I'm getting reports that Madeleine is alive.

[John]

Everything below is pure speculation, based upon the likely lifestyle of my suspect.

I think that she will be living a rather nice lifestyle, but she will miss the fun of her home at Rothley with her fun filled Daddy and much loved Mummy.  She will sorely miss the twins too.

However, I fear that she will be restricted in many ways and moved on fairly frequently, leaving friends behind.  That is not nice.   I also wonder if she has unhappily been been subjected to mind alteration, possibly by shamans in the Drakensberg mountains of Lesotho, where I believe she has visited the other "Fatima"

She will probably mainly travel by luxury yacht and slip into countries within the Schengen agreement quite easily.   She will probably also visit other countries, by docking in small harbours.  Money is no object, so she will probably also travel by private plane.


All the above is pure speculation, based upon the likely lifestyle of my suspect.

With respect Sadie, you know very well that the forum is based on facts where possible. Have you the slightest evidence that any of this takes place or is this mere wishful thinking on your behalf?

ETA.  I know that you have shared this theory with us on many occasions and each time you refuse to provide anything to support it. Do you not think that it has worn very thin by now?

[Robittybob1]

With respect Sadie, you know very well that the forum is based on facts where possible. Have you the slightest evidence that any of this takes place or is this mere wishful thinking on your behalf?

ETA.  I know that you have shared this theory with us on many occasions and each time you refuse to provide anything to support it. Do you not think that it has worn very thin by now?

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11876.msg637404#msg637404

I did ask a question that can really only be answered by speculation.  I was trying to see what people are thinking.  In fact I'd like to ask Kate and Gerry the same question.  If you think Madeleine is still alive; what sort of life is she having?

It is a question about one's imagination, not actual facts.

[Vertigo Swirl]

With respect Sadie, you know very well that the forum is based on facts where possible. Have you the slightest evidence that any of this takes place or is this mere wishful thinking on your behalf?

ETA.  I know that you have shared this theory with us on many occasions and each time you refuse to provide anything to support it. Do you not think that it has worn very thin by now?

With respect John Sadie does acknowledge twice in her post that what she wrote was pure speculation. 

[G-Unit]

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11876.msg637404#msg637404

I did ask a question that can really only be answered by speculation.  I was trying to see what people are thinking.  In fact I'd like to ask Kate and Gerry the same question.  If you think Madeleine is still alive; what sort of life is she having?

It is a question about one's imagination, not actual facts.

For a purpose or just for fun?

[sadie]

With respect Sadie, you know very well that the forum is based on facts where possible. Have you the slightest evidence that any of this takes place or is this mere wishful thinking on your behalf?

ETA.  I know that you have shared this theory with us on many occasions and each time you refuse to provide anything to support it. Do you not think that it has worn very thin by now?

No, I haven't shared my main theory to any extent with anyone.  That is for OG only

The speculation post about Madeleines life style is based upon the very rich and elite man that I suspect.   His life style will, I think, be reflected in Madeleine lifestyle including the Countries where he has lived and has close friends.  My evidence is with Operation Grange.   

John, I have made it plain that it is speculation.  Pathfinder has a very comprehensive section on speculating that Kate and Gerry 'dunit' and it seems that there is no problem in letting that stand.   Pfinders work doesn't even say that it is speculation.  Why the differentiation between his/her stuff and mine ?

[Robittybob1]

For a purpose or just for fun?

profiling.

[G-Unit]

profiling.

How can you use imagination as a basis for that?

[Robittybob1]

How can you use imagination as a basis for that?

Profiling seems to be like imagination to me.  Anyone thinking Madeleine is alive must have thought of what life she is having, wouldn't they? 

[Robittybob1]

Rob... How much more are you going to perpetuate this nonsense?  IT'S A STOCK PHOTO... and nothing to do with Madeleine McCann!!!

Thank our lucky stars for that.  Do you think it would be possible to tell what agency had the stock photo on their books?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11876.msg637301#msg637301

[G-Unit]

Profiling seems to be like imagination to me.  Anyone thinking Madeleine is alive must have thought of what life she is having, wouldn't they?

It depends entirely on what people want to believe, rather than on what they know. Dave Edgar thought she was being held as a sex slave;

living with her captor in a hideaway home or underground den inland from the popular seaside towns on the Algarve from where she was snatched.
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/3512292/maddie-mccann-investigator-missing-could-be-alive/

I don't think profilers just make things up.

[Mr Gray]

It depends entirely on what people want to believe, rather than on what they know. Dave Edgar thought she was being held as a sex slave;

living with her captor in a hideaway home or underground den inland from the popular seaside towns on the Algarve from where she was snatched.
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/3512292/maddie-mccann-investigator-missing-could-be-alive/

I don't think profilers just make things up.

i think you will find Dave  Edgar thought that wa sone possibility...do you have a cite

[G-Unit]

i think you will find Dave  Edgar thought that wa sone possibility...do you have a cite

I included my cite with my post.

[Mr Gray]

I included my cite with my post.

Which shows im quite correct. Edgar said she could be being held...not that she was. a possibility thats all

[G-Unit]

Which shows im quite correct. Edgar said she could be being held...not that she was. a possibility thats all

My point stands. People's opinions of a live MM's lifestyle is connected to their opinions of who she might be with, which is also an opinion. What's more, all these opinions lack any evidence to support them, so they can't be used as a basis for profiling. It's all pie in the sky.

[Mr Gray]

My point stands. People's opinions of a live MM's lifestyle is connected to their opinions of who she might be with, which is also an opinion. What's more, all these opinions lack any evidence to support them, so they can't be used as a basis for profiling. It's all pie in the sky.

I agree with your point but your dave edgar quote wasnt correct. I'm absolutetly certain SY and the McCanns realise the maddie is almost certainly sadly dead...Its the only sensible option imo