Is It Possible For A Non Professional Investigator To Solve The Case?

[Mr Gray]

Tell Kate that.  She thinks it is a very real possibility.  The evidence of it is what Madeleine said, and the "tea stain".
Or are you denying those too?

What did madeleine say... You changed it.. Stick to the facts

[Mr Gray]

Do you know what was in the UK police files?

Yes.. So Where's the confirmation of a couple entering that apt to comfort maddie

[Robittybob1]

What did madeleine say... You changed it.. Stick to the facts

No one accurately remembers what Madeleine said.  There are several versions quoted in interviews over the years.

[Robittybob1]

Yes.. So Where's the confirmation of a couple entering that apt to comfort maddie

Was that "yes" an answer to the question: "Do you know what was in the UK police files?"?

[Mr Gray]

No one accurately remembers what Madeleine said.  There are several versions quoted in interviews over the years.

could you quote the one you claimed   it seems to me youve made it up

[Mr Gray]

Was that "yes" an answer to the question: "Do you know what was in the UK police files?"?

of course I do...and thwere is nothing in the files about a couple enetering 5a to comfort maddie

[Robittybob1]

could you quote the one you claimed   it seems to me youve made it up

I admit in the post it was a possible meaning to what Madeleine said.  I've never denied that.

My post was in http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10983.msg553403#msg553403

"Whatever, Kate sees the stain on the pyjamas I think she has some proof someone else came into their apartment.
Madeleine basically asked "why did someone else come and not you?""

[Mr Gray]

No one accurately remembers what Madeleine said.  There are several versions quoted in interviews over the years.

whio says no one remembers...where are these different accounts...more making things up

[Mr Gray]

I admit in the post it was a possible meaning to what Madeleine said.  I've never denied that.

so it wa s just your opinion

[Robittybob1]

whio says no one remembers...where are these different accounts...more making things up

Come on Davel are you admitting you are not aware of at least three versions of what Kate and Gerry remember Madeleine saying? I thought you were up to date on this case. 

[Mr Gray]

Come on Davel are you admitting you are not aware of at least three versions of what Kate and Gerry remember Madeleine saying? I thought you were up to date on this case.

i am...so can you cite the three and we can leave it there...simple as that

[Robittybob1]

so it wa s just your opinion

A very considered opinion yes.

[Mr Gray]

A very considered opinion yes.

That's your opinion too.. I think you've posted an absolute load of rubbish... I'm off to watch University Challenge now

[Robittybob1]

i am...so can you cite the three and we can leave it there...simple as that

Will you give me an apology when I do?  I've read the  three versions may times and I don't think it is a big deal but the sceptics make a big deal from it and you want me to repeat it!

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10983.msg553435#msg553435 is worthy of an apology IMO.

[Robittybob1]

That's your opinion too.. I think you've posted an absolute load of rubbish... I'm off to watch University Challenge now

Good on you.