Discovery Plus new 3 part documentary Feb 2021

[Mr Gray]

Unless he appeals the rape conviction which imo sounds dodgy ie word of a criminal and a single hair found at soc from a "brutal rape".

It seems the word of a criminal was quite accurate and matched the account given by the victim. Is that just a coincidence

[Holly Goodhead]

It seems the word of a criminal was quite accurate and matched the account given by the victim. Is that just a coincidence

Who did the matching?

[Eleanor]

Assuming you don't have a diary note to refer to, can you remember what you were doing on the eve of 3rd May 2007?  I doubt CB is the type to keep a diary and then retain for years.

I dont believe CB or FF have even heard the prosecutor's case against him.

I would if I was in Praia de Luz that evening and then changed my car to another registered owner the next day.

[Mr Gray]

Assuming you don't have a diary note to refer to, can you remember what you were doing on the eve of 3rd May 2007?  I doubt CB is the type to keep a diary and then retain for years.

I dont believe CB or FF have even heard the prosecutor's case against him.

PDL was in turmoil around that time. His girlfrirriend appears to remember the date

[Eleanor]

Unless he appeals the rape conviction which imo sounds dodgy ie word of a criminal and a single hair found at soc from a "brutal rape".

He's already lost that appeal.

How do you think his hair got into the bed?  And No, the cat won't do.

[Vertigo Swirl]

The claim is via a tabloid not direct from the horse's mouth.

Meaning?  You don't believe he said it anyway?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I didn't say I find FF highly credible.  I said polished and professional. FF is not the one making public proclamations.

I came up with a credible theory which ticks all the right boxes and I'm standing by it.

Polished and professional but not highly credible?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Unless he appeals the rape conviction which imo sounds dodgy ie word of a criminal and a single hair found at soc from a "brutal rape".

Are you questioning whether or not there was a brutal rape?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Who did the matching?

The police.  It's what they do. 

[Mr Gray]

Who did the matching?

How do you think the rape came to light. The informants described the rape and gave details. The PJ I believe looked through their cases and found one that matched the description. The rape happened in PDL and a hair found in the victims bed matched CB. I think that's good evidence

Perhaps if they have CBs DNA in 5a you will argue the cat brought it in

[Holly Goodhead]

I would if I was in Praia de Luz that evening and then changed my car to another registered owner the next day.

He lived in PDL albeit on the outskirts.

No reason to tie in a mundane chore with the disappearance of MM and 3rd May.

[Holly Goodhead]

PDL was in turmoil around that time. His girlfrirriend appears to remember the date

If he's  innocent, and I think he is, a  young guy isn't really going to take that much notice about a missing child.  The fact we're interested doesn't mean the rest of the world is.

[Holly Goodhead]

He's already lost that appeal.

How do you think his hair got into the bed?  And No, the cat won't do.

He lost the appeal based on the extradition process.  He might well appeal based on the so-called evidence.

I would like to see a full chain of custody of the hair.

[Holly Goodhead]

Meaning?  You don't believe he said it anyway?

Nothing like hearing it from the Horse's mouth.

[Mr Gray]

If he's  innocent, and I think he is, a  young guy isn't really going to take that much notice about a missing child.  The fact we're interested doesn't mean the rest of the world is.

I was speaking to an Austrian friend who I haven't seen for a long time. He knew all about it and said they've got that German guy who did it.

How can you think he's innocent... Surely you don't have enough information to reach such a decision