth noting that e-fits are usually produced by an operator under the direction of a witness, in accordance with strict police guidelines.
The e-fits created from this sighting were assembled in 2008, several months after Madeleine disappeared, when witnesses were likelier to misremember.
On the other hand, if they were made without the direction of witnesses – but rather from their statements – the operator is likelier to have influenced the end result.
http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/640497/madeleine-mccann-news-missing-found-parents-smith-sighting-2007Association claimed by a detective from a firm the boss of which apparently had excited the interest of American law enforcement to the extent that they went to the bother of extraditing him to face trial, does not in my opinion do anything to enhance the value.
There is perhaps a lot more to the smithman episode than meets the eye ... maybe HOLMES worked it out.