Is It Possible For A Non Professional Investigator To Solve The Case?

[Myster]

Hi Myster, I apologise for asking: are you sincere in saying this?

Hi Anthro, no need to apologise.  Of course I am... absolutely!

Are you not confident in your own judgement?

[Anthro]

Thank you, Myster. I am not British, thus I am not always sure how to interpret comments. And, yes I am confident the person who might have been involved in removing Madeleine, in whichever way, has been overlooked due to his predatory profile. Criminal activity is diverse.

[Myster]

Thank you, Myster. I am not British, thus I am not always sure how to interpret comments. And, yes I am confident the person who might have been involved in removing Madeleine, in whichever way, has been overlooked due to his predatory profile. Criminal activity is diverse.

I'm mostly serious, but sometimes like to joke. I've known Holly for years here, but she takes my occasional ribbing in good heart... I think!

As I understand it, your suspect was arrested last year in Spain and is currently on trial for a 1998 child murder in Netherlands.

[Anthro]

I don’t have a theory, merely a line of thinking and a tentative hypothesis. I will happily share it with you, but not in the way you commented on Holly’s theory on this forum. She has entrusted you and your initial response was, in my view, harsh and judgmental.

[Myster]

I don’t have a theory, merely a line of thinking and a tentative hypothesis. I will happily share it with you, but not in the way you commented on Holly’s theory on this forum. She has entrusted you and your initial response was, in my view, harsh and judgmental.

Sorry if you feel that way, but I don't believe Holly's theory stands up at all.  I also feel she should have restrained herself from boasting that she had cracked the case and from contacting OG without anyone here having a clue who she suspected, which left them guessing and resulted in inevitable insults.

Share your thoughts by all means if you wish and I'll try hard to contain myself!

[John]

So you think the police should be giving Holly’s theory the time of day and should be putting resources into investigating her suspects do you?

I would have hoped that the individuals concerned had been scrutinised already.

Holly's theory is certainly plausible and as I haven't seen it suggested here previously, full marks for thinking outside the box.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I would have hoped that the individuals concerned had been scrutinised already.

Holly's theory is certainly plausible and as I haven't seen it suggested here previously, full marks for thinking outside the box.

What motive was given?

[Holly Goodhead]

I would have hoped that the individuals concerned had been scrutinised already.

Holly's theory is certainly plausible and as I haven't seen it suggested here previously, full marks for thinking outside the box.

Thanks John.

I agree in an ideal world investigating authorities would have scrutinised and either eliminated or pursued further. 

 

[Holly Goodhead]

What motive was given?

I made it clear to John (and Myster) that if my theory/suspects are correct I cannot be sure of the motive and put forward different scenarios in this regard.  I'm inclined towards thinking to raise as own and yes I have thought through all the obstacles as to how an abducted child could be incorporated into the lives of seemingly 'normal' people all of which I put to Myster and John. 

My suspects are seemingly wealthy with business connections in Europe which would allow them to roam the Schengen Area unfettered.  I do not believe they have any close immediate family although do have extended family but how close I have no idea.

[Holly Goodhead]

I don’t have a theory, merely a line of thinking and a tentative hypothesis. I will happily share it with you, but not in the way you commented on Holly’s theory on this forum. She has entrusted you and your initial response was, in my view, harsh and judgmental.

Myster and I go back a long way on the Bamber board and I'm use to his idiosyncrasies.  He wasn't as harsh and judgmental in his personal feedback.   

[Mr Gray]

I made it clear to John (and Myster) that if my theory/suspects are correct I cannot be sure of the motive and put forward different scenarios in this regard.  I'm inclined towards thinking to raise as own and yes I have thought through all the obstacles as to how an abducted child could be incorporated into the lives of seemingly 'normal' people all of which I put to Myster and John. 

My suspects are seemingly wealthy with business connections in Europe which would allow them to roam the Schengen Area unfettered.  I do not believe they have any close immediate family although do have extended family but how close I have no idea.

Jihn said your theory is plausible.... As are many.  As I have already said you have a possible solution but your claim to have solved the case is not supported by John... And Myster is quite scathing pointing out that your theory doesn't stand up... Both the posts by John and Myster support what I have said about your theory

[Vertigo Swirl]

I made it clear to John (and Myster) that if my theory/suspects are correct I cannot be sure of the motive and put forward different scenarios in this regard.  I'm inclined towards thinking to raise as own and yes I have thought through all the obstacles as to how an abducted child could be incorporated into the lives of seemingly 'normal' people all of which I put to Myster and John. 

My suspects are seemingly wealthy with business connections in Europe which would allow them to roam the Schengen Area unfettered.  I do not believe they have any close immediate family although do have extended family but how close I have no idea.

Where are these suspects living now?

[Mr Gray]

Myster and I go back a long way on the Bamber board and I'm use to his idiosyncrasies.  He wasn't as harsh and judgmental in his personal feedback.

It's, what he posts in public that counts and his post is scathing about your theory and claims

[ShiningInLuz]

Where are these suspects living now?

Wealthy and free to roam the Schengen area.  Surely that covers it.

[Holly Goodhead]

It's, what he posts in public that counts and his post is scathing about your theory and claims

I'm not getting dragged into all of this Davel.  I've shared my suspects/theory with John and Myster and each has given his opinion.  Nuff said.