Is the disappearance of MM connected to other reported crimes on Algarve?

[Mr Gray]

Depends what you mean by guilty.  I for one don't believe she killed her daughter but she assisted an offender after the fact and lied about it.

I don't think she did either  .I thought she confessed to everything when she was beaten

[G-Unit]

There's insufficient evidence to conclude that these villa invasions were related to each other, let alone to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

[Vertigo Swirl]

There's insufficient evidence to conclude that these villa invasions were related to each other, let alone to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

Says who?

[Mr Gray]

There's insufficient evidence to conclude that these villa invasions were related to each other, let alone to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

That's an opinion stated by as fact but it looks as though that's now perfectly acceptable

[Mr Gray]

There's insufficient evidence to conclude that these villa invasions were related to each other, let alone to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

It's possible they were and it's possible they were related to Maddie's disappearance

[John]

There's insufficient evidence to conclude that these villa invasions were related to each other, let alone to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

I certainly agree with that.

[John]

I don't think she did either  .I thought she confessed to everything when she was beaten

Actually she was beaten after being remanded in custody. She was remanded in custody because she admitted killing her daughter.

[John]

It's possible they were and it's possible they were related to Maddie's disappearance

Can you provide one tangible piece of evidence which supports that contention?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I certainly agree with that.

So can you confirm that opinions can now be written without IMOs?

[Mr Gray]

Actually she was beaten after being remanded in custody. She was remanded in custody because she admitted killing her daughter.

I thought you said she was guilty of lying.... So she, didn't kill her, daughter but she lied to the police and said she did kill her daughter....

[Mr Gray]

Can you provide one tangible piece of evidence which supports that contention?

Of course it's, a possibility... Unless you can prove they were not connected

[Mr Gray]

Actually she was beaten after being remanded in custody. She was remanded in custody because she admitted killing her daughter.

Everything I have read... Including the trial transcript where amaral is found guilty of false testimony.... Says she was beaten in order to confess.. ie a confession was beaten out of her.
The only statement I have seen saying she confessed first came from amarals lawyer trying to defend amaral from perjury,... All other sources confirm beating to obtain a confession

[John]

I thought you said she was guilty of lying.... So she, didn't kill her, daughter but she lied to the police and said she did kill her daughter....

Yes, she was convicted of perjury and received an additional sentence which was added to the original one.

And yes, she lied to the police in the first instance in order to protect her brother, she later told the truth and implicated him. I believe her current position is that her brother attempted to sell the girl to foreigners but the handover went dreadfully wrong ending up with the girl being killed.  Her remains are supposed to be buried up in the hills near the pig pens.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3343.msg127258#msg127258

[Vertigo Swirl]

Yes, she was convicted of perjury and received an additional sentence which was added to the original one.

And yes, she lied to the police in the first instance in order to protect her brother, she later told the truth and implicated him. I believe her current position is that her brother attempted to sell the girl to foreigners but the handover went dreadfully wrong ending up with the girl being killed.  Her remains are supposed to be buried up in the hills near the pig pens.

Why haven’t they been dug up then? 

[John]

Why haven’t they been dug up then?

Seems they are well hidden.