"Innocents Betrayed " by Sandra Lean

[Mr Apples]

What was the evidence of Mahasweta Roy

Don't know. It's not in the public domain -- although we have context of her appearance as a crown witness from the following:

https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/search-judgments/judgment?id=e2988aa6-8980-69d2-b500-ff0000d74aa7

Ground of appeal 6. My phone won't let me copy and paste the contents of that ground of appeal.

[Nicholas]

What was the evidence of Philip Mitchell’s ‘new wife’ and what reason did she given for buying killer Luke Mitchell a Marilyn Manson calendar for his birthday?

[Nicholas]

How did killer Luke Mitchell collect 20 bottles or urine by the 4th July 2003 if detective constable Lindsay was at the house?

“During the search of 203 Newbattle Abbey Crescent on 4 July 2003 a number of bottles containing liquid were found in the appellant's bedroom, some on and some under the bed.

Did Corinne Mitchell buy her killer son Luke Mitchell empty bottles to urinate in ?

And what type of bottles were they?

[Nicholas]

Did killer Luke Mitchell also dispose of any computer equipment following his murder?

[Nicholas]

Did killer Luke Mitchell also dispose of any computer equipment following his murder?

Did the police seize all of the computer equipment found in killer Luke Mitchell’s bedroom?

”But yesterday Police Constable Anita Dow, 35, described the finding of a pouch similar to that belonging to the sample knife shown to the jury by Alan Turnbull QC, advocate depute, prosecuting.

“The court heard yesterday that Mr Mitchell was arrested in an early morning swoop on his home on April 14 this year.

Before he was led away in handcuffs, detectives found cannabis resin and herbal cannabis in his pockets.

After Mr Mitchell was taken to Dalkeith Police Station, other officers began to search his bedroom. Ms Dow said that Mr Mitchell appeared to sleep under a duvet which was on the floor, but not in his bed

"There were so many belongings on the top of it. There were computer keyboards and monitors lying on it, " she said..


Why did killer Luke Mitchell have so many computer keyboards and monitors on his bed?

[Nicholas]

What was the name of the dog the Mitchell’s had before Mia?

[Nicholas]

Did the police seize all of the computer equipment found in killer Luke Mitchell’s bedroom?

”But yesterday Police Constable Anita Dow, 35, described the finding of a pouch similar to that belonging to the sample knife shown to the jury by Alan Turnbull QC, advocate depute, prosecuting.

“The court heard yesterday that Mr Mitchell was arrested in an early morning swoop on his home on April 14 this year.

Before he was led away in handcuffs, detectives found cannabis resin and herbal cannabis in his pockets.

After Mr Mitchell was taken to Dalkeith Police Station, other officers began to search his bedroom. Ms Dow said that Mr Mitchell appeared to sleep under a duvet which was on the floor, but not in his bed

"There were so many belongings on the top of it. There were computer keyboards and monitors lying on it, " she said..


Why did killer Luke Mitchell have so many computer keyboards and monitors on his bed?

Did killer Luke Mitchell forge a birth certificate and ID in the name of Ian Tyler before getting a tattoo in October 2003?


[174] …. The appellant was asked for identification to prove that he was over 18 years of age. ……..he produced a birth certificate which showed that he was more than 18 and a photo identification card which matched the name.

[Nicholas]

Did killer Luke Mitchell forge a birth certificate and ID in the name of Ian Tyler before getting a tattoo in October 2003?


[174] …. The appellant was asked for identification to prove that he was over 18 years of age. ……..he produced a birth certificate which showed that he was more than 18 and a photo identification card which matched the name.

What was Ian Tyler’s evidence and why did killer Luke Mitchell (and Corinne Mitchell) choose to use the name Ian Tyler - as opposed say Ian Tanner - in order for the 15 year old killer to get an underage tattoo?

[Nicholas]

Did killer Luke Mitchell forge a birth certificate and ID in the name of Ian Tyler before getting a tattoo in October 2003?


[174] …. The appellant was asked for identification to prove that he was over 18 years of age. ……..he produced a birth certificate which showed that he was more than 18 and a photo identification card which matched the name.

Did the police find any forged documents/forged photo ID’s during their searches?

[Nicholas]

Did killer Luke Mitchell forge a birth certificate and ID in the name of Ian Tyler before getting a tattoo in October 2003?


[174] …. The appellant was asked for identification to prove that he was over 18 years of age. ……..he produced a birth certificate which showed that he was more than 18 and a photo identification card which matched the name.

Did other witnesses give evidence that killer Luke Mitchell used aliases or had fake ID showing him to be over 18?

[Nicholas]

What was the evidence of Philip Mitchell’s ‘new wife’ and what reason did she given for buying killer Luke Mitchell a Marilyn Manson calendar for his birthday?

Wouldn’t the Marilyn Manson calendar also have been from killer Luke Mitchell’s father Philip Mitchell?

[Nicholas]

What was the evidence of Philip Mitchell’s ‘new wife’ and what reason did she given for buying killer Luke Mitchell a Marilyn Manson calendar for his birthday?

Who decided to say the Marilyn Manson calendar was from the ‘new wife’ and not Philip Mitchell?

[Nicholas]

Wouldn’t the Marilyn Manson calendar also have been from killer Luke Mitchell’s father Philip Mitchell?

Did Philip Mitchell buy the Marilyn Manson calendar for his killer son Luke Mitchell for his birthday and this fact morph into it being from the ‘new wife’?

[Nicholas]

What was the evidence of Philip Mitchell’s ‘new wife’ and what reason did she given for buying killer Luke Mitchell a Marilyn Manson calendar for his birthday?

Why didn’t Donald Findlay call killer Luke Mitchell’s fathers (Philip Mitchell) ‘new wife’ to give evidence about why she had bought her step son a Marilyn Manson calendar for his birthday ?

[Nicholas]

The evidence points to killer Luke Mitchell utinating in bottles before he committed his murder

Excerpts from Sandra Lean’s 1st discredited book No Smoke

“”Another complete red herring was the finding of bottles of urine found in Luke‟s bedroom
“The perfectly innocent explanation – that the trauma of events had triggered a form of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), compelling him to "hold on" to literally everything, never made it to the public domain.

The evidence points to these bottles of urine having been in killer Luke Mitchell’s bedroom before he committed his murder