Yes I said I wasn't going to get drawn into further discussion about it, but I came across this very interesting perspective from another cadaver dog handler on Reddit, a comment which has the ring of truth to it, from someone who obviously speaks from experience. Feel free to dismiss it if it doesn't fit with your own agenda.
https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/b4oroa/sniffer_dog_alerts_in_madeleine_mccann_case/Hectorabaya2 -
It wouldn't even necessarily have to be an actual death. Cadaver dogs are typically reacting to the presence of decaying tissue and/or blood. If you had, say, a diabetic person who was neglecting basic care and had chronic foot ulcers that left weeping, decaying tissue behind, that would be very gross but it would also potentially trigger an alert in the right conditions. And that's just one example; there are a lot of things that can cause potential false positives. Especially in a dog that specializes in blood detection; just in my career I've run into multiple instances where unrelated traces of blood have resulted in correct (from a dog training standpoint) but still irrelevant alerts.
I am the cadaver dog handler who has been mentioned a few times in this thread (I got locked out of my first account but I just can't post from it, still have access to it, so I can provide proof of that in the form of screenshots if need be), so I obviously am pretty supportive of dogs as investigative tools. I believe that an alert should never be taken as proof on its own, though. As probable cause for digging or further forensic testing, sure. As part of the body of evidence in a largely circumstantial case, maybe, but there are some times when it does make sense. But never just proof on its own without further backing. There are too many variables and you never know for sure what your dog is alerting on.
I think Grimes most likely did cue false alerts, though I don't necessarily blame him for that (though I will also say he isn't the superstar in the cadaver dog handling world that he is perceived as in the general population; he's not terrible, but there's some controversy around him, and not just related to the McCann case). I have known many skilled handlers who accidentally cued false alerts. I've done it myself once, though luckily for me it was obviously false so we ignored it (my dog was distracted by another very exciting scent and as I tried to redirect her, I managed to cue an alert). Dogs are so tuned into us that it is ridiculously easy to do. Good handlers spend a lot of time training ourselves and our dogs to ignore/avoid that, but it still happens.
And Grimes was under a lot of pressure in this case. Even if the local investigators were genuinely unbiased, he was under international media scrutiny and I'm sure was very aware of that. It's a really bullshit attitude, but people really do see lack of alerts as a failure, even when the lack of alert is 100% correct. Especially if everyone is sure there "should be" evidence there. I've been involved in a couple of locally high-profile cases where I'm sure my dogs acted 100% correctly in not alerting, and then it kind of stings to go online and read judgmental comments about how the dogs failed, even though logically I know it's from people who don't understand how this stuff works. I can't even imagine the pressure this handler must have felt with the whole world watching. That's going to have an effect on your dogs, even if your intentions are 100% pure.
I actually never paid much attention to the McCann case until I got involved in Reddit a few years ago, and I always assumed the parents were guilty. It was literally a PM asking me about the cadaver dog evidence in the case that made me reevaluate that, because the K9 evidence just didn't make a lot of sense to me with any plausible theory of the crime. The more I looked into the timeline and other evidence and even the K9 evidence, it just didn't make sense to me. The McCanns are weird and I do think they were probably neglectful to leave such young kids alone in the way they did, but looking at the evidence I just can't believe they were directly involved with Maddie's death. And a big part of that is the K9 evidence being such a "smoking gun," because it really isn't for so many reasons. If that's the best evidence, well, that's a shitty case.