I would say they were damned unlucky to lose one.
There is abundant evidence in the files that they ran very regular checks and while theft (of property) is common enough, child abduction is incredibly rare.
I would say, statistically, far the most probable (deleterious) outcome was all three children safe but possessions from the apartment taken.
Statistics can not be used to explain a SINGLE case. That is not scientific. You can not apply "probailities" here.
I believe the abductor may be a burglar but versatile offender, who took Madeleine because she went to the window, and did not see the twins.
Heri.
No, but the way the statement is stated is a correct use of statistics.
I disagree with you, debunker. You can not infer from statistics, from a lot of past cases, any characteristic of a SINGLE NEW CASE. Even the new case may have characteristics which are not in the past cases statistics. So you can not say you have a probability of 1, 10, 50, 90, or 99% about nothing.
Heri.
No, but you can say, in a class of situations such as this, these are the likely outcomes. Statistics exchanges precision for knowledge.
If you were to meet me for the first time you could reasonably believe that the likelihood of me being GAy is about 3-5%. I happen not to be Gay, but before you have any information, the statistics do give you knowledge without precision.
Consider the following thought experiment
You have a choice between two doors. Behind the each door is a man with a gun. Door One has someone from an aggressive society where gun use is normal when someone breaks into a house; behind Door 2 is someone from a society where such behavior is very unlikely.
Now statistics tells you nothing about the definite outcome for each individual, but still gives you knowledge that you did not have before.
Which door would you choose, or would you ignore the statistics.