Author Topic: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case  (Read 19994 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #15 on: May 06, 2013, 05:36:59 PM »
No

Check the Portuguese law regarding costs - each side is responsible for their own.

If they decide to drop it then a statement along the lines of "We have decided to concentrate on the search for our daughter, the libel case is proving to be a distraction and we have decided to drop proceedings" - no problem.

Why maliicious - they have good legal grounds for bringing the action in the first place.  And punishment for dropping a case?  You are joking.

But all this is speculation - Amaral is in much teh same position as Bennett - up creek, no paddle.  Even in a Portguese Court.  Sorry.


I do hope you're right Jean-Pierre, although I have to say I am not so confident.  Portuguese law seems to be very different to UK law.  It's a mystery to me that although it has been adjudicated by the Portuguese courts that Leanor Cipriano's 'confession' was extracted by torture, - she is still in prison.  Would that be the case here ?- I don't think so.

Portuguese law in general does take a bit of explaining.

A Portuguese officer (Almeida) is actually convicted of inflicting a barbaric (medieval) torture of bastinado and receives a suspended sentence.

Meanwhile police officers (unidentified) are judicially proven to have tortured Leonor and not merely does her conviction stick.  It is actually increased because she is deemed not to have got her story completely straight while she was having the cr*p beaten out of her with a bag over her head ...

It's perverse.

It's not funny

There was no evidence against Leonor besides the (extorted) "confession".

A further point; she was beaten (nearly) blind, but her eyesight recovered (for now)

That needn't mean she'll get away with it ...
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 05:39:12 PM by ferryman »

Offline Benice

Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #16 on: May 06, 2013, 05:54:54 PM »
No

Check the Portuguese law regarding costs - each side is responsible for their own.

If they decide to drop it then a statement along the lines of "We have decided to concentrate on the search for our daughter, the libel case is proving to be a distraction and we have decided to drop proceedings" - no problem.

Why maliicious - they have good legal grounds for bringing the action in the first place.  And punishment for dropping a case?  You are joking.

But all this is speculation - Amaral is in much teh same position as Bennett - up creek, no paddle.  Even in a Portguese Court.  Sorry.


I do hope you're right Jean-Pierre, although I have to say I am not so confident.  Portuguese law seems to be very different to UK law.  It's a mystery to me that although it has been adjudicated by the Portuguese courts that Leanor Cipriano's 'confession' was extracted by torture, - she is still in prison.  Would that be the case here ?- I don't think so.

Portuguese law in general does take a bit of explaining.

A Portuguese officer (Almeida) is actually convicted of inflicting a barbaric (medieval) torture of bastinado and receives a suspended sentence.

Meanwhile police officers (unidentified) are judicially proven to have tortured Leonor and not merely does her conviction stick.  It is actually increased because she is deemed not to have got her story completely straight while she was having the cr*p beaten out of her with a bag over her head ...

It's perverse.

It's not funny

There was no evidence against Leonor besides the (extorted) "confession".

A further point; she was beaten (nearly) blind, but her eyesight recovered (for now)

That needn't mean she'll get away with it ...

The whole case appears to be appalling from beginning to end - and although they took Leonor back to court  - the relevant authorities seem to be unconcerned as to who did torture her. She sustained those dreadful injuries in a police station - you would think the Pj would leave no stone unturned to find the perpetrators.  But apparently not.

This is one of the reasons why I am not convinced that the McCanns will get justice in Portugal.





The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #17 on: May 06, 2013, 06:13:55 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

Rachel Granada

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #18 on: May 06, 2013, 06:17:36 PM »
Benice said: The whole case appears to be appalling from beginning to end - and although they took Leonor back to court  - the relevant authorities seem to be unconcerned as to who did torture her. She sustained those dreadful injuries in a police station - you would think the Pj would leave no stone unturned to find the perpetrators.  But apparently not.

This is one of the reasons why I am not convinced that the McCanns will get justice in Portugal.


Benice, I am flabbergasted that a police officer who was arguido in the torture of Leonor was put in charge of another missing child case!  In the UK, I would think an officer would have been suspended pending further investigation? It beggars belief! Plus the fact that statements given to the UK police by the Gaspar couple, who probably thought as they were giving statements to the UK police that they would remain confidential, were then released by the PT Authorities!!

I have all my fingers and toes crossed that Kate and Gerry McCann will get justice in PT, and Amaral and his slurs will be stopped once and for all.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #19 on: May 06, 2013, 06:20:31 PM »
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?
These are good questions.
Of course they can withdraw since the initiative was theirs.
No punishment but :
Mr Amaral wouldn't have to pay the court costs (he would likely have to pay his lawyer)
As Mr Amaral's properties were frozen, he certainly were entitled to receive a compensation for that.
The pro would call the withdrawal magnanimity and the anti malice...

You have an amusing take on the law!

Why would he be entitled to compensation- it was the courts, not the McCanns who decided that freezing assets was legal.

Rachel Granada

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #20 on: May 06, 2013, 06:21:26 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #21 on: May 06, 2013, 06:21:57 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

in the UK he would have to apply and prove "wasted costs/expenses" or that an action was vexacious, I have no idea what happens in Portugal

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #22 on: May 06, 2013, 06:30:16 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

debunker

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #23 on: May 06, 2013, 06:31:27 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

WHat for? What would be the claim?

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #24 on: May 06, 2013, 06:33:13 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

you missed my reply

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #25 on: May 06, 2013, 06:35:29 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

you missed my reply

I just saw it, thanks for that

I guess we need someone with knowledge of Portuguese law to give us the answer

Rachel Granada

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #26 on: May 06, 2013, 06:36:10 PM »
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

Yes, sorry icabod - I just got a little emotional there! Interesting question, but what would he sue for? It was the courts that froze his assets, not the McCanns.  Plus would he have the funds for a counter-sue? What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...

Offline Eleanor

Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #27 on: May 06, 2013, 06:44:30 PM »
Does the 'stay' in proceedings allow for negotiations to be re-opened during that period ?

What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,  could they come back with an improved offer as long as it was made withing the  'stay'  period  ?

While they all wait for a new Trial Date, any of them can try to negotiate a Settlement.  The "Stay Period" is now over.  They are simply waiting for a new date of Trial  This will not prevent a settlement being reached.
Amaral can still offer a better settlement during this time.

PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #28 on: May 06, 2013, 06:53:24 PM »
Quote
PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.

wrong - either side can propose a settlement

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
« Reply #29 on: May 06, 2013, 06:57:51 PM »
the most common proposal being: I think I can win xxx if this case goes to court - but to avoid that I will settle for xxx minus something now.