A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Mr Gray]

Hichens:That which can be asserted without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.”

Beat you too it.. What, are the chances of two posters coming up with the same quote at the same time

[barrier]

Beat you too it.. What, are the chances of two posters coming up with the same quote at the same time

University challenge.

[Mr Gray]

University challenge.

Dont spoil it

[The General]

Dont spoil it

s..mbag College

[G-Unit]

It's like the claim the McCanns are involved in their daughters disappearance..
That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence

It depends what you call evidence. In my opinion there's evidence that the McCanns were up to something. There's no evidence that their daughter had noteworthy DNA or that she was abducted to be kept until old enough to breed.

[Eleanor]

It depends what you call evidence. In my opinion there's evidence that the McCanns were up to something. There's no evidence that their daughter had noteworthy DNA or that she was abducted to be kept until old enough to breed.

It's called Hope.  Some of us still do.

[G-Unit]

It's called Hope.  Some of us still do.

My hope is that whoever ruined that little girl's life gets their just desserts, but I don't expect it to happen.

[Eleanor]

My hope is that whoever ruined that little girl's life gets their just desserts, but I don't expect it to happen.

It will.  But then Madeleine's life might not have been ruined.  That is the difference between you and me.

[Vertigo Swirl]

s..mbag College

Uncalled for.  I thought I was meant to be the bitter one?

[Erngath]

It depends what you call evidence. In my opinion there's evidence that the McCanns were up to something. There's no evidence that their daughter had noteworthy DNA or that she was abducted to be kept until old enough to breed.

" the McCanns were up to something"
Can you add to what that "something" was?

[The General]

" the McCanns were up to something"
Can you add to what that "something" was?

Delete your phone records.
Vista do Mar.
There's two.
Summat not reet mert.

[Erngath]

Delete your phone records.
Vista do Mar.
There's two.
Summat not reet mert.

Oh my goodness.
Is that it?
Forward that information immediately to NSY.

[The General]

Oh my goodness.
Is that it?
Forward that information immediately to NSY.

You asked for 'something'. I mean, there's dozens more, as you know.

Actually, you've inspired me to do a 'We Didn't Start the Fire' parody.
It's gonna be epic!
Do do be doo be doo doo....(that's not it by the way, Ern)

[Brietta]

It depends what you call evidence. In my opinion there's evidence that the McCanns were up to something. There's no evidence that their daughter had noteworthy DNA or that she was abducted to be kept until old enough to breed.

The problem you have with that is that what Amaral wrote in his book detailing what he thought was evidence quite simply was not.  It was just his belief.
He based his book, his theories, his contribution as coordinator on Madeleine's case on ephemera which lasted only in his fevered certainty for as long as it was not subject to scrutiny and when it was, simply vanished like a puff of smoke.

There is absolutely no evidence that the McCanns "were up to something".  If there had been one or both of them would probably still be doing time in a Portuguese jail and like Joana before her, there would have been no need for anyone to bother keeping the flame alight in the search for Madeleine.

Please bear in mind that tagging a libel with 'opinion' doesn't make it less of a libel.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Delete your phone records.
Vista do Mar.
There's two.
Summat not reet mert.

What is Vista do Mar?