A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[G-Unit]

Calpol is not a sedative fact
There is no report anywhere in the world of a 4 yr old fallung off a sofa and dying.. Fact.

Sadie believes Maddie us, from a certain bloodline.. Fact

So it's possible that others, do.. Fact

Why do you cling to those two points so desperately? Dismissing them doesn't dismiss the possibility of sedation or death, you know.

Believing in something doesn't make it factual. Lots of people believe lots of things and a lot of the time they're wrong.

[Mr Gray]

Why do you cling to those two points so desperately? Dismissing them doesn't dismiss the possibility of sedation or death, you know.

Believing in something doesn't make it factual. Lots of people believe lots of things and a lot of the time they're wrong.

I don't cling to anything.  I repeat them because this is what amaral and according to amaral... What the initial investigation believed.  An investigation which you and others support as being competent when believing such rubbish is the height of incompetence

[G-Unit]

And you dismissing Sadies theory does not rule it out... That is another fact...

Of course not. It's right up there with the lizards, the end of the worlders, moon landing questioners and the twin tower conspiracies. None of them are impossible, but they are very very very unlikely.

[G-Unit]

I don't cling to anything.  I repeat them because this is what amaral and according to amaral... What the initial investigation believed.  An investigation which you and others support as being competent when believing such rubbish is the height of incompetence

One man does not an investigation make, despite some choosing to pretend he does. One man's hypotheses are not the only possibilities either.

In my opinion sedation could have occured without Calpol being involved at all. In my opinion death could have occured without a sofa being involved at all.

[Mr Gray]

One man does not an investigation make, despite some choosing to pretend he does. One man's hypotheses are not the only possibilities either.

In my opinion sedation could have occured without Calpol being involved at all. In my opinion death could have occured without a sofa being involved at all.

according to amaral his views reflected those of the entire team...his book was based on the police files...im sure you remember ...im pretending nothing you are totally mistaken

[Mr Gray]

Of course not. It's right up there with the lizards, the end of the worlders, moon landing questioners and the twin tower conspiracies. None of them are impossible, but they are very very very unlikely.

yet none have been ruled out...so to claim something has significance because it hasnt been ruled out ...is  a pretty pathetic argument.

[Eleanor]

Just Catholics? Other Christians are available.

I requested some care with language regarding Catholic Beliefs.  I did not ask for a lesson in Theology.

[Eleanor]

Of course not. It's right up there with the lizards, the end of the worlders, moon landing questioners and the twin tower conspiracies. None of them are impossible, but they are very very very unlikely.

I have already said that I am not having Sadie mocked anymore.  So don't go there again.

[G-Unit]

I have already said that I am not having Sadie mocked anymore.  So don't go there again.

I'm not mocking anyone. I reserve the right, however, to express my views on a theory which, in my opinion, is so out of the ordinary it is not believable. Theories should rest on evidence, not on myth in my opinion.

[Eleanor]

I'm not mocking anyone. I reserve the right, however, to express my views on a theory which, in my opinion, is so out of the ordinary it is not believable. Theories should rest on evidence, not on myth in my opinion.

So you agree that Sadie has a right to her opinion.

[The General]

My theory: Sergei Malinka and Robert Murat conspired with the T9 to sell MM to Moroccan carpet dealers in return for an antique Persian Mahal rug. The rug was sold at Sotheby's and the proceeds split evenly (minus commission).
All my opinion, of course. Please don't scrutinise it, or mock it in any way, as I may be offended.

[G-Unit]

So you agree that Sadie has a right to her opinion.

Everyone has a right to an opinion including me. If, in my opinion, Sadie's theory is beyond belief I have the right to say so imo.

[Eleanor]

Everyone has a right to an opinion including me. If, in my opinion, Sadie's theory is beyond belief I have the right to say so imo.

Beyond your belief.  Personally, I have a bit of a problem with your beliefs.  But I don't mock you.

[G-Unit]

Beyond your belief.  Personally, I have a bit of a problem with your beliefs.  But I don't mock you.

Thank you, but feel free to mock/criticise my beliefs if you wish. Just don't mock/criticise me as a person.

[Eleanor]

Thank you, but feel free to mock/criticise my beliefs if you wish. Just don't mock/criticise me as a person.

You do mock Sadie, so don't try The Semantics Game with me.  I am so much better at it than you are.