Author Topic: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?  (Read 23361 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #15 on: May 08, 2013, 05:10:32 PM »

There doesn't have to have been a Murder, just a need to dispose of a body.  The hours of the night would have been a very much better idea if this was the case.
What need to dispose of a body if no murder occurred ? You're not supposed to do it yourself in Portugal.

But Anne - isn't this exactly what Amaral said happened -  i.e. that Madeleine died in the apartment and her parents disposed of her body?
This is one thesis, it's not presented like reality. The question is why would they have disposed of a body since, according to GA and everybody, no murder was suspected ?

Thats a question Amaral and everybody (whoever everybody is) should be asked, Anne. It was him that said, she died in apartment 5A.
The PJ team concluded this, but, as you know, no evidence of this could be produced.
If this thesis were by chance confirmed, it wouldn't be enough to incriminate the McCanns.

Sorry, Anne, but the PJ team didn't conclude it, Amaral did.

It won't do to dismiss Amaral as a  'rougue cop'  ...  it became clear in the trial in Portugal that Amaral's colleagues were in agreement with his conclusions 

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #16 on: May 08, 2013, 05:16:02 PM »

There doesn't have to have been a Murder, just a need to dispose of a body.  The hours of the night would have been a very much better idea if this was the case.
What need to dispose of a body if no murder occurred ? You're not supposed to do it yourself in Portugal.

But Anne - isn't this exactly what Amaral said happened -  i.e. that Madeleine died in the apartment and her parents disposed of her body?
This is one thesis, it's not presented like reality. The question is why would they have disposed of a body since, according to GA and everybody, no murder was suspected ?

Thats a question Amaral and everybody (whoever everybody is) should be asked, Anne. It was him that said, she died in apartment 5A.
The PJ team concluded this, but, as you know, no evidence of this could be produced.
If this thesis were by chance confirmed, it wouldn't be enough to incriminate the McCanns.

Sorry, Anne, but the PJ team didn't conclude it, Amaral did.
I meant the first team.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #17 on: May 08, 2013, 05:22:47 PM »

There doesn't have to have been a Murder, just a need to dispose of a body.  The hours of the night would have been a very much better idea if this was the case.
What need to dispose of a body if no murder occurred ? You're not supposed to do it yourself in Portugal.

But Anne - isn't this exactly what Amaral said happened -  i.e. that Madeleine died in the apartment and her parents disposed of her body?
This is one thesis, it's not presented like reality. The question is why would they have disposed of a body since, according to GA and everybody, no murder was suspected ?

Thats a question Amaral and everybody (whoever everybody is) should be asked, Anne. It was him that said, she died in apartment 5A.
The PJ team concluded this, but, as you know, no evidence of this could be produced.
If this thesis were by chance confirmed, it wouldn't be enough to incriminate the McCanns.

Sorry, Anne, but the PJ team didn't conclude it, Amaral did.

It won't do to dismiss Amaral as a  'rougue cop'  ...  it became clear in the trial in Portugal that Amaral's colleagues were in agreement with his conclusions
There was some reason to examine Robert M's cars (if credit was given to the TPs' statements), but joint the Scenic was very unfortunate, imo. It turned a rather simple if not ordinary case into a implausible one.

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #18 on: May 08, 2013, 05:29:28 PM »
Amaral had made his conclusions, on the morning of the 4th of May

FIRST INTERROGATIONS AND REQUESTS TO THE BRITISH POLICE FOR INFORMATION

Friday May 4th

This morning I am worried; something isn't right in the account of the events:
the little girl allegedly disappeared at 10pm while she was sleeping close to her brother and her sister. They were alone in the apartment because their parents were dining with friends. A system of checks had been put in place by the adults. Every 30 minutes according to some - every quarter of an hour according to others -, someone went to have a look at the children. It is Madeleine's mother who realised she was gone and is immediately talking about abduction

Amaral had made his conclusions, from the morning of the 4th May.

FIRST MORNING OF THE INVESTIGATION;

AN ABDUCTION?

Still May 4th

When drawing up the report of the first observations, which must be forwarded to the district Judiciary Court of Lagos, we are undecided about the legal classification of the events. Finally, we opt for "abduction??," adding two question marks after the word to express our uncertainty. The decision was not taken lightly. That decision preserves the interests of the various opposing parties, those of the parents, those of the child, not to say those of the investigation itself.
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #19 on: May 08, 2013, 06:08:49 PM »
If I had to think of a very unintelligent way of disposing my own dead child it would this -

I would carry the body uncovered through the streets of town at a time when restaurants and bars were still open, myself undisguised and hurriedly looking for a bin or upturned boat to dump the corpse into / under, whilst my partner was back at home busy raising the alarm that my child had gone missing, bringing our family and friends to the attention of the local and national police force, media etc.
The accidental death of a child is never in the media, in Portugal, unless it is spectacular or implies some dangerous device.

A child that mysteriously goes missing from a holiday resort does make the Portuguese media though doesn't it?  We know this for a fact.
A child suspected to have been abducted in Portugal as broadcast by foreign media is a story the Portuguese media buy, yes.

Right, so if I'm (rather unintelligently) disposing of my child's body whilst my partner is busy setting the stage for an abduction a few hundred yards away it's likely our actions will draw the attention of the police, media etc to ourselves and our friends, as I said earlier, yes?
I don't think so, Martha. If you don't claim forced shutters, window, locked doors and abduction the media will keep quiet, observing and waiting.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #20 on: May 08, 2013, 06:17:08 PM »
Not many [ censored word] replying to this thread/ >@@(*&)

It's a horrible thread !

What an awful title ...  and what an awful subject to speculate over in detail
Horrible because it rather neatly demonstrates the idiocy of the most popular "sceptic" theory you mean...? 8)-)))

I don't care what it is meant to  'demonstrate'  ...  it is a horrible thread

Why would anyone want to speculate in detail in such a distashut upl way for any  reason

Hold on. The ......... have been speculating for years that the McCanns hid their daughter's body, froze it, buried it, transported it, disposed of it in a dead dog, burnt it in a pet crematorium and so on.

All this thread points out is how stupid the McCanns were if they chose the method guessed at by AMaral- there were far easier ways; and they are anything but stupid.

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #21 on: May 08, 2013, 06:19:24 PM »
A DISAPPEARANCE, A WINDOW AND A BODY

It is now important to present a summary of this case, based on our deductions: reject what is false, throw out what we can't show with sufficient certainty and validate that which can be proven.

1. The theory of abduction was defended from the start by Maddie's parents.

2. In their group, only the McCanns state that they saw the bedroom window open. The others cannot confirm it since they arrived at the apartment after the alert was raised.

3. The only person to have seen that window open with the shutters raised is Amy, one of the play workers from the children's centre of the Ocean Club. She made that observation at around 10.20/1030pm, which means well after the alert - which doesn't exclude that the window could have been closed at the time of the criminal act.

4. The witness statements raise a great number of inaccuracies, inconsistencies and contradictions. Jane Tanner's witness statement in favour of the theory of abduction is probably false: little by little it has lost all credibility because of successive modifications introduced by Jane, modifications that have ended up invalidating it.

5. The body, the existence of which has been confirmed by the EVRD and CSI dogs but also by the results of the preliminary laboratory analyses, cannot be found.

The conclusions my team and I have arrived at are the following:

1. The minor, Madeleine McCann died inside apartment 5A of the Ocean Club in Vila da Luz, on the night of May 3rd 2007;

2. There was simulation of abduction.

3. Kate Healy and Gerald McCann were probably involved in the concealment of their daughter's body.

4. The death may have occurred as a result of a tragic accident;

5. The evidence proves the parents' negligence concerning the care and safety of the children.
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #22 on: May 08, 2013, 06:20:26 PM »
A DISAPPEARANCE, A WINDOW AND A BODY

It is now important to present a summary of this case, based on our deductions: reject what is false, throw out what we can't show with sufficient certainty and validate that which can be proven.

1. The theory of abduction was defended from the start by Maddie's parents.

2. In their group, only the McCanns state that they saw the bedroom window open. The others cannot confirm it since they arrived at the apartment after the alert was raised.

3. The only person to have seen that window open with the shutters raised is Amy, one of the play workers from the children's centre of the Ocean Club. She made that observation at around 10.20/1030pm, which means well after the alert - which doesn't exclude that the window could have been closed at the time of the criminal act.

4. The witness statements raise a great number of inaccuracies, inconsistencies and contradictions. Jane Tanner's witness statement in favour of the theory of abduction is probably false: little by little it has lost all credibility because of successive modifications introduced by Jane, modifications that have ended up invalidating it.

5. The body, the existence of which has been confirmed by the EVRD and CSI dogs but also by the results of the preliminary laboratory analyses, cannot be found.

The conclusions my team and I have arrived at are the following:

1. The minor, Madeleine McCann died inside apartment 5A of the Ocean Club in Vila da Luz, on the night of May 3rd 2007;

2. There was simulation of abduction.

3. Kate Healy and Gerald McCann were probably involved in the concealment of their daughter's body.

4. The death may have occurred as a result of a tragic accident;

5. The evidence proves the parents' negligence concerning the care and safety of the children.


And how wrong has he been proved to be?

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #23 on: May 08, 2013, 06:20:36 PM »
Not many [ censored word] replying to this thread/ >@@(*&)

It's a horrible thread !

What an awful title ...  and what an awful subject to speculate over in detail
Horrible because it rather neatly demonstrates the idiocy of the most popular "sceptic" theory you mean...? 8)-)))

I don't care what it is meant to  'demonstrate'  ...  it is a horrible thread

Why would anyone want to speculate in detail in such a distashut upl way for any  reason

Hold on. The ......... have been speculating for years that the McCanns hid their daughter's body, froze it, buried it, transported it, disposed of it in a dead dog, burnt it in a pet crematorium and so on.

All this thread points out is how stupid the McCanns were if they chose the method guessed at by AMaral- there were far easier ways; and they are anything but stupid.

All I know is that it is you and others who are doing it now,  and it's disgusting   

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #24 on: May 08, 2013, 06:21:17 PM »
Not many [ censored word] replying to this thread/ >@@(*&)

It's a horrible thread !

What an awful title ...  and what an awful subject to speculate over in detail
Horrible because it rather neatly demonstrates the idiocy of the most popular "sceptic" theory you mean...? 8)-)))

I don't care what it is meant to  'demonstrate'  ...  it is a horrible thread

Why would anyone want to speculate in detail in such a distashut upl way for any  reason

To demonstrate how idiotic the theory is, and how unlikely it is to have happened the way the "sceptics" say - that's the opposite of distasteful in my view!

It is very strange that people should find this distasteful after what we have been treated to by the ......... over the last six years!

Offline Eleanor

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #25 on: May 08, 2013, 06:22:20 PM »
Not many [ censored word] replying to this thread/ >@@(*&)

It's a horrible thread !

What an awful title ...  and what an awful subject to speculate over in detail
Horrible because it rather neatly demonstrates the idiocy of the most popular "sceptic" theory you mean...? 8)-)))

I don't care what it is meant to  'demonstrate'  ...  it is a horrible thread

Why would anyone want to speculate in detail in such a distashut upl way for any  reason

Why speculate about anything?  That has been going on for six years, and always to the detriment of The McCanns.

In fact this same question was raised several years ago, but the dice were loaded in those days, so those of us with that sort of cheek were promptly dispatched, so it never got discussed beyond the original question.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #26 on: May 08, 2013, 06:27:55 PM »
4. The death may have occurred as a result of a tragic accident;

May?  So what other conclusion do you think Amaral might have come to if Accident was only a maybe?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #27 on: May 08, 2013, 06:32:13 PM »
If I had to think of a very unintelligent way of disposing my own dead child it would this -

I would carry the body uncovered through the streets of town at a time when restaurants and bars were still open, myself undisguised and hurriedly looking for a bin or upturned boat to dump the corpse into / under, whilst my partner was back at home busy raising the alarm that my child had gone missing, bringing our family and friends to the attention of the local and national police force, media etc.

That's the trouble with you, Martha.

You've just got no imagination ...


Not only does Martha have no imagination, she forgot to explain how the parents communicated this to the various members of the T7 and got them to agree to cover up for whatever they are supposed to have done.

And explain how no person in that Tapas restaurant that night could state that Gerry was absent at the crucial time.

Amazing feat.

The most extraordinary feat was Kate's, who found the body of her loved and cherished daughter (it's true, we know it's true, cos Amaral says it's true, cos Eddie picked up some of her clothes) and somehow pulled herself together from the shock to communicate this dreadful news to Gerry, oblivious and unaware in the restaurant, without anyone else noticing.

Extraordinary feat ...

Rachel Granada

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #28 on: May 08, 2013, 06:58:51 PM »
ferryman said: The most extraordinary feat was Kate's, who found the body of her loved and cherished daughter (it's true, we know it's true, cos Amaral says it's true, cos Eddie picked up some of her clothes) and somehow pulled herself together from the shock to communicate this dreadful news to Gerry, oblivious and unaware in the restaurant, without anyone else noticing.

Extraordinary feat ...


Or if something terrible had happened earlier in the evening, Kate and Gerry McCann going for dinner as if nothing had happened and appearing their usual selves.  Another extraordinary feat.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #29 on: May 08, 2013, 07:40:26 PM »

I don't think so, Martha. If you don't claim forced shutters, window, locked doors and abduction the media will keep quiet, observing and waiting.
You've lost me.  Please read my premise above again  and explain to me why mine and my partner's actions would not attract the attention of the media?




Well, Martha, some questions have to be answered :
Why the staging and where the disposal ?
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 08:58:26 PM by Admin »