Author Topic: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment  (Read 42773 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline faithlilly

Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Where do you think SY got, eight important new leads, from?

I presume from the same place they got the 195 from last year that didn't come to anything.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

The McCanns and friends were more than happy to do a recon in May 2007 when events would have been fresh in their minds... it was kyboshed by the PJ.  When the holiday friends were asked to return in 2008 it had become clear that the PJs motives were to stitch up Kate and Gerry McCann, so the holiday party quite rightly refused.

The point,   is that it is Murat who is asking for a reconstruction 'now'  ( under Scotland Yard's auspices )  ...  the McCanns and their buds are not


And? Murat has no business asking for a reconstruction - he wasn't there when Madeleine went missing, so what has it got to do with him?. It's not for him to ask for a recon.  The McCanns and the holiday party were more than willing in May 2007 but the ever-bungling PJ put the brakes on it.

Who says the McCanns were willing to do a reconstruction in 2007 ? Perhaps it was simply fortuitous for them that the PJ did decline to do one just after the disappearance ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

ferryman

  • Guest
My understanding of the position is that in the case of contempt of court occasioned by breach of an undertaking (in this case the proceedings must be triggered by the offended party, as opposed to the court itself), the court does not seek to punish the contemptnor, merely to do whatever is necessary to prevent further breaches.

One of the remedies is a term of imprisonment.  However, all the contemptnor has to do to be released is to agree to comply with the undertaking - he is therefore held to be "in possession of the keys to his own cell".

Thereforer Bennett does not have a criminal record.

From Debuker's link:

b. civil contempt involves disobedience of a court order or undertaking by a
party who is bound by it. The court’s sanction in civil contempt has been seen
primarily as coercive or remedial. Civil contempt has largely arisen in respect
of an order or undertaking made in civil litigation. However, as some civil
orders now are made in criminal cases, for example the restraint order
considered in R v M, a civil contempt may occur in the course of proceedings
in a criminal court.

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Quote
Faithlilly

Who says the McCanns were willing to do a reconstruction in 2007 ? Perhaps it was simply fortuitous for them that the PJ did decline to do one just after the disappearance ?

thankyou for confirming that the PJ declined to do one just after the disappearance - you know - the time when it would have had maximum effect!

ferryman

  • Guest
Quote
Faithlilly

Who says the McCanns were willing to do a reconstruction in 2007 ? Perhaps it was simply fortuitous for them that the PJ did decline to do one just after the disappearance ?

thankyou for confirming that the PJ declined to do one just after the disappearance - you know - the time when it would have had maximum effect!

Of "establishing guilt or innocence"?

"Maximum effect"?

Is there anywhere else that uses reconstructions for such a purpose?

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
For some reason the tapas group are criticised for not going back to do a reconstruction - to prove their innocence.

Where is the criticism of the PJ for declining to do a reconstruction to help trying to find a missing child shortly after the event?
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 05:41:21 PM by amaraltheofficeboy »

Offline Eleanor

For some reason the tapas group are criticised for not going back to do a reconstruction - to prove their innocence.

Where is the criticism of the PJ for declining to do a reconstruction to help trying to find a missing child shortly after the event?

It's them blooming planes, you know.  The ones that fly over Praia da Luz all the blooming time.  Don't know how The PJ were going to stop that in 2008.
Although as far as I can remember, Amaral said that The PJ didn't DO Reconstructions, possibly due to all them blooming planes.

And at what point in time did the Tapas Group have to prove their innocence?  None of them were ever made Arguidos.

And if I had received the sort of Email replies that The Tapas Group got from Rebelo, you wouldn't have seen me on the same Continent as Portugal.  The Tapas Group were refused any assurances, and could have been Arguidos the minute they landed. 
No thank you.