Author Topic: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges  (Read 23952 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

debunker

  • Guest
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« on: April 30, 2013, 10:37:17 AM »
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #1 on: April 30, 2013, 10:44:30 AM »
Nor have Murat, the Tapas 7, Malinka, the waiters, the nursery staff or anyone else in PdL on the night of 3rd May 2007 for that matter.  All innocent until proven guilty but "not cleared" of committing a heinous act.   >@@(*&)

Totally agree.

So we should not claim that the McCanns have been cleared, just that theyare due the presumption of innocence.

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #2 on: April 30, 2013, 11:18:34 AM »
I really do not understand the question.  It is not possible to "cleared" of something which does not exist. 

As an aside, Lord Soper (if you remember him) used to be a regular at Speakers Corner.  One day a heckler called out "You are mad".  He ignored the interruption.  The man kept repeating "You are mad".  In the end, Soper took the bait.  "I am NOT mad.". 

"Prove it!" came the challenge.

Soper pondered for a moment.  "I can't".  "But can you prove that YOU are not mad?"

The man proudly produced a certificate of discharge from a well known mental hospital. 

There is a moral to this somewhere........   

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #3 on: April 30, 2013, 11:22:28 AM »
I really do not understand the question.  It is not possible to "cleared" of something which does not exist. 

As an aside, Lord Soper (if you remember him) used to be a regular at Speakers Corner.  One day a heckler called out "You are mad".  He ignored the interruption.  The man kept repeating "You are mad".  In the end, Soper took the bait.  "I am NOT mad.". 

"Prove it!" came the challenge.

Soper pondered for a moment.  "I can't".  "But can you prove that YOU are not mad?"

The man proudly produced a certificate of discharge from a well known mental hospital. 

There is a moral to this somewhere........

Totally agree- there is no procedure to 'clear' suspects, theyare merely presumed innocent.

As a retired mental health nurse I have told that story many times.

Offline muratfan

Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #4 on: April 30, 2013, 11:43:42 AM »
The McCanns, it was said, in the final report, were not implicit in any wrong doing concerning the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine McCann. Sounds like cleared to me.

Now remember we have different laws in different countries. Cleared of charges means different things.

UK means going to court and found NOT GUILTY

Portugal means being cleared by those prosecuting

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #5 on: April 30, 2013, 11:57:13 AM »
The McCanns, it was said, in the final report, were not implicit in any wrong doing concerning the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine McCann. Sounds like cleared to me.

Now remember we have different laws in different countries. Cleared of charges means different things.

UK means going to court and found NOT GUILTY

Portugal means being cleared by those prosecuting

I don't believe so. Perhaps you could produce evidence that a prosecutor failing to find sufficient evidence (no indication- note NOT 'no evidence') of a crime having been committed by an individual.

Cite please.

The prosecutor would look a right wally if he cleared someone, only later having to charge them when sufficient evidence is later found.

I am afraid all we can say is that they are still due the presumption of innocence!

Unless you can provide a reference to Portuguese Law which contradicts this......

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #6 on: April 30, 2013, 03:41:45 PM »
Debunker, do you agree that when someone on the "sceptic" side of the argument says "The McCanns have NOT been cleared" that this implies they are still suspects, albeit unofficially so?  What is the McCanns' status then if not cleared of suspicion and yet not official suspects?

They may mean that but they are wrong. The McCanns are due the presumption of innocence but they have not 'been cleared'.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #7 on: April 30, 2013, 05:03:37 PM »
If you were once an official suspect but are now no longer an official suspect then that means you are no longer officially suspected doesn't it?

Yes.  Unless something (at present unknown) should come to light to suggest otherwise.

A crime remains unsolved and a child remains missing.



debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #8 on: April 30, 2013, 05:27:48 PM »
Debunker, do you agree that when someone on the "sceptic" side of the argument says "The McCanns have NOT been cleared" that this implies they are still suspects, albeit unofficially so?  What is the McCanns' status then if not cleared of suspicion and yet not official suspects?

They may mean that but they are wrong. The McCanns are due the presumption of innocence but they have not 'been cleared'.

Surely the McCanns' and Murat's status is somewhat different to that of the Tapas 7, waiters etc who have also "not been cleared" - by virtue of the fact that they (the McCanns & Murat) WERE at one time official suspects and are now no longer. 

If you were once an official suspect but are now no longer an official suspect then that means you are no longer officially suspected doesn't it? >@@(*&)

Arguido status confers rights on people. It does not change their legal status apart from that.

There is an interesting conundrum here.

Most Pros would say that being an Arguido says nothing about culpability
Most [ censored word] would say that being an Arguido at least arouses suspicion- no smoke without fire.

Now if Arguido status is withdrawn (as in this case) then I would argue that it would be illogical for an anti to suggest that such a release did not lessen their potential culpability and most importantly a pro can not really claim that being released from Arguido status removes suspicion if they previously maintained that being made arguido did not increase their potential culpability.

Logic is a bit of a b....r!

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #9 on: April 30, 2013, 05:36:51 PM »
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #10 on: April 30, 2013, 05:44:04 PM »
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

Correct.

You will find that Pro forums like to claim that the McCanns have been cleared of criminal charges by the processes of the judicial system. This is a false statement as there is no such process available to suspects.

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #11 on: April 30, 2013, 05:52:31 PM »
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

Correct.

You will find that Pro forums like to claim that the McCanns have been cleared of criminal charges by the processes of the judicial system. This is a false statement as there is no such process available to suspects.

I think you will find that pro forums say that the Mccanns have been released from arguido status and no criminal charges have been made.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #12 on: April 30, 2013, 05:54:13 PM »
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

Correct.

You will find that Pro forums like to claim that the McCanns have been cleared of criminal charges by the processes of the judicial system. This is a false statement as there is no such process available to suspects.

I think you will find that pro forums say that the Mccanns have been released from arguido status and no criminal charges have been made.

Some say that. Many say that they have been cleared.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #13 on: April 30, 2013, 10:12:22 PM »
Debunker, do you agree that when someone on the "sceptic" side of the argument says "The McCanns have NOT been cleared" that this implies they are still suspects, albeit unofficially so?  What is the McCanns' status then if not cleared of suspicion and yet not official suspects?
The McCanns have no statute at all, they're free, if persons suspect them it's these persons' problem, not the McCann's.
They couldn't be relieved from their arguido (not exactly "suspect" but person of interest) statute  before the end of the investigation. Now if they had a strong element to ask for the reopening of the case, I don't know what their statute would be. It would likely be related to the nature of the element. If, desperate to see the case reopened, they'd ask for a reconstitution, would they be made arguidos just to protect them ? I've no idea !

Offline Chinagirl

Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #14 on: May 01, 2013, 12:34:05 AM »
Quote:
Most Pros would say that being an Arguido says nothing about culpability
Most [ censored word] would say that being an Arguido at least arouses suspicion- no smoke without fire.

Unquote

I agree with Martha's comment above that "most pros" would agree with [ censored word] that being made arguido arouses suspicion of wrongdoing on the part of the arguido.  However, the removal of the arguido status because no evidence of criminality was found against that arguido removes all vestige of suspicion, and the arguido is then CLEARED.
A