A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[G-Unit]

It may be lazy, it may be meaningless but it is actually largely true.  Which sceptic here thinks the dog alerts were meaningless, that Amaral was a dishonest cop not very good at his job and that the McCanns were truthful in their statements?  Come on, name them.

No, it's just lazy and meaningless. Or is it an attempt to set the agenda? If I ask you what you believe you can answer as you wish. If I tell you what you believe you're diverted into denials and corrections.

[Mr Gray]

See you're a sceptic at heart.

im  a sceptic with a small s as opposed to a Sceptic

[The General]

It may be lazy, it may be meaningless but it is actually largely true.  Which sceptic here thinks the dog alerts were meaningless, that Amaral was a dishonest cop not very good at his job and that the McCanns were truthful in their statements?  Come on, name them.

You're still distilling this down to suit your narrow view.
Consider the sample size. There's feckin 7 of us, FFS. Broaden it out, what if, heaven forbid, there were 300 of us (SSPPPAAARRTAAAAA). You couldn't possibly distil us down to 3 main beliefs. There'd be all sorts of beliefs. You'd end up with diametrically parallel, ludicrous versions of the Jewish bloodlines for a start.

[Mr Gray]

You're still distilling this down to suit your narrow view.
Consider the sample size. There's feckin 7 of us, FFS. Broaden it out, what if, heaven forbid, there were 300 of us (SSPPPAAARRTAAAAA). You couldn't possibly distil us down to 3 main beliefs. There'd be all sorts of beliefs. You'd end up with diametrically parallel, ludicrous versions of the Jewish bloodlines for a start.

when you distil down to core beliefs there are basically two opposing sides. Then in the centre are a  around four who dislike the mccans but dont subscribe to the accident theory

[Vertigo Swirl]

You're still distilling this down to suit your narrow view.
Consider the sample size. There's feckin 7 of us, FFS. Broaden it out, what if, heaven forbid, there were 300 of us (SSPPPAAARRTAAAAA). You couldn't possibly distil us down to 3 main beliefs. There'd be all sorts of beliefs. You'd end up with diametrically parallel, ludicrous versions of the Jewish bloodlines for a start.

Why on earth  couldn’t you possibly distil it down to 3 main beliefs?  Or 4 or 5?  You can do it for supporters so why not sceptics?

[Vertigo Swirl]

No, it's just lazy and meaningless. Or is it an attempt to set the agenda? If I ask you what you believe you can answer as you wish. If I tell you what you believe you're diverted into denials and corrections.

Go on then , tell me what I believe.

[The General]

Why on earth  couldn’t you possibly distil it down to 3 main beliefs?  Or 4 or 5?  You can do it for supporters so why not sceptics?

You're not distilling me down to one of your (in)comprehensible, convenient tropes. No way sister.

[G-Unit]

Go on then , tell me what I believe.

I think that would be arrogant of me, even if I cared what you do or don't believe.

[Vertigo Swirl]

You're not distilling me down to one of your (in)comprehensible, convenient tropes. No way sister.

Oh dear, I think I touched a bit of a nerve.  I know from your posts what you think of the McCanns , that the dog alerts were highly significant and that Amaral is a top geezer.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I think that would be arrogant of me, even if I cared what you do or don't believe.

I’ve made it very clear what I believe, why would I mind if you reminded me?

[G-Unit]

Oh dear, I think I touched a bit of a nerve.  I know from your posts what you think the McCanns, that the dog alerts were highly significant and that Amaral is a top geezer.

Is that due to your supposed skill in understanding the hidden meanings behind posts or do you have cites?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Is that due to your supposed skill in understanding the hidden meanings behind posts or do you have cites?

The General doesn’t do hidden meanings, he calls a spade a spade, unlike yourself.  I have not misrepresented his views as I’m sure he will confirm in due course.  In the meantime all his posts are available to search if you really need proof.

[ShiningInLuz]

sceptics all seem to believe in the dogs.  In fact I would describe their belief as almost religious in its unquestioning devotion.  They also seem to believe Amaral was a decent honourable cop, wronged by the system.

Tripe.

[G-Unit]

The General doesn’t do hidden meanings, he calls a spade a spade, unlike yourself.  I have not misrepresented his views as I’m sure he will confirm in due course.  In the meantime all his posts are available to search if you really need proof.

Why are you talking to me about the General? He can think what he likes and he can answer for himself just as I do.
I have no intention of answering for him.
   

[Vertigo Swirl]

Why are you talking to me about the General? He can think what he likes and he can answer for himself just as I do.
I have no intention of answering for him.
 

Because the post of mine you questioned regarding my understanding of posts was addressed to him of course!