Author Topic: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment  (Read 42771 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

ferryman

  • Guest
Exactly.

Now answer the question- Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record?

No.  Because he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence for a civil violation.

debunker

  • Guest
"There are both civil and criminal components to the Act. The criminal offence of Contempt of Court carries a gaol sentence of up to two year and an unlimited fine."

http://www.inbrief.co.uk/legal-system/contempt-of-court-act.htm

debunker

  • Guest
"Contempt of court is a criminal offence and carries severe penalties: an unlimited fine and/or up to two years imprisonment"

http://www.independentproducerhandbook.co.uk/72/5b-contempt-and-reporting-legal-proceedings/contempt-or-subjudice-rules.html

ferryman

  • Guest
"There are both civil and criminal components to the Act. The criminal offence of Contempt of Court carries a gaol sentence of up to two year and an unlimited fine."

http://www.inbrief.co.uk/legal-system/contempt-of-court-act.htm

That is all about breach of sub judice in active proceedings.

debunker

  • Guest
"There are both civil and criminal components to the Act. The criminal offence of Contempt of Court carries a gaol sentence of up to two year and an unlimited fine."

http://www.inbrief.co.uk/legal-system/contempt-of-court-act.htm

That is all about breach of sub judice in active proceedings.

Which is civil contempt- punishable by two years in gaol. The 'Civil' distiction merely separates background contempt (refusal to comply with court orders) from contempt in the face of the court. Both may be dealt with formally or informally. If dealt with formally they may involve criminal sanction such as fines or imprisonment that are not available for torts!

There is a good quote that I cam across that sums up the problem you have:

"As birds go, contempt of court is a strange one. Perhaps rather than birds, one should think platypus, that peculiar Australian mammal that lays eggs. That's because contempt of court quacks like a civil duck but walks like a criminal one."


ferryman

  • Guest
I was (originally) of the same view as you.

It was actually (of all people!) Tony Bennett himself in debate who corrected me.

I researched it, discovered he as right and conceded the point.

You should do the same ...

And yes, the platypus is (I think) the only exception of a mammal that lays eggs.

It is still an egg-laying mammal

Same as prison for (civil) contempt is a prison sentence, for a civil violation ...

debunker

  • Guest
I was (originally) of the same view as you.

It was actually (of all people!) Tony Bennett himself in debate who corrected me.

I researched it, discovered he as right and conceded the point.

You should do the same ...

And yes, the platypus is (I think) the only exception of a mammal that lays eggs.

It is still an egg-laying mammal

Same as prison for (civil) contempt is a prison sentence, for a civil violation ...

I think you will find that Tony Bennett was splitting hairs to save face (as usual). It is a principle of English Law for over a century that you cannot be detained or fined for a tort. Imprisonment is a coercive response to breaches of the criminal law. Although there are two 'types' of contempt, there is only one disposal if detention is necessitated.

ferryman

  • Guest
I've finally sussed the source of Debunker's confusion

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_difference_between_civil_offense_and_criminal_offense

(sic)

2. The loser in a civil case cannot be imprisoned, even if he or she cannot pay the damages.

One small problem: Debunker is citing American law, not English.

debunker

  • Guest
I've finally sussed the source of Debunker's confusion

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_difference_between_civil_offense_and_criminal_offense

(sic)

2. The loser in a civil case cannot be imprisoned, even if he or she cannot pay the damages.

One small problem: Debunker is citing American law, not English.

I am not citing American Law.

ferryman

  • Guest
I've finally sussed the source of Debunker's confusion

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_difference_between_civil_offense_and_criminal_offense

(sic)

2. The loser in a civil case cannot be imprisoned, even if he or she cannot pay the damages.

One small problem: Debunker is citing American law, not English.

I am not citing American Law.

One dead give-away is the spelling of offence (standard British English) as offense (standard US English)

Here's the other (from the link)

3. State or federal statutes always establish criminal law.

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Can I ask, what all this has got to do with the title of the thread?.  >@@(*&)
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

ferryman

  • Guest
Fair question.

The diversion stemmed from this series of exchanges:

What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter


I'm not sure that the Express and the McCanns are the best of friends...


(my post):

I think I'm right that The Express has to tread carefully with the McCanns because, having libelled them once, the editor could actually go to prison if the paper transgresses a second time.

I think that's the case, an impression I gained from somewhere. 

Perhaps Jean Pierre could help us out here?


Then Debunker insisted there could not be imprisonment for civil matters and it went from there ...

debunker

  • Guest
Have checked all my cites. No legal ones were US ones.

You also mis-state the use of 'offence' between US and UK (and other) usage. It is far more complicated than that. I write and speak both received southern English and Standard American English and am quite aware of the differences.

Offline Jean-Pierre

My understanding of the position is that in the case of contempt of court occasioned by breach of an undertaking (in this case the proceedings must be triggered by the offended party, as opposed to the court itself), the court does not seek to punish the contemptnor, merely to do whatever is necessary to prevent further breaches.

One of the remedies is a term of imprisonment.  However, all the contemptnor has to do to be released is to agree to comply with the undertaking - he is therefore held to be "in possession of the keys to his own cell".

Thereforer Bennett does not have a criminal record. 

debunker

  • Guest
My understanding of the position is that in the case of contempt of court occasioned by breach of an undertaking (in this case the proceedings must be triggered by the offended party, as opposed to the court itself), the court does not seek to punish the contemptnor, merely to do whatever is necessary to prevent further breaches.

One of the remedies is a term of imprisonment.  However, all the contemptnor has to do to be released is to agree to comply with the undertaking - he is therefore held to be "in possession of the keys to his own cell".

Thereforer Bennett does not have a criminal record.

According to the current review of the Law of Comtent, the case law has become so complicated that it no longer makes any sense and is difficult to decide what is in fact the case.

http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/criminal/docs/invitation-to-comment.pdf