Author Topic: Could the PJ have asked every male between 20 and 50 to give a DNA sample?  (Read 4204 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline alphonse

The population of Luz was very small. I suppose this may have been out of bounds under Portugese law. The police never really had any good leads. No car sighted, no body found. No good ID of either Tannerman who is now thought to be Dr Totman or Smithman-- really almost zero to go on except Madeleine was not there when Kate checked. It is a most frustrating case

Offline Robittybob1

The population of Luz was very small. I suppose this may have been out of bounds under Portugese law. The police never really had any good leads. No car sighted, no body found. No good ID of either Tannerman who is now thought to be Dr Totman or Smithman-- really almost zero to go on except Madeleine was not there when Kate checked. It is a most frustrating case
How would taking all those samples and spending millions on the analysis really help?  I'm not aware they have a reference  crime scene DNA sample to compare it too.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline ShiningInLuz

The population of Luz was very small. I suppose this may have been out of bounds under Portugese law. The police never really had any good leads. No car sighted, no body found. No good ID of either Tannerman who is now thought to be Dr Totman or Smithman-- really almost zero to go on except Madeleine was not there when Kate checked. It is a most frustrating case

Basically, the PJ cannot take DNA from visitors or inhabitants, unless that person gives their agreement.

The vast bulk of the OC guests had long dispersed to foreign climes.
What's up, old man?

Offline Robittybob1

It has been done in other countries.

https://web.archive.org/web/20140415060905/http://www.hnkcnews.com/2014/04/14/france-tries-mass-dna-test-in-hunt-for-school-rapist/
"French police took DNA samples from hundreds of male pupils and staff on Monday in the hope the mass test could help them find the assailant who raped a 16-year-old girl in the toilets of a school in western France last September.

Two police officers were deployed to take DNA samples from under the tongues of 475 school boys, 31 teachers and 21 staff believed present at the premises of the Catholic secondary level school at the time of the attack.

The victim was attacked in the dark and unable to identify her attacker but police managed to retrieve her attacker’s DNA imprint from her clothing.

Six months on, the public prosecutor in the area decided to order mass DNA tests, which are due to be completed by mid-week, with test results expected in a month.

“The operation began calmly at 8 a.m.” Anne-Sophie Guilbot, a spokeswoman for the Fenelon-Notre-Dame school, told media.

Mass testing of the kind is rare even if DNA-checking has become far more widely used since it emerged in the late 1990s that police might have been able to nab serial rapist and killer.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline barrier

It has been done in other countries.

https://web.archive.org/web/20140415060905/http://www.hnkcnews.com/2014/04/14/france-tries-mass-dna-test-in-hunt-for-school-rapist/
"French police took DNA samples from hundreds of male pupils and staff on Monday in the hope the mass test could help them find the assailant who raped a 16-year-old girl in the toilets of a school in western France last September.

Two police officers were deployed to take DNA samples from under the tongues of 475 school boys, 31 teachers and 21 staff believed present at the premises of the Catholic secondary level school at the time of the attack.

The victim was attacked in the dark and unable to identify her attacker but police managed to retrieve her attacker’s DNA imprint from her clothing.

Six months on, the public prosecutor in the area decided to order mass DNA tests, which are due to be completed by mid-week, with test results expected in a month.

“The operation began calmly at 8 a.m.” Anne-Sophie Guilbot, a spokeswoman for the Fenelon-Notre-Dame school, told media.

Mass testing of the kind is rare even if DNA-checking has become far more widely used since it emerged in the late 1990s that police might have been able to nab serial rapist and killer.
But you have a known crime there Rob,in the McCann case its not known,The one you linked to had her attackers DNA,with out Madeleine or her cloths at the time where would any foreign DNA come from which could be linked to her disappearance.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline barrier

The population of Luz was very small. I suppose this may have been out of bounds under Portugese law. The police never really had any good leads. No car sighted, no body found. No good ID of either Tannerman who is now thought to be Dr Totman or Smithman-- really almost zero to go on except Madeleine was not there when Kate checked. It is a most frustrating case

Interesting age range in the title, why that particular range,and also why not women,if one is going for an imaginary scenario of abduction just because at least one unidentified male remains unknown,to the general public at least,why not an a female accomplish?
Bolded bit its only frustrating if one is of a mind they think they can solve it.

 
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Holly Goodhead

It has been done in other countries.

https://web.archive.org/web/20140415060905/http://www.hnkcnews.com/2014/04/14/france-tries-mass-dna-test-in-hunt-for-school-rapist/
"French police took DNA samples from hundreds of male pupils and staff on Monday in the hope the mass test could help them find the assailant who raped a 16-year-old girl in the toilets of a school in western France last September.

Two police officers were deployed to take DNA samples from under the tongues of 475 school boys, 31 teachers and 21 staff believed present at the premises of the Catholic secondary level school at the time of the attack.

The victim was attacked in the dark and unable to identify her attacker but police managed to retrieve her attacker’s DNA imprint from her clothing.

Six months on, the public prosecutor in the area decided to order mass DNA tests, which are due to be completed by mid-week, with test results expected in a month.

“The operation began calmly at 8 a.m.” Anne-Sophie Guilbot, a spokeswoman for the Fenelon-Notre-Dame school, told media.

Mass testing of the kind is rare even if DNA-checking has become far more widely used since it emerged in the late 1990s that police might have been able to nab serial rapist and killer.

In the case you've quoted above a rape took place so presumably the perp left behind semen?  If this is the situation here then its completely different from 5A in that the forensic scientists have a clear reference sample ie the semen and this will not be analysed by LCN.  With LCN it is not even possible to identify the biological source eg blood, skin cells, semen etc.

With LCN a swab is collected but nothing identifying is seen on it with the naked eye.  The collection might contain thousands of skin cells from various individuals some of which might be incomplete and/or degraded from say heat or sunglight hence in the case of 5A the results were deemed "inconclusive". 
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline alphonse

Thanks for the replies. I know we don´t know exactly what crime was commited. Good point about a woman.I do think the case is frustrating in the sense the police were very unlucky, didn´t get any real breaks. Of course if it had been solved we probably would not be talking so much about it and looking at another case

Offline Holly Goodhead

Thanks for the replies. I know we don´t know exactly what crime was commited. Good point about a woman.I do think the case is frustrating in the sense the police were very unlucky, didn´t get any real breaks. Of course if it had been solved we probably would not be talking so much about it and looking at another case

I've looked at 4 cases in any sort of detail excl this one: Bamber, Bain, Jill Dando/Barry George and murders at Rettendon/Steele and Whomes.  Bamber imo is definitely a miscarriage of justice.  I'm inclined to see Steel/Whomes also as a miscarriage of justice.  Bain and George had their convictions overturned rightfully so imo.  Jill Dando's killer still remains at large and she was shot at point blank range at circa 11.30 am on a busy London street in Fulham.  This case, MM, imo is solvable and will be solved but has been hampered by the McCanns 'Find Madeleine' campaign which generated too much poor quality material and caused the investigation to go all over the place.   
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Robittybob1

I've looked at 4 cases in any sort of detail excl this one: Bamber, Bain, Jill Dando/Barry George and murders at Rettendon/Steele and Whomes.  Bamber imo is definitely a miscarriage of justice.  I'm inclined to see Steel/Whomes also as a miscarriage of justice.  Bain and George had their convictions overturned rightfully so imo.  Jill Dando's killer still remains at large and she was shot at point blank range at circa 11.30 am on a busy London street in Fulham.  This case, MM, imo is solvable and will be solved but has been hampered by the McCanns 'Find Madeleine' campaign which generated too much poor quality material and caused the investigation to go all over the place.
Have you got any evidence supporting your opinion that  "'Find Madeleine' campaign which generated too much poor quality material and caused the investigation to go all over the place"?
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Miss Taken Identity

Have you got any evidence supporting your opinion that  "'Find Madeleine' campaign which generated too much poor quality material and caused the investigation to go all over the place"?


I do believe that to be the case as well, I would also add the biggest issue was what I believe as a red herring the parents version about timelines- and the huge bit about the jemmied shutters/window access/exit  for an abduction in the initial claims.  Dismissing out of hand woke and wandered ans being VERY defensive about their own behaviour.
'Never underestimate the power of stupid people'... George Carlin

Offline Holly Goodhead


I do believe that to be the case as well, I would also add the biggest issue was what I believe as a red herring the parents version about timelines- and the huge bit about the jemmied shutters/window access/exit  for an abduction in the initial claims.  Dismissing out of hand woke and wandered ans being VERY defensive about their own behaviour.

Yes I agree. 
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline The General

Thanks for the replies. I know we don´t know exactly what crime was commited. Good point about a woman.I do think the case is frustrating in the sense the police were very unlucky, didn´t get any real breaks. Of course if it had been solved we probably would not be talking so much about it and looking at another case
The police did solve it. They even published a report. They just couldn't prove it.
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline Robittybob1

Holly a few posts up I asked a question:

"Have you got any evidence supporting your opinion that  "'Find Madeleine' campaign which generated too much poor quality material and caused the investigation to go all over the place"?"
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Robittybob1

The police did solve it. They even published a report. They just couldn't prove it.
I'd call that "just another theory"
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.