Feasibility Of Disposing Of A Small Child's Body In The PDL Area

[Vertigo Swirl]

I remember that GM was rather keen to convince people that he crossed that road to speak to JW.

Convince what people?  And what difference does a few feet make anyway?

[barrier]

Well they were scenting something or someone otherwise they wouldn't have moved.

Using that logic,a couple of dogs must have been scenting  something in 5a.But let it not be another dog thread,feasability of disposal in and around PDL.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Using that logic,a couple of dogs must have been scenting  something in 5a.But let it not be another dog thread,feasability of disposal in and around PDL.

Spoilsport.

[barrier]

Spoilsport.

 

[Holly Goodhead]

Possibly, but I don’t believe the dogs will ever be proven to be correct.

If you think the case will be resolved then I think we will find out about the reliability of the S&R dogs deployed in the search for MM. 

[Holly Goodhead]

I remember that GM was rather keen to convince people that he crossed that road to speak to JW.

But that was GM not MM.  If the McCanns were trying to fool the s&r dog handlers by handing them some item that had been in proximity to the body of GM then how would it assist any fooling by GM keen to convince people he crossed that road to speak to JW?  GM was involved in searches for MM pre S&R dogs arriving and his last known movements were much further out than the potential spots he was talking to JW in. 

[Holly Goodhead]

Using that logic,a couple of dogs must have been scenting  something in 5a.But let it not be another dog thread,feasability of disposal in and around PDL.

How could the S&R dogs be scenting another dog?  They were scenting off items handed to them by KM that had supposedly been in contact with MM's body.  Some here believe KM attempted to fool the S&R dogs/handlers by handing them items that hadn't been in contact with MM's body.  This begs the question who were the dogs  scenting if not MM because they didn't scent last known paths taken by KM/GM or twins.

 

[barrier]

Using that logic,a couple of dogs must have been scenting  something in 5a.But let it not be another dog thread,feasability of disposal in and around PDL.

How could the S&R dogs be scenting another dog?  They were scenting off items handed to them by KM that had supposedly been in contact with MM's body.  Some here believe KM attempted to fool the S&R dogs/handlers by handing them items that hadn't been in contact with MM's body.  This begs the question who were the dogs  scenting if not MM because they didn't scent last known paths taken by KM/GM or twins.

 

Pardon?

[barrier]

But that was GM not MM.  If the McCanns were trying to fool the s&r dog handlers by handing them some item that had been in proximity to the body of GM then how would it assist any fooling by GM keen to convince people he crossed that road to speak to JW?  GM was involved in searches for MM pre S&R dogs arriving and his last known movements were much further out than the potential spots he was talking to JW in.

HG you started a thread about the feasibility of body disposal in and around PDL,I've shown its possible from the Needham case to be so near without knowing.Wasn't there also road works happening at the same time in Luz,we've even had pictures of officers looking into drainage pipes,they must have thought its a real possibility 7 yrs after the event.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-27713826

[G-Unit]

Whatever the S & R dogs did, it's not enough to rule out the possibility that MM was disposed of in PdL imo. It's a pity they weren't given items to sniff that were clearly hers.

[Holly Goodhead]

Pardon?

My mistake.  I misread your post and thought you were saying one dog might have been scenting another!

[Holly Goodhead]

HG you started a thread about the feasibility of body disposal in and around PDL,I've shown its possible from the Needham case to be so near without knowing.Wasn't there also road works happening at the same time in Luz,we've even had pictures of officers looking into drainage pipes,they must have thought its a real possibility 7 yrs after the event.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-27713826

I don't understand your point about BN?  His whereabouts remain unknown. 

[Holly Goodhead]

Whatever the S & R dogs did, it's not enough to rule out the possibility that MM was disposed of in PdL imo. It's a pity they weren't given items to sniff that were clearly hers.

I agree its not enough to rule out the possibility that MM was disposed of in PDL but the S&R dogs not scenting beyond the immediate vicinity AND all the searches carried out under the management of search expert Mark Harrison suggest MM was not disposed of in PDL. 

According to KM the dog handlers were given items that had been in close proximity to MM's body.  For those that believe KM might have been attempting to fool the dogs/handlers by handing them items that hadn't been in contact with MM's body then whose body had they been in contact with?  KM only had access to a finite number of items and the dogs didn't scent in the last known paths that KM/GM/twins had walked. 

[G-Unit]

I agree its not enough to rule out the possibility that MM was disposed of in PDL but the S&R dogs not scenting beyond the immediate vicinity AND all the searches carried out under the management of search expert Mark Harrison suggest MM was not disposed of in PDL. 

According to KM the dog handlers were given items that had been in close proximity to MM's body.  For those that believe KM might have been attempting to fool the dogs/handlers by handing them items that hadn't been in contact with MM's body then whose body had they been in contact with?  KM only had access to a finite number of items and the dogs didn't scent in the last known paths that KM/GM/twins had walked.

I'm no expert on S & R dogs, but if MM was abducted then she was carried. I find it hard to believe that the dogs followed her (carried) scent to that lampost but didn't pick up her walking scent from there. She had walked by that spot four times on 3rd.

[barrier]

I don't understand your point about BN?  His whereabouts remain unknown.

True his remains unaccounted for but its the professional belief of South Yorkshire police that he died in an accident.
The accident happened as close to the place he was staying as could be,Showing a body could be disposed of easily.
What the Needham case showed was, that it was a third party talking that brought it to light 25 yrs on,who's to say thats not what it'll be in the McCann case.