A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Mr Gray]

Why bother?

He bothered

[Vertigo Swirl]

He bothered

And failed presumably.

[Mr Gray]

And failed presumably.

Yes

whats significant imo is that the pj didnt seem to mind who knew they had tortured cipriano....It seems they felt they could do as they wanted and were untouchable

[Brietta]

Well with an embarrassment of riches,OG can't ,just can't find anything to prove his theory is wrong.
Supporting evidence to the contary wouldn't go amiss considering the PJ in 2017 said in relation to the abduction theory,"we have to be prepared for different scenario's".

No-one requires to spend a brass farthing on any of Amaral's musings and I doubt if anyone either here nor in Portugal have ever paid him much never mind since independently reviewing the mess of an investigation he left behind him when he was sacked from Madeleine's case.  IMLO of course.

[Brietta]

Reading Amaral's book he mentions discussions and meetings within the PJ team and between the PJ and UK police also. You really should accept that he didn't he didn't think or act alone.

                           I really do accept "that he didn't think".

[ShiningInLuz]

No-one requires to spend a brass farthing on any of Amaral's musings and I doubt if anyone either here nor in Portugal have ever paid him much never mind since independently reviewing the mess of an investigation he left behind him when he was sacked from Madeleine's case.  IMLO of course.

Wrong.

[Brietta]

And failed presumably.

His criminal conviction was upheld.

[Brietta]

Wrong.

I may be wrong but I have outlined why I really believe I am absolutely correct in my assessment.  What a shame you are unable to uphold your opinion in similar fashion not having the ground to stand on :)  IMLO

[barrier]

Nope.  You got that wrong.  The question is - is he lying or has he been tipped off by the PJ? Which do you think?

Couldn't care less,the answer to the disappearance imo is not languishing in a foreign jail.

[Mr Gray]

Couldn't care less,the answer to the disappearance imo is not languishing in a foreign jail.

I couldn't care less as to what amaral.. A convicted liar... Has to say

[Brietta]

Nope.  You got that wrong.  The question is - is he lying or has he been tipped off by the PJ? Which do you think?

I think it shows there remains "wheels within wheels" with the old boy's network still breaking the secrecy law of an active criminal investigation.

[G-Unit]

                           I really do accept "that he didn't think".

I have offered evidence that;

Amaral was not in charge of the investigation and that the initial investigation did have brainstorming sessions. In my opinion your facetious replies are designed to deflect attention from your inability to find anything with which to refute that evidence.

[barrier]

I couldn't care less as to what amaral.. A convicted liar... Has to say

I some how doubt he know's nor cares.

[Mr Gray]

I some how doubt he know's nor cares.

He's the one making public statements...interesting that he's talking about the present Portuguese investigation... Doesn't seem as though the mccanns are being investigated  ..that must annoy him

[barrier]

He's the one making public statements...interesting that he's talking about the present Portuguese investigation... Doesn't seem as though the mccanns are being investigated  ..that must annoy him

Or there again rule the look a like out,doesn't leave much room for manoeuvre does it?