the bottom line is, icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.
I think it is important to demonstrate whether or not it was possible for the man who Jane saw to be the abductor, in the limited time frame allowed
If a re-enactment demonstrated that it was
not possible, for instance ( that there simply wasn't enough time for the abductor to have carried out the crime in the time allowed ) then everyone ( including the McCanns ) could eliminate that scenario, and concentrate on the next three quarters of an hour ... when an abduction really was possible
On the other hand, If it was demonstrated that it was entirely possible for the man Jane saw to have been the abductor, ( because it had been established that there was, indeed, enough time to carry out the crime ) then the McCanns could be reassured that the man they have been highlighting as the abductor, almost certainly was
I really do believe that such a re-enactment would be helpful in that regard