A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Miss Taken Identity]

Pretty odd, knowing the Scouse female in intimate detail. None, and I mean none I have come across would opt to simply run across and then create a fuss, not if their husband was within earshot and not as an instinctive reaction.
But feel free to think I think it's also suspicious if you think it somehow discloses my real opinion.

The abduction theory is put out by the McCanns. I find it easy to disregard it even as a possibility.
Because .  IF you KNEW your daughter had been abducted, any normal parent would shout very loudly   “my daughter has been abducted help! help!” Or someone call the police.

 Kate claims she said “Madeleine is gone” after running to the tapas area to alert the group. The reason I would give for their behaviour in those ‘crucial’ moments (if the crucial moments were between 9.30 and 10pm as they claim), is ; they all went back to the apartment to discuss what they were going to do, and what to explain to people about children being left alone every night. Especially, when there was sufficient child minding services available.

Not to mention their claim that they were like sitting in a garden like. So, if they are so close, as they claim then Kate would not have been required to shout very loud at all., OR leave the twins!

[Vertigo Swirl]

Read it back, lid.
The 'that I have come across' bit is a hint.

So.  You’re from Scouseland.  You must have encountered quite a few Scouse women in  your time, and I’m not just talking about the ones you’ve known intimately, but ALL the ones you have ever encountered would behave in the same way?  That’s some generalisation.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Read it back, lid.
The 'that I have come across' bit is a hint.

PS: “Lid”?  I hope this is not a derivation of Thalidomide? 

[Wonderfulspam]

The abduction theory is put out by the McCanns. I find it easy to disregard it even as a possibility.
Because .  IF you KNEW your daughter had been abducted, any normal parent would shout very loudly   “my daughter has been abducted help! help!” Or someone call the police.

 Kate claims she said “Madeleine is gone” after running to the tapas area to alert the group. The reason I would give for their behaviour in those ‘crucial’ moments (if the crucial moments were between 9.30 and 10pm as they claim), is ; they all went back to the apartment to discuss what they were going to do, and what to explain to people about children being left alone every night. Especially, when there was sufficient child minding services available.

Not to mention their claim that they were like sitting in a garden like. So, if they are so close, as they claim then Kate would not have been required to shout very loud at all., OR leave the twins!

I'd have my mobile in hand ringing the police immediately.

The excuses given are that they didn't know the number, seriously, who goes on holiday to a foreign paedophile hell hole & doesn't make a note of the emergency service number?

Then there's the language barrier, guaranteed if you stayed on the line long enough you would be put through to an English speaker imo

But Kate & Gerry tried none of that, despite the immediate paedo abduction certainty, it was left to Fiona to suggest to Matt that he goes to reception, while Kate screamed b*****ds.

[Mr Gray]

The abduction theory is put out by the McCanns. I find it easy to disregard it even as a possibility.
Because .  IF you KNEW your daughter had been abducted, any normal parent would shout very loudly   “my daughter has been abducted help! help!” Or someone call the police.

 Kate claims she said “Madeleine is gone” after running to the tapas area to alert the group. The reason I would give for their behaviour in those ‘crucial’ moments (if the crucial moments were between 9.30 and 10pm as they claim), is ; they all went back to the apartment to discuss what they were going to do, and what to explain to people about children being left alone every night. Especially, when there was sufficient child minding services available.

Not to mention their claim that they were like sitting in a garden like. So, if they are so close, as they claim then Kate would not have been required to shout very loud at all., OR leave the twins!

I've said for a long time abduction is the odds on favourite based on the evidence... and it seems SY agrees with me

[Miss Taken Identity]

I've said for a long time abduction is the odds on favourite based on the evidence... and it seems SY agrees with me

The evidence you rely on is based on parents statements-which has been shown to be inaccurate in some instances. Therefore, your theory is based on opinion.

SY have not said MBM was abducted as described by the parents. It seems you are havering.

[Wonderfulspam]

I've said for a long time abduction is the odds on favourite based on the evidence... and it seems SY agrees with me

But not the PJ apparently, they don't know what happened. Just being awkward aren't they.

[Mr Gray]

The evidence you rely on is based on parents statements-which has been shown to be inaccurate in some instances. Therefore, your theory is based on opinion.

SY have not said MBM was abducted as described by the parents. It seems you are havering.

Not just parents statements..
SY spokesman... However she left the apartment she was abducted.

The PJ have said the mccanns are not susoects and there's no evidence against them

[Miss Taken Identity]

But not the PJ apparently, they don't know what happened. Just being awkward aren't they.

At least the PJ aknowledged MBM came to some harm. Unlike the parents claiming she came to 'no harm'!. ???

The PJ were looking at woke and wandered, had an accident as far as I am aware. They obviously saw the McCann version as being questionable IMO.

[Mr Gray]

At least the PJ aknowledged MBM came to some harm. Unlike the parents claiming she came to 'no harm'!. ???

The PJ were looking at woke and wandered, had an accident as far as I am aware. They obviously saw the stupidity of the McCann version right away.

If you read, the, archiving report you will see how  wrong you are.. The pj rated woke, and, wandered as highly unlikely

[John]

I've said for a long time abduction is the odds on favourite based on the evidence... and it seems SY agrees with me

Strange that given no such evidence exists!  ...but then you know that.

[Mr Gray]

Strange that given no such evidence exists!  ...but then you know that.

Plenty of circumstantial evidence....

[Wonderfulspam]

Plenty of circumstantial evidence....

So let's revisit this topic.

Start a new thread, The Plenty Of Circumstantial Evidence Of Abduction.

Should give us something to talk about.

[John]

Plenty of circumstantial evidence....

An open window with only Kate's fingerprints identified?

I think posters need to discriminate between abducted from the bedroom or abducted from the street outside.

[Mr Gray]

Strange that given no such evidence exists!  ...but then you know that.

I've challenged posters to give a breakdown of the odds as they see them as, to what happened, to Maddie... No ones, had the conviction to answer