Is It Possible For A Non Professional Investigator To Solve The Case?

[Vertigo Swirl]

So it was a holiday maker who was staying at the same resort as Madeleine McCann when she went missing and who came home with an extra child and no one noticed. OK, sounds plausible.   

[Holly Goodhead]

Excuse me, but I only have your word for it that your theory is extremely well thought out, and that all the pieces fit together puuuuuurfectly.   Am I just supposed to congratulate and thank you without knowing any detail?   I'm sure if you had the courage of your convictions you would post your theory in the private section of this forum for all of us to marvel over, or more likely tell you why it wasn't so perfect after all, which is no doubt the real reason you don't want to tell us.

I do have the courage of my convictions that's why I'm not posting it as I promised OG I wouldn't.

You seem to want to ridicule everyone Vertigo Swirl ranging from those who believe the McCanns were responsible to the likes of myself who have forwarded to OG a well thought out theory that fits together puuuuurfectly and identifies the suspects behind a stranger abduction.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I do have the courage of my convictions that's why I'm not posting it as I promised OG I wouldn't.

You seem to want to ridicule everyone Vertigo Swirl ranging from those who believe the McCanns were responsible to the likes of myself who have forwarded to OG a well thought out theory that fits together puuuuurfectly and identifies the suspects behind a stranger abduction.

You have invited ridicule upon yourself I'm afraid, you must surely have anticipated this? 

[Holly Goodhead]

So it was a holiday maker who was staying at the same resort as Madeleine McCann when she went missing and who came home with an extra child and no one noticed. OK, sounds plausible.   

MTI raised the same point.  Problem for you guys is that my theory covers this off. 

[Holly Goodhead]

You have invited ridicule upon yourself I'm afraid, you must surely have anticipated this?

Who exactly has ridiculed me/my claims?  You have but most haven't and/or have simply ignored me.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Who exactly has ridiculed me/my claims?  You have but most haven't and/or have simply ignored me.

I don't think I'm alone in believing your claim is ridiculous. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

MTI raised the same point.  Problem for you guys is that my theory covers this off.

It's not a problem, just tell us how, otherwise expect further ridicule. 

[ShiningInLuz]

It's not a problem, just tell us how, otherwise expect further ridicule.

I have chosen to 'ignore' Holly as I am not in possession of sufficient knowledge to praise or ridicule Holly's theory.

That you have chosen ridicule in absence of knowledge speaks volumes.

But OMG, it has gone beyond boring now.  Can't you find a new game to play?

[Mr Gray]

I have chosen to 'ignore' Holly as I am not in possession of sufficient knowledge to praise or ridicule Holly's theory.

That you have chosen ridicule in absence of knowledge speaks volumes.

But OMG, it has gone beyond boring now.  Can't you find a new game to play?

I have enough knowledge to know that what Holly is claiming is absurd

[Vertigo Swirl]

I have chosen to 'ignore' Holly as I am not in possession of sufficient knowledge to praise or ridicule Holly's theory.

That you have chosen ridicule in absence of knowledge speaks volumes.

But OMG, it has gone beyond boring now.  Can't you find a new game to play?

No.  Butt out. 

[Mr Gray]

Posters have been sanctioned for posting about the abductor... As though it were a fact... Now it seems its perfectly acceptable.

So that's one positive... Is now acceptable to state as a fact that maddie was abducted

[Mr Gray]

Who exactly has ridiculed me/my claims?  You have but most haven't and/or have simply ignored me.

Myself... G-Unit. VS... Faith... Posters who have been following the case for years.... But you think Stacy Solomon and Coleen Nolan know as much about the case as we do... Are those the experts you have posted about

[Mr Gray]

I wonder what Holly's excuses will be when nothing comes of her emails to SY and the PJ

[Vertigo Swirl]

I wonder what Holly's excuses will be when nothing comes of her emails to SY and the PJ

That they aren’t trained to think out of the box probably.

[ShiningInLuz]

I have enough knowledge to know that what Holly is claiming is absurd

Coming from the man who claimed that one could do 200kph on the EN125?

What knowledge do you have, o wise one?