I'm getting reports that Madeleine is alive.

[Robittybob1]

So where do you think he was standing when leaning on the wall?

So it appears he was a little way up the alleyway that was at the back of all the block 4 and 5 apartments.

[faithlilly]

From Tasmin Silences evidence and that of two other groups, it seems a man was seen watching the apartment

If I was standing waiting for a lift from a friend to work and I said that I’d meet them at the alleyway I’d probably have a quick nosey into the surrounding apartments, you know just to pass the time.

I think Tamsin Silence was a young girl who was caught up in the thrill of being a witness in one of the most highly publicised cases in history. Of course she only reported what she saw...it was the adults who interpreted that information.

The other sighting of the man was looking up towards the apartments. I’m not sure it can be narrowed down any further than that.

[sadie]

Video re-enactment https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/FMW/WITNESS%202.wmv

Tasmin Sillence's statement http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/T_M_S_AGE_12.htm

Well done, Rob for gathering the video clips together.  Having looked at them again, I realise that there were 5 sightings of this man watching 5A

1. -  Sighting by Tasmin of the man watching from the corner with a pencil attached to a string hanging from his pocket.  How observant she was … and how potentially pertinent is that pencil (to take notes, if needed?) hanging by a string from his pocket
2. -  Sighting by Tasmin of the man leaning against 5A garden wall peering in
3. -  Sighting by a woman with toddler
4. -  Sighting by a man and woman together.  (this is actually a double sighting)
5. -  Sighting by woman in green top coming out of the Tapas reception area, which is immediately across the road from where the man was standing.


Five sightings + plus the sighting by Mrs Tranmer, which describes a man who sounds very similar to Tasmins description.   So 6/7 sightings of a man who is suspicious or watching


Anyone here still doubting that this was a thoroughly planned abduction ?

[sadie]

If I was standing waiting for a lift from a friend to work and I said that I’d meet them at the alleyway I’d probably have a quick nosey into the surrounding apartments, you know just to pass the time.

I think Tamsin Silence was a young girl who was caught up in the thrill of being a witness in one of the most highly publicised cases in history. Of course she only reported what she saw...it was the adults who interpreted that information.

The other sighting of the man was looking up towards the apartments. I’m not sure it can be narrowed down any further than that.

Oh really?

He was seen at five different times.  Waiting for a lift to work, was he?

[Vertigo Swirl]

If I was standing waiting for a lift from a friend to work and I said that I’d meet them at the alleyway I’d probably have a quick nosey into the surrounding apartments, you know just to pass the time.

I think Tamsin Silence was a young girl who was caught up in the thrill of being a witness in one of the most highly publicised cases in history. Of course she only reported what she saw...it was the adults who interpreted that information.

The other sighting of the man was looking up towards the apartments. I’m not sure it can be narrowed down any further than that.

How do you know he was waiting for a lift?  How do you know Tasmin Silence was thrilled to be a witness in this case?  A couple of gross assumptions on your part there.

[faithlilly]

Oh really?

He was seen at five different times.  Waiting for a lift, was he?

Why not?

[faithlilly]

How do you know he was waiting for a lift?  How do you know Tasmin Silence was thrilled to be a witness in this case?  A couple of gross assumptions on your part there.

I don’t know that he was waiting for a lift but it is one logical explanation.

As to Tamsin, she was a young girl, young girls love drama. Besides she only reported what she saw, it was the adults who interpreted that information.

[Mr Gray]

All this of course is off topic which for some reason doesn't seem to matter today

[sadie]

All this of course is off topic which for some reason doesn't seem to matter today

I think this is very much related to the topic, Davel, because if the abduction was planned, then it wasn't some paedo who happened along and grabbed her on an impulse to do dreadful things to her and probably kill her.

I think that Madeleine was selected for a purpose and having seen the video (now with OG) showing her (99% certainty) in 2012, I think that she is likely to still be alive.

I know that you are convinced by HCWs words, so will not agree with me,

[Mr Gray]

I think this is very much related to the topic, Davel, because if the abduction was planned, then it wasn't some paedo who happened along and grabbed her on an impulse to do dreadful things to her and probably kill her.

I think that Madeleine was selected for a purpose and having seen the video (now with OG) showing her (99% certainty) in 2012, I think that she is likely to still be alive.

I know that you are convinced by HCWs words, so will not agree with me,

My post yesterday re the abduction was deemed off topic... So if mine was then yours is.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I don’t know that he was waiting for a lift but it is one logical explanation.

As to Tamsin, she was a young girl, young girls love drama. Besides she only reported what she saw, it was the adults who interpreted that information.

What a horrible sexist stereotype (and if you must insult her, at least get her name right). 

[Mr Gray]

I think this is very much related to the topic, Davel, because if the abduction was planned, then it wasn't some paedo who happened along and grabbed her on an impulse to do dreadful things to her and probably kill her.

I think that Madeleine was selected for a purpose and having seen the video (now with OG) showing her (99% certainty) in 2012, I think that she is likely to still be alive.

I know that you are convinced by HCWs words, so will not agree with me,

You continue with the fallacy that im convinced by HCWs words....stop insulting me and accept you are wrong.on that point. Ive considered stranger abduction by a paedophile the most likely for many years...not just because HCW says he has concrete evidence to support it. HCW simply confirms my thoughts.

I find  your theories of bloodlines psychics and snakes quite ridiculous. Ive never shown my views re your bizarre theories before but when you continually imply I beleive in stranger abduction simply because HCW says so I have to answer. Perhaps its about time you became a little more open minded
 

[faithlilly]

What a horrible sexist stereotype (and if you must insult her, at least get her name right).

I was a young girl at one point...I was surrounded by other young girls. I’m speaking from experience. It was not meant to be an insult.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I was a young girl at one point...I was surrounded by other young girls. I’m speaking from experience. It was not meant to be an insult.

I was a young girl too, I had a much younger sister and I have brought up a young girl too and I disagree that all young girls love drama to the extent that they would be "thrilled" to have to give a police statement in a missing child case.  I would have certainly been quite upset and scared by the experience, and would have treated it seriously and not like some sort of TV drama, as I'm pretty sure would my sister and daughter.   So, best not to generalise I think.

[faithlilly]

I was a young girl too, I had a much younger sister and I have brought up a young girl too and I disagree that all young girls love drama to the extent that they would be "thrilled" to have to give a police statement in a missing child case.  I would have certainly been quite upset and scared by the experience, and would have treated it seriously and not like some sort of TV drama, as I'm pretty sure would my sister and daughter.   So, best not to generalise I think.

Did I say that the young girl was ‘thrilled’.

I’m not going to play semantics. You have a different experience of young girls from me, that’s fine. We’ll leave the reader to decide which description most fits their experience.

The main point is that the child described what she had seen. The context of what she saw is unknown.