UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on September 23, 2017, 07:16:17 PM
-
This is most interesting:
-
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VITOR-SANTOS.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MW_STAFF.htm
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P4/04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_851.jpg)
-
Column 3 is admission date. What would admission date mean? Is that date of a previous charge?
Thinking about it that would be date they commenced employment at Ocean Club.
-
there is admission and admit -ion both are spelt the same.
"admission
noun
1.
a statement acknowledging the truth of something.
"an admission of guilt"
synonyms: acknowledgement, acceptance, recognition, concession, profession, expression, declaration, confession, revelation, disclosure, divulgence, avowal, claim, unbosoming, owning up; More
2.
the process or fact of entering or being allowed to enter a place or organization.
"the evening before her admission to hospital"
synonyms: admittance, entry, entrance, right of entry, permission to enter, access, means of entry, ingress, entrée, acceptance
"membership entitles you to free admission" "
-
there is admission and admit -ion both are spelt the same.
"admission
noun
1.
a statement acknowledging the truth of something.
"an admission of guilt"
synonyms: acknowledgement, acceptance, recognition, concession, profession, expression, declaration, confession, revelation, disclosure, divulgence, avowal, claim, unbosoming, owning up; More
2.
the process or fact of entering or being allowed to enter a place or organization.
"the evening before her admission to hospital"
synonyms: admittance, entry, entrance, right of entry, permission to enter, access, means of entry, ingress, entrée, acceptance
"membership entitles you to free admission" "
Not certain, but I think it refers to when they were hired.
-
Why do you find it interesting?
-
Why do you find it interesting?
Because OG found it interesting also. https://youtu.be/s93f4FHRfBk?t=2988 onward is Richard's interview with Vitor earlier this year.
-
Because OG found it interesting also. https://youtu.be/s93f4FHRfBk?t=2988 onward is Richard's interview with Vitor earlier this year.
Bilton was raking over old coals,Rowley said he (Santos) and the other supposed burglars were no longer of interest even by the end of 2014.
Q: How old were the suspects because I think you interviewed them originally through the Portuguese
beginning of July 2014?
MR: By the end of the year we were happy to have brought them out and we were moving on to other
parts of the investigation.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8138.30
-
Bilton was raking over old coals,Rowley said he (Santos) and the other supposed burglars were no longer of interest even by the end of 2014.http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8138.30
Even that is interesting to me. What makes MR lose interest in these people?
-
Even that is interesting to me. What makes MR lose interest in these people?
Lack of evidence,simples really,or even no evidence.
-
Lack of evidence,simples really,or even no evidence.
No evidence of what? That they were never burglars or that they weren't on some mission that night?
-
In my estimation there only needed to have been an attempted burglary and the burglars are disturbed after the shutters were raised, and then they abandoned their job that night. No one entered the apartment, so the burglars may not have taken Madeleine. So someone says "they are not involved", I need to know involved with what?
-
No evidence of what? That they were never burglars or that they weren't on some mission that night?
Evidence of anything that would help progress the investigation.
-
No evidence of what? That they were never burglars or that they weren't on some mission that night?
Any part in the mysterious and as yet unexplained circumstances surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
-
Any part in the mysterious and as yet unexplained circumstances surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
Well Vitor Santos can never be cleared then because he had the keys to every room and he took the bookings.
-
Well Vitor Santos can never be cleared then because he had the keys to every room and he took the bookings.
Speak to officers from Scotland Yard then,are you allowed to accuse like that?
-
Why would he be one of the first to be rung by Helder? Why did Helder need to ring him? Was it just to go there and see if the room looked like it had been broken into? Why didn't he assist with the searching? Did he help in organising alternative accommodation for the McCanns later that night?
Speak to officers from Scotland Yard then,are you allowed to accuse like that?
These are the words used in the BBC documentary. I think of them as facts not accusations.
-
These are the words used in the BBC documentary. I think of them as facts not accusations.
The part about never being cleared,cite?
-
The part about never being cleared,cite?
Well I should have made it clearer that is my opinion, and I don't need cites for my opinion.
And besides I think he was being evasive in the interview. Do you think he answered all the questions with ease? Had that been the way Gerry McCann answered a question it would be repeated a thousand times on YouTube.
-
Well I should have made it clearer that is my opinion, and I don't need cites for my opinion.
Fair enough, he may never be cleared in your eyes,but I'm sure you'll understand why I'd sooner take the word of the assistant commissioner of the MET.
-
Why would he be one of the first to be rung by Helder? Why did Helder need to ring him? Was it just to go there and see if the room looked like it had been broken into? Why didn't he assist with the searching? Did he help in organising alternative accommodation for the McCanns later that night?
These are the words used in the BBC documentary. I think of them as facts not accusations.
Matt goes to tell the receptionist to ring the police but the receptionist rings John Hill and Helder in that order. He had to have rung John first as he is quoted as saying what John Hill said and reacted like when told about Madeleine going missing.
"With regard to the date of the disappearance on 3rd May 2007, he remembers that at 22.00/22.15 he received a phone call from the reception, from receptionist Helder, who told him that John Hill was extremely agitated as a child had disappeared and that the GNR had been contacted but had not arrived yet. He added (the receptionist) that he had phoned the GNR post several times and that he had been told that they would arrive when they could but that they were investigating a theft in Odiaxere. The receptionist asked the witness whether he should contact the PSP, to which the witness replied no as this area belongs to the GNR."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VITOR-SANTOS.htm
-
Where is the proof the GNR had been rung several times by 10:15 PM?
-
If you are going to be selective in quoting.From your link.
When questioned about the availability of a baby sitting service from 19.30 to 23.30 he confirms that this service exists and that it is free.
When asked, the witness replies that he cannot understand why as the service was free, the McCanns did not use it.
-
Also this sentence is quite damning "The receptionist asked the witness whether he should contact the PSP, to which the witness replied no as this area belongs to the GNR." Was there someone else who could initiate the search? What about ringing the PJ immediately if the GNR were busy? Did he give Helder the correct advice?
-
If you are going to be selective in quoting.From your link.
"When questioned about the availability of a baby sitting service from 19.30 to 23.30 he confirms that this service exists and that it is free.
When asked, the witness replies that he cannot understand why as the service was free, the McCanns did not use it."
I take that as more evidence against him in fact. Why should he pretend to know what was behind the parent's decisions?
Was he in a position to know what the parents were doing and had he approved of this. Consider there was a note on the booking sheet, OC were aware to some extent the kids were being left on their own. Had they sanctioned that situation.
-
Because OG found it interesting also. https://youtu.be/s93f4FHRfBk?t=2988 onward is Richard's interview with Vitor earlier this year.
This man worked at the Ocean Club for 18 years. He worked his way up to Head of Accommodation ans held that post for 7 years. Obviously a trusted and useful member of staff.
Along came Mark Warner and then the McCann affair. He was made redundant along with many of his colleagues as a result and is now reduced to scratching a living doing boat trips during the season. Goodness knows what he does out of season.
I find it quite reasonable that he doesn't want to talk about the events that led to the changes in his life. Singling him out in a documentary was not acceptable. He wasn't the only one to be re-interviewed by Operation Grange, other senior staff were interviewed also. Perhaps they all told Bilton to do one so he tracked down and ambushed dos Santos.
-
"When questioned about the availability of a baby sitting service from 19.30 to 23.30 he confirms that this service exists and that it is free.
When asked, the witness replies that he cannot understand why as the service was free, the McCanns did not use it."
I take that as more evidence against him in fact. Why should he pretend to know what was behind the parent's decisions?
Was he in a position to know what the parents were doing and had he approved of this. Consider there was a note on the booking sheet, OC were aware to some extent the kids were being left on their own. Had they sanctioned that situation.
I can't see where he pretends to know whats behind the parents decision,he was replying to a question.
-
Why would he be one of the first to be rung by Helder? Why did Helder need to ring him? Was it just to go there and see if the room looked like it had been broken into? Why didn't he assist with the searching? Did he help in organising alternative accommodation for the McCanns later that night?
These are the words used in the BBC documentary. I think of them as facts not accusations.
Helder rang dos Santos because he was his boss. It sounds like Helder was being pushed by John Hill (who was not his boss). He wanted advice. Both men got their times badly wrong. It looks to me like Helder rang him after he had rung the GNR at least one, because dos Santos came from Lagos and arrived at Reception when the GNR were there speaking to Gerry McCann. The GNR drove to 5A and dos Santos followed, where he saw no evidence of forced entry. What he did after that he doesn't say.
-
I can't see where he pretends to know whats behind the parents decision,he was replying to a question.
If he had allowed the staff to block book the Tapas restaurant for the week on the basis that they were leaving the kids in the rooms someone in OC management knew about this and did nothing proactively to prevent it. I see hints that they were monitoring the parents that they were checking the kids. More evidence they knew what was going on.
The parents did it because it had been approved by the OC, IMO of course, but not only that there is some evidence of knowledge of the situation.
-
Helder rang dos Santos because he was his boss. It sounds like Helder was being pushed by John Hill (who was not his boss). He wanted advice. Both men got their times badly wrong. It looks to me like Helder rang him after he had rung the GNR at least one, because dos Santos came from Lagos and arrived at Reception when the GNR were there speaking to Gerry McCann. The GNR drove to 5A and dos Santos followed, where he saw no evidence of forced entry. What he did after that he doesn't say.
I don't think the people got all their times wrong but more that we think they got their times wrong. Could there be another explanation for all this?
Vitor's first port of call was the main reception. Was John Hill there? But according to John hill he arrives then rings the police to get the GNR to attend, so there is no way Gerry is talking to the GNR before John Hill arrives.
How does Vitor know it was Gerry talking to the GNR when he arrives?
-
If he had allowed the staff to block book the Tapas restaurant for the week on the basis that they were leaving the kids in the rooms someone in OC management knew about this and did nothing proactively to prevent it. I see hints that they were monitoring the parents that they were checking the kids. More evidence they knew what was going on.
The parents did it because it had been approved by the OC, IMO of course, but not only that there is some evidence of knowledge of the situation.
I'm sorry Rob but the responsibility lies with the parents and not the hotel. In my opinion the management went out of their way to provide free facilities so that parents could relax and enjoy their evenings out, it wasn't their fault that some parents chose not to avail of them.
-
I'm sorry Rob but the responsibility lies with the parents and not the hotel.
Responsibility yes but exclusive knowledge no.
-
I'm sorry Rob but the responsibility lies with the parents and not the hotel. In my opinion the management went out of their way to provide free facilities so that parents could relax and enjoy their evenings out, it wasn't their fault that some parents chose not to avail of them.
Jez Wilkins had used the free service the night before and it wasn't that great, part way through the meal the creche called up, the son was crying and they had to go and fetch him. It wasn't that convenient for those staying at the northern end of the complex as it was a long way to carry a sleeping child on cold nights.
-
If he had allowed the staff to block book the Tapas restaurant for the week on the basis that they were leaving the kids in the rooms someone in OC management knew about this and did nothing proactively to prevent it. I see hints that they were monitoring the parents that they were checking the kids. More evidence they knew what was going on.
The parents did it because it had been approved by the OC, IMO of course, but not only that there is some evidence of knowledge of the situation.
Most guests made requests but were aware that their requests might not be met. Look what is written on the Berry booking. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_334.jpg
The group were prepared to make an issue of it and asked for an assurance that they would be together. According to Matthew they got it too;
the operator had assured them accommodation sufficiently close together that, collectively, they had managed to assure the checking and supervision of their respective progeny. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
The only way Mark Warner could have assured them of that is if the Ocean Club, who were in charge of allocating guests to accommodation, had agreed. The Berry booking confirms that MW couldn't normally make such assurances.
I suspect that Vitor dos Santos knew that they wanted to be together and possibly knew why. I don't know if he was the only one who knew; that would depend in various factors.
1. If it was in his job description to make the decision or if he had to ask his boss.
2. How he, and other Ocean Club staff viewed MW, who were not just a tour operator making bookings, they were their new bosses.
3. How MW phrased the request. Was it as an order (because MW had misled the client into thinking there was a listening service). Or was it a favour; these clients want...Either way, the request came from MW. OC staff could be forgiven for assuming, therefore, that MW approved of their client's request.
4. Whether any of them thought it was up to them to dictate to clients how they cared for their children.
So you see, Rob, the situation was not a simple one. The clients in this case either misunderstood what was available or were misled. Either way, they wanted an assurance that they would be accommodated close to each other and they got it. Just as they wanted the times of the tennis events changed and they got it and they wanted a block booking at the Tapas and they got it. Whichever of them achieved all that should have gone to Reception to phone the police; Helder wouldn't have got rid of them so easily as he seems to have fobbed Matthew off.
-
All the following is from a professional translator Laura Rockert. (Proof of her qualification is the fact she has co-authored a dictionary. https://www.amazon.com.br/Michaelis-Dicion%C3%A1rio-Neg%C3%B3cios-Ingl%C3%AAs-Portugu%C3%AAs-Autores/dp/8506048230)
"Burla is a Portuguese legal term to define a specific type of stelionate.
An informal alternative would be scam.
However the term scam is not a legal term and the original term is a specific legal term therefore it requires an equivalent legal term when brought into English not an informal one.
The term "falsificação" can only be translated as "falsification" and nothing else both in legal and informal terminology.
It cannot be rendered any differently and to do so harms the principle of fidelity which MUST permeate any translation work.
The translator cannot substitute falsification for false for however close meanings these terms may have they do not mean the exact same thing especially in light of legal terminology which is the type of terminology in which those notes were jotted.
The Portuguese term for "false" is "falso" and the term "falso" can also be translated into English by the terms "fake" and "phony". In Portuguese language words are not neutral, they are either male or female. The term "allegation" is translated as "alegação" in singular or "alegações" in plural and both these substantives are female terms in Portuguese language and therefore any adjective related to them need to be declined into its feminine form so it would necessarily be written out as "falsa" in singular ou "falsas" in plural.
What is written in the original is "falsificação" and not "falsas alegações" as suggested by the other group member. There is absolutely no room there for this suggested interpretation. The term "falsificação" especially in this specific legal context can only be translated into English as "falsification".
Whether this person was a victim or a perpetrator of these crimes is simply not stated there. And the translator cannot interpret either way (as victim or perpetrator) without harming the principle of fidelity.
The translator is not the author and MUST not change neither meaning nor the style of the original when rendering any translation.
The entry besides the name of another employee of this list called "Vera Lucia Rodrigues de Almeida Valério" reads "Vitima dolosa" that is "fraudulent victim" in English.
And yet in another entry of this very list for a person called "Maria Isabel Ferreira Machado" it states "Has quitted in April 17th 07" and typed right besides this handwritten note is the date of her commencement of employment which is 03-19-2007. So she has held the job for less than a month!
What one can infer from these other notes is that they refer to any suspicious behaviour and any charge related events either as a perpetrator or a victim.
The only person that can been interpreted as a victim in this list is "Vera Lucia Rodrigues de Almeida Valério" for the entry besides her name does clearly states she was one.
Also besides Vitor's name is NOT written "burlador" or "burlão" or "burlante" or "burlista", nor "fasificador", nor "traficante" which would be translated as "stelionatary" or "scoffer" or "scammer" or "con artist", nor is it written "falsifier", nor "dealer" which would have clearly indicate he was a perpetrator of these crimes.
Any assumptions either way pertain to the reader and the reader alone. Neither the author nor the translator have given any indication that should lead to such interpretations."
-
The only term I did not understand was stelionate.
http://freefactfinder.com/definition/Stelionate.html
Definition of Stelionate
Stel"lion*ate (?), n. [L. stellionatus cozenage, trickery, fr. stellio a newt, a crafty, knavish person.] (Scots & Roman Law) Any fraud not distinguished by a more special name; -- chiefly applied to sales of the same property to two different persons, or selling that for one's own which belongs to another, etc. Erskine.
-
Another important observation by Laura
"That's because the people who probably rendered the translations were not professional translators. So even if they had good command of both languages they had no know how pertaining to this job. Also did not speak to each other. And until all is done it is quite common to need to go back and re write some of the stuff. A glossary needs to be agreed upon by all translators so everybody sticks to the same terminology. It is a very large file. It equals to 6 or 7 books! I'd never seen such a large file. The largest was 500 hundred pages long. I wonder how long Bin Laden's file was. One has to respect the amazing amount of work that has been put in order for it to be created. I hope the result will be of better quality. If I was to work on it and nothing else it would take some 10 months to do it all. I doubt even the hired version was done by a single translator. And perhaps some important details might have been lost even in the hired version...
... Need context in order to fully affirm and only after I've gone through the whole thing will I be able to really say, but it seems to be related to charges either as a victim or as a perpetrator.
Laura does not rate Google translate highly ... " (I) Wonder why anybody pays translators if it just comes down to using google translator or a dictionary."
-
Most guests made requests but were aware that their requests might not be met. Look what is written on the Berry booking. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_334.jpg
The group were prepared to make an issue of it and asked for an assurance that they would be together. According to Matthew they got it too;
the operator had assured them accommodation sufficiently close together that, collectively, they had managed to assure the checking and supervision of their respective progeny. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
The only way Mark Warner could have assured them of that is if the Ocean Club, who were in charge of allocating guests to accommodation, had agreed. The Berry booking confirms that MW couldn't normally make such assurances.
I suspect that Vitor dos Santos knew that they wanted to be together and possibly knew why. I don't know if he was the only one who knew; that would depend in various factors.
1. If it was in his job description to make the decision or if he had to ask his boss.
2. How he, and other Ocean Club staff viewed MW, who were not just a tour operator making bookings, they were their new bosses.
3. How MW phrased the request. Was it as an order (because MW had misled the client into thinking there was a listening service). Or was it a favour; these clients want...Either way, the request came from MW. OC staff could be forgiven for assuming, therefore, that MW approved of their client's request.
4. Whether any of them thought it was up to them to dictate to clients how they cared for their children.
So you see, Rob, the situation was not a simple one. The clients in this case either misunderstood what was available or were misled. Either way, they wanted an assurance that they would be accommodated close to each other and they got it. Just as they wanted the times of the tennis events changed and they got it and they wanted a block booking at the Tapas and they got it. Whichever of them achieved all that should have gone to Reception to phone the police; Helder wouldn't have got rid of them so easily as he seems to have fobbed Matthew off.
The knowledge I speak of was gained while they were at OC but you do make a good point that the concept of providing their own babysitting service seems as if it was thought of prior to the holiday.