Author Topic: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?  (Read 23353 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #45 on: May 09, 2013, 10:27:12 AM »
I don't understand your point, Martha. Abduction from bed, flat locked and shutters broken is an attractive story for the media, or rather a certain type of them. "Child missing, flat unlocked and shutters closed" isn't.

That is just silly.  Are you suggesting that The McCanns deliberately made this up to attract attention to themselves?  Why would they do that?

Offline faithlilly

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #46 on: May 09, 2013, 10:29:34 AM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

You are assuming that the McCanns didn't intend Madeleine's body to be found.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Eleanor

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #47 on: May 09, 2013, 10:39:32 AM »

More diversions and spurious answers.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #48 on: May 09, 2013, 10:39:43 AM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

You are assuming that the McCanns didn't intend Madeleine's body to be found.

Let us try some rationality and logic here.

You give some credence to the idea that the McCanns disposed of Madeleine's body in PdL in May 2007.

Let us assume they did this.

If so they have done very well as no trace of it has been found.

If they intended Madeleine's body to be found, why was it not. Did someone go on and abduct a dead body, thus stopping the McCanns from having it found.

You cannot have it both ways.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #49 on: May 09, 2013, 10:42:31 AM »
I don't understand your point, Martha. Abduction from bed, flat locked and shutters broken is an attractive story for the media, or rather a certain type of them. "Child missing, flat unlocked and shutters closed" isn't.

That is just silly.  Are you suggesting that The McCanns deliberately made this up to attract attention to themselves?  Why would they do that?
I certainly didn't say that and judging before making sure is unspeakable. Am I not sententious ? ;)

Offline Admin

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #50 on: May 09, 2013, 08:49:28 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

Time of death can only be established if a body is found within the first few hours of death.  After several hours it becomes almost impossible to establish, this also being dependent on many factors.  After 8 hours it is impossible to determine time of death to any great accuracy.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #51 on: May 09, 2013, 08:53:57 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

Time of death can only be established if a body is found within the first few hours of death.  After several hours it becomes almost impossible to establish, this also being dependent on many factors.  After 8 hours it is impossible to determine time of death to any great accuracy.

I didn't know that   ( you live and learn ... thanks )

Offline faithlilly

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #52 on: May 09, 2013, 09:08:35 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

You are assuming that the McCanns didn't intend Madeleine's body to be found.

Let us try some rationality and logic here.

You give some credence to the idea that the McCanns disposed of Madeleine's body in PdL in May 2007.

Let us assume they did this.

If so they have done very well as no trace of it has been found.

If they intended Madeleine's body to be found, why was it not. Did someone go on and abduct a dead body, thus stopping the McCanns from having it found.

You cannot have it both ways.

Body was placed in municipal bin as a stop gap after the Smith sighting spooked the carrier of the child, the carrier either intending the body to be found that night during search or , if not, to relocate the body later. The body, in the meantime, is taken along with the bin to landfill the next morning and, as the landfill wasn't searched, stayed there until dispersed by animals.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #53 on: May 09, 2013, 09:10:08 PM »
"Evidence" for the fantasy being what?

Offline Admin

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #54 on: May 09, 2013, 09:12:12 PM »

Time of death can only be established if a body is found within the first few hours of death.  After several hours it becomes almost impossible to establish, this also being dependent on many factors.  After 8 hours it is impossible to determine time of death to any great accuracy.

I didn't know that   ( you live and learn ... thanks )

As an example of this I refer you to the Luke Mitchell case and the murder of his girlfriend Jodi Jones (both 15).  Luke was convicted of her murder on the basis of an extremely narrow window of about 30 minutes and in the absence of any forensics linking him to the scene or the victim.

Shortly after the discovery of Jodi's body the police SOCO lady arrived on the scene but was so fat she couldn't get over a wall so left the body unexamined.  The incompetent cops even left the remains uncovered all night in light rain.  When the pathologist eventually examined the remains the next day he was unable to determine the time of death so the police could chose a time to fit a gap in Luke's alibi (as they do).

Offline sika

Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #55 on: May 09, 2013, 09:26:09 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

You are assuming that the McCanns didn't intend Madeleine's body to be found.

Let us try some rationality and logic here.

You give some credence to the idea that the McCanns disposed of Madeleine's body in PdL in May 2007.

Let us assume they did this.

If so they have done very well as no trace of it has been found.

If they intended Madeleine's body to be found, why was it not. Did someone go on and abduct a dead body, thus stopping the McCanns from having it found.

You cannot have it both ways.

Body was placed in municipal bin as a stop gap after the Smith sighting spooked the carrier of the child, the carrier either intending the body to be found that night during search or , if not, to relocate the body later. The body, in the meantime, is taken along with the bin to landfill the next morning and, as the landfill wasn't searched, stayed there until dispersed by animals.
Well! I've read some truly bonkers posts over he past few weeks but this one takes some beating! 8-)(--)

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #56 on: May 09, 2013, 09:30:06 PM »
Quote
Online Faithlilly

Body was placed in municipal bin as a stop gap after the Smith sighting spooked the carrier of the child, the carrier either intending the body to be found that night during search or , if not, to relocate the body later. The body, in the meantime, is taken along with the bin to landfill the next morning and, as the landfill wasn't searched, stayed there until dispersed by animals.

can you please confirm that is your opinion?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #57 on: May 09, 2013, 09:30:39 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

You are assuming that the McCanns didn't intend Madeleine's body to be found.

Let us try some rationality and logic here.

You give some credence to the idea that the McCanns disposed of Madeleine's body in PdL in May 2007.

Let us assume they did this.

If so they have done very well as no trace of it has been found.

If they intended Madeleine's body to be found, why was it not. Did someone go on and abduct a dead body, thus stopping the McCanns from having it found.

You cannot have it both ways.

Body was placed in municipal bin as a stop gap after the Smith sighting spooked the carrier of the child, the carrier either intending the body to be found that night during search or , if not, to relocate the body later. The body, in the meantime, is taken along with the bin to landfill the next morning and, as the landfill wasn't searched, stayed there until dispersed by animals.
Well! I've read some truly bonkers posts over he past few weeks but this one takes some beating! 8-)(--)

Faith has been peddling that for years.  She has even insisted that "the body" (of Kate and Gerry's beloved daughter, Madeleine) was not placed in any sort of container such as a bag, because a bag can leave this traces.

This was actually a crude tactic to draw people into arguing the point and reinforcing the illusion of some sort of substance to the fantasy.

It's how Faith works.

It's how Faith has always worked ...

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #58 on: May 09, 2013, 09:40:35 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

Time of death can only be established if a body is found within the first few hours of death.  After several hours it becomes almost impossible to establish, this also being dependent on many factors.  After 8 hours it is impossible to determine time of death to any great accuracy.

It is possible to give time frames, but not as accurate as loss of body core temperature which is pretty good to within a couple of hours when allowance is made for ambient temperature, amount of clothing, exposure to sun and wind etc. Less accurate measures are onset and relaxation of rigor mortis, skin color, decay patterns within the body and infestation with insects.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: Just supposing there had been an accidental death?
« Reply #59 on: May 09, 2013, 09:41:26 PM »
It's a pretty convincing argument against a carefully planned McCann plot to dispose of a body!

The time of death could be gauged when, or if, the body was found. This could have been a consideration.

But if this was a disposal of a body, it was done well enough to fool the PJ. If the body is not going to be found, why worry about the temperature which is only accurate for the first 36 hours or so?

You are assuming that the McCanns didn't intend Madeleine's body to be found.

Let us try some rationality and logic here.

You give some credence to the idea that the McCanns disposed of Madeleine's body in PdL in May 2007.

Let us assume they did this.

If so they have done very well as no trace of it has been found.

If they intended Madeleine's body to be found, why was it not. Did someone go on and abduct a dead body, thus stopping the McCanns from having it found.

You cannot have it both ways.

Body was placed in municipal bin as a stop gap after the Smith sighting spooked the carrier of the child, the carrier either intending the body to be found that night during search or , if not, to relocate the body later. The body, in the meantime, is taken along with the bin to landfill the next morning and, as the landfill wasn't searched, stayed there until dispersed by animals.

Write much fiction for a living?