Exhibit A and the Trial of D'Andre Lane.

[Vertigo Swirl]

He hasn't claimed he is being framed has he?. He could pull the race card, but the he said it was black men who kidknapped his daughter...

Yes he has, by his ex I believe.

[faithlilly]

What an incredibly stupid question, imo.  What should I be doing bearing in mind I agree that she is likely dead and probably at the hands of her father however I’m not certain of this and think the evidence against him was weak.  I would not be hugely shocked if it turned out he was wrongfully convicted and the child was still alive, but you would presumably be utterly gobsmacked and massively disappointed to be proven wrong if this was the case.  I guess I’m just not as arrogant and dogmatic as you appear to be.

What convinces you that she is likely dead and her father is probably the perpetrator ?

[Wonderfulspam]

Well good for you!  Your certainty makes not a jot of difference to the fact that the evidence against him was weak.

The evidence was strong enough to convince a jury & that's all that matters.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Yes he has, by his ex I believe.

.
His ex believes him. He comes across as a 'gaslighter'.IMO.  Witnesses claimed he was cruel to the children what does mum say about that?   Anyone know?

[G-Unit]

Morse failed to alert to the car seat back at the station when it was wrapped in brown paper.

That was reported in a newspaper, but is it a fact?

[Mr Gray]

That was reported in a newspaper, but is it a fact?

Not if it doesn't suit you it seems.... Who do you think made it up

[Angelo222]

one of the judges in the Cipriano trial did not think she was guilty....there was an interview with GA and  a portuguese journalist who said most portuguese dont think shes guilty....i support her because I dont think she is a child killer

I agree but she was complicit in the cover-up so was guilty by way of joint enterprise. I also believe she was given too harsh a sentence whereas the real killer got a light one.

[Mr Gray]

I agree but she was complicit in the cover-up so was guilty by way of joint enterprise. I also believe she was given too harsh a sentence whereas the real killer got a light one.

What was she found guiltily of

[Vertigo Swirl]

What convinces you that she is likely dead and her father is probably the perpetrator ?

What convinces you I’m convinced?  I’m not.  I think on balance it’s likely but I have reasonable doubt also.

[Wonderfulspam]

What convinces you I’m convinced?  I’m not.  I think on balance it’s likely but I have reasonable doubt also.

Why?

What evidence makes you think it likely?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Why?

What evidence makes you think it likely?

His strict, bullying treatment of his children mainly, although by most accounts he was a good father.  Not all bullies  become killers though.

[faithlilly]

What convinces you I’m convinced?  I’m not.  I think on balance it’s likely but I have reasonable doubt also.

What makes you think it’s likely then if not all bullies become killers ?

[Vertigo Swirl]

What makes you think it’s likely then if not all bullies become killers ?

The fact that some do.

[faithlilly]

The fact that some do.

But the majority don’t. Is that really all that it took to make you think that it was likely Lane was guilty ?

What if Gerry McCann is a bully ? Would it make it more likely that he was guilty of some part in Madeleine’s disappearance?

[Vertigo Swirl]

But the majority don’t. Is that really all that it took to make you think that it was likely Lane was guilty ?

What if Gerry McCann is a bully ? Would it make it more likely that he was guilty of some part in Madeleine’s disappearance?

If he was known to ram wet knickers into his child’s mouth and hit them with sticks, yes, definitely.