A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Are you aware of anything that's 100% reliable?

So that’s a no then.  Cadaver dogs do make false alerts and therefore unless corroborated cannot be relied on.

[Wonderfulspam]

So that’s a no then.  Cadaver dogs do make false alerts and therefore unless corroborated cannot be relied on.

Any sign of Maddie?  No?  There's your corroboration.

[The General]

So that’s a no then.  Cadaver dogs do make false alerts and therefore unless corroborated cannot be relied on.

A bit like a polygraph then. Or grainy CCTV. Or eye witness testimony. Or specks of gunpowder on a jacket sleeve. Or hand writing analysis.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Any sign of Maddie?  No?  There's your corroboration.

And I suppose the proof she’s dead is a dog barking. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

A bit like a polygraph then. Or grainy CCTV. Or eye witness testimony. Or specks of gunpowder on a jacket sleeve. Or hand writing analysis.

At least two of those are not admissable in UK courts, so yes, a bit like that. 

[The General]

At least two of those are not admissable in UK courts, so yes, a bit like that.

Ahh, narrow world view, OK.
I was thinking a bit wider.

[barrier]

Ahh, narrow world view, OK.
I was thinking a bit wider.

Its even narrower than that,the girl was abducted end of,or so tis alleged.

[Wonderfulspam]

And I suppose the proof she’s dead is a dog barking. 

She hasn't touched her bank account or phoned home in 12 years either.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Ahh, narrow world view, OK.
I was thinking a bit wider.

do elucidate.  In what way was what I wrote “narrow”?

[Miss Taken Identity]

Grime's reputation rested on him using his dogs honestly.

Exactly!

He had nothing to gain from pretending his dogs alerted to scents they were trained to do. And that was his only remit.
 He wasn't asked to find the McCann's guilty of anything. AND he never said it was Madeleine's cadaver scent either. Hence why it is strange the McCann's get all defensive about the dogs reliability.

 It is also strange that IF they claim their daughter was abducted what was preventing this abductor from killing their daughter and hiding her body for disposal at another time.

*  If It was me and I was told this- I would pass out thinking OMG she has been killed! But Gerry with a sniggering,arrogant reply said the dogs are wrong.  This is on an interview...

[Vertigo Swirl]

Exactly!

He had nothing to gain from pretending his dogs alerted to scents they were trained to do. And that was his only remit.
 He wasn't asked to find the McCann's guilty of anything. AND he never said it was Madeleine's cadaver scent either. Hence why it is strange the McCann's get all defensive about the dogs reliability.

 It is also strange that IF they claim their daughter was abducted what was preventing this abductor from killing their daughter and hiding her body for disposal at another time.

*  If It was me and I was told this- I would pass out thinking OMG she has been killed! But Gerry with a sniggering,arrogant reply said the dogs are wrong.  This is on an interview...

Oh, was that an interview carried out directly after he’d been informed of the dog alerts?

[Mr Gray]

Exactly!

He had nothing to gain from pretending his dogs alerted to scents they were trained to do. And that was his only remit.
 He wasn't asked to find the McCann's guilty of anything. AND he never said it was Madeleine's cadaver scent either. Hence why it is strange the McCann's get all defensive about the dogs reliability.

 It is also strange that IF they claim their daughter was abducted what was preventing this abductor from killing their daughter and hiding her body for disposal at another time.

*  If It was me and I was told this- I would pass out thinking OMG she has been killed! But Gerry with a sniggering,arrogant reply said the dogs are wrong.  This is on an interview...

I get the impression you pass out frequently

[Miss Taken Identity]

I get the impression you pass out frequently

Goading and pathetic.


Well put it this way  if my daughter was abducted by a paedo gang to be abused in a horrific manner. I would not be jogging, blogging and doing photo shoots!  for sure.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Goading and pathetic.


Well put it this way  if my daughter was abducted by a paedo gang to be abused in a horrific manner. I would not be jogging, blogging and doing photo shoots!  for sure.

What would you be doing?

[Miss Taken Identity]

What would you be doing?

moot point.  There is NO evidence of a paedo gang abductors who stole MBM.