[
Gerry walked through the living room ( no abductor there ). He checked his and Kate's bedroom looking for Madeleine ( no abductor there ). He used the bathroom ( no abductor there )
Gerry himself concedes that if an abductor was in the apartment whilst he did his check, then he was probably hiding behind the door of the children's bedroom
Another good reason to do a reconstruction ... it would demonstrate whether or not is was possible for a man to be standing behind the door when Gerry opened it, and if it was possible for him to be not visible to Gerry as he stood looking down at Madeleine
[/quote]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What about the kitchen - the entrance is opposite Madeleine's bedroom door. Could he have hidden in there, where Gerry didn't look?
Also Jez Wilkins said he was talking to GM for 3 to 5 mins - if it was nearer 5 mins before Jane passed them by then that gives a longer time for the abductor - say 4 mins before JT saw him.
There may have been 2 abductors and Madeleine could have been handed over the wall to the other one in the carpark. That would cut down the distance to the carpark entrance and also explain why Madeleine's head was on the L/h side of the man Jayne saw.
I honestly don't see how a physical reconstruction would be helpful. Apart from Gerry - everyone else could only give approximate times for their movements. Normally to be a couple of minutes adrift here and there in a reconstruction wouldn't matter but in this case precise timing is vital and they could not give exact times. Also they would need to remember exactly what speed they walked at - how long exactly they spent checking etc. They can't be expected to remember all that with precision. Therefore there is no way they could guarantee a faithful reproduction of their movements.
On the other hand SY have the expertise and the equipment to conduct a forensic analysis of the timelines given, and no doubt could key in all the possible variables. They are satisfied that there was a clear opportunity for Madeleine to have been abducted. If it was not possible, then I don't think they would confirm, as they have, that it was.