A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Where did I say that there was ‘all this evidence’...I said the friends being involved was a ridiculous idea.

It’s worth pointing out that it was adjudged that there wasn’t enough evidence to arrest Barrymore and that is why he sued. I’m sure any police force will now make sure they have as solid a case against a perpetrator as is humanly possible after cases like Barrymore’s wrongful arrest.

”the friends being involved was a ridiculous idea”??!  You seem to be trying very hard today to persuade yourself otherwise!

[faithlilly]

I’ve no idea.  Is he lying though?  Faithlilly seems to think it’s possible.  The question is, why...?

Where did I say that ?

[kizzy]

I’ve no idea.  Is he lying though?  Faithlilly seems to think it’s possible.  The question is, why...?

Well it seems to me he is saying that its SY suspects - not his.

Although IMO there is a strong likeness - to gmcn


https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7741505/Ex-Portuguese-police-chief-claims-leading-Madeleine-McCann-suspect-mystery-German-paedophile.html#i-457a6e2d31d9b289

[Vertigo Swirl]

Where did I say that ?

you do have a short memory.  A little while ago I asked you if you thought Amaral was making up the German paedo story for attention.  Your exact reply was

“Possibly...I have no way of knowing Amaral’s motivation”

[Vertigo Swirl]

Well it seems to me he is saying that its SY suspects - not his.

Although IMO there is a strong likeness - to gmcn


https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7741505/Ex-Portuguese-police-chief-claims-leading-Madeleine-McCann-suspect-mystery-German-paedophile.html#i-457a6e2d31d9b289

1) beside the point and 2) beside the point.

[kizzy]

1) beside the point and 2) beside the point.

What point is that VS

[Mr Gray]

What point is that VS

does anyone still take any notice of the discredited amaral

[Miss Taken Identity]

Everything they have said and done since the case reopened points to an investigation of stranger abduction.  Amaral claims they are investigating a German paedo.  Is he making this up for attention?

They are still looking at ALL scenarios. They may or may not be interested in a German Paedophile, but as a suspect?   If they were to interview him that would be seen as interfering with a witness  to a crime where they have no justification as the crime was in Portugal.  Something else the supporters need to keep reminding themselves about.

[Mr Gray]

They are still looking at ALL scenarios. They may or may not be interested in a German Paedophile, but as a suspect?   If they were to interview him that would be seen as interfering with a witness  to a crime where they have no justification as the crime was in Portugal.  Something else the supporters need to keep reminding themselves about.

What do you mean by all scenarios...they obviously are not looking at the parents

[Miss Taken Identity]

What do you mean by all scenarios...they obviously are not looking at the parents

You do not know who  or what is going on  or who is or isn't being looked at - pretending you do and rehashing old news doesn't make it so.

[Mr Gray]

You do not know who  or what is going on  or who is or isn't being looked at - pretending you do and rehashing old news doesn't make it so.

its obvious the parents are not suspects after what SY and teh PJ said...and the complete absence of any action around them...its more than a bit silly to suggest they are..imo..but that doesnt stop some people

[kizzy]

does anyone still take any notice of the discredited amaral

Of course, they do D - do you think they would have donated so much to his crowdfunding if they didn't

The crowdfunding to fight against the mcns

[kizzy]

does anyone still take any notice of the discredited amaral

Discredited or not = he was the closest thing to try and get to the truth of what happened to maddie

[Mr Gray]

Of course, they do D - do you think they would have donated so much to his crowdfunding if they didn't

The crowdfunding to fight against the mcns

perhaps a handful of poorly informed people...who dont undersatnd the evidence did...and still support him....did you contribute...i dont beleive SY officers contributed 10k...I think thats an outright lie

[Mr Gray]

Discredited or not = he was the closest thing to try and get to the truth of what happened to maddie

he didnt understand the evidence so he had no chance of finding the truth