Shane not being able to provide an alibi for his own brother, for me personally, above all else, is the single most damning piece of evidence against Luke (at least, from what I’ve read of the case so far). And, of course, when you consider Shane’s testimony, and place it alongside all the other evidence, we have a strong circumstancial case against Luke, imo. Enough to prove he was guilty beyond reasonable doubt? That is the crux of the matter.
But, let me go back to Shane’s testimony. I still haven’t had the time read Sandra’s book (will endeavour to read more over the weekend), but I’m guessing there will be an in-depth commentary about what evidence Shane gave in court and the circumstances surrounding it, and, of course, the different interpretations of it. Now, here are a few questions: to what extent was Shane a reliable witness? It’s common knowledge he said he had a memory problem that was the result of a drug problem. To what extent? Were there medical certificates produced in court, proving this? Was Shane, unlike Luke, bullied by police? Remember, Shane was aggressively arrested by numerous police officers on April 14th, 2004, along with Luke & Corinne, and told he would face charges of attempting to pervert the course of justice. Did they, while Shane was in shock and probably scared and vulnerable, ambiguously ask if Shane was looking at pornography whilst on the internet between 1653 - 1716 on 30.06.03? For example, SL indicates that the connection to the porn sites only lasted literally sections, implying that images SM was looking at were not images consciously & deliberately accessed, but were pop-ups. If this was the case, then that puts Shane in a dilemma, because, while he may not have been seeking out porn to look at for his own gratification, he was still looking at pornography wether he like it or not, cos of these pop-ups. It could’ve been that, on 14.04.03, Shane was scared to saying anything at all, lest he was arrested; that Shane was bullied by police aggression, and ambiguous questioning that he didn’t fully understand. I’ve never read any stories where SM has stated that, categorically, he was masturbating during the above timings (can someone refute this?), and, even if he was, he was in his own bedroom. The bulk of the online material SM was viewing was car repair websites (which ties in with Shane helping his friend fix his car that day and why he arrived home later than normal; he normally got in from work around 1530, before Luke, but got home that day at 1630/1640). Furthermore, if you combine all of this police aggression, tactics of ambiguous questioning, a vulnerable, scared Shane with memory loss issues from drug abuse, along with the distress and humiliation of appearing at a high profile murder case where one has to talk about porn and masturbation, then, damn, that is one stressful situation. Taking all of this into account, I’m not so sure Shane’s testimony was/is reliable. That’s not to say I categorically think it isn’t, but it does make one wonder.
Also quite interesting is the evidence from DCI Cravens, who forensically analysed SM’s hard drive. Mr Cravens said that 131 files were stored on SM’s hard drive. Problem with this is that it does not mean 131 individual separate images; it is files — i.e. gifs, html, JPEGs, etc. To put it in context, a single solitary image accessed on the internet can create up to 50 or 60 files on your computer’s Hard drive. Very ambiguous stuff, like most of the evidence from this case.
https://www.scotsman.com/news/pc-used-access-internet-porn-day-jodi-died-2509716Ps: typing from my iphone. Sorry for any typos, etc.