Kate McCann's unanswered questions.

[sadie]

Maybe he thought it was too light outside?

Good thinking Lace 

[sadie]

Just to be clear, the emoji attached to my replying posts, is not mine. I have never used them and never will.

These emojis kept attaching themselves to the start of my posts about a month ago too.

I wondered if they were deliberately attached to downgrade the seriousness of my posts.

IIRC the emoji which kept attaching itself was the laughing one i.e.  … so laughing at and ridiculing my serious post before anyone read it

[sadie]

I don't support your idea, but theoretically Madeleine could have been passed through window head first or feet first and picked up from right or left of window.

Very awkward with a chair being almost up against the bed under the window.  This left very little space for feet to stand.  In fact one foot would have to be behind the other in the narrow gap.

To be quite frank, I doubt that a (bendy) child of 90cms length could be passed through safely, with such an unbalanced foothold and the distance required.  Would be good if someone tried this to see if it was possible.   I think she was just carried thru the front door and passed over to Tannerman.

[sadie]

The Tanner sighting has been ruled out.

No, it hasn't, but there are alternative thoughts.  It hasn't been ruled out.

[sadie]

Possibly but in order not to wake her, she could have been picked up from her bed with her head on the right arm and passed in that same position to someone at the other side of the window.

Sorry Anthro, but I doubt that would be possible, given the limited space between the under window bed and the chair.   IMO, the possible lifter would be unbalanced just standing there, one foot in front of the other, without the added weight of Madeleine pulling him over, when leaning forward and slightly sideways.
Also the window is very narrow to pass Madeleine through without her touching either side and leaving traces IMHO

I am happy to be found wrong on this, if someone would like to set up an exact replica situation

I think that s/he had to be carried out via the front door.  A very safe thing to do given the recessed almost pitch black porchway - and no-body passed by that doorway.  It was like being at the end of a cul de sac, no one went past unless visiting 5A

[sadie]

As off-topic as most of the recent posts but here's a SS from Sexta9 (Portuguese TV) 25/9/2020

Like with lots of videos on MoJ, I cannot open this.   I wonder why I am denied access?

I would have liked to watch it altho' I don't speak Portuguese.

[Eleanor]

Sorry Anthro, but I doubt that would be possible, given the limited space between the under window bed and the chair.   IMO, the possible lifter would be unbalanced just standing there, one foot in front of the other, without the added weight of Madeleine pulling him over, when leaning forward and slightly sideways.
Also the window is very narrow to pass Madeleine through without her touching either side and leaving traces IMHO

I am happy to be found wrong on this, if someone would like to set up an exact replica situation

I think that s/he had to be carried out via the front door.  A very safe thing to do given the recessed almost pitch black porchway - and no-body passed by that doorway.  It was like being at the end of a cul de sac, no one went past unless visiting 5A

It doesn't really matter, Sadie.  Front Door or Window, Madeleine could have been passed to someone else.

[sadie]

Again, Davel has explained that Wolters has communicated what they have on Brückner. Operation Grange do not have that intelligence, hence treating it as a missing person case.

And possibly other reasons supplied by yours faithfully ?

[faithlilly]

Perhaps Redwood should have found out the direction in which Dr. Totman should have been walking.

Perhaps he picked up his child from the creche and was going back to a restaurant to pick up his wife ?

[faithlilly]

No, it hasn't, but there are alternative thoughts.  It hasn't been ruled out.

All but ruled out. Redwood moved the timeline on so he must have been pretty sure...and of course he’s the real detective.

[faithlilly]

It doesn't really matter, Sadie.  Front Door or Window, Madeleine could have been passed to someone else.

But there’s absolutely no evidence of it.

[Eleanor]

Perhaps he picked up his child from the creche and was going back to a restaurant to pick up his wife ?

Carrying his child over two arms?  Okaaayyy.

So why didn't he go straight to the restaurant?

[sadie]

Perhaps he picked up his child from the creche and was going back to a restaurant to pick up his wife ?

No

Walking in wrong direction dear.

Google Earth is very good at getting it right, if you are not sure.

[sadie]

But there’s absolutely no evidence of it.

Oh yes there is evidence.
Madeleine was passed from one person to another

The arm swap is evidence, whether you like it or not.

[faithlilly]

Carrying his child over two arms?  Okaaayyy.

So why didn't he go straight to the restaurant?

Detour to pick up a bottle of wine ?

As to the way he was carrying the child, there is no way of doing it without the head and hair of the child being in view. The mockumentary showed that clearly.