Another view of dog evidence

[registrar]

Registrar pls provide evidence that eddie has ever alerted to a vegetable when he is trained to alert to dead human bodies, its not rocket science

A coconut dearest, is a seed or a fruit - NOT a vegetable - and certainly not part of a human skull

[debunker]

Registrar pls provide evidence that eddie has ever alerted to a vegetable when he is trained to alert to dead human bodies, its not rocket science

Produce ANYTHING apart from Mr Grime´s claims that Eddie reacts correctly to cadaver scent or blood.

[Carana]

Eddie alerted. Humans had a look to see what he barked at. They found what they thought to be a piece of skull, and assumed that that was he was alerting to. It was the humans who got it wrong.

A likely explanation, in my view, is that the coconut fragment was part of a meal and got chucked out along with the rest of the meal. If that meal contained pork, he could have been reacting to decomposed meat.

Poor old Eddie could hardly explain "Noooo, not the coconut...."

[John]

Prout said he killed her in the building outside, then put her body in the car and went in the car to a pub, with the body in the car still.

So he had a curtain prepared in the car to wrap her up in? Rather than sneek her body back in the house and use a curtain to do so? pls do cite now the report where he killed her in an outbuilding, cheers, and you DO realise dont you that even if he personally didnt bring her body into the living room HE may have contaminated it with HER death scent? Food for thought before you run off and say Eddie is useless

I caught your comment in passing Redblossom and I too was corrected on this just last week.  Here is the discussion and the links.  Apparently he murdered her in the shooting lodge and wrapped her in one of its curtains.

He put her body in the back of the Land Rover but whether he took it or another vehicle to the pub is still debatable.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1112.msg31414#msg31414

[Redblossom]

Thanks John.

[John]

Always glad to help