Author Topic: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges  (Read 23945 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Chinagirl

Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #30 on: May 01, 2013, 07:33:38 AM »
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...
A

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #31 on: May 01, 2013, 07:42:18 AM »
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #32 on: May 01, 2013, 07:43:50 AM »
What is the status of a statement by someone who insists that the McCanns have been 'cleared'?

It is a claim backed by no evidence- merely the belief of the utterer. It has no meaning in law and is as meaningful as someone who says that they are still suspects- merely a social opinion with no standing in law.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #33 on: May 01, 2013, 08:14:18 AM »
Just watching the news.

Amanda Knox.

Under the Roman Law based legal system as Portugal.

Has she been cleared?

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #34 on: May 01, 2013, 08:17:01 AM »
I look forward today to the first post from someone insisting that the McCanns have been cleared that includes a reference to the procedure that legally 'clears' people.

Offline Chinagirl

Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #35 on: May 01, 2013, 08:42:58 AM »
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

Has the UK attorney general (or any law enforcement authority) stated that there "are no indications of a crime" committed by them?

The McCanns and Murat have had such a statement made about them by Portugal's AG, effectively clearing them of any crime.
A

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #36 on: May 01, 2013, 09:24:25 AM »
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

Has the UK attorney general (or any law enforcement authority) stated that there "are no indications of a crime" committed by them?

The McCanns and Murat have had such a statement made about them by Portugal's AG, effectively clearing them of any crime.

Nothing to do with the UK.

The events occurred on Portuguese soil.

Offline Chinagirl

Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #37 on: May 01, 2013, 09:30:42 AM »
Agreed, Stephen - but Debunker has stated a general concept - that no one can be "cleared" of suspicion of having committed a crime unless found not guilty in a court of law - in any jurisdiction.
A

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #38 on: May 01, 2013, 09:45:18 AM »
Just watching the news.

Amanda Knox.

Under the Roman Law based legal system as Portugal.

Has she been cleared?

Christ knows.  She WAS aquitted but now she is being re-tried.  When they find her guilty again will she have a right to appeal and be acquiited again?  It's madness.

It is noit madness, but a different judicial system where 'getting it right' is more important than 'winning a case'.

The continental inquisitorial system works under the philosophical misapprehension that it is possible to make a decision now about exactly what happened at an earlier time. The adversarial system is more pragmatic, relying on what is provable ablout the past but making no claim to accuracy about the true events.

But you do see what I mean by the difficulty of saying someone is 'cleared'.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #39 on: May 01, 2013, 09:46:55 AM »
So, if the McCanns have not been cleared, then neither has Murat.  What can these people do to clear their names of suspicion once and for all?  Insist that they are tried for abduction and cover-up?

They do not need to clear their names any more than other people with means, motive and opportunity (Tapas 7, Warner staff etc.) who are all due the same thing- presumption of innocence.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #40 on: May 01, 2013, 09:51:12 AM »
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

Has the UK attorney general (or any law enforcement authority) stated that there "are no indications of a crime" committed by them?

The McCanns and Murat have had such a statement made about them by Portugal's AG, effectively clearing them of any crime.

It does not in any way change their legal status regarding potential culpability.

1/ They were once not under suspicion (before Madeleine disappeared)
2/ They came under suspicion along with all others with mean, motive or opportunity
3/ They became arguidos which gave them more rights
4/ They were released from Arguido status which removed those rights
5/ If further evidence emerges, they may become under suspicion again.

Items 1,2 and 5 apply to all others ever under suspicion.

No-one ever lost the right to presumption of innocence.

No-one entered any special category from which they needed to be legally freed (cleared.)

There is no process in law to clear someone of a suspicion.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #41 on: May 01, 2013, 09:52:17 AM »
Agreed, Stephen - but Debunker has stated a general concept - that no one can be "cleared" of suspicion of having committed a crime unless found not guilty in a court of law - in any jurisdiction.

That is correct.


debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #42 on: May 01, 2013, 09:53:30 AM »
I think we have to accept that when we say the McCanns have been cleared we are using the phrase in the idiomatic sense, ie:

Idioms:
clear the air
To dispel differences or emotional tensions.
in the clear
1. Free from burdens or dangers.
2. Not subject to suspicion or accusations of guilt: The evidence showed that the suspect was in the clear.



http://www.thefreedictionary.com/clear

As the McCanns were never charged then they can not be cleared of charges of criminal activity, only of any suspicion of guilt that being an arguido may have conferred on them. 

Is being cleared even a legal term out of interest?

Idiomatic equals opinion.

I have no problem with people having the opinion that (in their eyes) the McCanns have been cleared.

What is not true is the claim that the McCanns have been cleared.


debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #43 on: May 01, 2013, 09:54:31 AM »
So, if the McCanns have not been cleared, then neither has Murat.  What can these people do to clear their names of suspicion once and for all?  Insist that they are tried for abduction and cover-up?

They do not need to clear their names any more than other people with means, motive and opportunity (Tapas 7, Warner staff etc.) who are all due the same thing- presumption of innocence.

However, other people were not made arguidos or had their reputations ruined by the press for months.

Legally that makes no difference.

None of them have been 'cleared' because there is no such process.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
« Reply #44 on: May 01, 2013, 09:56:21 AM »
Just watching the news.

Amanda Knox.

Under the Roman Law based legal system as Portugal.

Has she been cleared?

Christ knows.  She WAS aquitted but now she is being re-tried.  When they find her guilty again will she have a right to appeal and be acquiited again?  It's madness.

It is noit madness, but a different judicial system where 'getting it right' is more important than 'winning a case'.

The continental inquisitorial system works under the philosophical misapprehension that it is possible to make a decision now about exactly what happened at an earlier time. The adversarial system is more pragmatic, relying on what is provable ablout the past but making no claim to accuracy about the true events.

But you do see what I mean by the difficulty of saying someone is 'cleared'.

So can Amanda Knox EVER be said to be cleared, even if she is acquitted again?

Once the final court has heard the case, she will be cleared by the Italian System of Justice if they find that she did not kill anyone. The Inquisition will be finalised and she will be cleared.