To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough. Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body. Also, it seems to me Gerry could not be Smithman. The Smith´s grandson said this man was wearing a long coat or a dark jacket. Silvia said Gerry was wearing a dark shirt. Are we sure Smithman is the suspect? 0f course not but it is one of the few things to go on in this case. No strange sightings of cars, Jane´s sighting discounted by SY--- Mrs Totman telling press they think this was Dr Totman etc.
To me the perp is likely an Anglo or at least someone who understands English and quite likely between 30 and 40 years old. He is also someone who either had access to the checking info or stumbled across it either visually as the Mc Canns said good night to their friends on the way up the hill every night or through loose talk about the partying doctors and their unusual checking regime