“A Laughable Story”

[Robittybob1]

Rather like Brueckner. Yet we hear supporters talk of his part in Madeleine’s disappearance as if it’s fact.

Can you point out one post, please?

[Erngath]

Rather like Brueckner. Yet we hear supporters talk of his part in Madeleine’s disappearance as if it’s fact.

No . I don't.
However it does seem that three police investigations are not interested in the theory theorised by Amaral!
Just so you are absolutely clear about my feelings about this.
I would much rather your theory that Madeleine died an accidental death in the apartment due to an overdose of Calpol and her father chucked her body in a bin was the correct theory rather than that which the German police are now stating they know to be the fact.

[Eleanor]

Can you point out one post, please?

I would like to see that.

[faithlilly]

No . I don't.
However it does seem that three police investigations are not interested in the theory theorised by Amaral!
Just so you are absolutely clear about my feelings about this.
I would much rather your theory that Madeleine died an accidental death in the apartment due to an overdose of Calpol and her father chucked her body in a bin was the correct theory rather than that which the German police are now stating they know to be the fact.

An overdose of calpol ? What a ridiculous suggestion. Calpol is not a sedative.

As to the German police stating Madeleine’s death at the hands of Brueckner as a fact, the Portuguese police also stated as a fact that the parents were complicit in their daughter’s disappearance. Not enough evidence to charge in both cases.

[faithlilly]

I would like to see that.

Can I then suggest you try reading back ?

[Erngath]

An overdose of calpol ? What a ridiculous suggestion. Calpol is not a sedative.

As to the German police stating Madeleine’s death at the hands of Brueckner as a fact, the Portuguese police also stated as a fact that the parents were complicit in their daughter’s disappearance. Not enough evidence to charge in both cases.

So that's not your theory.
Apologies.
But you do believe Madeleine's father chucked her body in a bin?

[Eleanor]

Can I then suggest you try reading back ?

Your statement.  It's down to you to prove it.

[faithlilly]

So that's not your theory.
Apologies.
But you do believe Madeleine's father chucked her body in a bin?

I believe he may have made that pragmatic choice yes. Not sure what that has to do with the subject though.

[faithlilly]

Your statement.  It's down to you to prove it.

I’d prepare myself for a disappointment then.

[Erngath]

I believe he may have made that pragmatic choice yes. Not sure what that has to do with the subject though.

He may have made the "pragmatic choice" to chuck his daughters body in a bin.....why?
What do you theorise caused him to do so?
What do you believe was the cause of her death?

[Brietta]

An overdose of calpol ? What a ridiculous suggestion. Calpol is not a sedative.

As to the German police stating Madeleine’s death at the hands of Brueckner as a fact, the Portuguese police also stated as a fact that the parents were complicit in their daughter’s disappearance. Not enough evidence to charge in both cases.

Maybe you should get Amaral to amend his book then and while you are at it you should catch up on what the real Portuguese police had to say about Amaral's thesis.

You appear to be a bit bogged down in conspiracy theory while the rest of the world read the facts and has moved on from the groundhog day you seem to prefer..

[Vertigo Swirl]

Not one supporter here has claimed as fact that Bruckner took Madeleine, the woman is making stuff up.

[Robittybob1]

I’d prepare myself for a disappointment then.

So you won't mind if I delete all the posts with your unverified claim in it then?  [You can claim you never read this as you have me on "ignore".]

[faithlilly]

Maybe you should get Amaral to amend his book then and while you are at it you should catch up on what the real Portuguese police had to say about Amaral's thesis.

You appear to be a bit bogged down in conspiracy theory while the rest of the world read the facts and has moved on from the groundhog day you seem to prefer..

Why would I get Amaral to do anything ? Do you realise how nonsensical that sounds?

The facts ?

That OG, even when given a particular remit, I note it’s in your signature, and millions of pounds have in 9 years yet to come up with a coherent solution that fulfils that remit ?

That the German police even after years of investigation, a worldwide appeal and three months of newspaper headlines have yet to connect Brueckner to the disappearance?

Those facts ?

[Brietta]

Why would I get Amaral to do anything ? Do you realise how nonsensical that sounds?

The facts ?

That OG, even when given a particular remit, I note it’s in your signature, and millions of pounds have yet to come up with a coherent solution that involves any suspect ?

That the German police even after years of investigation, a worldwide appeal and three months of newspaper headlines have yet to connect Brueckner to the disappearance?

Those facts ?

Do move on ... bluster just doesn't do it anymore.  In my opinion all your posts show is that you are reluctant to move with the times and you are desperately worried about the end of your era drawing to its close.

Because it has you know.  I think it probably started with the Netflix documentaries but the tin lid was put on it when Amaral and then the Germans introduced Brueckner into the equation.

What's the saying about fooling some of the people etc - etc.