A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Anthro]

Thank you, KMC. Do you perhaps have a picture and/or reference of the person you are referring to?

[Brietta]

Here's Amaral's theory!

Gonçalo Amaral in El Mundo: Gerry McCann hid Madeleine corpse in the Beach

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1857.msg58322#msg5832

_________________________________________________________

Q - So, what are we talking about?

Amaral - About an accident. The child could have fallen from a sofa, could have had an accident with Calpol (a sleeping solution). We never had access to the girl’s medical history, so we don’t know whether she was healthy or not. We can only speculate. There are many very strange details.

_________________________________________________________

And how do you hide the corpse of a girl of nearly four years old so that no one can't find it?

A – This is what we were investigating when I was dismissed from the case. I want to recall that there is an Irish man who claimed to have seen Gerry McCann with a girl in his arms, on his way towards the beach that same night. That testimony has been hidden. The dogs specialized in finding traces of blood and odour of cadaver, found both in the wall of the apartment and in the boot of the car that the McCann rented 23 days later.

_________________________________________________________

He wrote a book and he made a media career for himself built on theories such as those above; were they good, bad or average theories he has promulgated for all those years?

[Brietta]

Here's Amaral's theory!

Gonçalo Amaral in El Mundo: Gerry McCann hid Madeleine corpse in the Beach

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1857.msg58322#msg5832

_________________________________________________________

Q - So, what are we talking about?

Amaral - About an accident. The child could have fallen from a sofa, could have had an accident with Calpol (a sleeping solution). We never had access to the girl’s medical history, so we don’t know whether she was healthy or not. We can only speculate. There are many very strange details.

_________________________________________________________

And how do you hide the corpse of a girl of nearly four years old so that no one can't find it?

A – This is what we were investigating when I was dismissed from the case. I want to recall that there is an Irish man who claimed to have seen Gerry McCann with a girl in his arms, on his way towards the beach that same night. That testimony has been hidden. The dogs specialized in finding traces of blood and odour of cadaver, found both in the wall of the apartment and in the boot of the car that the McCann rented 23 days later.

_________________________________________________________

He wrote a book and he made a media career for himself built on theories such as those above; were they good, bad or average theories he has promulgated for all those years?

Amaral claims "There are many very strange details."

If that is a fact ... which of these 'strange details' have been proven or are they all figments of a febrile imagination which didn't have a grasp of what was going on around him ?

[jassi]

Good to see you giving him publicity    

[The General]

Good to see you giving him publicity   

Top lad. He's looking well.

[John]

Amaral claims "There are many very strange details."

If that is a fact ... which of these 'strange details' have been proven or are they all figments of a febrile imagination which didn't have a grasp of what was going on around him ?

To be honest, I believe Gonçalo will always be haunted by the need to have his theory vindicated. I also believe that he genuinely holds the belief that Madeleine's parents were in some way involved in her disappearance. Unfortunately for him however, it would appear that the authorities are no closer to solving this case than he was 12 years ago. 

[pathfinder73]

I agree with Amaral's theory as it connects with the strange timelines. Matt 21:50 Gerry 22:13 - time to get real.

[barrier]

To be honest, I believe Gonçalo will always be haunted by the need to have his theory vindicated. I also believe that he genuinely holds the belief that Madeleine's parents were in some way involved in her disappearance. Unfortunately for him however, it would appear that the authorities are no closer to solving this case than he was 12 years ago.

OG will always be haunted imo by its failure,its seeing off numerous DCI's , commissioners plus assistant commissioners.

[jassi]

OG will always be haunted imo by its failure,its seeing off numerous DCI's , commissioners plus assistant commissioners.

Certainly it seems  the graveyard for DCIs - probably other ranks as well

[Mr Gray]

To be honest, I believe Gonçalo will always be haunted by the need to have his theory vindicated. I also believe that he genuinely holds the belief that Madeleine's parents were in some way involved in her disappearance. Unfortunately for him however, it would appear that the authorities are no closer to solving this case than he was 12 years ago.

But the PJ have made it clear the McCanns are not suspects and theres no evidence against them and i think its clear they are not being investigated

[Brietta]

But the PJ have made it clear the McCanns are not suspects and theres no evidence against them and i think its clear they are not being investigated

But what is crystal clear is that the Policia Judiciaria and Scotland Yard have continued the investigation into the who, the what and the why of Madeleine's disappearance and at the moment I don't think there is any sign of them giving up on her just yet.

I think that in a nutshell knocks Amaral's theories into a cocked hat.

[jassi]

Best  to wait for them to come up with their solution before discarding anyone else's - IMO

[Brietta]

To be honest, I believe Gonçalo will always be haunted by the need to have his theory vindicated. I also believe that he genuinely holds the belief that Madeleine's parents were in some way involved in her disappearance. Unfortunately for him however, it would appear that the authorities are no closer to solving this case than he was 12 years ago.

I think he had so much invested in the vindication of his vendetta against Madeleine's parents from the word go that any consideration for Madeleine or her wellbeing went right out of the window along with the whooshing curtains.

In my opinion if he is waiting for any of his absurd and indeed vicious theories to come to fruition he is going to have a very long wait; much of his 'professional' support lies as we have seen with criminal cops himself not excluded; I think Amaral must be an embarrassment if not a total laughing stock as far as the guys conducting the case presently are concerned.

His investigation into Madeleine's case lasted a couple of months before he publicly changed tack completely and backed the wrong horse.
I think it is telling that the initial investigation into a missing child which lasted no more than three months had to be continued privately by her parents' initiative and continues to be under investigation more than twelve years after her disappearance.

[jassi]

The initial investigation lasted until the Portuguese  closed the case and published their files.
Rather more than 3 months.

[Eleanor]

The initial investigation lasted until the Portuguese  closed the case and published their files.
Rather more than 3 months.

Didn't they do well.

I don't think Amaral cared at all.  He desperately needed The McCanns to be guilty.  The man is a convicted criminal along with his best buddy who went down to The Algarve at the time that Leonor Cipriano suffered such awful injuries.