KM's Paperback (PB)

[The General]

She did answer all the questions asked of her throughout the investigation and during very lengthy sessions until she was made an arguida when she exercised her right to silence on legal advice.
As she recalled in her book, Murat did exactly the same when attending a confrontational meeting ... consulting with his lawyer and on at least one occasion both leaving the room to consult ... as was his right.

Portuguese law allows the right of arguidos to silence ... why is Kate to be castigated when the focus of the inquiry turned from searching for her daughter to attempting to implicate her in Madeleine's supposed death?  Pretty daft of her to dignify PJ nonsense of mistaken and misguided conclusions, and abandon Madeleine to her fate as they had done?

Seemed pretty reasonable questions to me.
Kate's book.

[Holly Goodhead]

How can we have a debate about opinions... You have yours... I have mine... Where is the possibility of debate.. Csn you not see that really simple fact

What do you think students debate and discuss in English lit classes? 

[Mr Gray]

She did answer all the questions asked of her throughout the investigation and during very lengthy sessions until she was made an arguida when she exercised her right to silence on legal advice.
As she recalled in her book, Murat did exactly the same when attending a confrontational meeting ... consulting with his lawyer and on at least one occasion both leaving the room to consult ... as was his right.

Portuguese law allows the right of arguidos to silence ... why is Kate to be castigated when the focus of the inquiry turned from searching for her daughter to attempting to implicate her in Madeleine's supposed death?  Pretty daft of her to dignify PJ nonsense of mistaken and misguided conclusions, and abandon Madeleine to her fate as they had done?

More excuse for intelligent debate... Do sceptics really want to raise the same points over and over again... Do they expect a different outcome... We know what Einstein had to say about such behaviour

[Holly Goodhead]

If I say Donald Trump comes over to me as  really nice person... What value, would that statement have

My answer to that would be in what way do think he's a really nice person please provide some examples.

[Mr Gray]

What do you think students debate and discuss in English lit classes?

They debate on opinion based on facts.. Opinion based on too little information is totally worthless... Fact

[The General]

More excuse for intelligent debate... Do sceptics really want to raise the same points over and over again... Do they expect a different outcome... We know what Einstein had to say about such behaviour

On topic? No.
Kate's book.

[Mr Gray]

My answer to that would be in what way do think he's a really nice person please provide some examples.

And my answer would be why should I have to justify my opinion to you

[The General]

And my answer would be why should I have to justify my opinion to you

Well apparently it's worthless anyway.
Kate's book is also available in paperback.

[Mr Gray]

My answer to that would be in what way do think he's a really nice person please provide some examples.

Why do you think Kate cones over to others, as a really nice... Kind.. Considerate parent

[Holly Goodhead]

They debate on opinion based on facts.. Opinion based on too little information is totally worthless... Fact

The fact you consider opinion based on too little information is totally worthless doesn't make it a fact its just your opinion. 

Back to KM's PB we have 400 hundred odd pages which cover everything from her childhood friend eating pickled onion crisps to her child disappearing to her sex life. 

[The General]

Why do you think Kate cones over to others, as a really nice... Kind.. Considerate parent

errr....people forming OPINIONS based on the data available, including Kate's book? Sheesh, keep up Davros.

[Mr Gray]

The fact you consider opinion based on too little information is totally worthless doesn't make it a fact its just your opinion. 

Back to KM's PB we have 400 hundred odd pages which cover everything from her childhood friend eating pickled onion crisps to her child disappearing to her sex life.

So why do you think there is such a totally diverse opinion and to her character... Why isn't it clear cut..

[Mr Gray]

errr....people forming OPINIONS based on the data available, including Kate's book? Sheesh, keep up Davros.

And why are this opinions often so polarised

[Mr Gray]

Davel please read my post carefully:

I cannot warm to her at all through her book.  She comes over to me as controlling, judgemental and with a massive sense of entitlement.

In what way controlling... Do you mean that in a negative way and opposed to a woman who is assertive

[The General]

And why are this opinions often so polarised

In this instance? It's obviously because of the manner of the disappearance. 'Opinion' would almost certainly be overwhelmingly sympathetic if the circumstances were different. Perhaps even the simple act of locking the doors might have swayed public opinion.
Opinion is pretty important.