A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Mr Gray]

Either you get humour or you don't.

Amaral pointed out that it wasn't him who mentioned Ney, it was the UK press. He also pointed out that the 'abductor' was 'similar, almost the same' to Gerry McCann, which Ney isn't.

Humour is subjective... It's not a matter of getting it or not.
I don't like jokes at maddies expense... Some do

[Brietta]

I see that our most senior and highly respected  sceptic G-Unit (who claims no one here believes the McCanns were involved in Madeleine’s disappearance) has liked Wonderfulspam’s facetious and nonsensical reply to my post.  Does she too understand the interview with Amaral to mean “the parents dunnit”?

To be fair in the absence of an English transcript, it is a very good guess.  Since as far as I can make out Amaral has dedicated himself to pushing that particular theme since 2007 using various theories which although patently nonsensical are avidly accepted by his following.

The 'swingers' ... the tennis bag ... the fridge ... and that is just for starters.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Either you get humour or you don't.

Amaral pointed out that it wasn't him who mentioned Ney, it was the UK press. He also pointed out that the 'abductor' was 'similar, almost the same' to Gerry McCann, which Ney isn't.

Oh I see, you're choosing to believe the Mail's coverage now are you?  So you think Amaral's having a laugh, is that it?  Where does the German paedo fit into it then?  Is he a police suspect or not, in your view?

[G-Unit]

Oh I see, you're choosing to believe the Mail's coverage now are you?  So you think Amaral's having a laugh, is that it?  Where does the German paedo fit into it then?  Is he a police suspect or not, in your view?

In my opinion when Amaral said what he did to Mark Saunokonoko he was suggesting that OG might be trying to close the case by involving a German paedophile. Then the UK newspapers raised the possibility that the man was Ney. Amaral was rejecting that possibility in the interview, saying it wasn't Ney he was talking about, it was someone else.

He also pointed out that in his opinion Gerry McCann or someone looking very similar to him was involved, and Ney looks nothing like him.
https://www.cuatro.com/enelpuntodemira/comisario-portugues-gonzalo-amaral-madeleine-mccann-pedofilo_18_2857845411.html

[Vertigo Swirl]

In my opinion when Amaral said what he did to Mark Saunokonoko he was suggesting that OG might be trying to close the case by involving a German paedophile. Then the UK newspapers raised the possibility that the man was Ney. Amaral was rejecting that possibility in the interview, saying it wasn't Ney he was talking about, it was someone else.

He also pointed out that in his opinion Gerry McCann or someone looking very similar to him was involved, and Ney looks nothing like him.
https://www.cuatro.com/enelpuntodemira/comisario-portugues-gonzalo-amaral-madeleine-mccann-pedofilo_18_2857845411.html

Can you provide a cite from this latest report where Amaral says Gerry McCann (or someone looking similar) was involved, ta.  My interpretation is that Amaral is trying to excuse away the Smithman sighting by claiming this German paedo bears a physical resemblance to Gerry McCann.  He does not say Gerry McCann was involved, not in this intereview anyway, in my opinion.  And, what is more interesting is a) how did he come by this info (PJ leaking again?) and b) how does this information square with the oft voiced belief that the McCanns are still prime suspects? 

[Mr Gray]

In my opinion when Amaral said what he did to Mark Saunokonoko he was suggesting that OG might be trying to close the case by involving a German paedophile. Then the UK newspapers raised the possibility that the man was Ney. Amaral was rejecting that possibility in the interview, saying it wasn't Ney he was talking about, it was someone else.

He also pointed out that in his opinion Gerry McCann or someone looking very similar to him was involved, and Ney looks nothing like him.
https://www.cuatro.com/enelpuntodemira/comisario-portugues-gonzalo-amaral-madeleine-mccann-pedofilo_18_2857845411.html

To use your words amaral is guessing based on smithman being the abductor and that the efits are accurate when it seems none of the Smiths saw the mans face...
As I said I dont think much if what amaral says... Perhaps
We will know when MI5 open their files.. Lol.


Some opinion and some fact

[Vertigo Swirl]

Interesting that Amaral is clearly entertaining the idea that Gerry wasn't involved now.  What happened to his unshakeable belief in his own theory? 

[G-Unit]

To use your words amaral is guessing based on smithman being the abductor and that the efits are accurate when it seems none of the Smiths saw the mans face...
As I said I dont think much if what amaral says... Perhaps
We will know when MI5 open their files.. Lol.


Some opinion and some fact

I also think he's referring to the Smith's evidence. The German paedophile is not part of his theory.

[Mr Gray]

I also think he's referring to the Smith's evidence. The German paedophile is not part of his theory.

But M15 is which I think is, derisory

[ShiningInLuz]

Interesting that Amaral is clearly entertaining the idea that Gerry wasn't involved now.  What happened to his unshakeable belief in his own theory?

As he was talking about a line of enquiry being pursued by current police, why do you keep mixing it up with whatever theory Amaral personally has?

[The General]

But M15 is which I think is, derisory

Libel!

[The General]

As he was talking about a line of enquiry being pursued by current police, why do you keep mixing it up with whatever theory Amaral personally has?

It's a wind up. A rubbish one at that.

[Vertigo Swirl]

As he was talking about a line of enquiry being pursued by current police, why do you keep mixing it up with whatever theory Amaral personally has?

"He also pointed out that in his opinion Gerry McCann or someone looking very similar to him was involved" - G-Unit.  Take it up with her.

[Vertigo Swirl]

It's a wind up. A rubbish one at that.

What are you on about?

[Angelo222]

I dont see amaral as a reliable source of information

Whyever not?   He was after all privy to everything the police knew about the case and the parents unlike us cyber warriors.